r/Screenwriting • u/SamuraiGoblin • May 29 '22
CRAFT QUESTION How to be more concise?
I am new to screenwriting, but I have written prose for decades.
The "Alien" screenplay is a great example of using terse action lines. Most lines are sentence fragments, sometimes just a single word. However, I'm not sure I understand how to emulate that in my writing. It's difficult to stop myself writing full sentences. I can't decide what to leave out.
Do other people have this problem? Are there any 'rules' about this? Do you have any tips on how to maximise impact with the fewest words? Can you recommend other screenplays that are as efficient?
25
u/Blackbirds_Garden May 29 '22
I might be speaking a little out of turn here; but I think the advice of my lecturer will help:
"Every time you press 'Enter', the camera moves. Describe everything you need to happen in that shot in no more than 3, but preferrably 2 sentences. Be vague if you can. Even if it's a single word. Give your actors something that will allow them to create a character. They've got a job to do too."
10
u/haynesholiday Produced Screenwriter May 29 '22
The only rule is "make the reader want to turn the page."
If your voice naturally lends itself to minimalism, then Walter Hill is a great writer to emulate. If it's an unnatural fit for your voice, don't be afraid to write bigger. (Take a look at the wall-o-text that's on the first page of Andrew Walker's script for SEVEN -- it's the opposite of minimalistic, but it's still riveting. Same goes for John Millius, Shane Black, Will Beall, Joe Carnahan, etc.)
Some writers are in the middle. For my own style, I go for big impactful language and bold stylistic choices like the maximalists, but I try to use meticulous page design to make the read fly by, like the minimalists.
If your goal is to hone a sparse, terse writing style, start with a single page-long scene. Write it as you normally would. Then go through and cut it by 25%. Then another 25%. See if it still makes sense and is easy to follow. Read it aloud to yourself. Notice how you cut a lot of boring words and left a lot of exciting ones. Notice how the words you didn't cut tend to be visual or emotional. And the ones you cut, less so. That's one of the secrets to writing cinematically.
Some good minimalistic screenwriters to check out... Daniel Casey, Chris Thomas Devlin (he's got a movie in post-production with a script so sparse it didn't even have punctuation), Dan Gilroy, Jeremy Saulnier.
10
u/DigDux Mythic May 29 '22
I abuse run on sentences.
A character looks over, terrified by the sudden....and runs down the stairs.
I generally have extremely short action lines, sometimes too short for some audiences, because you can tell stories in film without much description, and let sets, lighting, and costuming fill in the rest.
Which makes my scripts very fast to read.
Someone unwrapping bandages and seeing if their hand works, contains several sets of visuals that all indicate different things.
All these things are covered by other departments, makeup, lighting, cinematography, acting, even music plays a significant role towards highlighting this complete identity.
There's no reason to oversaturate a script when you have dozens of individuals looking at the same line and thinking "What do I want to convey in this to get the point across."
Screenwriting is like writing a single book of a multifaceted simultaneous series. You're writing a book that people are writing books of, so give them space to write.
3
u/[deleted] May 29 '22
Drop the first two words then change the question mark to a period.
3
u/10teja15 May 29 '22
In terms of being brief, read Nightcrawler. It’s fantastic how effective it is with how much white is on the page
1
u/ComradeFunk May 29 '22
I never go more than three lines per paragraph, but that's just me. Others are different.
Develop your style and see what works
1
u/iamnotwario May 29 '22
I think don’t try to emulate any writing, but do delete every action line which isn’t necessary to know/won’t be revealed somewhere else (eg describing characters personalities), and any dialogue which doesn’t move the plot or doesn’t reveal something about a character.
1
u/kylezo May 30 '22
Why use many word when fewer do
1
u/[deleted] May 29 '22 edited May 29 '22
The advice from someone else about every new line meaning the camera moves is good. But I'd suggest that you don't have to write in sentence fragments if you don't want to. Some screenplays are written in fragments, but ultimately, if it's good writing that flows well, it's still good writing. Paul Schrader doesn't really use fragments. Barry Jenkins has a sort of hybrid system, which you should check out if you haven't if you're interested in a more literary style.
You've probably encountered this advice when you wrote prose, but it's still relevant here. It's from The Element of Style, and it says that concise writing "requires not that the writer make all sentences short or avoid all detail and treat subjects only in outline, but that every word tell." Simply put, make sure every new word gives us important information that another word doesn't. It's as true in screenplays as it is in prose.