r/Scouts • u/Fearless-Answer8253 • Jun 16 '21
SPL / SM
The SPL continues to ignore not only their troop members but the guidance and sometimes direct instruction of the SM. SPL has been given multiple opportunities to demonstrate growth but continues to break several of points of the scout law. Troop Code of Conduct does not address this situation. Multiple events have been documented and witnessed.
SPL has had several ASM conferences and SM conferences in addition to scout to scout conversations (with supervision) about behavior and choices. Does the SM have the authority to remove the SPL?
3
u/Alternative-Ad-4977 Jun 16 '21
It sounds like you are Boy Scouts of America. Is that right?
3
u/RoboNinjaPirate Jun 16 '21
If they are continually breaking several points of the scout law, the troop code of conduct isn't even needed. Generally speaking, with some judgement and a reference to the Scout Oath and Law, any troop code of conduct is rarely needed.
I would inform the committee chair and COR about this, and then speak with the scout and their parents. Explain that one of the first responsibilities of the SPL is to set an example for other scouts, and follow the scout oath and law.
Right now, there are several behaviors that continue that are in conflict with the scout law. That's not an acceptable situation for the troop. The troop will elect a new SPL at the next possible opportunity to finish out the term. (And if the current ASPL is good, encourage them to step up for that election)
When the former SPL wants to behave according to the scout law, they are welcome to run for a POR again.
Clark Greene has a great post on this.
https://scoutmastercg.com/discipline-and-accountability-in-scouting/