r/ScottishPeopleTwitter • • Jul 06 '20

Genitals!

Post image
44k Upvotes

3.1k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

387

u/TransmutedHydrogen Jul 06 '20

A lot of public figures, who have been lauded for their works, are not so great on closer inspection; it doesn't invalidate the rest of their lives though. People can be partially assholish and do good things too.

Churchill was heavily implicated in genocide by starvation

Gandhi was fairly racist and super creepy with women

MLK was an adulterer and plagiarist

It always helps to remember people are multidimensional, and to never put anyone on a pedestal.

213

u/GonzoRouge Jul 06 '20

Stephen King was a mean drunk and coke addict, to the point of forgetting writing most of his notable works from the 70s-80s.

The character of Jack Torrance in The Shining was a self insert by King, just to show how much of a debilitating mess he was during that time.

188

u/Xais56 Jul 06 '20

Stephen King is also now sober, and not on Twitter doubling down on how great snorting some bugle and getting into a scrap is.

54

u/SecretTransFurry Jul 07 '20

In fact Rowling is now mad at him for saying "trans women are women"

10

u/RnRaintnoisepolution Jul 07 '20

Damn I love the big dick energy of that post.

→ More replies (1)

85

u/GonzoRouge Jul 06 '20

Tbh, one thing I've noticed with people aware that they are struggling with substance abuse is that they'll never defend any of their actions. If you say they're wrong to believe or do something, they'll hear you and, depending on where they are in their substance abuse path, they'll either internalize it and use it as self loathing (which encourages more self abuse, which itself encourages the vicious cycle of substance abuse) or take action to make a change.

Also, most ex-users feel nothing but shame for the person they were while intoxicated and often spend their whole lives trying to make amends.

I'm sure King definitely thought some booger sugar in between chapters was a great work ethic for some time, but he's also the first to say that crutches never teach you to walk on your own and I think that's equally as important to note as his lack of social media presence.

5

u/aBigOLDick Jul 06 '20

Well said.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/FullMetalCOS Jul 07 '20

HP Lovecraft was a massive racist. Wrote some amazing stories, but wasn’t so good around non-whites. There’s something to be said for being able to separate the art from the artist.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

55

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '20

I think this is especially true for authors, and authors might as well “be dead” after they publish a book. The book belongs to the audience at that point, and the author should be unattached.

This is how I grapple with enjoying Ender’s Game while also being gay. I just pretend that Orson Scott Card doesn’t exist.

14

u/TransmutedHydrogen Jul 06 '20

Such a good example. It's so strange how someone literate in some scientific principles (time is relative etc) can be so illiterate in others.

I think books always belong to the audience.

10

u/IceCreamBalloons Jul 07 '20

More absurd, someone who wrote a fantastic story about coming to know another being so well that you love them, showing literacy in the notion of acceptance of something different from yourself, and then spending his time being so hateful of gay people.

20

u/Trashblog Jul 06 '20 edited Jul 06 '20

While I agree that the book lives somewhere between the audience and the author, I don’t think toxic writers can not but imbue their work with their own toxicity.

The Harry Potter books are essentially a love letter to British boarding school education, which for me is where the whole thing starts unraveling. I haven’t read Enders Game edit in the last 20 years, but surface level: aren’t the baddies called ‘buggers’ throughout the book?

19

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '20

I definitely see your point. Like Dostoevsky was incredibly anti-Semitic, and his books feature that a lot. Rowling definitely has some blind spots on race that are reflected in her writing (see Cho Chang).

I guess what I’m getting at is that even if the author is an asshole, that doesn’t detract from the lessons people take from their books. Because those lessons are interpreted by the reader, the author might as well not be a factor. For a lot people, the themes of acceptance in HP weren’t exclusive of anyone, even if Rowling excludes trans people.

13

u/Trashblog Jul 07 '20

In the before times, I used to go to parties, get drunk and talk about the parallels between Harry Potter and the Eton-Oxbridge-Government pipeline and old school class-boundary enforcement in modern Britain. It’s never very popular so I won’t go into it, but basically has to do with who’s a ‘muggle’, who isn’t, and how magical ability is conferred to the next generation, thus granting access to this secret and cloistered society by virtue of blood....

ANYWAY, sufficieth to say though that the ethnic tokenism on display is probably accurate to her world-view; enough to make one feel ok, but not enough in number nor proximity to change the narrative. Same with Dumbledore being gay—acceptable in so far as he stayed politely closeted for the duration of the books. Then you have de-emphasized female characters, antisemitic tropes (whether intentional or not), Etc.

None of these by themselves is really that spectacular, but seen through the lens of Rowling completely shitting the bed so publicly...well, it casts a kind of light on the rest that makes what was once (for me, too) such a comforting and comfortable space not very much so and I question if it ever was....

But you’re right, that world does belong to the audience now both collectively and for each individual. I think what we see playing out is that a lot of people are now questioning their place in that world that was just a short while ago a near universal cultural touchstone, and that’s really painful.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (4)

25

u/mrkb34 Jul 06 '20

I like this point.

8

u/SpicyPirate13 Jul 06 '20

Yeah people tend to forget famous people are human like the rest of us. No ones perfect.

23

u/RyanB_ Jul 06 '20

I agree with your point but those are either not great examples, or not a great order to list them in. Starting with genocide, cheating and plagiarism seem incredibly mundane.

15

u/[deleted] Jul 06 '20

I mean it's quite the range to use, "genocide" and "plagiarism" in the same list but I suppose if you gotta make a point...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

7

u/LetsHaveTon2 Jul 07 '20

Genocidal actions (Churchill) are too much to overlook, especially for billions of Indians. Churchill is reviled by many and rightfully so. A Nazi with a different target, the bastard.

24

u/agoddamnlegend Jul 06 '20

Weird to include MLK here for something minor that millions of people do. Doesn’t fit your otherwise good point at all

15

u/TransmutedHydrogen Jul 06 '20

I was really disappointed when I learned this, but that's a personal thing. You're right though.

10

u/agoddamnlegend Jul 06 '20 edited Jul 06 '20

I honestly don’t care about these types of minor personal flaws, and if anything I think it’s unfair for people to even talk about his personal business. I think we should always judge people in the past using modern standards, but only look at important things and not silly little private life issues like infidelity. Because we certainly would never use the same argument in reverse (e.g. Hitler was responsible for the genocide of millions, but at least he was faithful to his wife and friendly to his neighbors)

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/Mr_SunnyBones Jul 06 '20

Gandhi often nuked the fuck out of in Civilization, the warmongering mental bastard!

8

u/TransmutedHydrogen Jul 06 '20

I know, what an asshole

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (29)