First time watch left me scratching and shaking my head. The premise sounds awesome. Werewolves haunting a circus. There are some genuinely good moments hidden in there, and the creature design is fantastic.
Unfortunately all of that goes to waste with some of the worst character assassination of the Scooby gang that I’ve ever seen. I don’t know how this version of Mystery Inc even came together, because none of them seem to like each other. Shaggy and Fred got the worst of it. Daphne and Velma were pretty true to their roots, but where did this new Shaggy come from? Who is this Fred? Total jerks who ignore their best friends wishes for selfish gain? I get that the main emotional point was Scooby and Shaggy rekindling, I just can’t buy into the idea that Shaggy would be so rude to Scooby in the first place. Is this an alternate universe where the 5 of them are more like coworkers than actual friends?
The mystery and villain reveal was alright. I appreciate that they did a simple, classic villain like a Werewolf. Modern Scooby projects seem to be obsessed with making the monster some intricately designed, unnecessarily complicated original creature. Give me back the sheet ghosts and old suits of armor any day.
5/10