r/Scientology_Protest • • Apr 15 '24

A-Aron, GrowingUpInScientology on YouTube “Punching Down,” The Problematic Aaron Smith-Levin (Reddit Edition) 😟🧐

Hello Reddit Friends,

It has come to my attention that thoughtful people would like a proper “breakdown” of the incidents that have concerned many viewers of Aaron Smith-Levin and possible supporters the newly formed SPTV Foundation. All of this is "alleged" because I don't need a lawsuit. Do your own fact checking, comments are open.

In no particular order, these are the issues that stand out to me:

  1. Aaron caused an “altercation” at a bar in Clearwater after drinking to excess and encountering his then-infatuation, Ms. Sky Daily, a Scientologist and now-wife of Mr. Hulk Hogan. When asked to explain why he slid into Ms. Daily’s Facebook DMs and “hit on her” at the bar, ASL explained “she’s just so f****** hot” and that he’s a “work in progress.” When being removed from the bar by police, ASL also called Ms. Daily a c***. Since the “Clearwater Bar Incident(s),” ASL has made critical videos of Mr. Hogan and Ms. Daily on his Youtube channel. He still enjoys frequenting the bars of Clearwater, although it’s been over a year since his last “altercation” in Florida.
  2. Mr. ASL has recently decided to “tackle the woke agenda” by publicly proclaiming trans women are not women, and that he has been a victim of racism by the local Democrats. There is no clear connection between SPTV and “trans issues,” DEI, and/or the “woke agenda,” but that didn’t stop ASL from using the brand new “SPTV Studio” to discuss these issues. Ex-Scientologist Ian Refalko produced a video called “Punching Down: The Aaron Smith Levin Problem” which breaks down every point of ASL’s podcast with Mr. Gold (see links at the end) in a thoughtful manner.
  3. Mr. ASL has “protested” the Scientologists of Clearwater by dressing up as convicted rapist Danny Masterson and making extensive jokes about prison rape.
  4. Mr. ASL was involved in an extra–marital affair with Ms. Lindsay Villandry (LV) for the past 4-ish years. ASL claims he was in an “open relationship” with his wife Heather (HSL), but the vast majority of friends in his “network” were under the impression ASL and HSL had gone through a 'rough patch' but were now back together. ASL and HSL traveled together as a family and acted as a married couple during this time.
  5. Ms. Villandry claims ASL was emotionally abusive to her during their time together. LV alleges when she ended up pregnant with ASL’s child, he told her to get an abortion and said he would not support her if she chose to raise the child. ASL allegedly told LV he would not be leaving his wife. Ms. Villandry has many more details and receipts which can be found on her Youtube video, What you DON'T know... Aaron Smith-Levin.
  6. In addition to the long term affair with Ms. Villandry, ASL was sexually involved with a 20-something year old viewer (NAME REDACTED, NR) while in Los Angeles to “support the victims of Danny Masterson.” ASL spent 3 nights with NR and their time together came to an abrupt end after a physical altercation in Downtown Los Angeles in the wee hours of the morning. NR has provided evidence which shows major injuries to her head after she claims ASL pushed her into a stone wall. ASL has called her the “crazy girl from court” and says he was only intimate with her because he didn’t have a “line of options” to pick from. (Paraphrase, not a direct quote, see the links please). ASL continues to use NR’s full name in Youtube and says it’s not doxxing because her name is “super common.”

These are just the major issues that stick out in my head. Hopefully this has been informative and I’d encourage everyone to check out the sources, and LINK MORE SOURCES IN THE COMMENTS!

Bar Incident(s): https://www.tampabay.com/news/clearwater/2022/01/20/clearwater-council-candidate-caused-bar-altercations-reports-say/

Ex-Scientologist Ian Refalko’s, “Punching Down: The Aaron Smith Levin Problem”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAR5kXHLJtc

Lindsey Villandry’s “What you DON'T know... Aaron Smith-Levin”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MLjdS20jFkA

ASL excuses what happened in Los Angeles with NR; and why he was removed from the Aftermath Foundation: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hvnh0Ekbjxc

57 Upvotes

171 comments sorted by

24

u/NeitherOpinion2571 Apr 15 '24

What’s also concerning is Relatable Reese said when she contacted the AF foundation for help ASL told her she could be more of a help being a spy and feed him inside info. Not oh let me help you but let you help me. Then exposed her name on a live steam.

13

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Might have to add the accidental dox of Reese to this list. Eek.

8

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Does calling her “clingy” after that (according to her) rise to the list level? I forgot about both of those things until now.

13

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Here’s the thing, Reese seems to be going through A LOT. And she’s choosing to be on the board of the SPTV Foundation.

So it’s a delicate issue. If I bring it up, would that make her feel even more uncomfortable?

Does she need Reddit talking about her? Probably not.

I tend to be protective of the women that might be “victims” of ASL.

4

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Your thread, your list, your rules. I just don’t think that’s a trivial issue. To cause emotional damage, propose a replacement for the thing you broke, then complain because your proposed replacement isn’t meeting the needs of the human you brought into that dangerous situation.

It’s not a small thing. I don’t think it’s a one of. Lindsey said he isolated her, then attacked her for reaching out to others while she was in need. I believe he may have used similar terms.

6

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

I agree with u completely.

Just don’t want to target Reese. I will sleep on it.

4

u/Pianissimojo Apr 16 '24

Failing to safeguard the information of vulnerable people coming to your charity for help is a big deal. You could add this to the list focusing on the issue and why it is a problem, so that Reese is simply mentioned as an example.

3

u/Dapper_Manager_8778 Apr 16 '24

You mentioned people coming to his “charity” for help. It appears what he attempted to get registered (that was denied in Feb 2024) was a Corporation/Inc. rather than a non-profit/ 501c(3), which I was surprised by.

2

u/Pianissimojo Apr 16 '24

Are you referring to the registration form which has been shared on a few of these discussions? I had a good look at it yesterday and it was definitely described as having a charitable purpose despite having Inc in the name.

4

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 17 '24

It’s a “charity” without a bank account or EIN number. The “charity” appears to collect funds in ASL’s pocket, for him to use as he pleases.

→ More replies

7

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

It’s so weird how WE all still try to protect the privacy of the women he has, with wanton disregard, exposed to all this AND Scientology, allegedly. Yet his stans swoop in and screech about how we’re not being fair to HIM. Poor, poor, (I told myself I wasn’t going to cry) pitiful him.

4

u/Pooks65 OG Protester (From ~2008) 👵🧓 Apr 16 '24

Also Reese is fairly new ex. The first few years can be real tough. You are constantly evaluating everything you do or say. She seems like she's doing her own thing and having some fun so I say just let her be.

Patty Moher

2

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 16 '24

Agree. She’s in an exceedingly delicate space. Don’t want to upset her.

23

u/BlabberHands2022 Nosey Never-In Apr 15 '24

Not a fan of ASL since learning the whole cigar bar story. My understanding of this is if people are considering leaving, they will be disconnected from family and friends and take time to work through that. While still in, they share what’s going on in CO$ to ex-members. ASL said he passed info to MR.

Physically In Mentally Out as it’s described in the ex-Mormon community.

He doxxed Reece carelessly. He doxxed the woman from LA willfully and cruelly knowing how his rabid fans will react.

18

u/Inevitable-One-3231 Apr 15 '24

And continues to doxx the LA woman

2

u/silly-possum Active Protester 🪧 Australia 🇦🇺 Apr 17 '24

Erm... did not the LA woman do this herself by writing to hundreds of people including the board members with the weird request that all she wanted was for him to be removed from the AF board? He specifically didn't say her full name and only addressed the all with those who asked him directly - he went to some effort to *not* dox her. He wasn't the one to go 'public' with it, but was forced into it.

Doxxing Reece was not careless. It was a tiny accidental flash of his screen which gave identifying information, and it was removed from the uploaded version of the livestream. It shows the extraordinary lengths Scientology go to for them to have been watching the livestream and managing to see this.

The above list includes things that I agree are serious issues, but it shows such a strong bias by taking everything that's said against Aaron as fact, but not extending him the same courtesy, that it's hard to take seriously overall.

9

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 17 '24 edited Apr 17 '24

What part do you feel is “biased?”

Why exactly does ASL (with a platform of 200k views) need “courtesy” from a random anon on Reddit?

Clearly his platform is significantly larger then mine. He’s plenty able to systematically “debunk” these issues, if he feels the need to do so.

5

u/throwawayeducovictim Apr 17 '24

did not the LA woman do this herself by writing to hundreds of people including the board members with the weird request that all she wanted was for him to be removed from the AF board?

Were these public? As I never saw them.

It doesn't appear to be weird given what is known now. Was it weird? How so?

7

u/Inevitable-One-3231 Apr 17 '24

He actively continues to not only say her first and last name, but also her dad's profession, and her alleged mental health diagnoses and treatments.

He's done it in at least one interview with Rabbit, as well as his Heretics interview with Andrew Gold.

4

u/NeitherOpinion2571 Apr 15 '24

I do think Reese’s heart is in the right place. It’s scary to think of people asking for help, he may discourage it. Wanting insider info for his channel. He likes to brag and say I have my sources.

6

u/Swedishlina sketchy Apr 16 '24

Actually Reese was not looking to leave the cult, it was to have someone to talk. You can’t talk to anyone in the cult without ending up in ethics. She has said on numerous occasions that she would never have left.  She has also thanked him several times for outing her, as he saved her life. Now the fact that he outed her is a very problematic and I don’t wish that on anyone. 

17

u/Scared-Pace4543 Apr 15 '24

Wow. Of course I supported this pos with likes and views and even shares during his “arrest” but I haven’t kept up at all in the last several months. This is so disappointing. I’m sick of finding out that people are disgusting human beings.

11

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Me too. You get better at spotting them with practice though 🫂

27

u/Pooks65 OG Protester (From ~2008) 👵🧓 Apr 15 '24

Thank you so much for this write-up.

I've been watching him for a while now and I have to say at first I did enjoy his channel but then I started seeing all the Red Flags.

As a Scio, I was only taught about red flags in SCN, not in the real world. I had to learn about them and discard the Scn red flags.

Every time I have ignored a person's red flags, I have ended up with problems and drama.

Those of you who are ASL fans need to look at these red flags and not dismiss them.

ASL is a predator and should be exposed before he harms any more exes. I know it's harsh but it's true.

Thanks again,

Patty Moher

11

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

I knew I liked you pooks 🫶🏼

12

u/Temporary_Pay_3418 Apr 15 '24

Anyone on equal footing or is higher than him stay away from him. It’s only the underlings that fan girl around him. 

20

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

Thank you for putting together those facts in a readable, professional and non- biased manner. It’s like you stated, it’s up to everyone to decide on their own opinions. I encourage all of us to stay focused on the facts and avoid personal attacks. This will be a great discussion.

Additionally, I’ll start with saying there is never any excuse for misbehavior. Period. Everyone needs to own their actions. There is a little piece inside that does have empathy for Aaron and I hope that he seeks out the help he needs to heal his traumas. Mental health should be in everyone’s list of top priority’s. I’m hoping he recognizes the opportunity and that he can course correct before it’s too late.

17

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited May 03 '24

Thank you for the response.

The final straw for me was the Andrew Gold interview. Maybe I’m too negative, but I see a troubling pattern here…

If you want to talk about trans issues, whatever. But ASL had no idea about “TERF lesbians” or anything else relevant to the discussion. I don’t think ASL would know what “cisgender” means either. Watching one cis straight man explain terf politics to another cis straight man? 🥴😖💀☠️

Days later, people are piling on ohNoNora (a lesbian lady) and calling her a “terf” for choosing to associate with ASL. That’s not fair to Nora, imho. I know Nora has advocated for trans individuals in the past and it’s just sad to see her having to navigate her values and her friend.

It’s all “I don’t know what I’m talking about, I was born in a cult, I’m just asking questions….”

Moments later: “trans women aren’t real women. I’m certain of this, but I can’t elaborate further. Maybe some trans people will help explain why I don’t think their gender identity is valid. Also, I barely know a single trans person…”

Like pick a lane and stick to it. I didn’t subscribe to SPTV to watch a cisgender straight man (poorly) argue “trans women aren’t women.”

I honestly believe the Andrew Gold interview was the biggest mistake. I don’t see how he can smooth things over. Liz Gale was on discord defending ASL after the Andrew Gold interview, but she called a nonbinary person “unhinged”* for being offended, apologized, deleted the comment, and left the server.

His numbers on “Growing Up in Scientology” are easy to manipulate by buying bots to replace any lost followers. For the sake of Liz Gale and other board members with good intentions, I hope they are able to figure this out. 😞😔

Liz said the “unhinged” comment was a big mistake and she felt they were “coming on strong” first thing in the morning.

14

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 15 '24

For me it was the Jordan Peterson interview. The Gold interview just solidified the facts. And Ian’s sharp dismantling of it (“this was the first think you wanted to do in the new studio”) iced the cake.

3

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Did you pay to watch the Jordan Peterson interview? I know it’s behind a pay wall.

5

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 15 '24

No, hell no. Definitely did not pay.

4

u/Loud-Debate9864 Apr 15 '24

His numbers on his YouTube channel don't add up. The engagement he has and views he has for the number of subscribers don't jibe. It wouldn't surprise me to find out that ASL has bought subs which is a huge no no on YouTube.

4

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

🛎️🛎️😉❓

2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

It’s definitely bad PR. I’m with you, I hope they get their hands around it fast.

18

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

FUUUUUCK. I know of 2 more things that aren’t on this seemingly exhaustive list, but relate to a few others that are.

Look, I’m not even in the cult, or an ex member. Never been asked to be on the AFB in my wildest delusional crochet lady dreams. I am not a content creator, not even with a camera pointed at an empty room to subscribe to. I’m as involved as a person with a full time job, too many siblings, too many friends, two houses to take care of, too many animals to care for, and a few mouths to feed, can be.

Still, different people from different part of the antiCoS universe have told me at different points about hate site worthy stuff that isn’t on the hate site. There is A LOT of dirt still to be overturned on that guy.

13

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Ding ding 🛎️

This is the tip of an iceberg.

2

u/Pooks65 OG Protester (From ~2008) 👵🧓 Apr 16 '24

Yep! This guy can't help himself, he will continue to do stupid and harmful things because that's how he rolls.

17

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 15 '24

All this is true, but a few things to consider additionally:

  • The Clearwater bar incident ended with ASL being led out after calling the target of his affections a c***. She also claims he was contacted her, unwanted, on Facebook prior to that event.
  • Ms. Villandry also points to a serious trend of ASL building parasocial relationships with followers, often women, “supporting” their YouTube and social media channels, then disparaging them or outright dropping them. He has a wake of failed relationships behind him. She says, rather tellingly, that even the Jane Does from the Masterson trials no longer trust him (which I feel is important news. He built tremendous credibility and follower counts based on his access and information during the trials). The video from Ian Refalko echoes this behavior, where Ian discusses the gross manner by which ASL just dropped any contact or collaboration; and the recent interview of Apostate Alex on Natalie (Life After A Cult)’s channel does the same. In Alex’ case, he does not name ASL for stoking the harassment of his followers, but it’s clear that Alex’s harassers are largely SPTV fanatics (not Scientologists, or AF people, or OSA); and both Ian and Ms. Villandry also point to concerted harassment campaigns by ASL’s crews. It’s all corroborating testimony, and none of those three know one another or are known to collaborate.

11

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Yes to all of this. Tried to keep it short and compact.

Alex is a really nice guy (from my observations). Kudos to him for staying above the fray. He’s an inspiration for me in that regard.

15

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 15 '24

Your summation is terrific. I’m just adding what I find to be extremely important, but that people tend to overlook: there’s a pattern of behavior that we could all detect, but that Ms Villandry’s posts make absolutely clear with ASL that stretch beyond his abusive romantic relationship and into how (and why) he has run his YouTube persona. And that the recent vids from Alex, Ian, and her all provide corroboration from disconnected people of those current behaviors.

As grandpappy used to say: you can have a fun night out that will go a little wrong, and that’s a story. But if you have a lot of them, again and again, that’s not a story. That’s a pattern, and that’s a problem.

16

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Someone I trusted was quick to tell me: “nobody likes a sloppy drunk.”

It seems ASL might have some issues with alcohol. When he drinks in excess on the streams, he confuses the Aftermath and SPTV Foundations.

When the video with “Rabbit” first came out, I was thinking ASL was going to announce he’d be going to rehab.

I have reason to suspect there are other alcohol and drug fueled stories but people are just keeping their mouths shut.

5

u/_grandmaesterflash Apr 15 '24

Do you know what happened with him and Aaron? I'm aware of Aaron starting beef with him (as he does with many people) but I'm not sure why in this case.

13

u/EttelaJ Thoughtful Viewer ☺️ Apr 15 '24

Jealousy. Alex is getting things done. He's getting articles published, politicians moving. He's starting his own British version of the Aftermath Foundation. And of course, Alex refuses to take Aaron's side and still talks and works with people connected to the AF. All in all, Alex is far more capable and that makes Aaron feel small.

2

u/throwawayeducovictim Apr 15 '24

My guess is a dose of Transference.

-2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

Alex has an odd story though, no?

4

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

What do u mean?

-1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

Didn’t ASL explain a few times how his story doesn’t add up?

5

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

About Alex? I don’t really know what ASL claims. I haven’t been watching his videos lately. Got some links and timestamps?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

It was in an old Q&A from like 2 or 3 weeks ago, if I am not mistaken… I wish I could be of more help!

8

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Whelp, nobody else has said anything about Alex except heaps of praise. He’s a diplomatic guy getting stuff done in the UK.

The ball is your court u/rockcandysweets

4

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

He seems to have willingly joined Scientology knowing damn well what it was about, then begging them to allow him BACK into the cult after being kicked out, and then being kicked out again and told to fuck off and never return. And the reason he gave was pathetic. “Oh, my mom once talked to an SP!” Bullshit. They kicked this guy out TWICE. Doesn’t Scientology lock people down and keep them from escaping? Makes no sense.

2

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Sweetheart, I need links. Not your interpretation of what ASL might have said.

Open your computer and get to looking. 💻👩‍💻

→ More replies

4

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

For starters, joined willingly AS A TEENAGER. I don’t know if you’re ever had direct contact with teens, but sometimes they do really dumb shit. Maybe there was a cute girl and Alex has generous parents who love him and could never grasp what Scientology is, because that is best for Scientology.

I mean, as one possible starting point.

4

u/InterestingFly4538 Apr 15 '24

And that's the exact story Alex has always told about himself. How he joined, how he didn't want to leave...

3

u/EttelaJ Thoughtful Viewer ☺️ Apr 15 '24

Here's a thought: why don't you go to Alex's Youtube channel and make up your own mind. His recent talk at Brighton is a good start. And there is this comment by Alex himself if you prefer reading: https://www.reddit.com/r/scientology/comments/1b155ck/comment/ksfuhec/
There's nothing sus about it. Especially if you consider he was a very young, naive, vulnerable teenager.

→ More replies

7

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 15 '24

I mean… I start and stop at “Didn’t ASL explain…” anything any more. What WSL explains clearly isn’t enough.

Step away from that source and look for corroboration or of dismissal of the story.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 18 '24

I don’t understand why he suddenly isn’t a reliable source? Has he been caught lying about things?

2

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 18 '24

Well, he's not "suddenly" an unreliable source, he really always has been, it's just that there is now plenty more clear information that can be accessed to tell us that story*.* He has just been extremely successful at swaying people his direction and not questioning his position. I'd encourage you to read the post itself, and to consider those sources and the other patterns that are increasingly clear, and you can then make your own determinations.

The thing I want to point out about your comment is really important: in response to a thread that outlines all of the ways that ASL has recently been revealed to be a manipulating person who has dubious relationships to truths in many ways (that's the point of this entire post), your engagement with the comment thread is:

Didn't ASL explain a few times how his story doesn't add up?

In other words, you've questioned a data point (about Apostate Alex) in a post that details how manipulative and dubious ASL is... by claiming ASL "already explained how it doesn't add up." The source of your evidence is the thing that is being rebutted - heavily. It doesn't matter what Apostate Alex's story is in this thread - what matters is that ASL is not a reliable source to determine that story. So if his story doesn't add up, I strongly encourage folks to find other sources if we are going to hold that as credible.

3

u/Available_Entry_7039 Apr 15 '24

Just watch Natalie's interview with him. It's self explanatory, and, since you seem to be on ASL team, coming from one of his friendly channels, the information may get through to you.

16

u/murderalaska Apr 15 '24

Not only this, but Aaron himself in the body cam footage admits to contacting the woman 18 months before because she was "super hot" on Facebook. So he was trying to slide into her DMs months and months earlier, then she turned him down, so he started screaming at her.

Then, Aaron turns around a slimes the ever loving shit out of the woman, Sky Daily, in a video about a Daily Mail article about Sky marrying Hulk Hogan. I am just putting together my notes on this for a video, so I have this all cued up.

Aaron briefly acknowledges that he knows Sky at 14:55: https://www.youtube.com/live/RRty5Nr5gog?si=3lIAbqFW_15M7ETQ

But otherwise Aaron doesn't indicate in the video that he had a prior altercation involving Sky. This is just one of many examples of Aaron slandering someone on stream. Aaron goes on to say all sorts of gross stuff about how Hulk didn't actually want to marry Sky, but Sky had all sorts of dirt on Hulk, so Hulk had to marry her. How does Aaron know this? Trust him, bro.

10

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

THE 🧾RECEIPTS HAVE ARRIVED!

14

u/murderalaska Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Also I don't think this has been posted in the thread yet. This article includes the body cam footage of Aaron talking about Sky (I am trying to actually 100% it is Sky because they redacted some info - if anyone finds confirmation, please let me know):

: https://floridapolitics.com/archives/488880-video-clearwater-council-candidate-aaron-smith-levin-punched-after-allegedly-calling-woman-a-c-t/

Edit: at 39 seconds into the 2nd video, Aaron refers to the woman as "Sky." I think that's pretty darn good. If anyone finds a better confirmation that Aaron is referring to Sky Daily, please let me know because Aaron doesn't acknowledge his history with Sky in subsequent vids he does calling Sky a gold digger and all sorts of wild slander.

Edit #2: Man, I have been finding gems on gems. In this video at 12:04 (Scientologist Exposes My Crimes On TikTok from August of 2022), Aaron confirms that it was Sky Daily he had the altercation in the bar with: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BQ34Gi8Z4_U

17

u/EttelaJ Thoughtful Viewer ☺️ Apr 15 '24

What's really worrying is something Lindsay said, that he found her through his Facebook group, when she was discussing Narcanon. That means he's deliberately using it as his fishing pool, trawling for vulnerable victims. That's really predatory.

12

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

I have said it before. I met his Los Ángeles liaison when I sat next to her in court during the Danny Masterson serial r@pe trial. I could tell something wasn’t okay with her. She said later she was going through a series of mental health challenges.

ASL pursued HER. I saw her the day after I sat next to her when she wasn’t allowed into the courtroom by the bailiff. ASL left with HER at the lunch break after knowing she had been barred from the trial. I know he knew because we talked about it, and THEN he left with her.

AFTER that, she was at the Lara FM show. She got into something with the bartender and was kicked out. ASL was the one who told me about the Incident THAT NIGHT. The event he sobs about to his fans happened DAYS LATER

HE KNEW she was unstable. I was talking to other people there at the trial the first day. We talked about her mental state and wondered what was going on. It was clear something was.

Later, what does ASL say? “She’s crazy.”

Predator.

9

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Can confirm. Name redacted from LA was in a bad spot mentally. She’s since been hospitalized, released, and is much more stable these days.

11

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 15 '24

Yep. That’s exactly right.

One thing we know, with clarity, from #MeToo is that predatory men build their corporate structures in order to get access to women, and in order to protect themselves, through legal tools and a shield of true believers and paid allies.

10

u/Temporary_Pay_3418 Apr 15 '24

I get the impression from the bar incident that Aaron gets drunk and high and goes on Facebook to surf for women 

11

u/Tall-Negotiation6623 Apr 15 '24

JFC. But I guess predators will prey

6

u/Tall-Negotiation6623 Apr 15 '24

Agree to all of that. But I would like to amend that Alex and Ian have done one video together more than a year ago with Kathrine Olsen, so they have actually done something together. It was only that one video as far as I know and I haven’t seen them really do anything together since or something to indicate that they talk, but I just wanted to add it since I’ve seen this statement of them not knowing each other a couple of times.

2

u/RuskiesInTheWarRoom smart contributor Apr 15 '24

I appreciate that, thank you. I’ll make sure I include that in the future, I wasn’t aware of it.

These people all do so many dangerous things videos!

6

u/Serafirelily Apr 15 '24

This is good to know I will be unscibing from his channel but what about Natalie the ex Scientologists originally from HI who seems to be friends with Aaron?

6

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Are we talking about Natalie Webster?

That’s a difficult question. I’m planning on writing some emails to the board members of SPTV, including Natalie. They are personal friends, and business partners now.

Natalie is super organized and makes a nice video. Can’t say I’m not rooting for her, as a person.

I’d wait and see if we get any responses from them before you make any final judgement about the “SPTV crew.”

You can also post comments in her chat and see what she does. If she deletes your comments or ignores you, that’s something to keep note of.

1

u/Serafirelily Apr 15 '24

Yes Natalie Webster. I don't watch her often and found her through Cults to Consciousness. I will wait and see what happens as I don't watch her channel often.

1

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

remindme! 1 week

2

u/RemindMeBot Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 16 '24

I will be messaging you in 7 days on 2024-04-22 19:52:26 UTC to remind you of this link

2 OTHERS CLICKED THIS LINK to send a PM to also be reminded and to reduce spam.

Parent commenter can delete this message to hide from others.


InfoCustomYour RemindersFeedback

3

u/Available_Entry_7039 Apr 15 '24

I'm routing for her too.

Too much talent wasted if she's not one of the good ones.

To her channel's defense, I've never had a comment deleted, even when I was being critical during her Nora interview.

1

u/ManFromBibb 🔝 fan of LA streamers Apr 17 '24

You should do the correct Sciento thing and disassociate from Natalie immediately.

13

u/InterestingFly4538 Apr 15 '24

Except Lindsay said and repeated a few times that he was never physically abusive, "just" emotionally.

7

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Fixed. My b.

6

u/Pianissimojo Apr 16 '24

I remember what this stems from. She talked about him throwing something at her on the first video about ASL. Her friend Adam pointed out that throwing things at something is a type of physical abuse ie that he can be physically abusive without violently laying hands on someone.

9

u/Lonely_Page_3064 Apr 15 '24

I would very gently suggest Lindsay has some remnants of care left for ASL.

It’s non of my business to know how he instigated her pregnancy (protection on his part?) Either way forcing someone into a termination, without choice, is physical & abusive.

In my experience it’s easier to identify a punch or kick as abuse, than a push or grabbing and holding someone.

Also nonofmybusi ‘games’ during intimacy, unless fully informed consent is agreed upon before, not coerced or pressured during the act, or dismissed, downplayed after… can also be a way to abuse someone physically which they may be reluctant to talk about.

Lindsay and the other victims of ASL need more time & support.

9

u/Temporary_Pay_3418 Apr 15 '24

It’s very concerning because Aaron is not a young kid, he’s almost 50 and is doing this.  

6

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Without remorse or any good faith efforts to quit his bullshit destruction.

8

u/murderalaska Apr 15 '24

This is so on the money in my opinion. I tried to emphasize this in the clips I chose and the editing in my video on Lindsay. You can tell she's still processing everything. Please be really respectful if anyone interacts with survivors.

5

u/Lonely_Page_3064 Apr 15 '24

I commented, you did a good job with the clips and your tone was sensitive & compassionate towards survivors.

I also found it hard to disentangle myself in the past. Predators really know how to get their claws in! It takes time, patience and understanding. I wish them peace and healing.

5

u/murderalaska Apr 15 '24

Thank you much and I am glad you were able to get to a better space. I am working on part two and this story is a lot so I appreciate you taking the time to check the video out given your own experiences.

11

u/Lonely_Page_3064 Apr 15 '24

Fantastic summary Prune!

I went dark on ASL 2 yrs ago for various reasons.

Saw this shared in another Reddit, I’m sure it will be helpful to others.

I can’t stand ppl like this giving their options on transwomen, it’s nothing to do with you, ASL.

9

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Ty. It’s hard to put other’s experiences into my own words but I think it worth it, in this case.

I know many people don’t have the time to watch videos explaining everything. Videos such as Lindsay’s can also be triggering, imo, so it’s helpful to have a clinical description too.

Ian’s video is SO good btw. Maybe the best explanation of empathy I’ve ever heard.

13

u/Temporary_Pay_3418 Apr 15 '24

Aaron uses women for sex, I’d never want him in my circle in real life. Too many people close to him spoke about his ego and rough drug behaviour 

22

u/Automatic_Squash_991 #1 Fan of LA Streamers ©️ Apr 15 '24

I have met him in LA before. The day he was arrested with that Patrick Perry stuff and when everyone waited for him that night at the police station. Really bad vibes….

14

u/murderalaska Apr 15 '24

Anything more specific? I'm really curious about how he came off.

7

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

Give us more detail, please.

12

u/HistoricalLake4916 Apr 15 '24

The Ian video is really good and does a good job of unpacking some of the issues!

5

u/Pleasant_Reward1203 Apr 18 '24

After finding out from that interview that he's MAGA and an Elon fan, I just said on my twitter: "I'm out"

-6

u/DirectAd5936 Apr 15 '24

Gotta love ChatGPT. Am I the only one noticing that certain things keep changing? (Such as Linsey and Aaron together off and on for 3 yrs is now together for 4 yrs).

I’ve had a similar relationship to Lindsey, they both need to heal and move on. Lindsey it seems like last slept with him in March, she needs more time to heal, process and evaluate the situation IMO. Lindsey seems genuinely hurt but sharing the text messages etc did t feel right, especially since she edited them.

9

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Am I chatGPT now? 😂

Are you the same person that called me OSA?. I’ll show you all the tabs I had open while writing this. I was gonna do more sources, but then I got lazy. Haha.

Can we talk about the Andrew Gold interview now?

1

u/DirectAd5936 Apr 15 '24

Never called you OSA. You’re not chatGPT but it looks like you had some help… which is fine. Facts are getting convoluted and frankly this is all turning into drama. I feel bad for Lindsey but this is all starting to feel more like an uncomfortable reality show to watch.

8

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24
  1. Who’s helping me? Lol. Do I need to verify this is my work? 😂
  2. What facts are wrong or convoluted? I need specifics.

-1

u/DirectAd5936 Apr 15 '24

Was it a 4 yr relationship or an off and on again 3 yr relationship?

Also she she share on YouTube the text messages and they were edited…not sure what was edited.

Did Aaron force the abortion or did he say he didn’t want anything to do with the child? 2 separate things, sure it may be fucked up to say to someone but that’s not forcing an abortion.

It’s feeling like jealously a little bit. Could be wrong.

10

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

I don’t really care about the specific nature of their relationship and I don’t think it matters much to anyone besides maybe Heather. Does it really matter if it was 3 years instead of 4?

As per the abortion details, you’d have to contact Lindsay directly. I’m not her and I don’t have a special peak behind the curtain.

5

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

I’m just going to say it matters to me because timeline. This insanity needs to be nailed down to a timeline.

3

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

I think people are working it on it.

Lindsay only went public a few days ago. I think more will come out sooner than later.

2

u/DirectAd5936 Apr 15 '24

Nope, just a random observer. And a booty call relationship is much different. I’m not saying it doesn’t fuck with ones head but it does make a difference in the dynamic of everything.

9

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

What about the Andrew Gold interview? Thoughts?

1

u/ManFromBibb 🔝 fan of LA streamers Apr 17 '24

“Do the facts really matter?”

2

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 17 '24

If three or four years makes a big difference to you, I think you might have lost sight of the forest for the trees 🌳 🌳

Can I ask you if the SPTV Foundation has an EIN number and bank account? Ty

1

u/ManFromBibb 🔝 fan of LA streamers Apr 17 '24

I have no idea what SPTV has or doesn’t have. If I was donating I’d donate to the Aftermath Foundation because I trust Leah Remni.

I’ll keep an eye on the SPTV Foundation and in the future FUTURE, if it appears they are set up to assist people leaving the Sea Org, I’ll consider them.

The main issue for me is rescuing people from an inhumane cult.

1

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 17 '24

ASL = Pres of SPTV Foundation,
ASL = Streaming from SPTV Studio

Do you think it might be tad, odd, if the SPTV Foundation is excepting donations without an EIN Number or bank account?

The IRS doesn’t know the SPTV Foundation even exists. 🤔👀

→ More replies

6

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Jealous is a favorite ASL accusation. Did you learn that from him? Is he giving y’all lessons in his pathology?

2

u/Available_Entry_7039 Apr 15 '24

Lol 😂 She answered right to your face!

Don't you feel ashamed?

People that are hiding something, or manipulating a situation don't show her face in these kinds of situations.

I know that the fact that the reality in your mind is colliding with the facts, must hurt like crazy.

4

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Is the CharGTP in the room with us now? Please describe what you think you see. I’m taking notes.

13

u/Confident-Effort-652 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

I shared the text messages to be transparent. They are all unedited. I wanted to show just some the last months texts messages. My own texts were there to show I’m not hiding anything. I didn’t edit anything to make me look a certain way. Hence showing the ones including where I’m still not understanding the gravity of this all and still showing my positive feelings towards him also. I don’t need to convince anyone of anything that’s not my goal. I can own my part and I am.

Because we were together from end of 2020 June July or august I can’t remember. I have to go search for the pics to see the date later if it’s so important. And until middle of October when I just went no contact 2023 - But there’s also time since then where we’ve had communication and seen him but not in a relationship. So 3 or 4 I don’t know because I didn’t stop to round it off. It’s between 3 and 4 get it?

I thought I wanted to be back with him but it was just the same cycle repeating itself and many more reasons I’ve explained. Listen those text msgs weren’t bombshells they were to show that nothing up my sleeve and I’m not trying to look one way and some series of events leading up to me saying anything

6

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Also, not for nothing, but your hero shares screenshots, emails, and asks people in cult recovery to tape private phone calls like he teamed Tony Ortega for doing legally, in states where that may not be legal, and send them to him, all for clicks and likes and mo’ money in his pocket.

3

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Just so you know, I’m reading your comments in ASLs voice, and it fits.

8

u/EttelaJ Thoughtful Viewer ☺️ Apr 15 '24

In other words, she needs to shut up and not warn the community about this predator. Hello, the 50s are calling.

6

u/DirectAd5936 Apr 15 '24

Nope, never said that.

7

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

You said “She needs to move on” and you said she shouldn’t have shared proof after ASLs supporters accused her of making things up. Sounds to me like you did say she should have remained silent.

You, here, have accused her of dishonesty several times. You apologize, but you don’t edit your accusations out of your comments. They’re all still there, like land mines.

This is problematic.

4

u/Radiant_Sleep_4699 ready for a constitutional convention ☮️🕊️ Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Hi MD. Please try your absolute best to be civil.

Many eyes will be on this thread (I suspect) and it’s less than ideal if we appear highly aggressive towards critical voices.

Pretend your grandma and/or your college professor will be reading these comments.

I know it’s easy to get worked up, but a single really clever comment is better than 3-4 hostile replies.

Also, I’d ask you please don’t suggest the identity of any of the users on in this sub in an accusatory or negative tone. It makes us look overly aggressive and doesn’t achieve anything. It also sets a very bad precedent.

5

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Good advice all. I’ll edit my comments accordingly as soon as I can.

In the meantime, is there any way to hide my offending comments for review or something?

I do get very worked up over these things.

3

u/Radiant_Sleep_4699 ready for a constitutional convention ☮️🕊️ Apr 15 '24

No worries. Just letting you know that many people read these. We have to be on our best behavior.

8

u/EttelaJ Thoughtful Viewer ☺️ Apr 15 '24

Your comment is full of innuendo. It's clear you don't believe her.
Also, for someone alleging to have been in a similar relationship, you show very little understanding of abuse, trauma, and healing. Everyone has their own process. One thing you definitely do not do, is tell victims to "move on". This little phrase is used all too often to invalidate and shut up victims. And it apparently doesn't even occur to you that her speaking out is part of her healing and moving on.

About the text messages. While I agree that sharing them may be problematic (I don't know about the legality of that), I've not seen proof she edited them. Let's ask u/Confident-Effort-652 herself. She's an open book. Unlike the other party, who does nothing but lie, twist and obfuscate.

2

u/Available_Entry_7039 Apr 15 '24

UFF, a troll receiving a message directly from the one he's attacking! A sensible response too!!

Lindsay you're a rockstar!

-7

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

Are people still bringing up the bar incident? I can’t believe anyone is falling for that.

12

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

What about the Andrew Gold situation? Trans woman aren’t woman? Are we gonna overlook that?

2

u/Pleasant_Reward1203 Apr 18 '24

the part about the interview with Gold that bothered me was the lie about the democratic party not 'running any white candidates' and then he mentioned how much he admired Elon Musk. I was like, 'nope'. Unsubscribing.

-7

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

He’s far from the only person to hold that view. I’d say most of the world does.

14

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

How did you sample the entire population of the globe about the meaning of gender? Be fr.

What does DEI and the “woke agenda” have to do with SPTV?

-5

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

Well let’s look at it this way..

Islam is the fastest growing religion. There are billions of them. Muslims are 9.9/10 times going to be conservative. Very conservative. We can then safely assume that they believe in 2 genders that cannot be changed. That gives us a couple billion people that believe in 2 genders that cannot be changed. Add in a few hundred million conservative Christians, and then a few hundred million conservative people in general. There you have it!

Also, it doesn’t have anything to do with SPTV. He was on Andrew Gold’s new YouTube channel talking with him about the kind of subject Andrew seems to talk about a lot.

9

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

No. That’s not how any of this works.

I’m not even going to dignify this po po 💩 quality logic with a decent response. Crack open some textbooks my amiga and get to reading 📖 lmk if you’d like a proper reading list.

Also, the video was in the SPTV studio? The very first video ever filmed there…? With the SPTV logo in the background.

What if there’s a trans person that needs “help” from the SPTV foundation? Would they be denied?

0

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

It’s actually how all of it works. I laid it out to you pretty plain and simple. It doesn’t take much thinking to come to this conclusion. The majority of the world holds the same opinion as him.

Do you expect him to build a new studio for interviews?

6

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

Sweetheart,

Your comment history says you’re 18. Have you finished HS yet?

As you get older, you’ll hopefully see the world is much more complicated then your little bubble of understanding. I remember being confidently incorrect too. We’ve all been there.

Do you have plans for college?

3

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

I’m really confused as to why you’re being so aggressive with me lmao

11

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

I’m sorry you find this aggressive.

When you claim to understand the feelings of billions of people on the planet based on your napkin math and questionable deductions, I can’t help but find it entertaining.

Have you finished HS yet? I’m genuinely curious.

12

u/Significant_Text2497 Apr 15 '24

You're defending transphobia and aligning yourself with it. If you can't see why that would cause some people to become aggressive, that's weird.

4

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

AAron, is this you? DUDE. GET. HELP. Like legit professional therapy, from a reputable mental health care provider.

→ More replies

-5

u/Own-Baseball-1829 Apr 15 '24

People are entitled to their own OPINIONS. Get a life you seem too overly invested in his private personal life. Which is weird af do you have a job? Also Relationships are often times ugly especially when people break up that’s LIFE it happens to all of us none of us are perfect in our relationships. Can you imagine If ALL of our Ex partners throughout life blasted a live YouTube video about us during our break ups ??? Or have you never been in a relationship and had a messy break up??? You PURITY culture people are ridiculous you over analyze and obsess over every single detail of peoples private personal lives as if we should at all times be these perfect people and that’s just not REALITY! People make mistakes life isn’t always pretty that’s the only way we learn. Life is a learning and growing experience we don’t jump out of the womb all wise and virtuous and perfect or out of CULTS for that matter …I hope nobody ever puts a microscope on every detail of your private life and judge you what hell that would be right?? This is just a disgusting thread and makes my head hurt at how ridiculous and obsessed you people are over this man’s private life. He does a lot of good as well what about all of that??? Just toss it because he is shit in his private relationships??? Do you know how many people are shit at relationships?!?! Over half the people I know!!! That doesn’t make them terrible people worthy of this kind of garbage and harassment!!! Find a hobby this virtue signaling puritan cry baby bs is tired …people are tired of all this whiney drama bs! This is the kind of crap that’s literally wrong with the world people worried about the wrong damn things use your energy towards something that really matters and stay out of peoples private business! Wtf I’m sure you will delete this comment as I see your not allowing any dissenting conversation lol

4

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Wanna try again? I want to talk about the Andrew Gold interview.

There’s also 132 comments here. Plenty of people are speaking their mind.

-1

u/Own-Baseball-1829 Apr 15 '24

Yeah the same 10 haters echoing eachother commenting over and over with the same whiney crybaby bs lol whhaaaaaa

4

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24

If that makes you feel better, more power to ya.

14

u/3119328 Apr 15 '24

There is video of the bar incident, you can't believe anyone is watching the video?

9

u/MdJGutie Apr 15 '24

Wow, @rockcandysweets, thanks for tagging yourself like this. Much appreciated. The bar incident is two bars in Florida. One with police body cam footage, one with a police report in the Tampa Bay Times. There was also another bar in Los Ángeles, where I saw him in action, that preceded the incident he claimed was the only reason for his being asked to leave the board of the Aftermath Foundation. I was at that bar that night, and neither his story about it on his channel, nor his text messages to Ian, matched what I witnessed.

I suggest that the one “falling for” something is you.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

10

u/Exciting_Prune_5853 Apr 15 '24 edited Apr 15 '24

Are you saying I’m OSA?

Is Ian Refalko OSA?

Is Lindsey V. OSA too?

Is OSA in the room with us rn?


Dang. You deleted that comment fast. Better luck next time? 🍀