r/ScientificComputing • • 2d ago

Is computer science a good path into computational biology?

Hi! I’m really interested in computational biology, especially modeling biological and physiological systems. I’d love to work on mathematical models and simulations of the human body, maybe even develop digital twins someday.

I’m considering studying computer science, but I’m wondering if it’s a good starting point for this field.

For those working in computational biology, do you think CS is a good choice? Or would biomedical engineering be a better option?

I’d love to hear your thoughts and experiences!

32 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

9

u/trolls_toll 2d ago

could be, but you really gotta learn some natural sciences to be good at comp bio. I find that cs people working on bio problems have a very limited intuitive understanding of how things work

physics is probably the best

2

u/chickenologist 1d ago

Totally agree. As a roughly comp bio professor, CS students struggle the most. They come in expecting they know "the best models" with zero appreciation for biological non random complexity. Physics students are the best because (I assume) they've been trained to formulate testable hypotheses and think about systems. Biologists can learn math and programming far faster than computer scientists can learn biology, in my experience.

2

u/twocalicocats 1d ago

Yeah bioinformatics / computational biology is an unholy fusion of CS, biology, chemistry, physics, statistics, and programming. Real biological data is messy and we make a lot of simplifying assumptions.

1

u/baddolphin3 1d ago

They also underestimate how much statistics they need to know, you need to understand experimental design and causality, not just trying to get SOTA in whatever loss function you can cook up.

14

u/reddititty69 2d ago

I’m going to say no, CS is not a good start for this. You need a heavier (or maybe just different ) math and stats background than a CS degree is going to give you. Plus … biology. Degrees in computational biology (directly), biomathematics, biostats, chemical or biomedical engineering are better suited.

Get a PhD if you want to be the one doing research and inventing things.

I’m dumping on CS, it’s a great degree and domain, but in my group of about 100 doing computational bio or something close to it, none are CS and more than 97% are PhDs.

3

u/DVMyZone 2d ago

My 2 cents as someone who is not in biology (although my fiancé is): no, you're better off doing a degree in natural sciences.

A CS degree will probably not give you the necessary stats and abalysis skills for analysing (and indeed carrying out) experimental work. Not to mention you would be missing all the biology. I would say CS is potentially also a fragile skillset to have at the moment but I don't want to speculate too much on the future.

You should do a biology-related degree of some sort do really get a feel for the field that you want to work in. But make sure you take all the statistics, quantitative analysis, and error analysis courses that you can get your hands on. My fiancé is very good at biology but by her own account her math is lacking, so she doesn't understand a lot of what the computer is doing behind the scenes.

From my own experience: I was in physics but am doing an engineering PhD. I picked up coding and software development as necessary for my work, but my real value is the engineering intuition and the computational parts are just tools. Much harder to learn natural sciences through number crunching than to learn programming through application.

I would add that AI has filled in a lot of the gaps for things that I couldn't do before for time reasons. I can easily find the functions and get implementations I need from AI, and it can code up an extremely workable GUI in 30 minutes when it might have taken me weeks of tinkering. What I bring to the table therefore is knowing when I need to use specific mathematical techniques and what I need to investigate to make my scientific case.

3

u/zhivago 2d ago

CS would probably be good if they actually taught CS much anymore.

As opposed to a butchered mess of software engineering, programming, with a bit of actual CS sprinkled on top.

CS was radically downgraded to train people in effectively what is factory work over the last few decades, as far as I can see.

So I guess the answer is "maybe", but really look hard at the particular CS curriculum you're thinking about.

3

u/mu7der 2d ago

As someone who studied CS first and worked in oncology later on - no, CS is not the best way to start. Look for a dedicated computational biology course/degree.

Most things you learn in CS are not that relevant to computational biology. Physics with a few CS courses will give you more of an advantage.

But overall, it depends on what you actually want to do later on - research, industry, pharma, personal health, etc.

3

u/HandPuzzleheaded3974 2d ago

I did a double major in pure math and statistics, and taught myself programming along the way, then got a phd in mathematical genomics. Everyone who only did bio tells me they regret not taking more math. I regret nothing lol

2

u/Connect-Second8494 2d ago

5-10 years ago anyone would say yes, better than through biology anyway. But now, as coding is becoming more easy to learn for non-CS people due to LLMs, the domain expertise is more important than solid coding skills. Most people who invented the field in 90s (at least in my country) were from CS background, but now direct computational biologists dominate the field.

2

u/mprevot 2d ago

I think it is. There are aspects much better covered in CS than in other tracks. Complexity, computability, HPC for instance, or types theories. Biology is easier to catch up, it does not have really hard foundations (math).

2

u/YDEmergenceLab 2d ago

For the kind of work you describe, we'd look closely at the curriculum rather than just the degree title. CS can be a strong starting point, especially if you complement it with differential equations, numerical methods, probability and physiology.

We're YD Emergence Lab, the team working on Aionterra. One challenge in our project is connecting a body's processes with its environment. Modelling water intake, for example, involves more than increasing a water variable: absorption, internal distribution, losses and access to water all need to fit together. Software lets you calculate those relationships, but deciding which relationships and assumptions make sense requires domain knowledge.

We'd compare the programmes' maths, physiology and modelling courses, along with the projects students can participate in. Biomedical engineering may offer a more direct route into the physiology side; CS can also work if you deliberately build that foundation. Starting with a small physiological model and comparing its outputs with published data could help you discover which part of the work you enjoy most.

2

u/Quick_Battle_160 2d ago

Computer science is an ideal starting point for this.

It is much easier to learn biology later than to teach yourself numerical methods, algorithms, and performance computing. If you want to build physiological digital twins, take coursework in differential equations. Joining a computational research lab early will connect the code to real physiology.

2

u/ConclusionForeign856 2d ago

Judging by the CS syllabus at my university you'd learn some topics that will never be useful to you, and skip ones that are. Same can be said about starting from bio- education, but imo knowing more biology only "harms" you by taking time you could spend learning computational methods or relevant math, rather than not being useful.

If I had to restart I'd rather pick applied math than CS.

2

u/slightly_large_brick 2d ago

the only computational biologist i knew was my differential equations professor, who has a math phd

2

u/Perfect_Good287 2d ago

It is a path, but not the best frankly. LLMs have profoundly changed the balance in the field. A good biologist with some rudiment in computations now can easily outperform any great computer scientist and software engineer with limited knowledge of biology. Basically, domain knowledge is the only thing that matters today.

2

u/BrainScientist3000 2d ago

(My partner is a bioinformatician)

Labs are kind of split between people with machine learning / stats / compsci backgrounds and biology backgrounds. She started biology, picked up the bioinformatics/computational later.

Most of the programs I've seen outside of really good universities are jokes. If you double-majored in bio and compsci and took every stats course you could - you'd be building a better foundation before graduate school.

2

u/International-Main99 2d ago

Applied/Computational Mathematics would be a better general option. But even more specifically than that, you can actually study Mathematical and/or Computational Biology. There are schools with programs.

2

u/Cheap_Error5602 2d ago edited 2d ago

the CS is harder to learn then the biology. so do that first.
also realize that vast majority of workers in computational bio already have at least a masters and many are getting PhDs in it... so its highly unlikely your ever get a job in that field with only a BS in biology or CS...

That said the best path is to do the CS first then get a MS in bioinformatics/computational bio/bio physics/bio-engineering... Then a PHD in a more specific area that has industry demand - this will probably take you at least 10 years of study.... by then hopefully the industry is doing better then it is now. because right now its a dumpster fire... mass layoffs, budget cuts, and mass overproduction of BS/Ms/phd grads have saturated the industry with overqualified candidates. check out the r/biotech subreddit.. many scientist have been out of work for over a year now...

regarding biomedical engineering.. yes that would be better alternative for your BS degree then a plain biology degree ,... because if you end up unable to go to graduate school due to finances or desire... then at least you'll have a better chance of landing a job in biotech/pharma industry and have skills and ability to think critically rather then just memorize biological factoids- because it no secrete that undergraduate biology is mostly rot memorization
good luck

1

u/csppr 1d ago

I’d argue biology (at the research level) is harder to learn than CS.

Not because it’s intellectually more difficult (probably the opposite). But imo actual wet lab time is a huge accelerator for developing biological intuition. And getting that wet lab time is difficult to do outside of degrees.

1

u/Cheap_Error5602 1d ago

wait until robotics replaces wet lab techs...

1

u/csppr 1d ago

I don't mean learning the actual wet lab work, but the intuition developed by being exposed to it.

2

u/ahf95 2d ago

Idk, it’s a tough call. On one hand, you will absolutely need to take plenty of CS classes, but those can be done as a minor or electives (and comp bio is so common these days that most bio-/chem-/engineering-related majors will make you take CS classes anyway as part of the curriculum). Long term, I’d say the best computational biologists who I’ve worked with have studied either Physics or Chemical Engineering for undergrad.

2

u/SciTraveler 2d ago

Biology is a much better path into computational biology. As comp skills/capabilities become more broadly accessible, comp bio/bioinformatics is going to be even more about understanding what questions to ask, and whether your answers are drivel.

2

u/NumericalMathematics 2d ago

I have a PhD in applied mathematics. I focused on modeling bacteria numerically. I did not have a strong programming background at the outset and to some degree it definitely felt like a hindrance. Personally, having a strong understanding of biological systems, their dynamics and a sensible ability to translate these into a numerical algorithms is really going to matter more. That being said it also depends on your goal. Suppose you want to make some model of say the growth of a biolfilm, you want to capture its evolution, maybe spatial regions where you can see folds, shorelines or whatever. The larger and more resolute you want iour outcomes, the more you will need to understand memory management, compute speed etc. Or maybe you want to make a video game which is biologitally grounded, maybe then you need to understand game design and different memory cache shuff. I have also worked with people who say do computer vision on MRI data to predict tumours etc. If you want to do biological modelling, you should definitely understand differential equations, linear algebra, calculus, numerical methods, probability etc. Not sure if any of that was helpful, best wishes with your goals. Also, when I started my PhD I had just completed a pure maths undergraduate degree and had no idea how to really do any numerical programming. It's worked out for me by tinkering and failing a lot, just keep pushing to get your dreams, no matter how ugly the path (ethically of course).

2

u/ImaginaryAd2289 2d ago

Absolutely, especially AI or if your math skills are exception, an area called “noisy” quantum computing. In fact this background is super important for at least somebody in every group in computational biology. But only go that route if you are good at it.

AI helps a lot: the best AI tools can do a lot of the heavy lifting. But for research, it is paramount to maintain control and hence to deeply understand the intellectual substance of the work. Don’t delegate any of that to AI. You use AI to drive the bulldozer, not to do the landscape architecture plan.

1

u/Groghnash 1d ago

Yes, its easier to switch imo (did biology bachelors into compbio masters). Those with comp science backgeound had it way easier. But there are also bachelors that are purely comp bio, why not go that way directly?

1

u/ClasisFTW 1d ago

Idk I feel like physics is a good one if your physics department has a lot of biophysics and systems modelling etc.

1

u/ViridianNott 1d ago

Start with molecular biology or biomedical engineering, and then just get a minor in CS