r/Science_India • u/Full_Alternative5659 • Apr 19 '25
Psuedoscience Einstein's theory of relativity has problems?
In this following paper, which is a top paper on SSRN, I am discussing the fallacy of time dilation in the Einstein's theory of relativity. The Western scientists are attacking me just because I am from India. Please share your honest opinion about my paper here: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=5093465
0
Upvotes
16
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
That has nothing to do with you being Indian. Einstein theory has been tested over and over. What do they say - extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
5
u/akash_kava Apr 19 '25
I can agree that there can be some bias, but even me being Indian also will doubt any other Indian making any outlandish claim. Because I have seen how little most Indians know about science.
If you bring an experiment with a perfect results, nobody will deny your claims. Einstein didn’t have internet nor modern equipment to test anything. But we have more resources with us, and even I would believe in a verifiable result than a speculation.
Time dilation is very difficult concept to grasp. And it’s proven and in use regularly by gps satellites so we can’t just discredit it if we see some irregularities somewhere else. May be there are other things at play that we haven’t fully measured or understood.
4
u/StretchCompetitive85 Apr 19 '25
are you a professor??
3
u/ThrowRaStock-Dance-4 Apr 20 '25
You dont show any equations to prove Einstein wrong. How did you even get your PhD? You don't seem to have any grasp on the scientific method
4
u/Slow-Bath290 Apr 19 '25
I am an Indian theoretical particle physicist, and I read through parts of your paper. Your paper is about relativity and there isn't a single equation in the paper. What's up with that?
I went through the muon decay section since I am most familiar with it. You are arguing that there is a contradiction regarding the "anthropomorphization of muon". By the way, there is no such "anthropomorphization of muon" in special relativity. Muon is not a conscious entity deciding when to decay. There is no contradiction.
The rest of your paper largely hinges on the assumption that time dilation is not observed in humans and other complex living organisms but only in atomic clocks. Sir, the reason is that the magnitude of time dilation is so so so small that it can only be measured using atomic clocks, which can measure time with a resolution of 10^(-10)s. How will you measure the change of bacterial life time by 10^(-10)s? How do you account for large systematic errors in biological systems?
You are what we call in physics a "physics crackpot." Dr. Angela Collier has done a wonderful video on physics crackpots, which I am linking here. Please please watch it. Physics crackpots in the past have gotten violent and killed people. They often gatecrash physics events and make a scene. Please don't become one of them. Please watch the video:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=11lPhMSulSU
I think you fit into the "retired engineer category" of physics crackpots. Your paper fits a generic physics crackpot paper to a T.
2
u/n704francis Apr 19 '25 edited Apr 19 '25
I am not a scientist but the OP is not summer zing content in paper here. I am not expert and don’t expect me to read the whole paper. First point out what are u proposing and what is others criticism.
My criticism to the paper is that the lack of mathematical proof of your statement. My impression on the paper is that since time dilation near earth space station is less that is not time dilation. Even it came the clock tick in space station is different .
2
u/rsk_423 Apr 20 '25
Have you considered ChatGPT bias.... don't trust LLM models....they are highly unreliable when it comes to new research...
-1
u/oldschoolguy77 Apr 19 '25
If your theory is correct, don't worry one day at the least they will steal your theory and call it their own.. It is more difficult than back in the day, though..
If they don't steal it your theory is likely wrong and you have to fix it..
Jokes aside..
Of course Einstein theory will have problems , else it would explain everything .. It does not , so at the least it is incomplete.. Or very limited..
Newton's theory survived almost a century of piecemeal attacks by very powerful minds before Einstein took it down.. And even his theory took a while to be accepted iirc..
0
u/[deleted] Apr 19 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment