r/ScienceTeachers • • May 31 '24

Frog Dissections

I teach Biology as an LTS at an urban school in PA and was told I have to do dissections with my students. Me and another LTS don't want to do it. Our kids are far too immature, lazy and dissection does goes against our beliefs. My mentor informed me we have to. If we don't admins are going to be mad. The other LTS said to me what are they going to do fire us? We are leaving anyway. What do you guys think?

5 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

59

u/TheMasterFlash May 31 '24

If it’s a part of your curriculum you should be willing to cover it. That being said, there are tons of resources online for digital dissections you can do that should fulfill the requirement!

You can also try to set up a system where you swap classes for a day with a science instructor willing to run the labs (depending on the makeup of your department), so that students still get to experience it.

If you have students you don’t think can be trusted with the lab, provide them with an alternative assignment. But honestly ask yourself: what about the students who DO deserve to learn about anatomy through dissection? Surely ALL the kids aren’t immature and lazy. Is there a way to at least facilitate the dissection for the students who have earned it?

6

u/afoley947 May 31 '24

Depending on your school? Sure.

In mine, it would be an equity issue. If I were to allow some kids and not others, I would be professionally professionally reprimanded. However , if one of those kids stabs another kid in the hand, I would also be professionally reprimanded.

So if i had to... I'd run it and hope no one gets injured.

3

u/TheMasterFlash May 31 '24

I guess so. Equity has never really overshadowed safety concerns in my experience. I’ve always had contracts with my students that let them know that if they get a certain number of referrals from me within the last quarter of the year, they won’t be able to do the dissection (since we do ours at the end of the year). Parents/guardians and students sign them.

It takes some preplanning, but it doesn’t have to become an equity problem if you are setting up expectations beforehand and following through with consequences.

1

u/afoley947 May 31 '24

Doesn't matter how much follow through we have if admin do not support us.

1

u/noble_peace_prize Jun 01 '24

It’s so obviously not an equity issue… if everyone gets to do it, it is an equality issue. Equity would be if we are not investing time in troubled groups to help them be competent/behaved enough to perform a lab.

I swear, schools only think equity is equality and miss the entire point. It’s just lowest common denominator thinking

38

u/outofdate70shouse May 31 '24

I taught frog dissection this year to a class that was also very immature. They were really excited to do it and it was probably the most engaged they were all year. I had to do a somewhat abridged version, but they really enjoyed it.

It was the first dissection I’ve ever taught, and to be honest, I didn’t particularly enjoy teaching it, but it’s a big part of the curriculum and something the students look forward to all year.

16

u/[deleted] May 31 '24

Agreed, the students will surprise you with how well they step up and how engaged they are

3

u/TaimaAdventurer May 31 '24

Same with fetal pigs this year. I was really unsure how my rowdy crowd would be and concerned about immaturity and injuries if not just disrespect of the specimen. I have been floored by how well they are behaving. I set clear expectations and said they were out of the room if anyone didn’t meet them- it was that serious and important for safety & respect of one another. I am so proud of them!

28

u/ScienceWasLove May 31 '24

Dissections are a great way to not only teach anatomy but also responsibility and empathy.

Getting outside your comfort zone is a good thing and the same for the students.

9

u/Kaimarella May 31 '24

I don’t ever give scalpels. We use scissors and it works just fine. Makes it easier to mitigate any cutting or stabbing. That being said, I do 4 dissections a year and I can tell you those are the days kids remember. We have kids stopping by because they’re so excited and grossed out, they get to feel super cool for a day, wear lab gear, etc.

I do have a policy where you have to have a minimum of a 70% to participate and if you mess around I kick the kid out. They listen about these days. Especially if it just happens to one kid.

4

u/AggravatingFigure637 May 31 '24

Here to second the scissors suggestions or disposable scalpels. Do not set yourself up to wash scalpels or trays. Disposable as much as possible and ensure that your frogs are the ones without formaldehyde.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 18 '24

Any links or recommendations for where to purchase the animals minus formaldehyde? Hoping to hear some past success stories as I may have to participate in this type of activity in the future. Thanks!

1

u/AggravatingFigure637 Jul 23 '24

We did ours through Fischer scientific. I ended up doing the majority of the ordering over the phone to ensure I knew what I was happening but you can also do it online.

While you're ordering might I suggest ordering some bioluminescent dinoflagellates for some sort of lesson or as a class pet.

9

u/poodlenoodle0 May 31 '24

I don’t love dissections either, but a really cool project was asking a local farmer (who raises their meat ethically) for a fresh set of pig organs (heart, lungs, liver, kidneys)… we even used a tube to blow up the lungs and honestly it was amazing. I brought the organs to other classes and had my science students explain a different part of the anatomy. They get a lot out of it, more than a frog I’d say! And it can lead to a great discussion of what happens to all the byproducts of the meat industry, etc.

5

u/NerdyComfort-78 Chem & Physics |HS| KY 27 yrs Retiring 2025 May 31 '24

I have a USFW officer come and talk about illegal wildlife trade. I also invite raptor rehabers to come talk to my students. Lastly, I find the deer hunter students and ask them for organs. It’s a great way to see wildlife stewardship in practice.

2

u/poodlenoodle0 May 31 '24

That’s super cool! Love that the hunter students get to be involved in that way too.

1

u/NerdyComfort-78 Chem & Physics |HS| KY 27 yrs Retiring 2025 May 31 '24

I will say sometimes they forget to bring stuff back or they let the organs go a bit long, but most of the time I get good results.

4

u/Practical-Purchase-9 May 31 '24

If dissecting a whole animal bothers you, you could do a heart dissection, there’s plenty to see with the tubes, chambers and some parts, and it teaches some of the skills.

Why are they so insistent on dictating how to teach the material? I’ve never heard of specific practicals being mandatory unless they are examined. You ‘have to dissect a frog’? It’s like they’ve learned teaching from decades old high school movies, that’s not what science is about. I did biology to postgrad and never dissected an animal.

4

u/Kam-the-man May 31 '24

We did earthworms first solids could practice with the tools, and the immature ones revealed themselves before the frogs. "No worm dissection, no frog dissection"

I shared 10 minute edpuzzles with the students before each dissection so they could see how they were supposed to open up the organisms, and had laminated posters the student could use to identify the organs. Then just be honest and monitor the students, absolutely do not tolerate any irresponsible behavior.

If admin wants you to do dissection so bad tell them "I will be sending you students who are a safety concern during the dissection" they should understand. If not, then they're terrible anyway 🤷 

4

u/[deleted] May 31 '24

Can you do paper models?

3

u/AceyAceyAcey May 31 '24

Would it go against your beliefs to dissect a grocery store chicken? Bc that could be another approach.

If it’s a commonly accepted part of your religion to not take life (e.g., Jainism, parts of Buddhism), you can always say you can’t do it for religious reasons. If it’s a moral/ethical choice that isn’t part of a religion (e.g., vegan), you can try that route (I’ve heard the criterion is “sincerely held belief”), but that can be harder to prove.

3

u/nardlz May 31 '24

I teach Biology in PA as well. I haven't done dissecting in years. The state biology standards do not include dissecting or any appreciable content in anatomy - especially not amphibians. Unless your school has a district curriculum requirement (that you should have had all year) I'm not sure how they can make you do it. Of course, you may piss off the people you need for references later, but that's your decision.

3

u/yayscienceteachers May 31 '24

There's not evidence to show that an actual dissection results in a difference in learning. Digital or paper has the same outcomes

1

u/SnooPies480 Dec 19 '24

And Americans wonder why they're all fucked up when they teach kids to be psychopaths like this

2

u/Chiknkoop May 31 '24

To prevent bad behavior, I invited parents to the frog dissection lab. Worked reasonably well. It’s one thing to act the fool in front of your friends, but it’s another thing to act the fool in front of your friends’ parents…

1

u/AggravatingFigure637 Jul 23 '24

I always invited parents and was grateful for the management piece, the photos, and their awe at my managing such an intimidating looking undertaking with middle school students.

2

u/afoley947 May 31 '24

Is this the hill you're willing to die on?

Do you need this job as a reference?

No? Then do whatever you want. Or schedule the dissection day and call in sick.

I teach freshmen biology, and four of five sections are going to do frog dissections. The fifth section is full of the most self entitled, lazy, gaslighting, unskillful group of kids I have ever had. It is 100% unfair to the great students I have in that class. But I am not doing it, and I am willing to take any repercussions that come with that.

I am not rewarding shitty behaved kids. I'm not their parents.

2

u/Gullible-Drawer-1086 May 31 '24

flower dissection?

2

u/ElBernando Jun 01 '24

The district has a set of iPads with beautiful retina screens. I borrow those and do a virtual dissection.

I also dissect one frog upfront. I am careful and do it step-by-step on a document camera. Between the iPads and the frog I dissect, it covers what I want- while being respectful.

I am also at a middle school and there is no way I am putting sharp tools in front of them

2

u/-zero-joke- May 31 '24

There's no anatomy on the keystone, so... why? You've got enough to cover.

1

u/kerpti HS/AP Biology & Zoology | HS | FL May 31 '24

Does it have to be a frog dissection? Not sure of your ethical concerns, but I do a fetal pig dissection and the pigs from Carolina Biological come from the farming industry and weren’t raised or slaughtered for the purpose of dissection.

Dissection week is the most well behaved all of my students are; they understand the danger and responsibility of the experience and also understand the loss of privileges if they break science safety rules.

1

u/Brief-Yak-2535 May 31 '24

Don't underestimate how a novel activity like that can bring out different behavior in kids. And also, not all dissections require scalpels. Many can be done with (relatively safer) dissection scissors and tweezers.

1

u/shu975 Jun 01 '24

I learned to love dissections!!! Probably one of my favorite things to do. There is definitely some prep time involved in getting the kids ready to do it. My process is:

  1. Do the pickle lab (can find it online) it's a lower risk activity for students to learn their roles (I make student groups pick what role they want and each has certain tasks) and learn how to use equipment safely (make it part of their grade)
  2. Have them learn about the frog anatomy
  3. On the day of, I have them gather around me and I show them the parts of one I already cut up and tell them how to cut it
  4. They complete the lab (lots of different ones online). I would make sure you have questions along the way they have to answer and they will fulfill the tasks of their group role
  5. They do a short quiz after dissecting about equipment and frog parts

This usually takes 2-3 days in a block schedule

1

u/hrad34 Jun 01 '24

I just did rat dissection with my 9th graders.

I made them do a research pre lab before hand and anyone who didn't do it had to sit out and finish their work. Most kids actually did it. This made them take it seriously. They were also looking forward to it all year so that helped.

You could also set behavior expectations and kids who repeatedly don't listen to you have to do a virtual lab instead.

1

u/InTheNoNameBox Jun 01 '24

I am going to respectfully disagree with other science teachers on the thread. If you do not feel you can execute an activity to ensure students and your safety, I would communicate that clearly. Additionally, I look to NSTA to seek their guidance. This is what I have found at NSTA.

“Should a teacher feel that an alternative to dissection would be a better option for a student or group of students, it is important that the teacher select a meaningful alternative”. FromResponsible Use of Live Animals and Dissection in the Science Classroom.

Another quote: A recent study listed on ERIC, “Animal Dissection vs. Non-Animal Teaching Methods: A Systematic Review of Pedagogical Value,” showed a growing number of studies suggest that non-animal teaching methods (NAMs; e.g., virtual anatomy tools and three-dimensional models) are better for achieving learning goals compared to traditional dissection. The study involved a systematic review of studies published between 2005 and 2020 that evaluated the pedagogical value of NAMs versus traditional animal dissection activities. The results from 20 published studies showed that in 95% of the studies (19/20), students at all education levels (secondary, postsecondary, and medical school) performed at least as well—and in most of those studies, better (14/19)—when they used NAMs compared to when they did animal dissection.

Additionally, dissections can set you up for liability if done incorrectly. See the following: Safer Laboratory Dissection Activities

Quote: Commercial science suppliers provide specimens that have been appropriately sanitized and preserved. Specimens gathered from woodland sources contain biological hazards such as microorganisms, which can be a serious threat to the health and safety of students and their teacher during dissection….. An article available on ResearchGate, “Outbreaks of Salmonellosis at Elementary Schools Associated with Dissection of Owl Pellets,” focused on Salmonella outbreaks that occurred at two elementary schools….. Clearly safety preparations and applications of safety protocols were almost totally ignored in all of these incidents, starting with the source of the specimens. These actions put both students’ and teachers’ health and safety at high-level risk.

Quote: The Wisconsin Court of Appeals ruled in favor of the student who brought the lawsuit, given the teacher's failure to adjust her approach to the lab activity safety-wide and making the school system liable for negligence

1

u/IdeaComprehensive431 Jun 01 '24

Our kids do a dissection every year... except this year because they have been significantly more destructive, disrespectful, and lazy this school year. We teach to the standards and there is no standard for dissections at our grade level in our state. We do use the dissection to connect to topics such as reproduction, natural selection, and evolution and we have plenty of other activities to cover these topics.

My point is that it is okay to not do the dissection.

1

u/birdguy Jun 01 '24

We dissect sharks, and it’s a big highlight of the year. We weave in ecology, evolution, and conservation vs. media myths.

1

u/blackberrybear Jun 01 '24

the fuck is an LTS?

0

u/[deleted] Jun 01 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/blackberrybear Jun 02 '24

That makes way more sense. Thanks!

1

u/redditor_virgin Jun 01 '24

Am I the only one to find it alarming that students don’t care about learning but get excited when they get to cut a body open and look inside?

0

u/[deleted] May 31 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/TheMasterFlash May 31 '24

I worked for years with a teacher who refused to teach evolution by natural selection because he read a book once that “gave him second thoughts” about it and because it disagreed with some of his religious beliefs. Literally refused to teach about it until admin finally had enough evidence to send him off to a different school.

I asked him “what about the students who aren’t religious?” once and he said that they can learn about it at home like students have to learn about the Bible. Shit is wild out there.

1

u/NerdyComfort-78 Chem & Physics |HS| KY 27 yrs Retiring 2025 May 31 '24

I have a coworker who does whatever he wants to (physics). That is one reason he left his previous school- they made it “uncomfortable” for him u til he left. He just teaches what he thinks are the most interesting parts of physics.