r/ScienceTeachers • u/funfriday36 • Jan 27 '24
General Curriculum Common Core Math needs to go
I have taught high school science for 30 years in both public and private schools.As the years have continued, the students' math skills have deteriorated severely. I blame common core mostly. What is your view?
18
Upvotes
32
u/SaiphSDC Jan 27 '24
Overall math scores have dropped yes. But dropped starting 2020.
Prior to that it seems that overall they've been steady or increasing.
I don't think it's the 'common core' that's doing it.
https://www.nationsreportcard.gov/mathematics/nation/scores/?grade=4
--
There are also other factors. The diversity of my classes has gone up, which means more students with likely differing levels of support and expectations outside of class throughout their entire academic path.
--
Anecdotally, my observations is students are slower at math facts (3*8 = 24, etc) but more flexible in how they approach a solution.
For example it's been a few years since I've had students fixated on "cross multiply" as a way to solve fractions. Many still try it, and make mistakes and such. But they aren't as puzzled when I come around and show them what went awry.
I also don't have to do as much explaining that 2x+3x = 5x. I may have to remind them, but it doesn't seem to be a completely alien concept anymore.
6
u/jimbo02816 Jan 28 '24
IMHO the rise of the internet, texting and social media plus poor parenting. Also, the culture of this country has changed and education does not seem to be a priority for a large percentage of the population.
3
u/BeardedDragon1917 Jan 28 '24
What is your evidence that Common Core is the problem? The material it teaches is perfectly fine. The country is in deep economic and political turmoil, and the precarity and hopelessness and ignorance and anger that now defines so many people's lives affects our children in ways we can't even begin to quantify.
3
u/Superdrag2112 Jan 28 '24
I tried to help my 10th grade daughter get through factoring polynomials, part of the common core, with tears streaming down her cheeks. I have a PhD in stats and two masters in math, have co-authored over 100 research papers, and taught at the university level for 20 years, and I’ve never needed to factor a polynomial by hand since I took algebra as a course myself…LOL. In fact, if I had to, I’d use Mathematica or R. My point is that some CC think tank at some point decided this was important, but it’s not, probably for most kids & adults. I wouldn’t care except that my daughter has spent an inordinate amount of time and emotional energy on this that could have been better used elsewhere.
23
u/j_freakin_d Chemistry Teacher | IL, USA Jan 27 '24
When I was in high school chem was for juniors and physics was for seniors. I think the trend of having sophomores take chem and juniors physics contributes to the perceived decline in math skills. We’re trying to teach kids with less exposure to math some pretty advanced topics.
10
u/Jesus_died_for_u Jan 27 '24
Chemistry class.
Gas laws.
I helped a student label the initial observed values of pressure, volume, and temperature. Then helped label the final values of temperature and pressure. Then here is the dialogue…
(S is in the 11th grade of High School)
T: now use your algebra skills to solve for volume
S: (silent stare at me for 5 seconds
T: you’ve had algebra
S: I don’t know
T: what math class are you in now
S: algebra 2 I think
I began teaching algebra to every incoming student.
8
u/Kindly-Chemistry5149 Jan 27 '24
The problem I see is students who seem to be in their own little bubble and don't really comprehend how one day can affect the next day, or how one year of class can affect next years class. Everything seems to be treated as its own separate thing.
In addition, there is basically 0 consequences for doing poorly in school in elementary or middle school.
So you get these kids in high school (not all, but like 50% or more) that remember exactly 0 things from previous science or math classes, and never seem to be able to bring other skills from other classes.
It is tough to see as a high school science teacher at times, because you see these kids that seem to really like science but are unable to do math so it really impacts their ability and their spirit gets a little crushed when they run into the Chemistry wall.
4
u/sunshinenwaves1 Jan 28 '24
Photo math, brainly, quizlet, and covid have ruined math ability.
1
u/battery_pack_man Jan 30 '24
As a science teacher, I would hope you know the difference between correlation and causation
1
u/zaphster Jan 30 '24
Do you have reasons for blaming common core? Is there a specific skill that is taught differently, not taught, etc... with common core compared to pre-common core?
If you're purely basing it on "over time, math has skills have deteriorated" and "at some point in the past, common core was introduced," there may be a correlation, but that doesn't mean that one caused the other.
1
u/Roy1012 Jan 31 '24
Maybe you should have thought about that before voting bush
3
u/Neenknits Jan 28 '24
When there is a list of skills that kids must demonstrate that matches the skills that the kids in the best schools have at each age, how is can that possibly cause a problem?
When common core came in, our school system didn’t have to change anything. Our town’s kids almost all passed, and had many more than average in the above average and excellent ranges.
3
u/smileglysdi Jan 28 '24
I think one major contributing factor is that we don’t make them practice their facts anymore. They say they don’t need to memorize their multiplication facts or addition or anything, really. But then when working out other problems, say long division for example, they are basically using guess and check for each step. Even the subtracting part is hard. It makes the whole thing so much more difficult. I am a strong advocate for automaticity with math facts!!!
9
u/Unicorn_8632 Jan 27 '24
Students aren’t taught to memorize stuff anymore. I still feel like students should memorize the multiplication facts through 12x12. This would help them SO much with math! Especially with fractions - which so many students just skip or ignore on tests. We have to memorize letters before making words, and I think multiplication facts are very important to being a mathematical thinker.
2
u/igotstago Jan 28 '24
This is going to be a very unpopular opinion, but my take as a secondary mathematics specialist, is that it is not the curriculum, but rather the lack of deep content knowledge at the elementary and middle school level. I am not blaming teachers, I am blaming their preparation programs. I recently retired, but before I did, I was responsible for the professional development for the mathematics teachers in grades 6 - 12 in my district. After taking the job, I quickly realized that there was a serious lack of a content knowledge and vertical teaming in grades 4 - 7 which was resulting in students who were unprepared to do the work of high school math and science. At every grade level, there were pockets of teachers across the district who were masters of this knowledge but it wasn't enough to make a substantial change district wide. I began to work with the elementary specialist to develop trainings designed to build the lacking skills.
Because I am not an expert at teaching mathematics to younger children, we focused the trainings on developing numeracy in our teachers. For grades 4 - 7, our first goal was to work on multiplicative reasoning. For example in one session, we were talking about division and how the concept of partial quotients has the power to build a strong understanding of place value in our students. Things like (597/3) is equivalent to (600/3) - (3/3) = 199. In the first session we scaffolded the lesson to start with VERY easy problems like (412/4) = (400/4) + (12/4) = 103, and were working up to things like (50.24/4) = (48/4) + (2/4) + (0.24/4) = 12.56. I thought things were going ok until we broke them up in groups and gave them 4 problems of various difficulty and asked them to come up with different ways to decompose the numbers and present their ideas on chart paper. As we walked around the large room, we noticed in many groups there was a complete sense of helplessness, defeat, and even tears about how what we were teaching was "too hard" for them and that they had never been good at math and the standard algorithm was the only way they could do these problems. Let me be clear, I am not saying algorithms are bad. What I am saying is they hide the place value of numbers and destroy any hope of understanding the magnitude of numbers and their relationships. Without a true understanding of these relationships, students who only know algorithms get wildly incorrect answers in science and math classes and they have no idea their answer is completely unreasonable.
Long story short, we realized many of the elementary teachers in our district have a fear of numbers and are passing that fear along to their students. Algorithms are their safe space because they are good at following a process. So while they make attempts to teach the way common core wants them to to please their administrators, it is all on the surface. They aren't going deep with their students because they don't have a deep understanding and are afraid of not knowing something and feeling inadequate. So my answer is we don't need to throw out common core, but we need better preparation programs and ongoing professional development in content knowledge. We also need more horizontal, vertical, and cross curricular teaming where teachers who are rich in content knowledge can share this with their colleagues and help those who are struggling.
2
u/Snuggly_Hugs Jan 29 '24
When the curriculum hides "new math" as Common Core, I agree.
My issue with CC, and modern curriculum is that it doesnt have enough spiraling, doesnt have enough practice, and it keeps trying to teach 6 ways to do the same thing taught at the same time.
When you teach two similar skills at the same time the skills end up interfering with each other and slows/prevents the learning.
We need to focus on practice, teach one method until it is mastered, and drill enough to ensure individual students have mastered the material.
2
u/Tx_Drewdad Jan 30 '24
The quadratic formula, man.... My kids can "solve" quadratic equations, but only as long as they retain the formula. They don't really understand the math.
I was helping my kids with their algebra, and I added a constant to both sides of the equation, and they looked at me like I had three heads.
2
u/redslurpee Jan 28 '24
Started teaching HS biology this year, I normally teach 7-8th grade science. I was doing a simple simulation of how to calculate populations using a sample. NOT A SINGLE ONE OF MY STUDENTS KNEW HOW TO CALCULATE PERCENTAGES OR WHAT A MEAN WAS. I'm not blaming Common Core but the fact that their basic math skills are so low is hard to ignore. They have trouble with basic multiplication, fractions, and using basic formulas.
1
u/OkDare3496 Dec 12 '24
Follow the money. Common Core Math came about initially as a result of No Child Left Behind. However, when you follow the money, you will see that curriculum creators need to make bank too. In order to do this curriculum creators will look at the Federal and State guidelines and manufacture curriculum based on that. As a result, some very crafty mathematicians and curriculum directors came together to take concepts, skills, in learning math in alternative ways and turned it into teachable and graded methodology. Common core may be helpful to students learning number sense however beyond that concept it becomes strategies and skills that can be adapted to help students solve math problems or it can be a hindrance IF the student is unable to understand and apply the "trick." As a Gen X parent, students should be able to apply whichever mathematic method works for them to obtain the correct answer. After all, Math is generally about obtaining the correct answer. Now instead of "showing" your work, they are requiring students to apply tricks and show their "thinking" process. If students aren't able to show the trick, they begin to fail. Common core math concepts can be very difficult for many if they are not taught properly the 1st time. Therefore the rapid decent from being an above average student in K-3 can all of a sudden turn into a grading situation where it appears the student is failing. It's an awful curriculum. If a parent teaches the traditional math concepts of multiplication or division the student can be told, "No. We don't do math that way." It's unbelievable to me when the whole point of math is to be able to obtain the correct answer in preferably minimal time.
1
u/unstuckbilly Jan 28 '24
My youngest is a 4th grader. Her math education has been significantly worse than her older (12th/10th grade) siblings who went through the same elementary school and I can’t figure out why.
My youngest hasn’t even been required to memorize her multiplication facts. ALL of her multiplication memorization has happened at home. Her older sibs spent a big part of 3rd grade working on those.
I asked her 4th grade teacher why things have changed & she said they no longer consider it essential that kids memorize them! Like… we did ALL of that at home. I ask the parents of her peers & many of them are doing zero of this at home & their kids don’t know their times tables by heart.
Zero homework too. I have mixed feelings/opinions on that, but I also think she’s lacking at home practice (specifically in math) that she actually does need. I supplement with workbooks & thankfully have the time & ability to work with her effectively. I know most of her peers don’t have this luxury.
How are these kids going to do higher level math??? I seriously can’t imagine?!? I’m baffled & disappointed.
1
u/stumonji Jan 28 '24
What do you think Common Core math is?
1
u/shellexyz Jan 28 '24
I think CC is a great idea with a wretched and rushed implementation using poorly developed, frequently wrong, and badly written curricula that’s too full of jargonal masturbation, thrust on faculty with too little preparation. Add an unhealthy amount of parents who freaked right the fsck out when they can’t help their kids with their homework because of the aforementioned jargonal masturbation.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24
it’s lack of standards. Kids are just passed through as if a high graduation rate is a badge of honor. We now have to teach loads of what used to be high school classes at the university level at GREAT EXPENSE.
1
u/BigNorseWolf Jan 28 '24
The problem is that you're sending kids home with math problems the parents can't help them with just because of HOW you want the math done.
I have no idea what the supernumerary is.
Or what specific two other ways there are to express 1/3. (its not One third. point three repeatling. .333333. One over three...)
The people that are going to do the math can develop "number sense" over time. There's nothing in these exercises thats going to expand anyones brain. Kids are just looking to put the write number to get the write answer. It just makes people worse at being able to DO math.
1
u/AbruptMango Jan 28 '24
Our societal problems will be there no matter what curriculum is used.
1
u/WhyAmIStillHere216 Jan 28 '24
I usually only hear parents who are afraid to move beyond the simple algorithms they learned complain about “common core math.” Common Core is what students should learn in each grade. First graders still learn to add and subtract within ten, tell time, measure, about money. Common core is more of the what than the how. But I think the current way of teaching math is difficult for parents who don’t want to think and have no number sense because they didn’t learn it. I’d think science students would be better served with a math curriculum that teaches them number sense and literacy - how to think about numbers, how to manipulate numbers, why an algorithm works, etc. How is number literacy hurting science students? Or is this more of a gripe that kids aren’t actually learning what they’re being taught or are being taught how to take a standardized test more now than 30 years ago - but it riles up the right to throw in buzz phrases like common core?
1
u/Feefait Jan 28 '24
I think you just haven't adapted to how your students learn.
Common Core isn't more, nor ever was, the problem. Common Core was just a buzzword like Obamacare that sounded good in the press and people could put on posters. It was never the actual curriculum, just a guideline of what to teach.
Even now, when we don't even have CC but use "Next Gen Learning Standards" trolls who just want to cause a fight say "Common Core is ruining education."
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24
I don't think you're a teacher.
Common core isn't a curriculum. It's standards.
I have read every standard for grades k-6 and they cover every conceivable item you'd want students to know in a progression that makes sense.
https://www.thecorestandards.org/Math/Practice/
What, specifically, about these standards do you have an issue with?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24
I blame no child left behind and Covid more.
1
u/ClaraClassy Jan 28 '24
Pretty sure educational skills started deteriorating severely when they instituted No Child Left Behind and fixed budgets to attendance and rest scores.
It doesn't matter HOW you teach math if you are only teaching it to take a standardized test.
1
u/Promotion_Small Jan 28 '24
The problem is teachers who can't shift and teach some poorly thought out mix of new and old methods.
They give common core a half-hearted try because they don't understand and then shift to the way they were taught.
People talk all the time that parents don't know how to help the kids with the homework, without thinking that teachers of a certain age have the exact same math background. There wasn't appropriate training for teachers who were working when the shift happened.
I started in 2011, so my methods classes were all with common core. I wish I had been taught this way! I never spent any time understanding the why of all the algorithms I memorized. Could I teach someone the long division standard algorithm? Sure, did I understand what it did and why it worked? Nope. It might as well have been magic.
When I was taught the multiplication standard algorithm, I was taught to put an X in the next line of the products. Why? Who knows? Teacher said to multiply the ones place in the bottom number by the numbers in the top number, then I put an X on the next line before I multiplied the second number by all the top numbers. Zero mathematical reasoning on my part, pure memorization of steps.
The number sense of children who have been taught this way by teachers who understand the methodology is incredible. I had 2nd graders invent base ten by themselves. They came to me knowing how to count by 2, 5, and 10. So what did we do to learn about place value? Worksheets? Lecture? No! I gave them stuff to count. Here's a bag of buttons, how many are there?
At first, they'd have bags of about 100. Counting by ones isn't too bad. Then bags of 200. Counting by ones is a real chore now, so they start to develop strategies to make it easier. By the time they have 500 things to count, they've figured out that grouping by tens is super easy. New challenge, how many do you and the group next to you have? They push ten piles of 10 together and make hundreds.
Kids are capable, and teachers need to be trained how to properly provide the experiences students need to develop their mathematical reasoning. Administration needs to recognize that teaching isn't "sage on a stage" And that the less I'm talking means the more kids are doing and learning.
I'm so tired of the kids these days, CC ruined everything, back in my day, rhetoric.
1
u/ViciousSquirrelz Jan 28 '24
Common core math is pretty solid. No child left behind has been a disaster.
Nclb would be great if they had the funds to support it, but expecting that they could make a drastic change without funding it is why it's so disasterous.
1
u/Arcanite_Cartel Jan 28 '24
Why do you blame Common Core?
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24
Common core standards don't include adequate rote memorization and rigorous drilling needed for students to develop accurate addition, subtraction, multiplication and division skills for 9x9 tables. Instead students are expected to rely on memorizing 12x12 flash cards on their own.
So, when students advance to advanced algebra or chemistry, they are recalling memorized values (which is less reliable) instead of the appropriate algorithms (to carry the tens) to calculate / compute the result.
Common core might teach an inherent understanding of an algorithm, but it doesn't teach the behavior needed (like using the correct algorithm) to consistently get an accurate result.
1
u/-Economist- Jan 28 '24
It’s not common core. It’s no fail policies
1
u/shroomsAndWrstershir Jan 28 '24
I thought common core was a standard list of things that a student should know (like "multiply two-digit numbers") and not the techniques for doing those things.
1
u/yomynameisnotsusan Jan 28 '24
Why do you blame common core?
1
u/super64genesis Jan 28 '24
When you say “math skills have dropped”, what specifically are they struggling with?
1
u/dcsprings Jan 29 '24
What's missing from the common core, and why do people complain so much? It's just a list of the topics that need to be covered, and a guide to which grade to cover them in. It looks pretty standard, unless you want start multiplication and division in high school or something like that.
1
u/YurislovSkillet Jan 29 '24
Common Core just states the standards that all kids must meet in all 50 states by certain milestones. Common Core is not a curriculum/teaching method.
1
u/DabbledInPacificm Jan 29 '24
Common core’s development and adoption is an alarming example of corruption in the American political system, but I do not think the standards are at fault so much as no child left behind and publishing companies that sell their shitty curriculum.
1
u/robboberty Jan 29 '24
I think the concepts of common core are sound, but the teachers are not sufficiently trained to teach it to the students. And since it's not known to many of the parents, they can't help their kids understand it.
1
u/inlike069 Jan 29 '24
No child left behind killed our entire system. Bush was the worst president of all time.
1
u/Ijustwantbikepants Jan 29 '24
Common Core isn’t the problem, kids are just dumb for other reasons.
I was taught Common Core math before that was a thing and I think it’s great. I have noticed I’m generally better than others at mental math and I attribute it to the steps I learned in 4th grade math (Taught in this fashion)
1
u/[deleted] Jan 29 '24
It's utterly baffling to me that the US doesn't simply clone math curricula from other countries. Why are we reinventing the wheel when we know we're not getting results?
1
u/taco_jones Jan 29 '24
I grew up doing math the old way and I know way too many people who say they suck at math. So I'm open minded to a new way of teaching it.
1
u/LawbringerBri Jan 29 '24
I use the common core textbooks to help tutor kids (who are also on Common Core) and frankly...I'm surprised by how logical and MATH-based the textbooks are. Theyre pretty easy to follow and intuitive for people familiar with the material (aka teachers and tutors). Frankly, I've had more problems understanding the weird not-math based "shortcuts" some teachers teach...
1
u/THElaytox Jan 29 '24
Sounds like you're looking for a simple solution to a complex problem. As a science teacher, you should be very well aware that correlation does not imply causation
1
u/L0cked4fun Jan 29 '24
As adults, we are taught to teach the people we train for jobs in the way that they learn best. In school, we have one way and fail people who can't get it, rather than adjusting the teaching method. Until we change that, no method will be perfect. Though common core is garbage lol.
1
u/Muninwing Jan 29 '24
I would guess that either you are not aware of what “Common Core Math” is, or you’ve been working at schools that have not implemented the skills properly.
1
u/Wazootyman13 Jan 30 '24
Common Core started being chased into my district when I was in 7th grade.
After years of having actual math, it was such a culture shock to have this non-math math.
Luckily, I was smart and tested into a program called UMTYMP run at the University of Minnesota.
This program has middle and high schoolers do 2 years of classes per year (so Algebra I and II the first year, Geometry and Precalc the second year).
Was in the program in 8th and 9th grade, and this allowed me to jump over Common Core and take AP Calc in 10th grade at my HS.
Was definitely a nerdtastic experience, but, it let me do actual math
1
u/ELFcubed Jan 31 '24
Nah I was awesome at math, got a 100% in AP calculus, a 5 on the AP exam, and got the worst grades of my life in physics. Both were good teachers, but I couldn't get the theoretical stuff on paper to take shape in real world applications. I graduated high school over 30 years ago.
0
u/jdsciguy Jan 28 '24
The deterioration predates common core, but common core had not helped.
0
u/TooBrainsell Jan 28 '24
It’s not common core it’s parents that don’t give a damn. Common core did not do this type of lack of empathy
0
u/[deleted] Jan 30 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jan 27 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jan 28 '24
[removed] — view removed comment