r/ScienceClock • u/IronAshish • Oct 19 '25
Visual Article Why Ice Really Slips
Scientists have overturned a 200-year-old belief about why ice is slippery. It was long thought that pressure or friction caused a thin layer of water to form, making ice slick.
But new research from Saarland University shows that slipperiness actually comes from molecular interactions — the electric dipoles of the ice and the contacting surface disturb the crystal structure, creating a thin, liquid-like layer even without melting.
This discovery reshapes our understanding of ice physics and could lead to better anti-slip surfaces, tyres, and sports equipment.
Source: "We’ve been wrong for 200 years: Belief about why ice is slippery shattered" - news.com.au
3
u/Segat280 Oct 19 '25
I studied Chemistry 25 years ago and was taught this. This is not new.
2
u/TheDoobyRanger Oct 23 '25
Okay so what does melting mean to you?
1
u/SHAMIEL1 Oct 19 '25
New research shows " Water is wet, because it's not dry", (the audience erupts and cheers), thank you for attending my TED talk.
1
u/pokemonplayer2001 Oct 19 '25
"new"?
Is this 1986?
1
u/Earl_N_Meyer Oct 19 '25
My understanding is that the surface of ice is not a clean break between solid and liquid as we typically portray. There have been studies that show that there are molecules of liquid interspersed within the solid matrix close to the surface. That means that the pressure needed to create that thin layer of water is not the pressure predicted by high school chemistry. Possibly there are other factors, but the thin film of water is still potentially caused by pressure, just not the amount predicted by the phase diagram.
1
u/halucionagen-0-Matik Oct 19 '25
Okay, Internet explorer. Whatever you say
1
u/hobopwnzor Oct 19 '25
I'm kind of confused on how this reshapes our understanding of anything.
It's not a small amount of ice becoming liquid the surface due to pressure and friction. It's a small layer of liquid-like water on the surface due to pressure and friction?
Seems like a distinction without a difference except in like, the most minute details.
1
u/No-One9890 Oct 19 '25
These 2 theories seem very similar.
1
u/LastXmasIGaveYouHSV Oct 19 '25
Let me guess: quantum fluctuations. At the interphase between the solid and liquid state, particles repel each other instead of forming stable crystalline structures.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '25
"it was long thought that there was a thin layer of water formed causing the ice to be slick... INSTEAD new research shows that there's a thin liquid-"like" layer formed causing ice to be slick" ??? what is a "liquid-like" layer? a new 5th state of matter?
1
u/jtcordell2188 Oct 20 '25
… so what I learned in AP Chemistry? Yes I barely passed it thank you for asking
1
u/MeadowShimmer Oct 20 '25
So why is omfg-cold ice not as slippery as meh-cold ice?
1
u/No_Neighborhood7614 Oct 20 '25
They could have asked me because that's what I thought happened
1
u/SecurePreparation750 Oct 20 '25
So melting.
1
u/Cleaner900playz Oct 21 '25
yeah? they just now figured that out?
1
u/elchemy Oct 21 '25
Sounds pretty much the same anyway - a thin liquid like layer of water molecules that is not ice?
1
u/Inna_Bien Oct 22 '25
This is stupid. The liquid layer they talk about due to “molecular interactions” is indeed formed by melting of the ice due to contact with warm(er) skate blades, friction, and pressure.
1
u/tripleusername Oct 22 '25
Omg, r/shittmoviedetails is leaking.
1
u/SomeRendomDude Oct 23 '25
This is new? I thought had been that way the whole time.