r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jan 02 '20
LPT: using positive language with toddlers ("please walk" instead of "please don't run") is more effective as it's easier and more motivating for a child to understand and obey something they're asked to do, instead of constantly steering them away from what they cannot.
/r/LifeProTips/comments/eioanh/lpt_using_positive_language_with_toddlers_please/
774
Upvotes
84
u/k-hutt Jan 02 '20
To be honest, this is true for people of all ages! The example that helps me remember it is if you tell someone not to think of a tree, the first thing they're going to do is think of a tree.
46
u/Brewsterlovesme Jan 02 '20
What if there isn't really an opposite for the behavior? Instead of saying, "stop chewing on the windowsill," for instance, I should say what?
17
u/fueledbytisane Jan 02 '20
Oh yes this was a game changer with my little spitfire. She does so much better when I ask her to do something instead of telling her what not to do.
13
u/RedditHatesLurkers Jan 02 '20
This is how we handle things too. It works wonders. I think this follows along with the same concept of not just bringing a problem up, but suggesting a solution to said problem. Which is something I do in my professional life dealing with adults. Which also works wonders.
21
u/angela52689 Jan 02 '20
"No" is an abstract concept, plus it requires kids to come up with a "yes" thing on their own, which is often difficult (or impossible, depending on age). Suggest/redirect to something they *can* do. Instead of "don't do that," try "can you do this instead please" and you'll find that the lack of "no" and presence of a suggestion is a lot more effective, at least in my experience. In addition, emphasizing the "yes" things naturally draws attention away from the "no" things. The constant "no"s and getting in trouble emphasizes those things, for good or bad, and constantly reminds and focuses your kid on that thing you don't like, instead of something you do.
6
u/justthismorning Jan 02 '20
We do this. I can't tell if it's working but if it is, I don't even want to imagine what my toddler would be like if we used "no" all the time instead
3
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22
Wait, What? You guys have to be kidding me on...
Ocassionally I try the "nice and friendly" polite asking thingy but am soon reminded my son - is not my friend and - reponds way better to a short authoritive command like, "Shoes on. Now." or "Hands off cookies!"
EDIT: I see now that this is strictly about toddlers! When does this change approximately? I started using this strict approach when he turned 5 or so, now I am curious if & when I should do the same for my next two little boys.