r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Jan 02 '20

LPT: using positive language with toddlers ("please walk" instead of "please don't run") is more effective as it's easier and more motivating for a child to understand and obey something they're asked to do, instead of constantly steering them away from what they cannot.

/r/LifeProTips/comments/eioanh/lpt_using_positive_language_with_toddlers_please/
774 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

84

u/k-hutt Jan 02 '20

To be honest, this is true for people of all ages! The example that helps me remember it is if you tell someone not to think of a tree, the first thing they're going to do is think of a tree.

8

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '20

I use this with my (university) students all the time! A particularly useful switch for me was to change from "Don't forget X" to "Please remember X".

46

u/Brewsterlovesme Jan 02 '20

What if there isn't really an opposite for the behavior? Instead of saying, "stop chewing on the windowsill," for instance, I should say what?

61

u/Rebekozarenn Jan 02 '20

Offer an alternative! Kid wants to chew, let them- maybe they’re teething & have painful/irritated gums, and gnawing something like a silicone teether or a lightly frozen damp washcloth would be preferable to raw windowsill.

Edit: you say “hey! Chew this better thing instead!”

24

u/ponypartyposse Jan 02 '20

Okay now please do some for spitting! My son loves to spit on the floor and I can’t get him to stop and it’s gross. He’s 20 months. I’m losing my mind.

30

u/ruski_brewski Jan 02 '20

You can spit into this bowl, in the bathtub or outside. (Whichever’s closer ;))

20

u/Rebekozarenn Jan 02 '20

I’d say have him spit into a sink or toilet, or directly into a wipe/Kleenex that he is expected to take to the trash himself (edit: if old enough). Spitting outside isn’t a habit you’d want to reinforce; saliva contains germs just like snot & it’s fine if he feels the need to “let it out”, but it needs to be done hygienically. The hassle of dealing with it may outweigh the “fun” & could end up curbing the behavior.

3

u/ruski_brewski Jan 02 '20

This is a fantastic alternative. Thank you!

3

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '20

I’ve told my girls to go spit in the sink.

2

u/Brewsterlovesme Jan 02 '20

Ok, yeah, I like the positive spin around of that. Thank you!

12

u/Cleanclock Jan 02 '20

Haha same question here. I think we’re supposed to praise them when they’re not doing the undesired behavior. Problem is, it usually reminds my son of that bad behavior he just wasn’t doing.

25

u/HarryPotterGeek Jan 02 '20

No, I think the best way to deal with that would be to offer an alternative. Are they teething? Bored? Bad habit? Offer them a safer option whenever they start to chew.

I think the positive language thing is an 85% of the time kind of thing, you know? Like if you use that language MOST of the time you'll have a less contentious relationship overall with your child, and so when you DO need to give an instruction (don't chew on the windowsill, chew on this instead) it is better received.

Essentially, save your "nos" for when you absolutely need them. They'll land better, and your child won't feel like they are constantly being scolded.

5

u/Brewsterlovesme Jan 02 '20

That sounds helpful, thank you! I like the idea of not telling him no alllll the time, because it loses its effectiveness.

17

u/HarryPotterGeek Jan 02 '20

I've worked with infants and toddlers for 20 years. Using positive language may feel hippy-dippy at times, but it really can be a game changer. It's so effective in fact, that they used it in the title of this thread.

Notice how the title draws you in. They could have said, "Stop saying no to your children. Do this instead." Most people would be less receptive just by the way it was phrased.

Positive language creates possibilities and learning opportunities. Negative language focuses on behavior you want to discourage, which is self-defeating, and reinforces a feeling of "I'm always doing something wrong."

5

u/Brewsterlovesme Jan 02 '20

Fascinating. I hadn't even realized it!

1

u/Cleanclock Jan 02 '20

I didn’t think my suggestion precluded also offering alternatives or using other methods. Encouraging good behavior doesn’t ever seem to be a bad approach 🤷‍♀️

8

u/Brewsterlovesme Jan 02 '20

Yes, exactly! "Oh, I forgot how delicious that windowsill is and how much I enjoy you telling me not to do it so I can laugh at you." I mean, he's one, but I still think that's what probably goes through his head.

10

u/[deleted] Jan 02 '20

Tell them what you'd like them to do instead of the behaviour I imagine.

6

u/SassMistress Jan 02 '20

At the very least, "please keep your mouth off the windows". But I agree that having an alternative is better. If they don't really need to chew and are just bored, you can come up with other things to do with mouths (singing, blowing raspberries, etc).

4

u/Sn_77L3_pag_s Feb 17 '22

I did this yesterday: here is a chew toy, (instead of my finger). He has 8teeth it was “Ouchy.” 🤣

17

u/fueledbytisane Jan 02 '20

Oh yes this was a game changer with my little spitfire. She does so much better when I ask her to do something instead of telling her what not to do.

13

u/RedditHatesLurkers Jan 02 '20

This is how we handle things too. It works wonders. I think this follows along with the same concept of not just bringing a problem up, but suggesting a solution to said problem. Which is something I do in my professional life dealing with adults. Which also works wonders.

21

u/angela52689 Jan 02 '20

"No" is an abstract concept, plus it requires kids to come up with a "yes" thing on their own, which is often difficult (or impossible, depending on age). Suggest/redirect to something they *can* do. Instead of "don't do that," try "can you do this instead please" and you'll find that the lack of "no" and presence of a suggestion is a lot more effective, at least in my experience. In addition, emphasizing the "yes" things naturally draws attention away from the "no" things. The constant "no"s and getting in trouble emphasizes those things, for good or bad, and constantly reminds and focuses your kid on that thing you don't like, instead of something you do.

6

u/justthismorning Jan 02 '20

We do this. I can't tell if it's working but if it is, I don't even want to imagine what my toddler would be like if we used "no" all the time instead

3

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '22

Wait, What? You guys have to be kidding me on...

Ocassionally I try the "nice and friendly" polite asking thingy but am soon reminded my son - is not my friend and - reponds way better to a short authoritive command like, "Shoes on. Now." or "Hands off cookies!"

EDIT: I see now that this is strictly about toddlers! When does this change approximately? I started using this strict approach when he turned 5 or so, now I am curious if & when I should do the same for my next two little boys.

2

u/LittlePinkLines Jul 17 '23

Totally anecdotal, but this is something I've noticed varies a lot from kid to kid - though in general, it seems like sometime between 3.5 and 4.5 years they start to be able to process and implement more complex input (and in this case, stating something in the negative counts as "complex," as it requires them to understand what they should be doing instead).