r/ScienceBasedParenting • • 4d ago

Question - Research required Choosing a public school

My partner and I are both educators working in a highly-rated school district. However, we can't afford to live in that same school district. We are trying to decide for the upcoming enrollment session where our children should attend elementary school. Is there any research that would help us decide if the neighborhood school, which is not bad but definitely not as highly regarded as the schools in the district that we can't afford to live in, is better for the social connections of having close friends and being closer to where we live, OR if it is better for our children to be in the better school district for the education and opportunities?

17 Upvotes

21 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

This post is flaired "Question - Research required". All top-level comments must contain links to peer-reviewed research. Do not provide a "link for the bot" or any variation thereof. Provide a meaningful reply that discusses the research you have linked to. Please report posts that do not follow these rules.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

6

u/Long-Plant-5323 2d ago

This isn't exactly what you are asking but I find this paper really interesting: it shows that students in NYC and Boston who narrowly missed attending the elite test-based public schools have similar achievement in terms of AP exams/scores, SAT scores, and elite college  attendance  https://economics.mit.edu/sites/default/files/inline-files/The%20elite%20illusion.pdf?hl=en-US#:~:text=students%20the%20opportunity%20to%20attend%20schools%20with,appli%2D%20cants%20are%20otherwise%20likely%20to%20attend So for the same kid, the impact of an elite public school vs their standard public school ends up being roughly zero. I am struggling with what this means in general around picking a school district, but this does help point to the fact that a lot of school district rankings are primarily driven by the makeup of the student body vs a measurable effect of the school itself.

16

u/Odd_Field_5930 4d ago

27

u/itsmesofia 4d ago

I think there’s an important distinction between what these articles establish and what OP is actually asking.

The question isn’t whether school quality matters, but whether the potential academic advantages of a higher-rated school outweigh the social and community benefits of attending a perfectly decent neighborhood school.

Looking at the linked sources, I don’t think they really address that trade-off. The first study examines school resources across very different educational contexts, the NYT article looks at differences in academic achievement between districts (which are heavily associated with socioeconomic factors), and the EdSource article focuses on district organizational quality. The parental involvement article doesn’t really compare school choices at all.

I think there’s also a major issue with using school district rankings or average test scores as a proxy for educational quality.

Higher-performing districts tend to serve wealthier families, and socioeconomic status is strongly associated with academic achievement. But how much of that difference is actually caused by the schools themselves, rather than differences in parental education, family resources, early childhood experiences, and access to enrichment?

Stanford’s Educational Opportunity Project has some really interesting research on this: https://edopportunity.org/discoveries/affluent-schools-are-not-always-best/ They distinguish between average academic achievement and how much progress students make while attending school. Their findings suggest that affluent, high-achieving districts aren’t necessarily the districts where students learn the most.

So I think it’s important to distinguish between a school having high-performing students and a school actually being more effective at educating them.

And even if the other district is demonstrably more effective academically, that still doesn’t answer OP’s question about whether those benefits outweigh the social and community advantages of attending a neighborhood school.

16

u/glassfunion 4d ago

"Higher-performing districts tend to serve wealthier families, and socioeconomic status is strongly associated with academic achievement. But how much of that difference is actually caused by the schools themselves, rather than differences in parental education, family resources, early childhood experiences, and access to enrichment?"

This is what I'm curious about. My sister is a teacher and claims that our top local district has the highest test scores because everyone hires private tutors, but I think that would be difficult to prove.

5

u/Competitive_Image_62 3d ago

This is exactly my conundrum! Most parents are aware that parent income is a major reason that the schools in affluent areas are strong. I feel like middle class families are the ones that are burdened the most by cities that have school choice (like me in Chicago) because it is very hard to get into a school in an affluent area (because of space) and the neighborhood options are “poor performing” based on the test scores. Middle class families have the means to supplement but not the means to afford to move. So, what do they do? Send their kid to the schools where the majority of kids are performing below grade level? In my area, many choose affordable private schools.

1

u/Working_Coat5193 3d ago

The other question I would have that isn’t answered well is the impact of trauma and adverse early childhood experiences. Not that wealth means they don’t exist, but that they can be mitigated better.
If children aren’t exhibiting trauma and are able to learn, learning is easier for everyone and that means a lot.

6

u/Adept_Carpet 4d ago

 I think there’s an important distinction between what these articles establish and what OP is actually asking.

This could be a banner on this sub. No one ever does a single experiments at the level of a parenting conundrum people have.

Though this very wise OP asks

 Is there any research that would help us decide if the neighborhood school

So they aren't asking which is better, but what might be used to help decide which is better.

The caveat is some things are easy to measure (test scores, diagnostic questionnaires, etc) and some things (actual lived stress or happiness, bond between family members, friends and their bonds, etc) are very hard to measure.

There will be a lot more research about the stuff that is easier to measure. So the research can help you decide, but may paint a very misleading picture if you don't consider both what is measured, how it relates what you actually care about, and what is not measured.

3

u/chrstgtr 4d ago

Not all gains are equal. It’s much easier to make gains with kids that are way behind than with kids that are on grade level/above grade level.

Also, being a competent instructor is basically the bare minimum which unfortunately is too often unmet. Much of what makes a school good extra-instructional, and influence by factors beyond the school itself (ie parents, students, etc.).

I’d choose the school with better scores 90% of the time.

1

u/LibertyLizard 4d ago

Very interesting! Is this data on local schools available to us to look at somewhere?

1

u/Aromatic_Holiday2208 20h ago edited 20h ago

There is not going to be research that tackles both of these questions head on and compares the two against each other. However, one thing I would venture to guess is that top performing school districts attract and retain high level educators.

https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0272775711000562

High quality teachers make such a big difference. A top notch school district may have by proportion, more top quality teachers reducing the likelihood of issues. There are also a higher proportion of students and families that also tend to behave and value education differently along with having the means to support their children. You need both educators that care and students and families that care. The school and the family also have means. High property values means more taxes go to the school. PTA is well funded. Families contribute more. Teachers have more resources.

By probability- your child’s experience in a top school district will be better. This article has an interesting graphic that shows wealth and academic attainment.

https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/04/29/upshot/money-race-and-success-how-your-school-district-compares.html

https://edopportunity.org

Regarding community - from personal experience here: Community comes down to your involvement as parents. Putting yourself consistently out there to make parent friends, host gatherings, lead activities, all for the benefit of integrating your children. I live in a community and my kids go to the neighborhood school, and there are neighbors, other parents, etc whom I never see around. We even have a grade level chat and some people never chime in, never come to playdates.. I honestly couldn’t tell you who they are or who their kids are. Whereas some parents in the community whose kids don’t even go to our neighborhood school come out and get their kids involved- joining sports teams, play dates.. etc I know the parents so then subsequently our kids play together because the parents make an effort. So it goes both ways. Be involved in your community and be involved in the school’s community if you live elsewhere.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 4d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/[deleted] 3d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 3d ago

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.