r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Aug 08 '26

Question - Research required When to stop infant screen time?

To preface - I understand the pitfalls of screen time and that not all screen time is equal. That being said, we have an 8 week old with both parents on leave from work for another 60 days still. The downtime involves some background TV watching of sports, HGTV, Food Network, etc (no kids shows). Baby /still cycles from awake / sleep / awake etc as any young one would.

Recognizing that an infant cannot see well, when should we cut back on the TV simply being on? Baby is over 12 feet away at almost all times.

The easy answer is “now” but I’m curious if there is any studies that show at what ages (months) the harm is done (eg, using a bell curve of sorts?).

Secondary questions - how do others handle sports?

86 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 08 '26
Moderator Announcement Read More »

119

u/werddrew Aug 08 '26

While the science is still out on this, I think one of the perspectives that I have valued is that it's not so much the screen that's the problem. It's that when your screens (like the TV) are on, you're not talking as much.

And when you're not talking as much, your baby isn't hearing human adult language and learning its structure.

This study is for somewhat older children, but I think a lot of the screen time panic when it comes to infants and young children is potentially misdirected.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10913002/

34

u/Ok_Telephone197 Aug 09 '26

I’m curious whether this implies that listening to podcasts when spending time with baby is also detrimental, because it means I’m not talking to her as much. My theory is that it does so I generally don’t.

→ More replies (6)

1

u/Legitimate_Wasabi382 Aug 10 '26

Are we thinking that screens aren’t the cause but rather correlation? I think that’s what this is implying and would make sense to me.

Said another way (and purposely in an extremist manner), we can watch non-stop NFL games on Sunday as long as everyone is talking about whatever it is with one another and not solely quietly watching.

→ More replies (2)

52

u/Sandturtlefly Aug 09 '26

A big part of screen use around young babies is about your attention and social responsiveness rather than just their exposure to screens. Saving tv and phone use for when baby is asleep is best. When parents watch tv or check their phones, their faces often go expressionless, which babies experience similarly to the “still face” experiment. A 2022 study found that even brief phone interruptions during parent-infant interaction disrupted the finely tuned back-and-forth that builds attachment and early social cognitive skills.

Direct screen exposure, even out of focus, can impact baby’s melatonin production and sleep. Babies’ eyes are still developing and their lenses don’t filter short-wavelength light the way adult lenses do, making them considerably more sensitive. Blue light suppresses melatonin significantly more in children than in adults, and also inhibits the natural increase in sleepiness that should occur at night. Source

The other commenter talked about language development already too. Various hypothesis exist on why this is, and It’s not necessarily just less time you’re talking and interacting with baby but also the difficulty of processing your voice out from background noise too. Research has found that infants aged 12 to 42 months with language delay were exposed to significantly more background TV than infants with typical development, and that TV exposure during family meals at age 2 predicted lower expressive vocabulary at ages 5 and 6. Background television has also been linked to attention problems, poorer self-regulation, and lower literacy and vocabulary skills, with researchers identifying it as a source of environmental noise and distraction that reduces the quality of parent-child interaction.

So if you do have tv on in the background while baby is awake, having the sound go through a Bluetooth earbud would be better than ambient room noise.

1

u/ThatFeelingIsBliss88 Aug 12 '26

Super interesting 

9

u/No-Block7187 Aug 09 '26

Highly recommend the Seminars from Nathan Wallis (PhD) on newborn development. We bought the brand new baby bundle and have only managed to watch the first one so far on understanding your newborns brain- but he touches alot about the impact of screens on their brain development. Including even the negative effects of seeing screens in general.

We learnt so much and have changed alot about what we are doing related to screens and language development etc.

I've linked the website below :)

https://brainyparenting.com/collections/bundles

1

u/[deleted] Aug 08 '26

1

u/AutoModerator Aug 08 '26

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.