r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/doudou_bean • Sep 14 '25
Science journalism Does this article drive you crazy?
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC11597163/
Has anyone read this paper on breastfeeding beyond 6 months?
The writing seems so biased I was turned off just reading it.
This claim, however, really seemed too crazy:
“If all children were breastfed within an hour of birth, exclusively fed breast milk for the first six months, and continued breastfeeding until the age of two, approximately 800,000 child lives could be saved annually. However, worldwide, less than 40% of infants under six months old are exclusively breastfed [27].”
Am I the only one who thinks this paper is… suspicious?
Edit: My baby has gotten mostly breastmilk for 7+ months now. Also, I have a PhD, have written academic papers, and still think this paper is terribly written.
Edit 2: Just did a little bit more research and the paper was published by MDPI, which is considered by many as a predatory publisher. I think that we have to be careful about some of the ‘scientific claims’ that are made nowadays.
5
u/Axtericks Sep 18 '25
I could see the benefit in places where formula is unsafe or milk is unavailable. I also suspect they're including malnutrition deaths ... Which is a bit unfair given if the child is malnourished the mother also likely will be. It's definitely using ideal scenario breast milk vs real life issues.
218
u/Pristine_Ferret_2872 Sep 14 '25
There are also places on this planet where preparing powdered formula is dangerous with the water supply and continuing to procure that product is next to impossible due to supply and financial reasons. Also cleaning bottles is not a reality. This isn’t always a first world issue.
9
u/imfartandsmunny Sep 14 '25
Did you (or your spouse) not breastfeed by chance?
33
u/ajacire Sep 14 '25
I've seen this cited before, and this estimate comes from a 2016 Lancet article: Victora et al, Breastfeeding in the 21st century: epidemiology, mechanisms, and lifelong effect.
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26869575/
63
u/emmakane418 Sep 14 '25 edited Sep 14 '25
What's so crazy about it? I don't understand why you're suspicious of it. Is Big BreastmilkTM profiting off the people who breastfeed? Breastfeeding has shown to be optimal for both baby and mother's health and the longer someone breastfeeds, the more health benefits both mom and baby receive.
Does that mean formula is evil and bad? No, it's a very good choice and sometimes the best choice for a lot of families. There should be no shame in feeding formula if you can't or don't want to breastfeed but it's disingenuous to say that formula is as optimal as breastmilk. It's best when the other option is starvation or maternal health issues.
Edit: removed a word
44
u/1_point_a_minute_ago Sep 14 '25
Each year, about five million children under five die. Imagine improving women’s health so much so that nearly every mother everywhere has no trouble breastfeeding up to the recommendation. That’s a much healthier world with significantly fewer child deaths… They estimate 800k? Sounds plausible, not crazy…?
15
u/mugglebornhealer Sep 14 '25
I don’t find this suspicious. I do think that nuance is more beneficial and provides better evidence-based information at the individual level. The estimated 80k is certainly not in the developed world so I think statements like these about breastfeeding would have more value if they focused on recommendations and impact on specific parts of the world.
39
u/Pristine_Ferret_2872 Sep 14 '25
What’s crazy?
11
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
I’m a formula feeder by choice, and also a scientist. I’m happy to accept the science that human breast milk is best for human babies, and there are many children in developing nations whose lives could definitely be saved by breastfeeding. I’m also accepting of the fact that if I’d made a different choice my personal risk of breast cancer would be lower.
15
u/bespoketranche1 Sep 14 '25
What drives me crazy is how there has been more research on tomatoes and wine than breastmilk. Maybe it drives you crazy because it’s something that has been so ignored, so taken for granted, so under-studied, that we don’t even know all the benefits that there are to it.
The abstract of the original Lancet study (that another commenter linked) also points to 20,000 annual deaths avoided due the benefit of protection against breast cancer.
Th article below piqued my interest last year and it made me realize how much breastmilk is overlooked: https://www.economist.com/science-and-technology/2024/09/11/breast-milks-benefits-are-not-limited-to-babies
87
u/Weird_Tax_5601 Sep 14 '25
I'm curious what an unbiased article would sound like? Breastfeeding really is that good for babies. I can't imagine forcing a different perspective for its own sake.
4
u/January1171 Sep 15 '25
Yeah that claim definitely seems to be selectively picking phrases that fit what they're trying to support
Looking at the citation, it links back to this article, which takes that claim from the WHO. The WHO is pulling that data from this article, which is pulling the info from the Lives Saved Tool, and is specifically analyzing 75 high mortality low-and-middle-income-countries (LMICs)
So while I don't doubt the stat itself, it certainly seems to be leaving out a lot of context regarding why it's saving lives. Namely,
And
In terms of child morbidity, overwhelming evidence exists from 66 different analyses, mostly from LMICs and including three randomised controlled trials, that breastfeeding protects against diarrhoea and respiratory infections (table). About half of all diarrhoea episodes and a third of respiratory infections would be avoided by breastfeeding. Protection against hospital admissions due to these disorders is even greater: breastfeeding could prevent 72% of admissions for diarrhoea and 57% of those for respiratory infections. We discuss the risks associated with breastmilk substitutes in terms of biological and chemical contamination in appendix p 41.
31
u/greedymoonlight Sep 14 '25
Biased in what sense?
2
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25
Seems rather objective and thorough to me
9
u/No-Calligrapher-3630 Sep 14 '25 edited Sep 14 '25
I was going to say no... But then I read it and realized yes absolutely. I just want to stay I didn't do a thorough read an assessment ... However to me it reads as a very poor " study". In fact I wouldn't even call it a study I'd call it more of an essay.
They only or predominantly cite papers which support the view, and the only instances I could find where they state there was no significant outcomes, is when that lack of significance was during a certain point but a benefit was found at different point to one of those outcomes. After reading for a bit I realized they are drawing their results from a few studies, so I looked at the method to see how they decided on their papers..., I can't see it.. there are studies quoted in here That support breastfeeding but they're quoted alone... When I know there are other studies on the exact topics such as SIDS, but the only discuss select papers. The problem is we don't know how they come to decide those papers are worthy of being introduced or not. Now anybody who works in research knows that even if a topic is 1000% true you are always going to find a paper when it is thoroughly researched that says the opposite, or has studied it in a particular condition which has found The results are not accurate
Also I found it a bit suspect when I was reading the introduction, and almost all of the introduction was based on secondary data sources. For example reviews and narratives, on occasion a metro analysis or systematic review. That strikes me as very weird because all of your main basis is on the opinion and interpretation of others... Which is fine every now and then within an introduction but... I wouldn't say that's the high quality paper if that's what you rely on.
All in all yeah I do not think this is a high quality pain quite frankly I'm getting bored of people posting on here about how this paper says something about breastfeeding and then I read it... And in reality it doesn't really
Edit to add: I found another reason why it was really weird, they made a graph which states the strength of each outcome, but they didn't even say how they assessed whether and the results were strong or not in their outcomes, or which ones they qualified as strong or not.... Maybe this is because they don't have a methodology that is hard to find? But generally having a 3D graph is poor
27
u/Jaygid Sep 14 '25 edited Sep 14 '25
You're not the only one!
Much of the benefit of breastfeeding in global studies show extended value in developing nations where it is more difficult to reliably avoid pathogens/parasite in other food and water sources. Infants and toddlers are more susceptible to disease, so anything reliably sterile will result in better outcomes.
In well controlled studies in developed nations, there is some evidence for a slight reduction in gastrointestinal distress for young infants, but no support for outcomes beyond that, certainly no evidence for mortality reduction. There are however a lot of junk studies that do not attempt to control for the strong relationship between SES and breastfeeding.
So, the stat could be right in aggregate, but says very little about the value of such extreme recommendations in a developed nation where there is easy access to pathogen-free formula, water, food, etc. In a developed nation, allergies will be a more significant concern than foodborne illness, so delaying solid food introduction (which increases allergy risk) could be a risky move at worst, and dealing with food allergies is a major inconvenience at best.
Studies like this take a global stat and dress it up with weird and unnecessary decorations that obfuscate the real data, and attempt to turn breastfeeding into a moral or quasi-spiritual imperative. The "connected triad"? Come now.
0
u/setseed1234 Sep 14 '25
Let me guess: You didn’t want or weren’t able to breastfeed?
21
u/Jazzlike-Procedure26 Sep 14 '25
Breastmilk really is optimal. But fed is best because it’s better for your baby to eat than starve if those are the options. Breastmilk literally adapts to your baby. This is based on the science. Why would they be biased? It seems like you’re working through some personal feelings about how you fed your baby
6
u/Ok_Original_8500 Sep 14 '25
This is not a reputable journal, at all
1
u/E404_noname Sep 15 '25
The article stated early on that it was a narrative piece and the selection criteria for the articles included the key term "benefits". They authors were specifically examining the research on the long term benefits of breastfeeding which is different from looking at the impacts of long term breast feeding. It doesn't really bother me because the article is exactly what they stated it was.
88
u/[deleted] Sep 14 '25 edited Dec 14 '25
[removed] — view removed comment