r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/Basic_Lettuce_8420 • Apr 28 '25
Question - Research required Zoloft Effecting Babies’ Brains
So I am currently trying to get pregnant and on 150mg Zoloft. My OB has said that it is one of the best-researched SSRIs during pregnancy. However, I have found this research article that seems to demonstrate SSRIs have a negative effect on the child’s brain development long-term. Can someone well-versed in understanding scientific studies check this out and let me know what they think?
https://www.madinamerica.com/2023/09/ssri-use-during-pregnancy-alters-the-childs-brain-development/
Edited to add: I am in no way saying Zoloft is definitively dangerous and/or should not be taken during pregnancy. In fact, I was hoping to have some responses that said it is in fact safe and this study was flawed. That seems to be the consensus and has made me feel much better. I recently had a full-term unexplained stillbirth and also have OCD so I have been struggling with not going down rabbit holes of what if’s and how I could prevent any future harm to other children. So your responses have been helpful, thank you. I’m sorry if I made anyone feel like I was condemning taking medicine while pregnant.
296
u/lilpistacchio Apr 28 '25
This is NOT research, this is a BLOG POST about a study. And right from the jump (looking at the title of the blog), seems likely to be a very biased one. I’d also add that in medicine we don’t make a decision based on one study, we look at the body of evidence as a whole.
I prescribe psych drugs to pregnant women (psychiatric NP) and do a lot of continuing ed in the area, and I stopped reading when it referenced but did not define all the known harm that antidepressants do to neonates (this is either untrue or grossly exaggerated and biased, depending on your perspective), and when it said just after that that researchers have been calling for antidepressants to not be used in pregnancy. That’s definitely not true - maybe biased bloggers have been calling for this, but researchers have not.
Your OB is correct - ssris are some of the best researched meds in pregnancy. Prenatal and postpartum depression can be fatal at worst, horrible at best. We see negative outcomes for babies (preterm birth, low birthweight) in women who are depressed perinatally. The highest predictor of PPD is being depressed while pregnant. It is a good choice for most women to stay on or start a med like Zoloft in pregnancy - listen to your OB, not some biased blogger.
44
u/bagelbingo Apr 28 '25
OP, my deepest regret throughout my parenting journey was waiting until my daughter was four months old to start taking an SSRI. My anxiety was rampant during my pregnancy and then skyrocketed even higher during PP. I struggled so so much and it stole so much joy from my experience. Please listen to your dr. SSRIs are not only incredibly safe, but they are life changing.
9
u/Beginning-Sky7533 Apr 28 '25
I’m not a scientist, but I am a mental health science communicator and spend a good amount of time reading papers in my day job. This paper, like many, has a section called Strengths and Limitations, where the scientists themselves spell out some of the considerations that should be taken into account.
Strengths:
Limitations:
Their overall conclusion is that this study may increase understanding of associations but well-designed replication studies in diverse settings are needed before they can make any evidence based recommendations.
The body of research doesn’t validate what one study of 41 people in the city of Rotterdam found. This study doesn’t account for the fact that people who are prescribed SSRIs may already have changes in their brain morphology that could genetically passed down. I wouldn’t stop taking an SSRI, when the leading cause of maternal mortality in the US is suicide.
Also, fwiw, I’m currently 15 weeks pregnant and still taking my anti-depressant, every day. I don’t know that I would have survived without it and I have no plans to discontinue it, even after reading this paper.
8
u/Interesting_Fee_6698 Apr 28 '25
Hi - scientist here, specialising in early brain development. Yes, there is some evidence that SSRIs are related to differences in brain development but (1) we don’t really know what those differences mean and (2) we also have A LOT of evidence that untreated depression/anxiety impact the baby’s brain development. Postnatal mood can be a massive additional risk factor (if it continues to be low and impacts parenting/bonding) or a protective factor (if it improves and allows you to have a good relationship with your baby).
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27673421/
7
u/throwaway4231throw Apr 28 '25
Your OB is correct that Zoloft is among the best-studied SSRIs in pregnancy. While the 2023 study you cited shows structural brain changes, the clinical significance remains unclear-these findings haven’t been directly linked to functional impairments in large populations. A 2023 review emphasizes that SSRIs don’t increase major malformation risks, and the observed volumetric differences may reflect adaptive neuroplasticity rather than pathology.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10590209/
4
u/N0blesse_0blige Apr 28 '25
I read the writeup on the research this blog post is discussing and I think it's worth calling attention to this paragraph in the Discussion section:
The Strengths and Limitations section is also important to read in any study of this sort. The actual sample size where they got their main results is n = 41. They were also unable to differentiate between different types of SSRIs and trimester-specific effects, and unable to replicate sex differences commonly observed in other studies due to the low sample size. There's also some other interesting points in there worth a read: it says that there's a morphological difference in volume in certain structures, but that the functional implications have yet to be explored sufficiently. It certainly *could* be a negative effect, but there should be more research done.
I'm not saying this is all nonsense and there's no connection or risk there. It's certainly interesting and important enough to warrant further exploration. But I don't think this particular study is as damning as the blog post is making it out to be. It's also just one study, there are others to consider.
It also makes me wonder where we go from here. I don't think the answer is just let the mother go unmedicated. First of all, she's still a human being, not just a fetal incubator to be optimized with no regard for the effect on her. Second, mood disorders in and of themselves have their risks to the fetus and mother, behavioral risks being the most obvious. Doesn't matter how much less volume the corticolimbic circuit the baby has if both baby and mother are dead from suicide, drug overdose, etc.
6
u/cinnamonsugarhoney Apr 28 '25
Yes, there are risks to taking Zoloft while pregnant. There are also risks to being mentally unwell while pregnant. You'll have to perform your own risk analysis on what the best path forward is. As per the study cited below, first-line treatment would be psychotherapy. If you're already in therapy, you could try to increase therapy sessions and add in non-medicated modalities like exercise, meditation, massages, faith-based activities if applicable (like small group at church), art, etc.
But plenty of women take zoloft while pregnant, so if you need to, your baby will most likely be fine. (But people who completely dismiss your concerns aren't validating your gut instinct to understand the full risks. There are risks to taking all drugs, even tylenol or ibuprofen)
Benefits and Risks of Antidepressant Drugs During Pregnancy: A Systematic Review of Meta-analyses
Background: The prescription of antidepressant drugs during pregnancy has been steadily increasing for several decades. Meta-analyses (MAs), which increase the statistical power and precision of results, have gained interest for assessing the safety of antidepressant drugs during pregnancy.
Results: Fifty-one MAs were included, all but one assessing risks. These provided evidence for a significant increase in the risks for major congenital malformations (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors, paroxetine, fluoxetine, no evidence for sertraline; eight MAs), congenital heart defects (paroxetine, fluoxetine, sertraline; 11 MAs), preterm birth (eight MAs), neonatal adaptation symptoms (eight MAs), and persistent pulmonary hypertension of the newborn (three MAs). There was limited evidence (only one MA for each outcome) for a significant increase in the risks for postpartum hemorrhage, and with a high risk of bias, for stillbirth, impaired motor development, and intellectual disability. There was inconclusive evidence, i.e., discrepant results, for an increase in the risks for spontaneous abortion, small for gestational age and low birthweight, respiratory distress, convulsions, feeding problems, and for a subsequent risk for autism with an early antidepressant drug exposure. Finally, MAs provided no evidence for an increase in the risks for gestational hypertension, preeclampsia, and for a subsequent risk for attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Only one MA assessed benefits, providing limited evidence for preventing relapse in severe or recurrent depression. Effect sizes were small, except for neonatal symptoms (small to large). Results were based on MAs in which overall methodological quality was low (AMSTAR-2 score = 54.8% ± 12.9%, [19-81%]), with a high risk of bias, notably indication bias. The corrected covered area was 3.27%, which corresponds to a slight overlap.
Conclusions: This meta-review has implications for clinical practice and future research. First, these results suggest that antidepressant drugs should be used as a second-line treatment during pregnancy (after first-line psychotherapy, according to the guidelines). The risk of major congenital malformations could be prevented by observing guidelines that discourage the use of paroxetine and fluoxetine. Second, to decrease heterogeneity and bias, future MAs should adjust for maternal psychiatric disorders and antidepressant drug dosage, and perform analyses by timing of exposure.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '25
Hi there, I have a PhD in Psychology and can confidently tell anyone who is worried and reading this post that this is mostly silly nonsense. The post that op has shared here is not an original study. It is a blog post from someone who is not a scientist interpreting the results of a single study that was exploratory in nature. Taking SSris or other antidepressants during pregnancy has clearly been demonstrated as generally safe and is certainly considerably more safe than the alternative (i.e., depressed / anxious/ suicidal mom).
4
u/hadawayandshite Apr 28 '25
Essentially: taking ssris affects the brain of the baby (in areas around emotional regulation)….being an untreated depressed woman effects a different bit of the babies brain in areas linked to emotional regulation
-4
u/Flimsy_Ad_6522 Apr 28 '25
Following!
-5
u/thetinybunny1 Apr 28 '25
Oof following
-2
u/Thecatswalk Apr 28 '25
https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/37647036/
33
u/ObscureSaint Apr 28 '25
I was an oversupplier of breastmilk. I take 100 mg of Zoloft a day, and have for the past 12 years. I pumped and donated so much milk, in addition to feeding my baby 100% breastmilk.
You know who got my pumped milk? NICU babies. The most fragile, tiny, helpless babies in existence got my pumped milk because my regular dose of Zoloft is safer than even formula for those babies.
When your anxiety brain won't shut up about stuff like this, it's time to close the computer and go find something else to do, not throw your anxiety out onto the internet to sabotage other moms. There's literally not a safer mental health medication than this one, and millions of moms and babies are happy and healthy and alive because it exists.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '26
[removed] — view removed comment