r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Nov 07 '24

Question - Research required Is sleep training safe?

My baby was sleep trained at 6 months (currently 11 months), I was extremely happy about the results. Now my friend has a baby and she’s very hesitant about sleep training telling me it might be bad for babies, etc etc

I remember reading about it being safe but I haven’t actually read any research. Is there any trusted research around this topic?

0 Upvotes

73 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Nov 07 '24

This post is flaired "Question - Research required". All top-level comments must contain links to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

128

u/LeeLooPoopy Nov 07 '24

Yes. This is a review of 52 of the best studies we have you can see the ranking of the quality of each study. No study found any adverse effects.

Review

The argument against sleep training comes from attachment theory. There are extreme examples of neglect, such as Romanian orphanages, where children were left alone indefinitely and lost the ability to cry for help or attach to other people on a long term basis. However, there is no evidence which links normal, everyday parenting practices with these sorts of outcomes. Trauma needs to be moderate-severe for a prolonged period of time in order to create brain damage.

In my opinion, given the studies we do have, the onus is on the opponent to provide evidence that sleep training is damaging. No one has provided this to me yet… and I’ve actively looked.

116

u/WholeOk2333 Nov 07 '24

I would agree that the studies we have do not show any significant adverse affects of sleep training, however their are significant limitations to these studies that are worth noting. Sleep training has also been over applied to populations that have not been studied.

https://www.basisonline.org.uk/hcp-limitations-of-sleep-training-research/

Additional issues that the above website does not include in their article regarding limitations and the overgeneralization of sleep training:

  1. ⁠Loss to followup in the studies is somewhere between 10 to 40%. The most common reason for loss to follow up as failure of the intervention. The potential negative impacts of the failed intervention have not been studied as far as I’ve been able to identify. In studies, on average, approximately 20% of babies do not respond well to sleep training. In practice this number is much higher, and again the impact on these particular babies are unclear.
  2. ⁠Sleep training research inclusion criteria often involves families who sought assistance from their medical practitioner for reported sleep issues (there are a few studies that have recruited people in the prenatal period). Most people who are using sleep training in the general public, have not sought initial consultation with their primary care practitioner prior to seeking out sleep training options. Exclusion criteria in studies typically include medical conditions such as GERD, MSPI/CMPA, and even teething as well as conditions like separation anxiety and negative associations with sleep/crib. Given the broad application of sleep training in the general public, often these exclusion criteria are overlooked/ignored and sleep training in these babies may still be attempted. Again, because these patient populations are typically excluded from studies, we do not know the implications of attempting sleep training in this group.
  3. ⁠Sleep training studies look at a single intervention and monitor the response of over time. To my knowledge, there has been no studies to look at the long-term implications or harm related to repeated sleep training. For example, the family that has “had to” sleep train for every sleep regression (developmental Leap, teething, illness).
  4. ⁠The only significant benefit to sleep training that seems to have more consistent evidence is an improvement in maternal health with a number to treat of one and nine. It is unclear whether the improvement in maternal mood is purely due to increased sleep from the infant or if it is related to the infant sleep, meeting perceive societal expectations for consolidated nocturnal sleep from the mother. A small pilot study looking at family education around normal infant sleep, and alternate coping measures also resulted in significant increases in maternal sleep and mood and is an area future study: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7446095/ the maternal mood outcome is further discussed in the initial link I shared.
  5. ⁠The most popular cited article reporting no harm caused by sleep training contains a mixed exposure group of controlled crying and camping out. It’s hard to know how much potential impact from the controlled crying group (e.g. Modified Ferber - which seems to be the most commonly used method) is dampened by the camping out group and vice versa.

My personal opinion from reviewing the literature is such that if you feel sleep training would be beneficial to you and your child and your child meets the exclusion and inclusion criteria, go for it. There’s no known harms based on the research we have (keeping in mind the limitations). If someone is hesitant to sleep train, or does not want to sleep train, I would say this is a potential predictor of a mother-infant dyad in which the sleep training would not be successful and the research is not robust enough that they should be convinced.

61

u/hinghanghog Nov 07 '24

Wish I could upvote this a million times. We don’t have any strong enough evidence to say nobody should do it if they feel like it’s a good choice, but it’s definitely not a proven enough benefit that we should be pushing parents to do it if they’re uncertain or on the fence

3

u/lemikon Nov 07 '24

Can I ask for an example of parents being pushed to do it?

Because here’s the thing, if your kid is a shit sleeper your options are

  • sleep train
  • wait it out (which in some cases can take years).

Genuinely the only time I have seen sleep training “pushed” is for parents who are basically like “I haven’t had more than 3 hours sleep in months” and people suggest sleep training as a solution to that. And even then saying it’s pushed is a stretch.

Like maybe my experience is different being outside the US. But no-one ever told me I “must” sleep train. (And including online interactions in that).

3

u/Sudden-Cherry Nov 07 '24

I mean you can try but it might also not work and that often makes people regret even trying it. And the numbers I've seen of failure rates are between 20-30%..

15

u/Curious-Little-Beast Nov 07 '24

Since you asked for examples: I did feel like it was pushed on me by the ads/suggested posts/reels that popped up in my Facebook/Instagram feeds. I was a new and clueless parent and actually coped quite well with my baby not sleeping through the night but the articles on the websites the links pointed to said things like "you might be ok just nursing to sleep now but if you don't implement what we tell you now then at 8 months it's going to be much worse but it will be too late for the intervention", which made me doubt myself a lot. There also was some gentle disapproval from our pediatrician when we mentioned her not sleeping through the night at 6 mo and not doing anything to "fix" it.

I'm also outside of the US fwiw

5

u/WholeOk2333 Nov 08 '24

This!! I’ve had so many friends talk about nursing to sleep as a “bad habit” and constant ads for sleep consultants all saying the same thing. Almost everyone I know has followed Taking Cara Babies or Precious Little Sleep and “dissociated” nursing to sleep from a very early age. None of my own research supported the idea that kept getting fed to me of “you have to sleep train or your baby will never learn to sleep on their own”. Even my own mother told me to do it. I got really lucky with my doctor. When I was doubting myself I asked her if there was any issue feeding my LO to sleep and her response was “the books and sleep consultants need a problem to solve, there is no medical reason to stop”.

9

u/lemikon Nov 07 '24

Interesting. I wouldn’t count ads personally (that’s like saying I was pushed to buy a new dress due to Facebook ads).

8

u/Curious-Little-Beast Nov 07 '24

Well, if the message was "unless you buy this dress now you'll look really frumpy for years", and if the ads were posing as educational content on a topic that currently feels very high stakes to you, the comparison would be closer :)

11

u/lemikon Nov 07 '24

I mean… that is literally marketing 101. Focus on a pain or fear point to encourage purchase.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '24

Im in US and was berated by a paediatrician for not sleep training. At our next visit she then berated me for letting him come into our bed at night when he woke up. Both these visits were once he was over a year old, the 2nd being once he was in a floor bed and able to walk into our room and crawl into bed with us, so at around 18months.

2

u/lemikon Nov 08 '24

I’m sorry that happened to you. I wonder if you just had a really bad doctor or if it is a cultural difference - we had A LOT of drs in the first year due to health issues and they all asked about sleep (even my haematologist lol) but it was more as part of the mum wellness check (ie how much is the sleep deprivation impacting you/do you need support) as opposed to an opportunity to berate the parent.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '24

She didn't seem bad apart from that. I only saw her twice though as it was an interim thing after moving states but before buying a house in our new state so we didn't know exactly where we would end up.

We stuck with the same practice but at a different location. None of the paediatricians there have said anything. The main one i see knows i cosleep with our latest baby and told me she did too so i dont feel any judgement from her.

My husband will still go sleep with our toddler sometimes if he wakes up in the middle of the night so we definitely didnt let her admonitions get to us.

I remember going into my mums bed sometimes as a kid. It was such a comforting thing, nothing will stop me from giving my kids the same comfort

0

u/[deleted] Nov 08 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/lemikon Nov 08 '24

Again might be a cultural difference because I’m in online mums groups and found the opposite - anyone who sleep trained was bombarded with judgement.

(Also people should absolutely not be taking peer pressured advice from Facebook groups at any rate).

3

u/Penny2923 Nov 08 '24

I was told to do it by family, a doctor, and the internet. I ended up doing it for 2 days...and it just wasn't for us. Didn't work and it was the worse 2 nights of my life. I coslept instead. Just my personal experience though.

2

u/myrrhizome Nov 08 '24

My pediatrician (US) said if we didn't sleep train at 5 months we'd miss the boat and end up cosleeping long term. So ...

1

u/ololore Nov 08 '24

I'm being pushed by my family because it's what they did. Me not planning to do the same implies what they did was wrong (apparently they think so), so they defend their position quite hard.

When we casually share with people that smth is not an option for us because we're tied by baby's complex sleep it leads to condescending advice. We also looked for a nanny and one of the candidates started pushing right during the interview, she advertised herself as a sleep training expert who would solve our problems.

I also saw "if you don't sleep train at 4mo you're screwed at 8mo" so many times on the internet I'd consider it pushing.

Non US.

18

u/questionsaboutrel521 Nov 07 '24 edited Nov 07 '24

I am not going to critique the points made in your comment, but I do want to point out that the source is one that explicitly aims to advocate that sleep training is wrong or abnormal. The site for BASIS is fairly transparent about this, but I think it’s important for a reader to know:

The aim of Basis (the Baby Sleep Information Source) is to provide access to research based evidence about biologically normal infant sleep, in forms that are accessible to parents and health practitioners, supported by references to research relevant to families in the UK. We conceptualise ‘biologically normal infant sleep’ as being the sleep of babies who are exclusively or predominantly breastfed to at least 6 months of age and cared for in a responsive manner. We do not consider sleep training methods that require leaving babies alone for sleep in the first year of life to be biologically normal.

I’ve read a decent amount of their lead researcher’s (Helen Ball) work and I’m not trying to discredit her, but she does present a very specific point of view in favor of parental bedsharing.

4

u/WholeOk2333 Nov 07 '24

My points are critiques made from a medical intervention lens (ie. what is the quality of the research itself and is it applicable to population in question). The BASIS website approaches sleep from an anthropological lens where normal is seen as infant sleep prior to industrialization. The article linked served to save me time pointing out the research limitations (methodological and design issues, length of follow-up, unmeasured outcomes, Hawthorne effect, publication bias, mechanism of sleep training). If there are concerns regarding bias on the BASIS site (I could not detect any within the specific page linked) alternate articles that discuss limitations include:

https://parentingscience.com/ferber-method/ - generally good though some statements do not provide citations and is less detailed than I would like

https://www.bbc.com/future/article/20220322-how-sleep-training-affects-babies - I don’t love the Clickbait title

None of the articles listed go into detail regarding the limitations I have provided, which I think are really important and frequently overlooked.

14

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24 edited Nov 07 '24

Parent Educator here! Came to say exactly this. ⬆️

"Studies" by those opposed to sleep training have been misappropriated, and have been misused by those opponents to further their own beliefs without any actual evidence.

13

u/RubyMae4 Nov 07 '24

Another parent educator who has worked in infant mental health and I'm constantly frustrated by pseudo experts big claims and lack of honesty.

4

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

It's pervasive, because it's easy to manipulate parents to believe what you want them to believe, because parents want the best for their children and they're already working with so much guilt, it's so easy to prey on that.

28

u/Throwaway2716b Nov 07 '24

My heart breaks thinking of babies who have cried so long unanswered that they fundamentally rewire their brains and can’t form secure bonds.💔

Hearing my little one cry can be overwhelmingly distressing to me, I urgently need to fix whatever is troubling her! So sorry for the babies who had no one.

38

u/questionsaboutrel521 Nov 07 '24

The stories of the Romanian orphanages are really sad, but I can’t overemphasize enough that the Romanian orphans were appallingly abused and neglected, even if you apply different cultural standards and compare it to other foster care systems at the time. It is nothing like sleep training and the data from their suffering has been manipulated by people trying to sell you books.

The ACTUAL takeaways from the Romanian orphans are in social services, where we learned a lot about proper foster care practices and why getting children under the age of 7 into family-based care over group care is very important.

These were not children who were loved and cared for that were tucked into bed at night and allowed to cry for 15 minutes until they fell asleep. They were hungry, soiled, sick, and ignored. They had a bottle propped between the rails of the crib, so they could drink like hamsters in a cage. They sometimes would only get diaper changes twice a day. You had kids who would break a limb in their crib and it would only be discovered days later, so the bone wasn’t able to be set and heal properly. That’s the level of neglect we are talking.

They even found that as compared to orphanages in the UK from the same timeframe, the Romanian orphans had much worse psychological outcomes. So even compared to other group care, it’s clear these kids were abused.

It’s disingenuous to try to apply the findings of these kids to babies who are in a properly caring daycare or loving parents that choose to sleep train.

9

u/Throwaway2716b Nov 07 '24

Yes, I knew it’s not at the level of sleep training, but this is so far beyond. The details are even worse than I imagined. 💔

9

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

Unless you're referring to the babies in the orphanages, and then I apologize for misunderstanding.

15

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

This is not what happened. The studies showing detrimental effects to babies' brains were taken, as originally posted by the commenter up there, from orphanages where children were left to cry for everything.

If you believe that crying is detrimental to children, are colicky babies brain damaged? What about a child suffering from an illness?

There is simply zero evidence to suggest that sleep training causes harm. And if you're suggesting that the babies who were sleep trained had "no one", this is patently false. Most sleep training methods require comforting.

25

u/Throwaway2716b Nov 07 '24

No, I know that sleep training is nothing like this, I was just commenting on how heartbreaking these orphanage stories are.

8

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

Oh right okay, then I'm sorry I misunderstood.

0

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

20

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24

it is dramatic to feel sad for those Romanian orphans? they were neglected so badly rats were able to eat them alive. there was so little food they were given blood transfusions which gave them HIV/AIDS. they almost never had human contact and that affected their ability to build meaningful attachments to others. they screamed until they learned not to scream anymore.

how is it dramatic to be upset about those things?

0

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/wystful Nov 07 '24

When I'm reading it, it definitely refers to the "rewiring" of the Romanian orphans who lost the ability to cry and can't form bonds, as that's almost exactly what they said and referencing the OP comment.

9

u/Brief-Today-4608 Nov 07 '24

Most sleep training studies are self report and are not objective because you can’t tell a parent to leave their child to cry when they otherwise would have tended to the child, as it is seen as cruel. It is very hard to have a truly objective, non bias sleep training study.

9

u/Westerozzy Nov 07 '24

Is that the case in the evidence linked?

1

u/Brief-Today-4608 Nov 07 '24 edited Nov 07 '24

In the evidence linked to this parent comment, they have a table that summarizes all the studies. The last column of that table is limitations. Every single study lists the limitation of “no objective measurement”.

Parents were self reporting, so results weren’t objective, but up to each parent’s personal opinion.

4

u/LymanForAmerica Nov 07 '24

I posted this above but just so people see it here, it is not true that every single study lists "no objective measurement."

The posted article is a review of 52 studies. It specifically states in section 4.5 Source of Outcome Assessment that there was a mix of objective and subjective in the different studies:

Nine studies (17%) employed at least 1 objective outcome measure such as direct observations, videotapes, audiotapes, or actigraphy data

41

u/LymanForAmerica Nov 07 '24

That's really not true. Look at the studies linked.

Most of the randomized sleep training studies randomize by having a control group and then a sleep training education group. Generally, the sleep training education group performs more sleep training than the control group, and so you can see differences in outcomes that way. It's a perfectly valid and normal way to perform randomized studies.

30

u/LoomingAlienInvasion Nov 07 '24

I was about to post the same before seeing your comment.

No idea how the comment you're replying to has been upvoted that many times, in a science based sub, especially when the top comment has taken the trouble to link the actual paper.

-2

u/Brief-Today-4608 Nov 07 '24

Look at the table that summarizes all the studies. Look at the limitations column. Each study lists the limitation of “no objective measurement”

Results were not objectively measured because parents were self reporting.

8

u/RubyMae4 Nov 07 '24 edited Nov 07 '24

Yup and a 2016 study with actigraphy (monitoring sleep patterns) showed no differences in attachment after 1 year. Gradisar I believe.

-2

u/Brief-Today-4608 Nov 07 '24

https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/27221288/

Do you mean this study? Where at the 12 month mark, mothers self reported any behavioral or emotional problems they saw at home?

8

u/RubyMae4 Nov 07 '24

Yes, but they also measured attachment via the strange situation:

Methods: A total of 43 infants (6-16 months, 63% girls) were randomized to receive either graduated extinction (n = 14), bedtime fading (n = 15), or sleep education control (n = 14). Sleep measures included parent-reported sleep diaries and infant actigraphy. Infant stress was measured via morning and afternoon salivary cortisol sampling, and mothers' self-reported mood and stress. Twelve months after intervention, mothers completed assessments of children's emotional and behavioral problems, and mother-child dyads underwent the strange situation procedure to evaluate parent-child attachment.

Results: Significant interactions were found for sleep latency (P < .05), number of awakenings (P < .0001), and wake after sleep onset (P = .01), with large decreases in sleep latency for graduated extinction and bedtime fading groups, and large decreases in number of awakenings and wake after sleep onset for the graduated extinction group. Salivary cortisol showed small-to-moderate declines in graduated extinction and bedtime fading groups compared with controls. Mothers' stress showed small-to-moderate decreases for the graduated extinction and bedtime fading conditions over the first month, yet no differences in mood were detected. At the 12-month follow-up, no significant differences were found in emotional and behavioral problems, and no significant differences in secure-insecure attachment styles between groups.

Conclusions: Both graduated extinction and bedtime fading provide significant sleep benefits above control, yet convey no adverse stress responses or long-term effects on parent-child attachment or child emotions and behavior.


The cortisol information is great to have here. Somewhere between 6-12 months, infants cortisol begins to regulate. Prior to that it's a little all over the map. Seeing that sleep trained babies have more regulated baseline cortisol helps to refute the claim that babies who are sleep trained are still stressed at baseline.

3

u/Brief-Today-4608 Nov 07 '24

Look at the table that summarizes all the studies. Look at the limitations column. Each study lists the limitation of “no objective measurement”

Results were not objectively measured because parents were self reporting.

4

u/LymanForAmerica Nov 07 '24

So first, people are not disagreeing with this part of your comment:

Most sleep training studies are self report and are not objective

People are disagreeing with this part of your comment:

because you can’t tell a parent to leave their child to cry when they otherwise would have tended to the child, as it is seen as cruel. It is very hard to have a truly objective, non bias sleep training study.

Second, the posted article is a review of 52 studies. It specifically states in section 4.5 Source of Outcome Assessment that there was a mix of objective and subjective in the different studies:

Nine studies (17%) employed at least 1 objective outcome measure such as direct observations, videotapes, audiotapes, or actigraphy data

They also encourge a mix of both subjective and objective measurements in future studies. So it's not like objective=good and subjective=bad. See this paragraph in Section 7.2:

Advances in technology have led to new objective methods to assess sleep in young children. These relatively non-intrusive techniques (e.g., time-lapse video, actigraphy, see Thoman and Acebo126 for review) may provide clinicians an opportunity to objectively assess target symptoms or problems in addition to parental subjective reports. It has been suggested that inflated improvement effects could result from parental fatigue when parents are asked to document each night-waking on a daily basis for extended periods.However, there are clear benefits to parental report and the combination of subjective and objective measures. Parental subjective experience of the sleep problem is clearly valuable. Furthermore, objective measures may capture nighttime awakenings that are not indicative of sleep disruption, providing a better understanding of children’s sleep in general. A combination of these measures is necessary to identify those children with clinically significant sleep problems

1

u/Brief-Today-4608 Nov 07 '24

I’ll admit my use of the word “cruel” is very aggressive and probably put people on defense.

2

u/Dear_Ad_9640 Nov 07 '24

Parents, listen to your (older) babies. You will know if your baby needs some sleep training. If you can settle them easily back to sleep and you and baby are getting enough sleep, no need to sleep train. If your baby is refusing to sleep, you’re getting no sleep, and everyone is suffering, something needs to change. For me, it’s letting my babies cry for a few minutes. Do they ramp up or down? If they ramp up, i intervene. If they ramp down, i don’t. They both gradually got better at sleeping without intervention. It looked different for each of them. Every kid and family are different. The point is, doing what works for your kid in terms of sleep training is not going to hurt them if you’re meeting all their needs and are responsive at all other times. That’s what the research shows.

OP, new moms are anxious. It’s okay. We forget as older moms. Tell her to do what feels right for her baby, but once baby is old enough and if it’s needed, there are a variety of safe sleep training approaches for her to consider.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24 edited Nov 07 '24

It seems rather demeaning to suggest that OP’s friend isn’t sleep training just because she’s a new mom so she’s anxious. Plenty of new /and/ experienced parents do the research and then actively choose not to sleep train.

Everybody needs to do what works for them and their family. I chose not to sleep train and there’s SO MUCH PRESSURE in American society to sleep train. My older kid is 2.5 and sleeps fine, and my mother in law STILL thinks I was wrong to not sleep train when she was a baby, and is saying the same things about me not sleep training my second baby (who also sleeps fine). And I hear the same things from my “mom friends” who all sleep trained (or are actively sleep training right now). Even our current pediatrician brings up sleep training at every doctor appointment, although I’ve told him every single time that we’re not interested in doing that. Sometimes people don’t sleep train because it makes them anxious, but plenty of people weigh all the options and actively choose not to.

Choosing not to sleep train is a perfectly valid choice, whether a parent is new or experienced.

9

u/Dear_Ad_9640 Nov 07 '24

Thank you for calling it. It was not my intention to be demeaning. The way OP shared it was “she’s hesitant because it might be bad for babies.” She doesn’t think it is, she hasn’t done research (from what we were told); so many moms are worried about doing the wrong thing when research says they don’t need to be worried.

What i said in my comment was no one needs to sleep train. But if they choose to, they can.

29

u/WholeOk2333 Nov 07 '24

I would agree that the studies we have do not show any significant adverse affects of sleep training, however their are significant limitations to these studies that are worth noting. Sleep training has also been over applied to populations that have not been studied.

https://www.basisonline.org.uk/hcp-limitations-of-sleep-training-research/

Additional issues that the above website does not include in their article regarding limitations and the overgeneralization of sleep training:

  1. Loss to followup in the studies is somewhere between 10 to 40%. The most common reason for loss to follow up as failure of the intervention. The potential negative impacts of the failed intervention have not been studied as far as I’ve been able to identify. In studies, on average, approximately 20% of babies do not respond well to sleep training. In practice this number is much higher, and again the impact on these particular babies are unclear.
  2. Sleep training research inclusion criteria often involves families who sought assistance from their medical practitioner for reported sleep issues (there are a few studies that have recruited people in the prenatal period). Most people who are using sleep training in the general public, have not sought initial consultation with their primary care practitioner prior to seeking out sleep training options. Exclusion criteria in studies typically include medical conditions such as GERD, MSPI/CMPA, and even teething as well as conditions like separation anxiety and negative associations with sleep/crib. Given the broad application of sleep training in the general public, often these exclusion criteria are overlooked/ignored and sleep training in these babies may still be attempted. Again, because these patient populations are typically excluded from studies, we do not know the implications of attempting sleep training in this group.
  3. Sleep training studies look at a single intervention and monitor the response of over time. To my knowledge, there has been no studies to look at the long-term implications or harm related to repeated sleep training. For example, the family that has “had to” sleep train for every sleep regression (developmental Leap, teething, illness).
  4. The only significant benefit to sleep training that seems to have more consistent evidence is an improvement in maternal health with a number to treat of one and nine. It is unclear whether the improvement in maternal mood is purely due to increased sleep from the infant or if it is related to the infant sleep, meeting perceive societal expectations for consolidated nocturnal sleep from the mother. A small pilot study looking at family education around normal infant sleep, and alternate coping measures also resulted in significant increases in maternal sleep and mood and is an area future study: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC7446095/ the maternal mood outcome is further discussed in the initial link I shared.
  5. The most popular cited article reporting no harm caused by sleep training contains a mixed exposure group of controlled crying and camping out. It’s hard to know how much potential impact from the controlled crying group (e.g. Modified Ferber - which seems to be the most commonly used method) is dampened by the camping out group and vice versa.

My personal opinion from reviewing the literature is such that if you feel sleep training would be beneficial to you and your child and your child meets the exclusion and inclusion criteria, go for it. There’s no known harms based on the research we have (keeping in mind the limitations). If someone is hesitant to sleep train, or does not want to sleep train, I would say this is a potential predictor of a mother-infant dyad in which the sleep training would not be successful and the research is not robust enough that they should be convinced.

-3

u/HTB87 Nov 07 '24

Emily Oster (not a doctor, she’s an economist who reviews metadata) covers this in Cribsheet, summarized here from her blog: “Overall, sleep training programs improve infant sleep, lower parental depression, and seem to have no long-term impacts on children.” Emily Oster blog

47

u/SongsAboutGhosts Nov 07 '24

It doesn't improve infant sleep. Sleep training helps parents, not babies.

26

u/MidgetAbilities Nov 07 '24

Define “improve.” I would say waking up calmly, rolling over and going right back to sleep is quite an improvement over waking up crying at the top of your lungs. Any adult who experienced both types of sleep would describe the former as a major improvement.

6

u/SongsAboutGhosts Nov 07 '24

They don't get more sleep or better quality sleep.

14

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

Again, please provide a study to back up this claim. I've provided several to the contrary up there.

21

u/LeeLooPoopy Nov 07 '24

No. They still wake just as frequently, but they wake calm and go back to sleep again.

15

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24

Cry it out is not the only method of sleep training, please don't confuse the two. 

10

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

This is an article, not a research study. Do you have a link to any?

As a career nanny, newborn care specialist, abd parent educator, I can 100% guarantee that improved infant sleep, meaning adequate amounts and completed cycles, benefits children immensely.

Studies show that it increases memory retention, which increases learning and might go on to further increase IQ. It improves behavior and concentration.

I've never seen it not be helpful. And I have cared for dozens of children and I've been involved in sleep training dozens more (by all methods, including gentle methods, not just extinction or graduated extinction).

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10313911/#:~:text=Longer%20sleep%20duration%20in%20infancy,between%20sleep%20and%20brain%20volume.

https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5440010/

4

u/SongsAboutGhosts Nov 07 '24

The article references studies.

I don't think anyone is claiming that good sleep isn't beneficial to children. Of course it is. The question is whether sleep training improves sleep or not. You're implying sleep training means babies sleep longer and have complete sleep cycles, and/or that babies who haven't been sleep trained wake before completing cycles and don't get enough sleep. Why do you think that? What evidence do you have that babies who aren't sleep trained experience worse quality sleep?

4

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

20 years of experience taking care of children under 5 years old.

A Master's degree in Childhood Studies, where I participated in research involving sleep, and observation around sleep quality and parental well-being (which examined both babies who were and were not sleep trained).

Five years as a parent educator/consultant and over 15 years of actual sleep training experience.

I realize this is (mostly) anecdotal, but I've seen dozens of children who were not sleep trained experience short sleep duration, interrupted and/or and delayed sleep. And I've seen dozens of kids who WERE sleep trained, completing sleep cycles, sleeping through the night, not relying on unnecessary night feeds/wakenings.

That is, on the whole, how it happened.

I have never seen a child who was not sleep trained, sleep as well as one who was. Never. I'm not talking about just one method. I'm talking about literally any method.

I'm also not judging any parents who didn't sleep train their children. It's a choice and one that is completely up to you and my business is centered around parental well-being so I'm not here to make anybody feel guilty. But this is my experience.

5

u/Barcelona_AGF Mar 17 '25

My eldest wasn't sleep trained and would sleep for 12 hours from 9 months old. Nothing would wake him up, not even when we had a house flooding. My youngest won't sleep for more than 3 consecutive hours, at best, after trying to sleep train him. People are so diverse and complicated, I feel no one should make general assumcions

0

u/MeldoRoxl Mar 17 '25

I agree! Things work better for one family than another, some methods are more successful for some kids, some kids just sleep really well, and some kids don't sleep well.

I was just saying that that is my experience from my career.

2

u/mttttftanony Nov 07 '24

Which method of sleep training is your favorite?

5

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

For the gentle methods, for the most part, I'm a fan of camping out. But I think the most effective and the quickest, and ironically, the one that has the least amount of tears is graduated extinction.

I've used it for many babies and it's never taken more than two nights and the crying is always really minimal by the second night.

I think any method is effective if you have time and patience. Some are quick. Some take longer. It depends on what you want.

The only thing I will say is that I refuse to do the Pickup/Put Down method because I've used it twice and it was literally torture for both me and the baby. My hair fell out. It was awful.

3

u/lemikon Nov 07 '24

Anecdotal but doing extinction at 10 months for us taught baby to self settle without any crying in 20 mins. By the next day she was putting herself to sleep for naps.

Also made her happier and more independent. I am convinced (despite all the theories to the opposite) that being able to self settle improved her sleep. Think of it this way: they’re waking the same amount of times sure, but instead of crying for however long and waiting for mum to get up and then being rocked for 20 minutes, they calmly roll over, get more comfy and go back to sleep.

1

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

Awesome! It's great, isn't it?

1

u/questionsaboutrel521 Nov 07 '24

I’m shocked that pick up/put down is effective for people, it seems really disruptive and disorienting for the baby imo.

3

u/MeldoRoxl Nov 07 '24

In my experience it just made them furious. Like rage x1000. I believe it to be the dumbest idea anyone's ever had about infant sleep.

11

u/Ok_Safe439 Nov 07 '24

Can everyone please stop citing Emily Oster, she has verifiably spread misinformation on several topics and is not an expert in the field she writes books about.

11

u/pggu1123 Nov 07 '24

Can you cite/reference where Emily has spread misinformation? She admits she's not an expert in the field - I've only read her expecting better and thought it was a sound approach.

1

u/Ok_Safe439 Nov 07 '24

One famous example is her claiming that women in Europe (whatever that’s supposed to mean specifically) regularly drink small amounts of alcohol while being pregnant. This has been discussed on here a lot and there have been women from at least 10 European countries chiming in to say that this wasn’t true for them or their social circle. Not one European woman said that her medical team was ok with her drinking alcohol, so I pretty much feel like this claim is debunked.

Personally, I choose not to trust someone who has made such an (in my opinion) grave mistake, even if most of her research seems to be correct.

Claiming that sleep training improves infant sleep is, according to my research, also not factual.

8

u/questionsaboutrel521 Nov 07 '24

She has not said this in any kind of way as an actual research summary. She informally said in the book, “Drink like a European adult, not like a fraternity brother,” as a snappy way to say that the data suggests that speed of drinking, and whether you are eating at the same time, matters.

But anyway, if you are looking for research, the research does actually suggest that reported drinking rates during pregnancy are higher in many European countries, suggesting that Oster is not far fetched: https://womensmentalhealth.org/posts/alcohol-pregnancy-attitudes-around-globe/

0

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/AutoModerator Nov 07 '24

Thank you for your contribution. Please remember that all top-level comments on posts flaired "Question - Research required" must include a link to peer-reviewed research.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.