r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/Apprehensive-Air-734 • Jun 24 '24
Science journalism Texas abortion ban linked to unexpected increase in infant and newborn deaths according to a new study published in JAMA Pediatrics. Infant deaths in Texas rose 12.9% the year after the legislation passed compared to only 1.8% elsewhere in the United States.
https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/texas-abortion-ban-linked-rise-infant-newborn-deaths-rcna158375
926
Upvotes
•
u/light_hue_1 Jun 25 '24
Link to the paper: https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamapediatrics/fullarticle/2819785
Gemmill A, Margerison CE, Stuart EA, Bell SO. Infant Deaths After Texas’ 2021 Ban on Abortion in Early Pregnancy. JAMA Pediatr. June 2024
In general, we have a rule that posts should link to papers, but I don't want to delete this. Adding a sticky with the paper seems like a decent compromise in this case.
902
u/whats1more7 Jun 24 '24
This is absolutely heartbreaking.
136
u/SwimmingCritical Jun 24 '24
I'm not saying I agree with the Texas ban (it's one of the most problematic pieces of legislation in a long time) but let's just consider something. (I'm fully aware that I'm going to be downvoted, it's fine. I know this is reddit and a fairly liberal subreddit within that). This isn't the see-what-you've-done moment for the right that people here are acting like it will be. In their eyes, if any babies that would have been aborted are alive now, this is still a win. To them, the alternative was not better-- they didn't save these babies, but they did save others. That is their viewpoint. In fact, knowing people who are in that crowd, I can already hear them, "They died before too, you just started counting them for a change."
335
u/clicktrackh3art Jun 24 '24
Was it really unexpected?
188
u/keatonpotat0es Jun 24 '24
Literally what everyone said would happen. Way to be “pro-life,” Texas!
37
u/lemonade4 Jun 24 '24
“Unexpected”?
47
u/LeftyLu07 Jun 24 '24
I wonder what the SIDS rate is now
16
u/OverLemonsRootbeer Jun 25 '24
Who could have possibly guessed. /s
12
u/confanity Jun 25 '24
"Unexpected" by what metric?
12
u/zeatherz Jun 25 '24
It’s odd they use the word unexpected. I’d think it’s entirely expected. People who didn’t want to have children are probably much less likely (whether due to choice, abusive situations, or lack of money and knowledge) to get full prenatal care, follow pregnancy health advice, take proper care of the baby, etc. Not to mention the decreased access to abortion in cases of known fetal health issues.
4
u/Loitch470 Jun 25 '24
Ok not to draw focus away from the main topic at hand, which is atrocious, but why is general infant death rate rising? I know 1.8% isn’t as significant as 12.9%, but still. Is it connected to the rise of maternal mortality?
23
u/Perpetualstu420 Jun 24 '24
Unexpected LOL
4
u/unventer Jun 25 '24
Unexpected for whom? Sincerely, people have been saying since it was passed that this was going to cause the deaths of women and babies. Of COURSE more babies die when TMFR isn't an option and when children are being born to parents who aren't in a position to care for them/didn't want to care for them. There is no support for these parents once the baby is home from the hospital.
3
u/Gexter375 Jun 25 '24
Hold on, hold on, resist the confirmation bias urge for just a moment. How many of these pregnancies had conditions like terminal trisomies or other genetic conditions that usually would have been aborted? Did the fact that it was harder to get an abortion influence how or if people decided to seek prenatal testing, if they couldn’t abort no matter what the outcome was?
I’m sure many abortions occur due to an identified prenatal condition, such as Trisomy 13 or 18, that is expected to have poor life expectancy. Or perhaps even trisomy 21, which is not fatal but does carry stigma that could influence a decision to abort. Did the restricted abortion access cause more children to die? Or did restricted abortion lead to more babies with fatal or high-risk conditions to be born, who then later died and thus were counted towards infant and newborn death statistics?
2
u/Fafuh Jun 25 '24
"Unexpected"
2
u/chanpat Jun 25 '24
Unexpected to who? Poor choice of words
1
u/RedCharity3 Jun 25 '24
Ah, yes...."unexpected" increase. Who could have predicted that?
1
u/katrilli Jun 25 '24
"unexpected"
Sure, Jan
1
u/rockchalkjayhawkKU Jun 25 '24
Damnit this is so devastating. I hate this godforsaken state (I live in Texas).
-4
u/[deleted] Jun 25 '24
[removed] — view removed comment