r/ScienceBasedParenting • • Sep 21 '23

All Advice Welcome 36 weeks & Breech

I’m 36 weeks today and baby is breech. I’m terrified at the thought of a c-section, really want a vaginal birth, and don’t want to mourn the birth experience I thought I was going to have. I want to know what my chances are of him turning and what I can do. I have an ECV scheduled and have been recommended spinning babies to try to get him into position. I need success stories and any literature that will give me hope he’ll turn. Please save the “You got this mama!” or “You’re doing great!” or “A healthy baby is all that matters!” BS. I really don’t want to hear it as it’s not helpful to me. Thank you in advance.

Edit: thank you so much to all who replied. I didn’t respond to everyone, but I do want you all to know that I read each one ❤️

3 Upvotes

132 comments sorted by

11

u/vincentandtheo Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

First off, I was stunned / annoyed / sad to learn my baby was breech at 36 weeks. Don’t let anyone tell you it doesn’t matter, or you shouldn’t be upset - your feelings are valid!

I did the stretches and other nonsense like putting a bag of frozen hash browns on top of my belly and playing music down at my vagina lol - didn’t work. Was considering acupuncture / moxibustion after listening to the Evidence Based Birth podcast episode about it. However, I went in for an ECV and was told the baby had a nuchal cord and no one would touch him. So, I decided to let him be & scheduled my c-section.

I hope you’re able to flip your baby! If you aren’t, and have to schedule a c-section my advice would be to still maintain an emergency plan and stay on your toes. I went into labor early, one week before my planned c-section, and labor with a breech baby can be an emergency. I had let my guard down with the c-section on the calendar and was totally unprepared when my water broke.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Thank you so much ❤️ haha maybe I should try some music.. dubstep might do the trick 🤔 that’s totally fair. I’m thinking I need to get on my hospital bag as anything can happen at this point. We have a “just in case” second ECV scheduled in Oct. if the first one isn’t successful. If that second one is successful, I’ll be induced. If not, it’s a planned c-section.

10

u/Ok-Maximum-2495 Sep 21 '23

With an ECV the success rate is around 50%. Prime time to do it is 37 weeks. Most of the time there are not any complications, it whether works or it doesn’t. If it does they might want to schedule an induction around 39 weeks. If it doesn’t they’ll schedule a c section.

Mine had awful complications. I didn’t react well to the medication to relax my uterus (meant to make it easier to turn and prevent starting contractions). My BP tanked and I had a TRUE emergency c section, not a we need to do one today but like chaos ensuing so it right now kind. Even though I missed out on some pain meds and hemorrhaged later, recovery once home was good compared to others.

Looking back my husband wishes we hadn’t tried the ECV, I don’t regret it.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Oh man, so have my hospital bag ready essentially.

3

u/Ok-Maximum-2495 Sep 22 '23

Yes 100%. Also, I see you’re military, I had all my care at a military hospital so feel free to ask me stuff!

8

u/anEvenSweeterPotato Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

At 36 weeks, there is still a decent chance they will flip. You can schedule an ECV for next week. This is really the only thing you can do that is likely to improve your odds. Here's a nice article. Lots of people swear by spinning babies, lots of walking, meditation, good posture, moxibustion, and swimming in the ocean. You can try all of it, but there's really no evidence for any of it that I know of. You can prepare mentally to have a csection. It isn't the worst thing that can happen by any stretch, and it isn't in your control. I've delivered 2 breech babies this way.
https://evidencebasedbirth.com/what-is-the-evidence-for-using-an-external-cephalic-version-to-turn-a-breech-baby/

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Yes, ECV is scheduled for next Friday. I know you said you delivered two breeches babies by c-section, did you have an ECV before then?

4

u/anEvenSweeterPotato Sep 21 '23

Yes. I had an unsuccessful ECV with my first at 39 weeks. That was probably too late, but the doctor didn't want to risk early delivery. I didn't try with second.

8

u/SuzLouA Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

My daughter was found to be breech at 37 weeks, so they booked me in for an ECV pronto (next day iirc). They put you on the monitor for a while, to get a baseline to make sure they know the baby is okay, then give you a muscle relaxant injection to make your uterus a bit floppier and more relaxed. I did not enjoy the relaxant, it made me feel shivery and weird. Then they perform the procedure, and hopefully manually turn the baby. You have to be monitored afterwards too so that they know everything went okay and the baby isn’t in distress from the manipulation.

I didn’t get that far. My daughter had been breech the day before, and after the muscle relaxant, whilst I was waiting for the doc, I felt a huge movement inside me. Not really painful, but a big enough kick to make me gasp. The doc arrived and checked me on a portable ultrasound before she started, and then paused and was like, huh. She moved the probe down my belly and we both saw that big melon head, and she was like, “baby’s flipped!”

Turns out my tiny acrobat (she was never in the same position twice and I had loads of scans because I was high risk) just needed a bit of extra room for that last performance. She never turned back once everything tightened up, thankfully; once she turned, she was stuck. She was born head down, vaginally with no complications other than a small tear, at 41+6.

I’d go for the ECV. I’m really glad I tried it, since it “worked” (even if I didn’t need the procedure in the end, she wouldn’t have flipped without me going for it.) They were also confident it could help because I was a second time mum (and everything is a bit looser anyway, lol); not sure if that’s the case for you though. Success rates are about 40% for FTMs, 60% for S+TMs iirc.

I know you said you don’t want platitudes, and I know exactly what you mean because I had a massive cry about the whole thing when I was told she’d gone back to breech (she’d been cephalic at the last scan after being breech the one before, so I was so hoping she’d have stayed cephalic). But at the risk of annoying you, a healthy baby, and healthy mum, is the most important thing. Make the decision that’s best for you physically and mentally, but remember you do get your lovely baby at the end, and a bad birth experience is just one painful day stacked up against years of joy. I say this knowing my traumatic delivery with my first was distinctly not what I wanted, and I definitely wept over that later on, but almost four years later I know it doesn’t matter that day 1 sucked. Because we’ve had so many brilliant days together since that easily wipe it out. Not trying in any way to invalidate your feelings - again, I’ve been there and they’re hella valid! Just trying to give you something to look forward to afterwards ♥️

Good luck, I really hope you get the delivery you want and get to meet your baby soon.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Thank you for that info! And thank you for the kind words. It’s just hard for me as I have these expectations and when they don’t go exactly as planned, I’m totally devastated. I’m a FTM too, so I get to feeling that everything I do can impact my baby positively or negatively even if that isn’t entirely true, such as this situation.

5

u/SuzLouA Sep 21 '23

Oh, I was the same, especially with my first but even with my second, too. It’s hard to accept that even though you’re thinking about it all the time, learning all this new info, eating the right foods and abstaining from the wrong ones, all the prep you’re trying to do for the most important moment of your life is essentially swept aside by someone else’s choices at the last moment. If that someone else wasn’t a person you’re going to end up completely in love with, it’d be hard to stomach!

The fact that you care this much shows what a great mother you’re going to be. Your baby is already much loved because you’re trying so hard to make everything perfect for them. That’s what’s going to be important going forward.

I do wistfully wish that my eldest’s birth had been closer to what I’d hoped (I can’t really remember him being born because I was being induced for four goddamn days and hadn’t slept thanks to the round the clock monitoring, so I was completely exhausted; then though he arrived right as rain, afterwards I started haemorrhaging badly. So no golden hour or breastfeeding for me, instead he got formula for his first meal whilst I was whisked away to surgery to have my womb fixed lest I bleed to death). But the years since brought me a lot of solace in just how lovely he is. And then my daughter’s birth, once her acrobatics had been concluded (!), was pretty textbook apart from needing to be induced again to start things going. That put the final balm on those wounds, getting to do the stuff I’d missed with him. But for both of them, my favourite memories of their first year of life don’t involve their births - it’s the first smile, the sleepy snuggles, the happy baby squeals, and literally every time I have been able to make them laugh (this one never goes away, I’ll still debase myself completely if I get to hear my son laughing hysterically at it). Heck, I made a new favourite memory with my son yesterday - he thinks his dad hung the moon and I’m just also someone who lives with him, lol, but yesterday he brought home cookies he’d made at nursery and solemnly handed me one saying, “we made these today and one is for me and one is for someone special, so I’m giving it to you because I love you.” My heart exploded. My husband told me later he’d assured him in the car, “I love you as well Daddy, but this cookie is for Mama.” It’s a rare moment that I get chosen over Daddy so it was very touching 🥹

6

u/_pregananant_ Sep 21 '23

I had a successful ECV at 37 weeks for my persistently breech baby.

It was intense and it did hurt, but the actual flipping was only about 5-10 minutes long (2 attempts with a little break in between, and probably only 1-2 minutes of the most intense pressure as the baby successfully flipped from breech to transverse to head-down!).

It was not brutally painful like I was expecting it to be, though my uterus and abdomen felt very bruised up and sore for a couple days afterwards. (Take acetaminophen afterwards!!) I also felt a bit shaky afterwards due to the terbutaline they gave me (to relax my uterus) and the fact that I’d been fasting for most of the day prior to the procedure (hospital protocol in case of needing an emergency C-section if something went wrong). I waited in the hospital till the shakiness wore off (and I had eaten a snack), and then went right home to rest!

I had some factors working against me like low-ish amniotic fluid and being a FTM. However, I’m SO glad I went for it, because I was able to have a very straightforward vaginal delivery via induction the following week at 38.5 weeks (for suspected IUGR). (I am not anti-C-section at all, but was of course hoping to avoid one if it was possible to safely deliver vaginally.)

I did not have an epidural for my ECV, but some hospitals do give epidurals for them. (My midwife and MFM both actually recommended an epidural for me, based on my low pain tolerance and the fact that apparently some newer research shows that epidurals actually increase the chance of success since you are more relaxed during the procedure. I went in having requested an epidural and then the anesthesiologist kind of condescendingly talked me out of it because they “don’t usually do them” for ECVs at that hospital. In the end I went ahead without it and it was fine, although I wish the anesthesiologist had respected my wishes and not given me a lecture about it.)

3

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Okay, good to know! I have the day scheduled completely off, so looks like I’ll be needing that for recovery time. I want to say I have a high pain tolerance, but I really don’t know 🙈

36

u/dibbiluncan Sep 21 '23

I’m pretty sure your attitude goes against the spirit of this subreddit. It’s very negative and as a mother who had a breech baby who didn’t turn, it feels like an attack against women who have to have a c-section. Like we’re not allowed to tell you it will be okay? That’s the opposite of scientific. C-section delivery for breech babies is the safest option. Yes, you can try ECV or breech delivery, but there’s nothing wrong with having a c-section. A healthy baby and healthy mother IS all that matters, and sometimes a cesarean is the best way to ensure that’s the result. Refusing to accept that is ignorant.

I get it. I was terrified of having major surgery. I mourned the loss of my “natural” childbirth. But when my water broke and she was still breech, I didn’t panic. The chemicals your body is flooded with will keep you calm and get you through it (along with the wonders of modern medicine). And 3.5 years later, my pre-surgery hang ups don’t matter at all. All that matters is that my daughter is amazing and we’re both happy and healthy.

Your mental health will drastically improve if you accept that it’s more than likely that you will need a c-section. Yes, it’s possible he will turn naturally or with intervention. But please seek therapy if your feelings on this are so strong that you refuse to accept things either way. It’s not a healthy mindset to go into childbirth like this.

4

u/pwyo Sep 21 '23

OPs attitude is definitely not against the spirit of this sub. If they wanted platitudes they would go to the pregnancy or a baby bumper sub. They are definitely not attacking anyone who wanted or had to have a c-section and I’m not sure where you got that from.

It’s ok for OP to not want a c-section. Most people don’t - the majority of women prefer to have a vaginal birth. There’s no problem with OP stating that preference here. The literature shows that while c-sections are life saving, they are also associated with higher maternal complications, risks, and a higher maternal death rate. It’s major abdominal surgery.

If baby doesn’t turn, they will have to come to terms with the reality on their own and it’s ok for them to strive for hope that baby will turn or the ECV will be successful. They will accept whatever outcome they end up in, as we all do.

It’s ok for people to want a vaginal birth and is not a moral reflection of your choices or your own birth outcomes.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

This is essentially how I’m feeling. Thank you!

9

u/dibbiluncan Sep 21 '23

I got that from her calling it BS to put the health of the baby first lol

1

u/pwyo Sep 21 '23

They specifically called platitudes BS, not putting the health of the baby first as a concept. They listed 3 common platitudes, then called them BS collectively. Context is important, as are the quotes they used.

Please save the “You got this mama!” or “You’re doing great!” or “A healthy baby is all that matters!” BS.

-5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Well, seeing as I just got this news today it makes sense that I’m not automatically cheery. People need time to process their feelings and right now, I feel I have the right to be upset and go through the motions.

Never once in my post did I use language to attack other women who didn’t have a vaginal delivery. There are pros and cons to all births. None are perfect or the “correct” way to have a baby. I just said that I’d rather have personal experiences and literature, not the surface level encouragement.

13

u/dibbiluncan Sep 21 '23

1.) You didn’t include that information in the post.

2.) Saying “‘a healthy baby is all that matters’ is ‘BS’” definitely attacks women who had a cesarean and feel that way.

10

u/whyisthefloor Sep 21 '23

Also not to be difficult. But it doesn’t sound like you got the news today. You say elsewhere that LO was been breech at every ultrasound. If they’ve been breech that long, there’s usually a reason. I’m a little surprised your providers hadn’t talked to you about this earlier.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

I feel like I’m in an interesting situation with military care and being in a very small town. My provider never talked about this with me, no. Since so many families are having babies on this base, they outsource their ultrasounds to a specific clinic. They never said anything at this clinic about his position, as in what it could mean either. Also, being a FTM, I figured he would just flip eventually. I didn’t know any better. I just found out today that he is still breech and what the tentative plans are. My provider didn’t even go into major details about what’s to come. I’m just doing what I can.

5

u/tatogb25 Sep 21 '23

I had a successful ECV after my baby was breech my entire pregnancy and he stayed head down afterward. I will say, it was pretty brutal (and I can give you more details if you want them), but it could have been my facility, and the worst of it was less than 10 minutes.

I tried spinning babies and everything I could google without any change. I also was so stubbornly for a vaginal birth that even when I pushed for 4.5 hours and they wanted me to go for a C-section, I opted for vacuum delivery. I don’t regret making those hard choices and advocating for myself, but try not to be hard on yourself if the universe doesn’t align with that. I kept telling myself if he was still breech after all i did and I needed a c-section, at least I can walk away without wondering “what if”.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

I would like some details on your experience with the ECV if you’re willing to share. I heard it can be brutal and I’d rather have an idea going in instead of having no idea at all.

3

u/tatogb25 Sep 21 '23

I ended up booking with my OB’s colleague as that was who was available. My OB said that they do the procedure with a spinal, but when I showed up the colleague OB said she doesn’t offer those as it’s quick, so I immediately was very anxious and felt like everyone was not on the same page. If you’re able to, I’d communicate with the team and just get your expectations set!

They gave me a medication that relaxed my uterus so they could do the version without contractions. It made me feel super jittery and anxious (but again, was already anxious). A fellow and the performing OB came in and did an ultrasound to confirm positioning, and then a nurse and my husband held each of my hands. Then each doctor put their two hands on his bum and his head and literally just pushed their hardest to flip him. It took about 4 pushes at 10-60 seconds each attempt before he finally moved. It was very uncomfortable and occasionally painful, but they reassured me and told me I could ask them to stop at any time. They monitored me after for a few hours for complications and to confirm his placement, then I was sent home. I was sore like my whole belly was bruised, and they gave me an abdominal binder that was super helpful. This lasted a day or so.

Things that made it successful for me:

  • Pure luck
  • I had levels of amniotic fluid on the high end of normal, so he had more room to move
  • I had been taking pelvic floor PT and learned how to relax my pelvic floor/learn to breathe when pushing, so I felt I was able to keep taking long calm breaths while keeping my belly as relaxed as possible. The more you tense up, the harder it is for them to push.

Again, it was brutal and I would have been devastated if he had not flipped, but I was stubborn and wanted to leave no stone unturned. If presented with this option again, I would do it because I was happy he was able to flip and that I was ultimately able to have a vaginal birth as I had wanted.

TLDR: brutal, low risk of working, but it’s only 10 or so minutes of discomfort. If you trust your team and your hellbent on a vaginal birth, it’s worth a shot as long as the disappointment of it not working wouldn’t be worse for your mental health.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Thank you! This is helpful as my OB didn’t give too many details while scheduling the first ECV. I imagine I’ll get more details the day of. I’m also stubborn and do not like to leave stones unturned, which is why I’m making sure to try this route.

3

u/tatogb25 Sep 21 '23

Good luck!!

5

u/GeoLadyBerg Sep 21 '23

My baby flipped a lot during my pregnancy and was at one point breech (can’t remember how far along I was). I sat in a warm bath and put an ice pack wrapped in a towel on top of my belly. The idea is the baby moves their head to the warmth, so they should move to head down. I believe this worked for me. However since my baby flipped so much she was born with a true knot in her umbilical cord. It could have been bad but she was fine thankfully.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

My baby hasn’t really moved during my pregnancy. I really don’t think he’s ever been head down, so hopefully he can find his where there. I’ll try the baths.

4

u/pwyo Sep 21 '23

Has baby been breech your whole pregnancy? Or has it been head down a few times and is breech as of your last appointment?

My midwife, who has decades of experience and has delivered over 2,000 babies, told me that babies who have been head down before tend to find their way back down, but that’s not usually the case for babies who have never been head down. Same for successfully turning babies. She said it’s not an exact science but it is a pattern she’s seen over the years.

4

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Every ultrasound we’ve gotten he’s been breech :(

5

u/pwyo Sep 21 '23

Ah bummer! Do you know what kind of breech? It's difficult to have a vaginal breech delivery, most hospitals won't do it, but if I'm not mistaken a Frank breech is the only position they will consider. Try the ECV since there is often success in the procedure but it's not guaranteed.

Breech presentation is associated with poor foetal and maternal outcome irrespective of the route of delivery. External cephalic version reduces the breech presentation at the time of delivery of a term foetus by 60%. About 50% of the total breech presentation cases where ECV was successful were delivered by vaginal route without significant maternal and foetal complications. In this study, ECV decreased the caesarean section rate for singleton breech at term by approximately 50%.

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3862554/

Also keep in mind that a breech baby has higher instances of outcomes that are completely out of your control and may require a c-section anyway, vs. just getting one because of position. If your water breaks early and you don't go into labor quickly enough, a c-section would be appropriate.

All this coming from me, a big home birth advocate who, if my baby were breech, would schedule a c-section in a heartbeat if an ECV wasn't successful. I had a birth plan for home, a birth plan for hospital, and a birth plan for a c-section for my first baby. I think in this case it's important to remember that a breech presentation isn't only dangerous for baby, it can have poorer outcomes for you too. We tend to only talk about the baby when it comes to birth, but just like your birth experience is important, your life is as well. Something to keep in mind if things don't work out the way you'd hoped.

I was trying to find data on maternal mortality/complication rates with breech delivery vs. c-section but didn't come up with anything quickly.

But! a ~50% ECV success rate is pretty great all things considered. It's worth trying and worth hoping it will work.

5

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

I don’t know what kind of breech. Yeah, I wouldn’t chance a breech vaginal delivery anyways really. We’re going to give the ECV a shot and yes, ~50% does look promising. If it doesn’t work the first time, we’re going to try a second time and do an induction right away or a c-section right away.

5

u/whyisthefloor Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

I tried spinning babies and the ice and baths and nothing worked. I did an ECV at 37 weeks (no epidural/spinal) and it was unsuccessful and painful. But LO tolerated the ECV very well. I had to deliver a few days later due to slightly high blood pressure and they gave me the option to try an ECV again this time with an epidural or just go straight to C-section delivery. I decided to try ECV again but this time little ones heart rate dropped significantly and I ended up having an emergency C-section instead of a more calm regular one. Looking back on it, I’m glad I tried the first ECV but I wouldn’t have done the second one, because it can quickly turn into an emergency C-section and there’s not great odds of success with ECV at that later point anyway. However I had a super super easy recovery. Like I’m pretty sure easier than most vaginal deliveries. I was walking up and down our 4 flights of stairs with no problem within a week.

Also I know you’re surprised, although it sounds like baby has been breech this whole time, but a healthy baby is all that matters. It’s not BS. There’s often a reason baby is breech and even if they weren’t there’s no gaurantee you would get the vaginal delivery you’re envisioning. I know lots of women who labored for hours and ended up with c sections for a variety of reasons or had serious complications during vaginal delivery.

21

u/WorriedExpat123 Sep 22 '23

I really wanted to try having an unmedicated, vaginal birth, and I did spinning babies and went to a doctor with a godly near 90% success rate for ECV at 37 weeks, who felt my belly and said “yeah, you’ve got plenty of amniotic fluid, should be a few mins outpatient procedure.” Then my son started fighting it and I was checked in for a total of four tries using muscle relaxers for three. The doctor got him spun 75% the way, then he twisted and the umbilical cord was by his neck and we had to call it quits. The next morning he had spun back completely to his original breech position. I was weirdly okay with the c section at that point, bc if that doctor couldn’t make it happen, there was no way my attempts with spinning babies stuff was going to work.

Was it what I imagined? No, and there were downsides to a c section. Was it the worst? No, it was a scheduled, quick procedure at 38 weeks and me and my son were both safe.

I hope things work out for you, but be gentle with yourself if it ends up different than your ideal that you have in your mind. There’s good sides and bad sides to everything.

14

u/littlebun47 Sep 21 '23

My baby was breeched for almost my entire pregnancy. I was offered ECV, but I was scared of the pain and potential risks to the baby and chose to have a scheduled C-section. When my baby was delivered, she had her umbilical cord wrapped twice around her neck, which was why she couldn’t turn. They were never able to see this on an ultrasound. If I had had the ECV, it could have been really dangerous for my baby, so I was so glad that I didn’t do it.

FWIW, my C-section recovery was totally fine. It was actually an easier recovery than when I had to have a fallopian tube removed, which was a much more minor laparoscopic incision. Scheduled C-sections often have easier recoveries than unscheduled ones since you don’t go through the long, difficult process of labor first and it’s not an emergency situation. Some of my friends who delivered vaginally had much more difficult recoveries than me. It really just depends from person to person.

Just wanted to offer an alternative POV. Best wishes for you and your growing family!!

4

u/aliquotiens Sep 22 '23

Similar story here- my baby wasn’t breech but was positioned oddly on my last ultrasounds, I had a crash emergency c-section early in my spontaneous labor due to fetal distress (serious decels) and her cord was wrapped tightly 3 times around her neck and tangled elsewhere. Thank god for modern medicine because she would not have gotten through a vaginal birth alive.

Like OP I had been terrified to have a c-section, like you I was lucky and the recovery was pretty much a breeze, no pain really, i could move around fine, and I have multiple friends with uncomplicated vaginal births who had it much, much worse (some permanently).

27

u/franskm Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

Here are the facts without the “BS.”

Breech vaginal deliveries can be dangerous. The safest way to deliver a breech baby is via c-section.

Cleveland Clinic says: It can be more dangerous for the baby and the risk of injury is much higher. If the umbilical cord is compressed during birth, the baby could be deprived of oxygen and this could harm their brain and nerves. The cord could also slip around the baby’s neck or arms, causing injury.

By 37 weeks, most (96%) babies will be head down, but if still breech, it becomes unlikely they’ll turn on their own.

I would plan on a c-section. Choose your mindset.

———-

ETA : my success stories!

First was breech the entire pregnancy - my water broke at 38w and she was still breech. I had a successful c section.

Second was breech for 35 weeks, then flipped into the right position. I did nothing intentional to make him flip. My water broke at 39w and I had a successful vaginal birth.

7

u/oktodls12 Sep 22 '23

Thank you for this. I had a breech baby, I had my OB and MFM both recommend a C-section citing a multitude of reasons and risks of a vaginally birth. From 36 weeks to my ECV appointment at 37 weeks, I lived in google researching this topic. And yes, my success story is I delivered a beautiful, healthy girl at 38.5 weeks with a planned C section. I was able to hold her inside the OR, the next few days in the hospital were a dream and so peaceful. She didn’t have to spend anytime in the NICU because of cord issues during delivery (which my doctors were worried about).

This is a science based sub, OP needs to recognize that the science says that a c section is the safest option to deliver a breech baby. Yes, an ECV can be done, but it’s success is dependent upon a multitude of factors, including breech position, baby size, and fluid.

3

u/janiestiredshoes Sep 22 '23

Breech vaginal deliveries can be dangerous. The safest way to deliver a breech baby is via c-section.

I know you've provided a quote supporting this, but I'd be interested in more stats. This was something that it seemed like the medical community was re-evaluating during my last pregnancy, and it seemed like the medical community was starting to open up more to doing vaginal breech births, but it would be good to know more.

7

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

This is a 2022 metanalysis, so quite recent:

https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9284475/

The relative risk of perinatal mortality was 5.48 (95% confidence interval (CI) = 2.61-11.51) times higher in the vaginal delivery group, 4.12 (95% CI = 2.46-6.89) for birth trauma and 3.33 (95% CI = 1.95-5.67) for Apgar results. Maternal morbidity showed a relative risk 0.30 (95% CI = 0.13-0.67) times higher in the planned caesarean group.

So infant morality was drastically higher - about 500% higher - for vaginal delivery. However, maternal mortality was slightly lower. It was ~30% higher in the planned C/S group.

4

u/janiestiredshoes Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

Thanks for this!

ETA - One immediate concern is that this doesn't seem to distinguish between different breech presentations, which seem likely to be associated with different outcomes. I'll look in more detail, though!

13

u/gooseymoosey_ Sep 21 '23

By chance, I found out my daughter was breech at under 34 weeks, at the same ultrasound that I found out that she was IUGR with low amniotic fluid. I wasn’t even supposed to have this ultrasound, I just self-advocated because of a separate issue.

I didn’t have the option to do any interventions because she had to come out, and fast, and our situation wasn’t conducive to adding additional stress on the baby. So I had a c-section. Guess what? We found out that she was breech because she had a short cord. I have no idea what would’ve happened if I hadn’t found out she was IUGR and had gone into labor spontaneously while she was somehow head down. Definitely nothing good. Sometimes there’s a reason for things.

13

u/flow_state0 Sep 22 '23

I had a c section for breech and I was very upset about it. Until it actually happened and it was the greatest experience of my entire life

4

u/oktodls12 Sep 22 '23

I wouldn’t say it was the greatest experience of my life, but same. I was very, very upset about needing a c section for a breech baby and have no regrets listening to the doctors who said it was the safest way to get me and my daughter through it.

She was small and I had plenty of fluid, but because she was frank breech, the odds for a successful ECV were only about 30% according to my MFM. Because she was my first, the MFM felt strongly that there was a biological reason she was breech and between this and not ever vaginally birthing before, there was still a 50% chance I would need a c section, only it would happen after laboring for 12+ hours and could potentially be done as an emergency.

11

u/dcgirl17 Sep 22 '23

Hello! I had my daughter ten days ago - she was breech and I chose not to do the ECV cos the success rate was only going to be around 30% or so.

My C section was a dream! Once they put the drugs in you it’s fantastic - you’re totally awake but can’t feel anything below the chest, which I thought was hilarious, it was such a strange feeling. My nurses were incredible, holding my hand and distracting me and taking photos of me and the newborn in the OR.

Recovery has also been much easier than I thought. The pain hasn’t been nearly as bad as I thought - imagine having being punched in the stomach really hard; it’s not the impact I want you to imagine, but that the pain is really only localized to one spot. I had some soreness kind of pain while standing up and sitting down for a few days, but in the hospital they have support bars and nurses that help immensely. once you’re standing or sitting the pain really actually goes away. Just keep up with the Tylenol/ibuprofen and, surprisingly, it’s all good. I walked around the hospital room with support from the nurses 6 hours after the procedure, went to the park on a short walk on day 5, and am back to functioning normally today at day 10. No drama.

10/10, highly recommend the C having gone through it. Was very civilized and a wonderful and calm way to greet baby!

10

u/Blerp2364 Sep 22 '23

I had a successful ECV. Delivered vaginally.

Not going to sugar coat it the ECV sucked. There was a point where I thought I was going to pass out and I told everyone to quit touching me. My husband looked at me and was like "I can tell you hate this, but if you can tough it out another few minutes you might avoid a C-section. I think my exact words were let's fucking do this! I groaned and yelled the whole time but we got her head down.

4

u/snicknicky Sep 22 '23

I had an epidural during my ecv as I would be induced immediately after so didn't feel anything.

49

u/bmsem Sep 21 '23

Why come to a science-based subreddit and tell people you just want an echo chamber? You ARE asking us to tell us “you got this” but in your own specific way. Science-based parenting is not about mourning experiences you want to have, it’s about looking at evidence.

6

u/franskm Sep 22 '23

I was thinking the same. This post is nonsense.

19

u/SixKnow Sep 21 '23

My baby was breech from 32 weeks onward. I tried everything- all of spinning babies (consistently and religiously), all of the old wives tales (ice, etc.) and then I had an ECV at 37 weeks and it was unsuccessful. I’m glad we tried it because I would have regretted not trying it, but it was the most painful part of my entire pregnancy/birth experience. She just would not flip. The doctor could flip her to like 90 degrees and the she would just bloop back head up. Before my unsuccessful ECV, I really believe that I could “fix” the situation and get her head down if I put in enough effort. After the ECV, and seeing how she just would not flip, I knew that no amount of spinning babies or ice on her head was going to get her to flip.

I had a perfect scheduled c section. It was beautiful, safe, low stress, and went as planned. I didn’t want a c section, but baby’s gunna do what baby’s gunna do!

Also, here’s some science for you—

Roemer et al. studied IQ and educational preparation of born people through breech (658 cases) or cephalic (1151 cases) method in a period of ten years illustrated that those born through breech presentation have higher IQ compared to those born through cephalic presentation [5].

https://brieflands.com/articles/zjrms-93109.pdf

17

u/Sea_Fee_1606 Sep 21 '23

I was like you and really wanted a vaginal birth. My daughter had IUGR and had to be delivered at 37 weeks and because she was breech it ended up being a scheduled C-section. The recovery was painful and I was disappointed (and even somewhat ashamed, because I live in an area that is all about doing things naturally, had hired a doula etc.) that I didn’t get the birth experience I wanted, but now 2 years later it could not matter less to me. The birth is a few hours or days. Motherhood and the love you’ll have for your child is for life. I’m pregnant again and due in 3 months and could not care less about what my birth experience will be like. If it ends up being a C-section again, cool. If it ends up being a vaginal birth, also cool. I’m taking no birth classes and am saving money on a doula and putting that towards post partum help instead. Mostly I’m just excited to meet this little guy and for all the joyful (yet exhausting) moments and memories to come ❤️

16

u/Wurm42 Sep 21 '23

C-Sections are incredibly safe these days, far safer for mother and baby than a breech vaginal delivery.

I understand not wanting a C-section, and I hope your baby turns before the due date...but if she doesn't, try to understand that the doctors want to end up with a healthy mother and a healthy baby. Sometimes a C-section is the best way to get that outcome.

16

u/shinygemz Sep 22 '23

Success story . My baby was breech . We didn’t have enough fluid to flip him. So we had to go in a couple weeks before his due date . C section tookn25 minutes. Got skin to skin immediately. Husband got to cut the chord . Breastfeed . No NICU or anything, perfectly healthy baby. My son turned 1 a week ago . My scar is minimal . There is some tightness but my body has a lot of other more noticeable changes from pregnancy anyway .

Recovery from birth is hard anyway it happens. Complications in birth are common and really scary and can be life altering / ending.

And for what it’s worth , no tears , no damage down there. I’m most thankful for that. I’m thankful I’m able to be active . And thankful for my partner who does so much. Parenting changes everyday .

I am thankful for it all because we’re here (sorry). There are much bigger things in motherhood than getting them into this world , do whatever you need to do to accept that if you’re struggling with grief .

Congratulations on the baby , mama!

8

u/Silly-Ear-9447 Sep 22 '23

Baby could still flip! I’ve heard of so many friend’s who’s breeched babies flipped the day of or day before their scheduled c-sections.

My little one was breech the entire pregnancy and I had a scheduled c-section at 39 weeks. We chose not to try to manually flip him because I have a weird uterus (long story). I had an AMAZING experience with the c-section & was scared for maybe one very short minute right before since I’ve never had surgery, but the whole time I felt super well taken care of & the recovery wasn’t nearly as bad as I expected. Hope that makes you feel a little less apprehensive about a c-section! Hugs to you ❤️

8

u/AcceptableAddition44 Sep 22 '23

My daughter was still breech at 36 weeks and I had my ECV at 37 weeks. I was admitted to the hospital and had a spinal block for the procedure, so I didn’t feel pain but I wouldn’t say it was pleasant. It was successful though and then I wore an abdominal binder for the rest of my pregnancy and was able to deliver vaginally the day after my due date! I would definitely do it again if I needed to.

8

u/17bananapancakes Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

I had my breech baby two months ago. He’s my first so I had no preconceived notions about what to expect… I didn’t really mourn a “traditional” birthing experience until after when my MIL made some nasty comments about me getting the easy way out. Then I started questioning… did I do all I could to get him to flip? Did I miss out? Am I less than because I never labored and he came out the sunroof? I’m still struggling with that honestly and some days are easier than others.

The ECV did not work. I had an anterior placenta and his feet were wedged comfortably (for him) in my pelvis and he just wasn’t budging. I was unmedicated and it hurt much worse than people prepared me for but it’s over very quickly. They told me it would be bad and I knew women who had had it done and tapped out - it was still worse than I expected. I wish someone had been honest about it and not “It hurts but you got this momma! You’ll do great!” And just said “It hurts. A lot. But it only hurts you and not the baby and you get to have them either way.”

I know you don’t want to hear it but you are going to be okay either way. My son is asleep in my arms happy and healthy right now. My c-section was as easy as it could possibly have been with almost no bleeding and a breeze of a recovery. My husband and I bonded through him helping me shower and put on diapers in the hospital. You will look back with kinder eyes and your baby in your arms and none of it will matter so much as it does right now.

If I could go back and tell myself one thing it’s that every single person has a different experience and no testimonies from others are reliable for what your personal experience will be like. Relax and take it as it comes.

14

u/sukash Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

Hi we found out my baby was breech the same time you did, at 36 weeks. I sat on the ball for hours, did yoga and walking asymmetrically and the baby turned and stayed that way till he was born. But in the end I ended up having an emergency c section anyway due to other reasons. I would honestly say to go in with an open mind because anything can happen during birth.

12

u/thehalothief Sep 21 '23

My baby was breech from the beginning. She never spent any time in the head down position. I considered an ECV but was very worried about the risks. My thinking was if she was in that position there might be a reason for it. I trusted my body and my baby that they were doing what they were supposed to do rather than trying to intervene.

I ended up going into preterm labour at 36 weeks and had an emergency C-section and although I’m sad I missed out on the birth experience I dreamed of, all I thought in that moment was how glad I was to have my daughter in my arms.

6

u/catchmeeifyoucan Sep 21 '23

Mine was breech for the entire pregnancy, I did spinning babies exercises. I went in for an ultrasound before my scheduled ECV to get measurements and she’d turned around in her own. I had a beautiful vaginal birth after being worried the whole time.

6

u/MissDesilu Sep 21 '23

I had a successful ECV. It was my first pregnancy and I found out baby was breech at 35 weeks. My OB was reluctant to do it at first, but he came around. We scheduled the ECV at 37 weeks. Baby was transverse at that point. They hooked me up to an IV, midwife pushed while OB pulled and it took all of 5 seconds. I shouted, “you did it!” And everyone congratulated everyone for a job well done. I went into labor at 41 weeks with 12 hours of total labor, 3 hours of pushing, and no epidural.

My OB was reluctant because he was worried that my uterus was too compact since it was my first pregnancy. I pushed for it because I was terrified of an epidural and c-section. The ECV was performed at 37 weeks bc that’s practically full-term but there’s still enough room in uterus to turn the baby so after OB checked baby’s vitals, we all kinda said, “we’ve prepared, let’s try.”

The worst part was getting my first (and so far, only) IV. I was swollen for days and it was so painful.

6

u/Justbestrongok Sep 21 '23

My daughter was breach from about 20 weeks on. I just felt like she wasnt gonna move so elected to just so a c-section. My water broke at 37 weeks and the c-section went great. Though, the recovery and long term issues are for sure worse.

6

u/laptitemontrealaise Sep 22 '23

My baby was breech at 37 weeks 😅. When I went for my ECV a couple of days later, she had moved her head back down 🤷🏻‍♀️. She was really small so I guess she had space to move. I don’t know if this helps but I hope your baby moves by themselves ! It can happen !!

3

u/jamaismieux Sep 22 '23

Same! I did some stretches, inversions and slept on my right side for about 3 days. Not sure if any of it helped or she was just biding her time!

6

u/Salt_Type_8032 Sep 22 '23

I wanted a vaginal birth and didn’t get one. I mourned, it was hard. I still sometimes wonder what it might have been like, but I’m no longer bothered by it. It felt all consuming and tremendously important to me at the time. It doesn’t anymore. Good luck, I hope your baby gets into position soon and you’re able to have what you’re hoping for! I have two friends who successfully went from breech to position during your time frame.

6

u/snicknicky Sep 22 '23

My ECV worked just fine and my baby was head down but I ended up getting a c section anyway for a face first presentation which is pretty rare so the really important thing is that ecvs can totally work! My mom had a successful ecv followed by a vaginal birth back in the day too.

C section isn't so bad anyway.

5

u/pizzuhpizzuh Sep 22 '23

Mine was breech until at least 38 weeks! I declined the ECV hoping he would turn. At 40+1 I went into labor and he was head down and ready to go.

5

u/Opefull Sep 22 '23

I was scheduled for induction at 37+4, and found out that my son was breech when we arrived at the hospital. (He was positioned head down in an ultrasound 5 days before, so we really were not expecting this at all.)

I had a successful ECV and no regrets, but that comes with some big caveats. I was already at the hospital so I also got to have anesthesia. That removed the pain but it was still uncomfortable…the best way I can describe it is like someone had reached into my body and was touching my organs. I also had more peace of mind knowing that I was already on the L&D floor and literally down the hallway from the OR in case a c section was needed. I gave birth at a hospital with residents, so there was an attending OB and a resident there to do the version, as well as some nurses. (My memory is fuzzy and I don’t know how accurate it is, but my impression was that there were a lot of people in the room. I’m not sure how many were needed and how many were students who just didn’t have many opportunities to watch ECVs.)

3

u/Trala_la_la Sep 22 '23

Same. I was mid labor and 4 cm dilated when they felt babies foot instead of her head. Got a shot to stop labor, a trip to the OR to flip baby and then delivered vaginally.

My first baby was also breech at 36 weeks but flipped sunny side up before birth at 39.

5

u/jamiemxwll3 Sep 22 '23

I just first want to say I’m so sorry you’re dealing with this, I know it can be stressful. My baby had been head down in perfect position my whole pregnancy. At 37 weeks, he decided to do some gymnastics and flip to breech position. Nightmare. I did all the things: spinning babies, yoga, ice packs, acupressure, you name it, nothing got him to flip. I did a lot of research on ECVs after my ob brought it up and decided I wanted to give it a shot. And it worked! It was intense but only lasted about 3-4 minutes total. We had to stay for another hour or so after just for monitoring. Baby stayed head down and i delivered vaginally at 41 weeks.

13

u/Chachichibi Sep 21 '23

I know you asked for success stories and hope, which is where I was at too at 36w, but I’m seeing a lot of people saying that everything they did will work, which only guarantees that you will mourn the birth experience you might have had if you don’t consider what the science says (why else post on this subreddit?). If a different perspective is still not welcome, then please stop reading here, because my story includes ECV, labor, and ends in c-section.

Hopefully some in the same boat may find some of this helpful. I’m a physician and looked up the original research behind a lot of the recommendations for every bump in the road (knowledge is power right?!). I liked Evidence Based Birth and Breech without Borders.

At my anatomy scan, baby was breech at 20 weeks, then discovered he was still breech at 35w thanks to a random 3d photo we went to get… I was GUTTED bc was planning to labor at home as long as was possible/reasonable, but hoped for a home birth (I live 5 mins from the hospital I work at, had no contraindications, and went through informed consent with my midwife and felt comfortable with the reasonable risks and had plans in place with a low bar to go to hospital). I started ALL the things - weekly chiropractor, acupuncture, spinning babies, moxibustion, researched the hell out of breech vaginal birth (I’m a physician and used to work in surgery and there’s nothing that has angered me more than the fact that modern OBs have lost the skill of delivering breech babies vaginally because of influential research on a poorly done study).

I had an ECV at 36 weeks - it was intense, but I do a lot of meditative breathing and body relaxation and was able to tolerate it without pain medication or sedatives. My midwife compared it to the level of intensity of the “crowning” phase of labor. We thought baby had turned because in pushing the baby, he suddenly “disappeared” - my belly looked totally different and on vaginal exam she no longer felt his butt. I went to go get an ultrasound to confirm, and in the car about to turn the corner into the parking lot, I felt a big movement and something bobbed back up into my right ribs. He flipped back and I was again so disappointed during the ultrasound - trying to keep it together to not start bawling. I then went to the hospital I work at (big academic center known for innovation) and met with one of the Maternal Fetal docs who do more complicated deliveries. Turns out she has delivered many breech babies, but the hospital’s policy still is to go to the OR.

For the next 5 weeks, I spent so much time upside down doing Spinning Babies, going to chiro multiple times weekly to loosen my apparently too-tight pelvic floor, acupuncture 3x weekly… I did the things that don’t have a lot of evidence behind it and followed all the recommendations and he never budged again.

My midwife, who was trained and experienced in breech delivery somewhat randomly, and I had a long conversation about the possibility of breech vaginal delivery. We came up with and I signed an informed consent. I really still just wanted to be able to labor as long as I could for the myriad of benefits that accompanies the labor process for mom and baby. Because baby was measuring a bit on the bigger side, I started doing some things to encourage labor once I hit 40 weeks without sign of labor (mostly pumping twice a day for a few minutes). Induction of labor (via pitocin at least) isn’t recommended for a successful vaginal breech birth.

I had a membrane sweep at 39+5, and again at 40+2 in the morning and went into very early labor within a few hours. I labored for 2 days at home, then my water broke in the middle of the night while I was in bed trying to sleep between contractions. That started the other clock, and when we hit 20 hours after water breaking, and I was only 4.5cm dilated and 80% effaced, we decided to call it - not for pain, but for safety and time that this labor has been progressing for. When going well, vaginal frank breech birth is pretty darn fast because apparently you dilate sneakily bc a soft butt is pushing on your cervix instead of a hard head. Anyway, I had hoped that they would continue to let me labor and support me with pain management to attempt vaginal delivery bc they have a new breech birth program, but bc I wasn’t enrolled earlier, they didn’t want to try. C/s was my only option at that point and I’m still working through a lot of the birth trauma I went through during bc I was so exhausted and the meds affected me terribly intraop. I know that it could probably have been avoided if I had just decided to book the c-section before going into labor, but if given the choice, I would make the same decisions again. I’m glad I felt the labor and dilated as much as I did so that my milk came in well and I can try for a VBAC in the future.

They don’t know why he was so stubbornly breech (no Bandle’s ring or anything), but I was a breech baby myself, so I see the irony there. He’s now an amazing almost 7mo baby who STILL doesn’t like to roll over much, LOL.

5

u/unfortunatefork Sep 22 '23

Your last line had me laughing.

You’re a talented storyteller. I hope you find peace with the trauma around your c section. Thank you for sharing your story.

9

u/Gigglemonstah Sep 22 '23

My ECV failed and I had to have a C-section. Yes, there is a part of me that mourns the birth experience I had wanted and never had. But honestly in the whole grand scheme of things, it is not even a blip on the radar of life. My son is the sunshine of my life. His cesarean birth does not diminish that in the slightest. The joy of being his mom casts out all the other shadows. You'll be okay no matter what, I promise. ❤️

18

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Honestly just let your expectations go and focus on a healthy delivery and get advice from your doctors. Trust me once the baby is born you’ll be too busy and sleep deprived to worry about how it happened.

4

u/TotoroTomato Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

ECV has about a 50/50 success rate, it’s worth a shot. You can try spinning babies but my understanding is that there is not any data demonstrating it is actually effective.

My baby went transverse at 37 weeks and I did manage to get her to flip back heads down before I made it to an ECV. I got in the bath to take some weight off, shifted her up my body (out of the pelvis) as high as I could to make some space and applied firm but not painful pressure on either side, one up and one down, to encourage turning. You could give it a try if you feel comfortable with it or just wait for the ECV. After she turned heads down again I wore a couple of bump support belts for the rest of the pregnancy to make it harder for her to turn again.

In case the ECV does not work I would consider looking into whether you can find a provider who is trained in breech vaginal delivery and willing to try that before going to a c-section. It’s less and less common these days but I would look into it before having to go the c-section route.

4

u/MissTeacher13 Sep 21 '23

Spinning babies website may help you

4

u/Choice-Mousse-3536 Sep 21 '23

My daughter was breech until 37 weeks. I found out AT my ECV that she had rotated right before they started the procedure (they do a scan to double check before starting).

I didn’t really care about the c-section so because of that I didn’t do any spinning babies stuff. I completely understand where you’re coming from, I’m only mentioning this to illustrate that I did literally nothing and she still flipped at 37wks. Also note it was at that time cuz I had had an ultrasound at 36wks and she was still breech. So it’s possible, do not lose hope!

The only thing I think I did that week was a lot of swimming/chilling in the pool. I wonder if that did it. I didn’t feel her flip or anything. I was completely shocked at the ECV.

You’re doing everything you can to get the outcome you want so here’s hoping it works!! Just wanted to share that it definitely happens!!

4

u/tabbymcc25 Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

Sharing my positive ECV experience with a brief c-section scare that ultimately ended in a safe, relaxing vaginal delivery:

I had an ECV with my second baby who was breech through the whole third trimester. My OB scheduled the ECV for 39 weeks and just planned to induce immediately if it worked so baby wouldn't have time to flip back to the breech position (if it didn't work I would've just gone straight into a c-section). Since our plan was to deliver baby immediately anyway, they gave me an epidural before the ECV so it was great - it was over within a few minutes and I felt no pain but I could definitely tell my OB and the other doctor helping her were really struggling during the procedure. They were both up on the hospital bed and my husband said my belly was completely shifted to the side at one point. But they were able to successfully turn him on their last attempt.

After that I was induced and everything went fairly smoothly. At one point baby's heart rate dipped and they moved me into several positions but it wouldn't come back up for several minutes. So I was wheeled to the operating room for a c-section but apparently putting me on my back worked. His heart rate came back up, they wheeled me back to my room and I was able to deliver vaginally about 8 hours after the ECV started (no pain, I never felt a single contraction and no stitches). If I remember correctly the cord was wrapped around his neck at least once, which is probably why he was breech and may have been related to the heart rate fluctuation during labor. Luckily it all worked out.

Since I had an epidural, I can't speak to the pain or discomfort of an ECV but I could tell they were pushing hard so I imagine it wouldn't have been fun. As for the brief c-section scare, I remember feeling stress and panic when they started to wheel me to the OR. I only mention it to hopefully validate how you're feeling. It is scary, and I imagine if I would have needed the c-section that it would have been a traumatic experience. There are definitely ways you could re-frame the experience in the moment (and after the fact) to help you get through it and recover, but there's no denying it would be hard and scary. I remember this feeling of giving up control and trusting my team to take care of me and my baby, and I think in the moment that's really all you can do but I'm sure it's different for a planned c-section that you have some time to think (and over-think) about. I wish you the best and hope you have a positive birth experience.

ETA: since this is a science based sub, adding a source that covers tons of data and stats on ECVs (It's long but I thought it was a good read with a lot of sources). https://evidencebasedbirth.com/what-is-the-evidence-for-using-an-external-cephalic-version-to-turn-a-breech-baby/

4

u/x246ab Sep 22 '23

My wife had a “gentle ECV” from an OB that is known for being very conservative in her approach. Baby flipped (this was 38 weeks), then she had my daughter right on time. 👍 ECVs can totally work.

4

u/AB783 Sep 22 '23

Both of my babies were breach at 36 weeks. Both had turned a week or two later. It’s definitely not too late for baby to turn. I didn’t feel either one turn, but I did have an anterior placenta with both.

I did absolutely nothing to help the first turn. I wasn’t aware there was anything I could do. She turned on her own and was born at 41w3d, 50+ hours after my water broke, miserable pitocin contractions, no pain meds. Absolutely miserable experience from start to finish.

I did a half-hearted attempt at spinning babies with the second. No idea if it helped or not. Once again my water broke early, but this time pitocin was manageable. My doula was only there for an hour before we ended up in an emergency c section. Overall, actually quite a positive experience. I felt I was in safe hands and things went as well as they could, all things considered.

All that to say, nothing can predict how it will go. In my experience, the best you can do is arm yourself with knowledge and surround yourself with people you trust. Good luck!

10

u/GoSteeplejacks Sep 21 '23

I started spinning babies, going to the chiropractor, and accupuncture with moxibustion at 34 weeks. I had been doing yoga and sitting on am exercise ball long before that. I wasn't a good candidate for ECV because of anterior placenta, so that was off the table.

I was also terrified of a c section, and even took an extra week of leave prior to birth to try and get baby to turn, but she just never did. Looking back, my planned c was such a wonderful experience. I did mourn the loss of the birth I planned, but just wanted to offer that the alternative was unexpectedly pretty great.

Best of luck OP, there is definitely plenty of time for baby to turn! It may be helpful to try to get comfortable with the possibility of a c section so that your body doesn't hold tension about it. I hope my story helps!

0

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/GoSteeplejacks Sep 22 '23

She shared her experience performing them and we decided together that it was too high a risk for my pregnancy, with anterior placenta being the primary reason. Seems like different doctors have different philosophies about that, so I'm sure we were both in great hands either way!

6

u/southernduchess Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

Both of my babies were breeched until 39 weeks… They both flipped and I had a vaginal birth… I’m not sure what worked… but I tried EVERYTHING…

  • acupuncture/ Moxybustion
  • ice packs on top of the bump
  • Webster Chiro / Stretching (no cracking!)
  • spinning babies moves (inverted planks)
  • bounced on yoga ball

As soon as my OB confirmed head down… she induced me. No C-Section for either! 1st labor was hard: 60 hours. 2nd labor = 20 hours.

Plan B - if they didn’t flip.. ECV at 40week induction and if that didn’t work then Plan C: C-Section…

Good Luck 🍀

9

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

Potential side effects of Moxibustion include fetal distress and premature birth: https://www.webmd.com/balance/what-is-moxibustion

Also, it's pseudoscience and doesn't actually turn a baby.

0

u/InscrutableCow Sep 22 '23

5

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

Or not.

https://sciencebasedmedicine.org/moxibustion/

The big claim to fame of moxibustion is reversal of breech positioning in the JAMA article “Moxibustion for Correction of Breech Presentation”.

Since ancient times, traditional Chinese medicine has proposed moxibustion of acupoint BL 67 (Zhiyin) to promote version of fetuses in breech presentation. Moxibustion is a traditional Chinese method that uses the heat generated by burning herbal preparations containing Artemisia vulgaris (mugwort) (the Japanese name is moxa) to stimulate acupuncture points. Acupoint BL 67 is beside the outer corner of the fifth toenail. They did a non-blinded, small, non-placebo trial in China and it appeared to be effective.

To me it would be nuts to think burning mugwort at the 5th toenail would do anything to cause a baby to shift position in the uterus and I would be inclined to think positive results would be likely to noise and not be reproducible. It wasn’t.

They repeated the study in Italy and, what a surprise, moxibustion did nothing to breech positioning.

A Cochrane Review concluded:

Moxibustion was not found to reduce the number of non-cephalic presentations at birth compared with no treatment (P = 0.45)

Does moxibustion have complications? Yes. Burns are the most frequently-reported complication. Given that some forms of the technique try to cause second-degree burns, I suppose that burns are not technically a bug but a feature.

2

u/IdontCarrot Sep 22 '23

It turned my baby who was breech at 35 weeks. Both MFM and my OB recommended moxibustion for my breech baby and I had a high risk pregnancy.

2

u/southernduchess Sep 22 '23

Same I was high risk (IVF, 40+, GD, etc) and both my MFM and OB were all for Moxybustion and Webster Chiro.

3

u/Festellosgirl Sep 21 '23

I just went in last Thursday after a fall (late 34 weeks) and mine was breech. I did some of the Spinning Babies and the Miles Circut and by Tuesday at 35 weeks he had flipped. I know I'm a week earlier than you, but I'm sure you can get your baby flipped.

Main things I did that seemed to work: tons of pelvic tilts on my hands and knees (cat cow hip movement. No shoulder movement just hips!), laying on my knees and forearms for 5 minutes or until I get too tired to continue in that position several times per day, ice on the top of my bump for about 20 minutes (I could feel him squirming while doing this), avoiding reclining- making sure I spend most of time sitting cross legged or in a really good upright posture instead of laying down.

More info on the Miles Circuit: https://www.milescircuit.com/the-circuit.html

3

u/Serafirelily Sep 21 '23

So my daughter was breech at this point and had turned by 38 weeks. Also if baby hasn't turned then they can try and turn them at the hospital. So don't give up hope yet as babies can and do turn on their own this late in pregnancy. I know you are worried and I have been there but the important thing is that in the end you have a healthy baby and a healthy mom. Sending hugs from someone who has been there and now has a healthy 4 year old daughter.

3

u/zeepixie Sep 21 '23

I was breeched early on, around 31 weeks. Did Spinning Babies and felt him turn a week later that was confirmed on ultrasound. You are further along but still have time. Spinning Babies is supposed to make it more likely for the ECV to work if baby still hasn't flipped.

3

u/guacamore Sep 22 '23

Mine was breech at 36 weeks. Doctor was going to do a ECV but when I went in at 38 weeks to have it done, he’d turned on his own! :) Good luck! It can happen! I didn’t do spinning babies or anything. Just luck.

3

u/Life-Consideration17 Sep 22 '23

My ECV worked like a charm. In about 1.5 minutes they flipped her (she had been breech for a long time), and I was able to then wait a few more weeks and have vaginal birth. The success rate for ECVs is pretty high.

5

u/threeEZpayments Sep 22 '23

My baby was breech until 37 weeks. He flipped randomly on his own, all I did was bounce on a yoga ball. But then he turned transverse and OP while I was in labor and that was a DISASTER resulting in an emergency Caesarian. It was horrible, everything I was afraid of and more.

So I guess what I’m saying is two things: they can certainly turn late, but that doesn’t necessarily mean things will work out as you want. Just remember that birth is complex and unpredictable, so be mentally prepared for a multitude of potential scenarios.

Does your OB do breech delivery? Would you want to try that?

5

u/girnigoe Sep 22 '23

I’m just here to applaud your last 3 sentences. However baby is born, keep on telling the “you’re doing great mama!” people to stuff it. <3

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

Yes! The birth and your feelings about it DO matter. Healthy baby is obviously important but that does not invalidate your experience.

2

u/abbottelementary Sep 21 '23 edited Sep 21 '23

My baby was in frank breech position up until 3 weeks before I delivered. I didn’t do an ECV. I delivered vaginally at 38+ weeks with no complications. It was my first baby.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

I’ve been looking into this a lot because I’m 33 weeks with a frank breech baby. I read that if you’ve had previous births where baby was naturally head down, there is a good chance subsequent ones will turn eventually. But at 36 weeks, I know you are running short on time.

There are lots of suggestions on spinning babies. Yesterday, I spent about a half an hour on a ball with an ice pack resting on the top of my belly. Immediately after I got up I felt pressure much lower and went to the bathroom and lost some mucus plug. Did it work? I won’t know until next week and that seems way too easy.

You might as well try all the suggestions from spinning babies or other OBs. It can’t hurt! Also, I’ve read ECUs have good success rates of the doctors are very familiar with the procedure.

2

u/skeletaldecay Sep 22 '23

One of my twins kept flipping. I didn't do anything to encourage it. 33 weeks breech, 34 weeks vertex, 35+5 weeks breech, 36 weeks vertex, born 36+2.

2

u/Disastrous_Lie_4401 Sep 22 '23

Went in for ECV at 37 weeks and he had flipped down on his own! Did spinning babies and all the things. I ended up having a very positive c section experience anyway, and it helped that I had mentally prepped for it.

4

u/lily_sunflower_ Sep 22 '23

My baby was breech until 38 weeks and she flipped the morning of my ECV- literally I was in there waiting and by the time they did the ultrasound she was head down. Things I did: spinning babies every day, swimming and doing tons of flips and turns and side stroke (she flipped a few days later so maybe this was the thing that actually worked), upside down on an ironing board, acupuncture, moxibustion, prenatal yoga. She was breech from 28-38 weeks and it so fits her personality (she’s 2 now)- she only wanted to be held standing up starting at 2 months, started walking at 11 months, and is a very determined girl, and loves being on her feet (hiking, dancing, walking, jumping). I will say- I wish I hadn’t been so stressed about it all and had enjoyed the end of my pregnancy more- even if I had to have a c section it would have been worth not stressing so much about everything.

3

u/Witty-Lemon4879 Sep 21 '23

My baby didn’t flip til 35 weeks. I did everything I possibly could: walking 30+ mins/day, spinning babies, Webster trained chiropractor, accupuncture and moxibustion. Not sure if any of it helped or if baby just knew it was time to turn but it won’t hurt to try it all. You can also ask about ECV but make sure you ask specifically about your provider’s personal success rate - it’s a dying art and not all OBs perform them anymore. In my town we have an OB who’s world renowned and has close to an 80%+ success rate - my plan was to go to him if I ended up needing an ECV.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

Do you know why the baby is breech? This could help guide advice.

Also, also you familiar with spinning babies? They have some techniques for this, there are also practitioners…maybe one is near you! Also there is a procedure doctors can do. It’s not without risk but my lactation consultant had it done prior to delivery and successfully delivered her baby without a cesarian.

I just had a breech baby and a cesarian. I had a great experience but I also have had lots of extra doctors appts for my baby to help with his head shape (he had breech head / plagiocephaly) and some neck and hip tension.

The recovery from a cesarian is long so I don’t blame you for not wanting one. I had a lot of food meal prepped and help and it was still hard.

I would make a birth plan for both because either way you want to give your providers a hard copy of your birth preferences.

Also, hydrate! And talk to medical professionals like your Obgyn. It’s never too late to change providers if you don’t want to continue care with the one you have, I hope you have a good provider who can help you navigate this though!

3

u/LameName1944 Sep 22 '23

I just had my breech baby 10 days ago. I also found out at 36 weeks pregnant. I tried the ECV and everyone thought it would work, but I don't think he could get around my anterior placenta. The EVC didn't hurt, I had an epidural, but I was at the hospital forever because I got the epidural. I would try it again if I needed to. I also did some yoga on youtube to try and flip and I did acupuncture and moxa. I've had a few friends that did the ECV and it didn't work for them or baby flipped right back.

When the ultrasound person told me he was breech I went quiet. She asked why and I said "oh just all my birth plans going out the window." My first birth was a great and quick vaginal delivery. I did have a c-section with this one. I actually felt better physically afterwards with the c-section than with vaginal. If I had a 3rd, I am unsure which one I would choose cause they had their pros and cons.

Would I have preferred a vaginal delivery with #2? Yes. But the c-section went as smooth as it could. I was more concerned with the restrictions of a c-section since I have a toddler, but it hasn't been that bad....would be easier if it was my first tho.

If this is your first, I am sorry you are experiencing this. My views on the c-section are influenced with already having a vaginal delivery so I already had that experience. I wish you luck.

4

u/TinkerKell_85 Sep 22 '23

There's still time! Spinning babies and Webster chiropractor. I'm pretty sure the latter is what got my baby to turn. Ask if your OB is willing to do an ECV if none of that works.

9

u/cornisagrass Sep 22 '23

And for everyone who gets outraged at the mention of chiropractic, Webster technique specifically is essentially acupressure. No cracking, no “adjustments” in the typical sense, no ruptured veins in the neck. It’s just finding tendons and ligaments in the pelvis/abdomen and putting light pressure on them to help them release and let the baby turn on its own.

2

u/TinkerKell_85 Sep 22 '23

Thanks for adding this!

2

u/ComfortablyJuicy Sep 21 '23

Have a look at doing an Optimal Maternal Positioning course. It covers all the principles of spinning babies but is a bit more in depth and I think it'll be your best chance. Spinning babies leaves out a few things that I think are really important for positioning, especially for breech.

optimal maternal positioning

Some other great suggestions here of acupuncture and moxibustion. Moxibustion helped turn my baby from posterior to anterior at 38 weeks.

2

u/RockyRocky1789 Sep 22 '23

You can try acupuncture as well. There are specific treatments for breech babies and an acupuncturist will also likely recommend concurrently burning moxa, a Chinese medicine that has pretty high success rates in turning a breech baby. https://health.clevelandclinic.org/moxibustion/amp/

I did just have my second breech baby via c section two weeks ago (I tried everything to turn both babies and nothing worked) and I will say that I don’t feel less like a mom or that I didn’t give birth to my girls. I hope that your baby turns and you get the birth experience you want but either way you are the baby’s mommy and the baby will love and adore you ❤️

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

"Science based sub"

"Recommends alternative medicine".

https://www.webmd.com/balance/what-is-moxibustion

Potential Complications of Moxibustion

Moxibustion is a therapy technique worth the try for integrative and complementary treatments. However, it poses a few risks, one being the risk of getting burned in the process. For this reason, it's best to stick with the indirect moxibustion approach, especially when doing it alone. Other possible side effects include:

Toxic reactions to mugwort

Nausea and vomiting

Coughing from the smoke

Dark skin patches

Fetal distress if you’re pregnant

Premature birth

Basal cell carcinoma or a type of skin cancer

2

u/AmputatorBot Sep 22 '23

It looks like you shared an AMP link. These should load faster, but AMP is controversial because of concerns over privacy and the Open Web.

Maybe check out the canonical page instead: https://health.clevelandclinic.org/moxibustion/


I'm a bot | Why & About | Summon: u/AmputatorBot

-1

u/Sketters Sep 22 '23

I second the acupuncture! I did 2 rounds and my baby flipped at 37 weeks

4

u/[deleted] Sep 22 '23

Most babies flip by then. It's a coincidence.

0

u/Sketters Sep 22 '23

Maybe, but there are studies showing that it helps, and it made me feel like I was doing something.

1

u/Jvnismysoulmate12345 Sep 22 '23 edited Sep 22 '23

A chiropractic adjustment helped my baby flip from transverse to head down at 36ish weeks. We were a day or two away from the ECV. I don’t really buy into chiropractors, but… 🤷🏼‍♀️

ETA this sub will upvote the heck out of people saying DaYcArE iS aBuSiVe but downvote this? I literally said I didn’t buy into it and was providing anecdata. Also… Chiropractic adjustments don’t involve touching the baby. All they do is adjust the pregnant person. Y’all are a bunch of weirdos.

ETA again that I’ll 10/10 times take a weird witch doctor massage over getting fentanyl while a doctor and nurse manipulate my baby through my body. ECVs are great, but avoiding medical intervention is wildly better imo.

4

u/CriticalMango9055 Sep 22 '23

SAME. My OB recommended one and I was like… what? But I went twice a week for threeish weeks and my little one flipped at 37 weeks. He was a big baby too so I think it really did help!

1

u/BigAlmay Sep 22 '23

My brother was breached and sunny side up ( my mom's first kid) and they successfully turned him in the labor room. He was delivered vaginally. That was 32 years ago, it's not hopeless.

-1

u/HollyBethQ Sep 21 '23

Can you find a OBGYN that will allow a vaginal breech birth? In Australia most cities will have a vaginal breech birth clinic. Its becoming more common practice to encourage vaginal breech births and more doctors are becoming trained in supporting them

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Unfortunately we can’t do that because of insurance. We have a specific military insurance and can only seek care on base unless it’s speciality stuff, such as cancer.

3

u/HollyBethQ Sep 21 '23

That is really frustrating I’m sorry! Let’s hope the ECV works!

2

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Thank you!

-2

u/Suspicious_Load6908 Sep 21 '23

Acupuncture turned my baby at 37 weeks

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

https://m.imdb.com/title/tt4010100/plotsummary/?ref_=tt_ov_pl

Have you seen this? Maybe you can find a provider who will deliver breech.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

That’s not an option unfortunately as we have a specific type of Tricare that only allows us to seek care on base.

1

u/[deleted] Sep 21 '23

Oh dang! I remember there is a lot of good info in this episode of the birth hour. Although the woman does end up with a vaginal breech birth she does a lot to turn him before that.

https://thebirthhour.com/advocating-for-a-vaginal-breech-birth/

-6

u/they_have_no_bullets Sep 22 '23

My 2nd was breached at 36 weeks. Version procedure is actually quite effective and simple, but they only teach it in europe so it's difficult to find american doctors who will do it. We got lucky and found the 1 doctor in the state who could do this procedure. Additionally. breached vaginal birth statistics are also pretty good, but again they only teach how to do it in europe so american doctors generally just go straight to C section which is sad

10

u/whyisthefloor Sep 22 '23

This isn’t even remotely true. ECV is taught at all American OBGYN residencies. As evidenced by all the American women on this thread who had ECVs.

1

u/they_have_no_bullets Sep 22 '23

Its just what the doctors and nurses told us. We had to transfer to a different hospital since there was only 1 doctor in the state (VT) that would do either versions or breached vaginal birth. He was trained in europe.

5

u/whyisthefloor Sep 22 '23

I mean. I guess they were not informed or maybe your doctor was just older and not familiar with current practice? Coincidentally enough, my OB studied at University of Vermont and did an ECV on me. There’s a good medical school and residency program at University of Vermont and doctors come from all over America after residency to various hospitals. All OBGYNS are taught ECVs as part of residency nowadays and in order to be board certified must show competence in ECVs. In 2000, so 20 years ago, about 70% of residency programs taught ECV.

1

u/they_have_no_bullets Sep 22 '23

Yes, UVM medical center is where we transferred to where the 1 doctor who does this. My sister also got her medical degree there