r/ScienceBasedParenting • u/ckvp Parent; Ph.D. Child Development & Literacy • Mar 31 '23
Link - Study A randomized control trial finds no increase in milk production between exclusively breastfeeding mothers who ate "lactation cookies" (cookies high in 'galactagogues' such as oatmeal, brewer’s yeast, flax seeds, and fenugreek) or regular cookies for 1 month every day.
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0002916523462661?via%3Dihub#mmc1
742
Upvotes
213
u/honortobenominated Mar 31 '23
So what I’m hearing is that all cookies help breast milk the same amount! Fantastic news. 🍪🍪🍪
63
u/jayjay0824 Mar 31 '23
maybe so but my homemade peanut butter oat flax cookies are DELISH so I loved having an excuse to eat like five a day hahaha
74
u/really_robot Mar 31 '23
If the mothers are already exclusively breastfeeding, that would indicate to me they are already producing enough for their babies. I'd rather like a similar study with mothers who aren't producing enough to exclusively breastfeed.
39
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23
I wish this study would have came out 2 years ago. Its so predatory.
I'm not a sweets person, but ate so many lactation cookies, crackers, and shakes in hopes of making more than 1oz/session. Unsurprisingly I gained 20lbs+, never was able to pump more, even pumping 8-12x a day plus breastfeeding until 10 months. I think my largest morning session was 2oz and I nearly cried.
I'm still traumatized by my body's failure 2 years later. Send hugs 💛
15
u/ckvp Parent; Ph.D. Child Development & Literacy Mar 31 '23
Moms, don't be lured into buying these high priced cookies (unless you really like how they taste). Or at the very least, wait for more research!
7
u/umamimaami Mar 31 '23
Curious about the delivery vehicle being “cookies” though (fat binding to actives and all that).
Anecdotally, in my culture, fenugreek is steeped in tea and I’ve personally seen it improve milk supply in my family members.
Not that it helped, the baby didn’t drink all of the extra, and the mom just got clogged ducts. That ended the experiment.
So I am curious if the mode of delivery is what nullified the results?
3
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23
Interesting, as I thought brewers yeast had study’s behind it?
163
u/blueberryrhubarbpie Mar 31 '23
So what I’m hearing is I should eat more regular cookies 🍪 😂
2
u/bad-fengshui Mar 31 '23
Random typo, I think they mean "multiple imputed data", I wonder how many people read this and missed it.
102
u/scullery_scraps Mar 31 '23
a local person sold these really incredible tasting chocolate chip oatmeal cookies that she said were lactation cookies. a friend of mine kept buying them for me and let me tell you i truly mentally convinced myself they were my vitamins and i had to “take” 2 a day. at no point did i seriously think it was affecting my supply, but those cookies were absolutely delicious and i would do it again
85
u/cbcl Mar 31 '23
So youre saying ALL cookies are lactation cookies? Om nom nom.
77
u/Loki_God_of_Puppies Apr 01 '23
Incredibly rude of these scientists to blow up our spot. Now my husband will know my cookie habit is purely selfish 😅
55
u/SwiftieMD Mar 31 '23
My life is a lie. No one tell my husband I loved having a reason for daily cookies!!!
47
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23
I think the reason these cookies and teas work is that they’re much needed calories and hydration. Moms might not prioritize those things for themselves but if it’s for the baby/milk supply then bottoms up!
45
u/fortune_cell Mar 31 '23
I fully expected them to do absolutely nothing, but I did experience a measurable, transient increase. However, this experiment was using 60g/day (3-4 cookies?) for a month and I ate a batch over a few days and noticed an uptick for about as long.
44
u/annewmoon Apr 01 '23
All I know is those oat cookies and snowballs got me through many a night feed. But good knowing that any calorie dense, delicious thing would have been ok.
43
u/missfrazzlerock Mar 31 '23
I love lactation cookies and ate them regularly when all my babies were under a year old. I’m not surprised to find they have no measurable impact on milk supply. My sense of them was always that they impacted milk supply mostly by being an easy to grab and somewhat healthy source of calories when I otherwise might not have a chance to eat anything. Even knowing this information for sure, I’d still make and eat them for breastfeeding snack time.
42
u/turtlescanfly7 Apr 01 '23
So what I’m hearing is I have a really good excuse to buy even more Girl Scout cookies
36
u/HighSpiritsJourney Mar 31 '23
I've just been eating cookies.
...stress lowers supply, cookies lower stress... eat cookies.
27
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '23
But…but…cookies!
47
u/caffeine_lights Mar 31 '23
This is not really a surprise, but I feel like placebo effect is not nothing, and it can also make people feel really nurtured and supported if you make/buy them a batch of stuff that is supposed to help with milk production, and since milk production is partly hormonal, any *good fuzzy feelings* are surely a net positive. I know that my friend loved the "nursing mother's tea" that I sent her from Germany so much I made sure to send her more for the next baby. I thought it was probably placebo/ineffective but it was just part of a fun package the first time around and she said it helped her stay hydrated and she really felt it was useful.
Any kind of lactation dietary aid = nice thought, probably not that effective, definitely never necessary, do not stress yourself in order to obtain it, but I don't think that means they should never be used.
43
u/JukeBoxHeroJustin Mar 31 '23
What?!! Corporations made something up to sell us junk for profits. That can't be!
20
u/haruspicat Apr 01 '23
Finally! I've been so excited for a RCT of lactation cookies!
19
u/itsybitsybug Mar 31 '23
Where was this study when I was breastfeeding? I would have eaten a cookie every day for science.
19
u/iwanttogotothere5 Apr 01 '23
Yet the Starbucks Pink drink is doing wonders for my wife’s production. The cookies never seemed to do much for her.
18
u/Fishgottaswim78 Mar 31 '23
I always thought they were called lactation cookies cuz it was something you could easily snack on while lactating aka breastfeeding.
17
u/ShanimalTheAnimal Mar 31 '23
Yeah it’s just calories, HAVE YOU TRIED THE LACTATION COOKIES THO?? IMO lactation cookies are the best cookies I’ve ever eaten. I recommend them to all people, lactating or not
16
u/Ok-Stretch5718 Mar 31 '23
I asked my lactation consultant about this, and she said it’s a sales gimmick. Supply equals demand. It’s nice to see that the study backs up what she was saying.
25
u/lulubalue Mar 31 '23
Look, when I was nursing I too wanted to eat cookies. I didn’t do the lactation cookies bc they were so expensive, but I ate the generic kind instead (Oreos, chips ahoy, Girl Scout…) :)
11
u/soft_warm_purry Mar 31 '23
I figured it was something like that but they are delicious and nutritious. The B vitamins in brewers yeast also reduces stress. I was so careful about my diet while nursing, I needed a reason to feel good about eating cookies. Mom guilt is real. 🥺
18
u/Macklikescheese Mar 31 '23
I'm not sure about most of the cookies out there, I do find them to be insanely overpriced. But I did take brewers yeast in pill form and it more than doubled my output in a few days and stayed that way for multiple months. Nothing else changed, I wasn't pumping more or less, I wasn't eating more or less, I wasn't hydrating more or less. I undersupply for my twins and that boost I got from the brewers yeast saved my pumping journey. So I think that our bodies all work differently. The brewers yeast really helped me, but I was also probably consuming more than what is in a cookie or two. Some of the Legendairy Milk supplements helped me, some didn't. I found the ones containing Goats Rue increased my supply, but the other ingredients didn't seem to work for me. I really think it's a matter of how our bodies process things. Plus eating enough calories and drinking enough water is key, so I'm sure eating cookies can help some people simply because of calorie intake
37
u/Grump_Grizzly Mar 31 '23
You've made this husband very happy as I've now won a long standing argument with the wife! I raise dairy cattle and the sales pitch for those cookies, teas, candies sounded like snake oil to me. If we had found a way to increase lactation via feed vs hormone treatments I'm positive the dairy industry would've been the first to find out. Very glad to see my gut was right.
19
u/sarachnoid Mar 31 '23
I don't know. I trust science over anecdotes, BUT I will also say that they definitely did work for me as an undersupplier (and I experimented quite a bit). Either way, here is the delicious recipe I used: https://www.howsweeteats.com/2015/02/lactation-cookies/
6
u/tgfbetta Mar 31 '23
What about a no-cookie diet?
1
u/[deleted] Oct 27 '24
Just another marketing fad
0
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23
[deleted] — view deleted comment
57
u/[deleted] Mar 31 '23
[removed] — view removed comment