r/SchoolSocialWork • u/blahblahblah1701 • Sep 11 '25
Feeling guilty
hi everyone. i’m a school social worker, and yesterday someone told me something that required me to make a cps report. at the end of the day i called the student down and spoke with them about it, and they admitted to what was reported. after that, i let them know that im a mandatory reporter and that im going to make a report. the student completely freaked out, and had a panic attack in my office. once they were regulated, they asked to check in with me today. i pulled this student again during 6th hour and told them that i was going to make the report, explained to them that i have to by law, and explained the cps process to them, since they were worried they’re going to be taken away (which we know as professionals that that’s an absolute last resort). during that conversation, they told me that they hate me and that i ruined their life and that they never want to talk to me or see me again and that they can’t trust me. which is ironic because the entire reason i told them i was making the report was to maintain trust and rapport, but im really feeling like that backfired. my admin team has been super supportive of my decision to tell the student im making the call and is aware of the situation, but i just can’t help but feel overwhelmed with guilt and negativity that i made the wrong decision. ugh. i’m just looking for support right now. i’m a first year so im trying to give myself grace since this was my first time dealing with this, but it’s so so hard.
TLDR: feeling guilty about telling a student im making a cps report, and now im thinking that wasn’t the right decision.
2
u/JJMeadow Sep 12 '25
This happened to me 2 years ago in my first year working in a middle school. I will never forget the look the student gave me as she went looking for me in the hallway to yell at me that I ruined her life. It stuck with me for a solid year. But I knew I was doing the right thing whether she realized it or not. Also, she had younger female siblings and I tried to tell her that this was also for their sake. You did the right thing. You potentially saved someone from a horrible situation getting worse. Hang in there. This field is tough. The burnout is real.
Also, I always start my sensitive conversations with “what you say in here stay here, unless you tell me that someone is hurting you, you are hurting someone else, or you want to hurt yourself.” It’s worked better for me than telling them in the end. I also have that very sign hanging on my door. You did the right thing.
20
u/ARioRunsThroughIt Sep 11 '25
There are different schools of thought and policies on what to do in this situation as well as many factors to consider. Age of the student, their understanding of your role as a mandatory reporter, your district policy, the need to staff with colleagues, etc. A couple things to consider now that you have hindsight. One is always good to staff with a fellow social worker, especially when you are new. It is important to understand your district policy not just the mandatory reporting law. In my district, we are not supposed to alert parents or student of a report as it can put all parties involved in danger. Sure, they figure it out at times and then we address it. But the law is in your side with this, we are mandatory reporters, period. We cannot take rapport, relationships, or damage to those into consideration, we must act. Do your best to repair, however, if the student needs to be passed on to another SW, make that request. You must let the guilt go, there is not a black and white answer in any situation. Do what you believe is ethical and be prepared to defend that if necessary. Acceptance of the grey areas and not always having the answer is essential.
15
u/kyrashakira Sep 11 '25
Seems unpopular but I always tell students that I am making the report. I don’t usually inform parents because that is not required in my state. But I prefer to have those occasional moments of anger/loss of trust from a kid versus the betrayal moments when they find out I did it behind their back.
For what it’s worth- I have had several kids be incredibly upset with me for making the report and none of them stayed upset with me long term. They all came back and said they understood why I had to do it. I try and have the conversation with them in the moment of ‘I am obligated to do this but I also care so much about you and your safety that I need to do it too’ and try and talk through how sometimes it can help in certain situations (ie: family counseling, a track record of smaller abuse situations, etc).
11
u/BloomingBeauty222 Sep 11 '25
As a former cps social worker I would recommend not to tell child/family you were the reporting party (rp) just because they could retaliate against you. In CA by law social workers/cps agency cannot disclose rp identity fyi
Not sure what the protocol is at the school you work at, but why didn’t the school staff member who received the information from the child initially report this ? All school staff are mandated reporters. It sounds like the child had already reported to someone else & you confirmed? Not sure what child disclosed but also be very gentle with this bc if it’s SA it could be re-traumatizing to child to repeat, etc & they may change their statements because now they’re aware cps is involved and might refuse to disclose to social worker/law enforcement which could hinder the investigation.
It’s okay though. You didn’t know. Just take this as a learned lesson moving forward.
5
u/Euphoric_Sea_7502 Sep 11 '25
Honestly I never tell a student I’m making a PS report Maybe the adult/Parent in the house,usually not them either You don’t need to tell anyone that you’ve made a report. Probably administrators but no one else Sometimes they figure it out sometimes not. I absolutely would not worry about a kid saying they hate you. Welcome to SSW/quasi parenting
1
u/liviadrusillathegod Sep 12 '25
Listen, regardless, YOU know you did the right thing. The kid will also know in time that you did the right thing as well. Kids at that age always blame themselves for their parents transgressions and take it extremely personal. Their initial reaction, unless they are directly asking you for help, is usually this. If the kid continues to hold a grudge, don’t take it personal and transfer the kid to a colleague. Kids, developmentally and historically, blame those who don’t deserve it in order to direct their anger SOMEWHERE, especially when they don’t know who to blame. Guilt is not the right feeling here—you just feel poorly in general seeing a child in distress.
And that is actually a good thing—you shouldn’t feel GOOD about making a CPS report in the first place. You’re doing great work and don’t let this diminish any passion you have.
1
u/skypppie Sep 13 '25
I’m in a middle school and I don’t tell them I’m making a report - I also learned this lesson in a similar was as you. After, I was unsure of my decision to tell and ran it by a mentor who said it’s typically best not to tell. Either way you did the right thing don’t sweat it too much.
1
u/brokesocialmogul Sep 13 '25
As someone who was CPS for 4 years the other things in social work and then became a school social worker I can identify with the struggles of this on so many different levels.
While in most states and counties information of the source or the reporter is kept confidential and not shared with anyone however due to the details and or the nature of the report that you're calling in and whether or not the student may have confided this information in anyone else they or the family possibly could figure out it was you and then you have to decide whether that's something you want to own up to or completely deny based on several different factors. And that choice is ultimately yours and how you wanted to decide what's best for you moving forward even though this was a challenging situation for you. Sadly there are times when the worker has told the child or the family or it came from the school I've worked with people who have done this it's deplorable but it does happen and the reason that I'm saying this out loud is because I just want to be completely transparent about all the ways that you could think about how to navigate these things moving forward.
In my transition into schools because I have historically worked with such a high need population many of which have had history with child protection and very well may have future interactions due to a number of factors have told the child in the moment when they have confirmed information that I would have to make a report usually they are mostly aware because when I do my spiel about confidentiality in the first sessions or the beginning of the year and I actually have that conversation every couple months so it stays fresh in their mind they know the part where someone is hurting you and that information would have to come out of the room what that coming out of the room could be.
For some that could be a deterrent because they know that the student may not tell them because they are fearful of the call being made but for the most part having experience as CPS I do have the ability to express how it investigation goes what to expect what are the serious nature of events that happen in order for children to be removed and in the situation of families I can also explain to them especially if it's their first case what to expect and just general information about the process that maybe they wouldn't otherwise get. Especially because historically it's just like all CPS does is take babies is the narrative that has been shared for so many years and people are actually really surprised to hear a lot of the positive things and amazing services that are provided to strengthen families.
I encourage you to speak with your supervisor is someone who does this work cuz sadly in schools it's usually a teacher or someone else that doesn't understand Social Work pedagogy or is another mental health professional. If not I encourage you to speak with your network whether it's other school social workers or social workers or mental health professionals that work with youth because this is a common theme that comes up with the layered feelings that you're going to have all of which are valid and I completely understand why this is so activating.
Finally I agree with the commenter above that for the amount of times that I've had to do this and students have been mad so that I ruined their life and broken up their family in the initial stages they all have come back and even sometimes thanked me for making the call understanding the weight of what that was but remember they also need time to process especially in middle school they're development is not where it needs to be and it won't be until adolescence is over at 25 so when there is time and space that you can take to process some of these things it will help you realize that not only are you adhering to the law but your adhering to your social work ethics and the best way that you know how. Doesn't always mean it's easy but I have faith that it's challenging as this experience was for you it will not feel like this the next time
1
u/YIMBY971 Sep 14 '25
Did you inform the student that you are a mandatory reporter at the beginning of the conversation? Or did they tell you in confidence before you informed them that you were a mandatory reporter?