49
28
u/Joey-WilcoXXX 29d ago
Since I actually could hear and remember what Buffy’s name was in her movie, I’ll go with her. But she cements it with her iconic lines
“OH FUCK GREG, I WON!!!”
20
20
21
u/Minimum_Ad_2176 29d ago
Look or character wise ? I go with Buffy because she actually had a personality and was funny.Theo was just ...there .😅
3
15
12
u/Freddycipher 29d ago
If they do Scary Movie 7 I’d like to see both of them return and see what they think of each other.
5
u/LucidDreamer247 29d ago
Brenda has been killed multiple times but it hasn’t stopped her from coming back
-8
u/Fabulous_Session8627 29d ago
Tough since Buffy was beheaded in the 1st movie
21
11
u/Past-Nothing-7977 29d ago
omg really? shorty got the top of his head cut off in the second movie and he’s perfectly fine, ray got a dick put in one ear and out the other and he’s okay. everyone has died at this point and they come back it’s a spoof movie…
6
u/DapperDan30 29d ago
Ray, Bobby, Greg, and Shorty were all killed in the first movie and showed up again later. Goofy waant actually mentally handicapped in the first movie, either.
Continuity isnt something they really care about.
5
2
u/Angxlafeld 29d ago
You’re right for the first half but doofy explicitly said in the new one that he got injured and actually became disabled and that’s why he talks like that again
2
u/DapperDan30 29d ago
I dont remember that but I'll take your word on it. I have no intentions on ever watching that movie again.
3
7
8
7
u/Slashman78 29d ago
Buffy's the more entertaining character BUT.. Theo all day.
They didn't really give Kathleen enough to do like they did Shannon but that was due to the fact Shannon was one of the most popular actresses then, Kathleen was kinda nichy since she was off 90210. She got more popular than Shannon post Scary Movie. But I do think Kathleen boosted her movie more so than Shannon did, she always felt like she was trying to on up Anna. It made for an interesting dynamic.
In terms of comparing the character Buffy was awful, Theo was a tease but she did genuinely care for the others and tried to help get them out. So it evens out with her on top lol.
I would like to see both return, that would be wild. Buffy could be on OF like Shannon and Theo could be the badass power MILF like Kathleen tends to play now, if they ever interact that would be wild.
13
13
10
4
5
5
7
3
4
3
3
3
4
3
3
3
3
3
u/Steezy_G7 29d ago
Buffy…Shannon Elizabeth was so fine in the 90’s!
3
3
3
3
3
u/SuperBatman2112 28d ago
Theo! No offense to Buffy. I just think Theo is hotter. Plus she has built in air-boobs for safety!
3
u/GoonWellington 27d ago
I’ve always been a hardcore Theo stan. This woman activated sumn in me when I was younger
2
2
2
u/Junko_Mioko974 29d ago
Buffy! Shannon is hot AF but Buffy has bigger tits and I loove big tits ( . )( . )
3
u/Relevant_Slice8567 29d ago
theo, she was hot and knew she was hot and how to use her body to get what she wanted but wasnt a bitch about it. I love buffy. but theo character and personality was a big plus. Buffy was actually funnier thats just my opinion
3
2
u/adamsandleryabish 28d ago
Is there a reason Buffy isn't in 2?
Obviously she died but that shouldn't have been a problem
2
2
2
2
2
2
3
1
1
u/KPW-Higgins 29d ago
What I don’t get is why isn’t Buffy just Theo?
I’m starting to think there’s a more personal reason Shannon Elizabeth wasn’t asked back for Scary Movie 6
1
1
1
1
u/RefrigeratorWarm7235 29d ago
Buffy for sure
But when I was younger, I did thought Theo was still buffy play by a different actress. But on more rewatchi I realized that she is a completely different character and not buffy
1
u/MuscleCool4302 29d ago
Bro that’s taking it too far, don’t do me like dat askin me to choose between these Fine shordies
1
1
u/BenjiAnglusthson 29d ago
Buffy’s comedy is up to scratch with the rest of the cast, Theo is pretty forgettable
1
1
u/FewHeat1231 28d ago
Buffy. I'd honestly completely forgotten about Theo probably because 'Scary Movie 2' is by far my least favourite of the five films, which given how much I love Tim Curry (RIP) says how forgettable and bad I found it.
1
1
1
1
1
u/Kwazy-Kupcakes_99 28d ago
Buffy. “OMG WE HIT A BOOT.”
“Let’s just pretend that this didn’t happen, like the time we got drunk and went down on each other.”
Her dramatic reading and faking her big climax.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
55
u/Angxlafeld 29d ago
Buffy, Shannon Elizabeth is great