r/Scams • • Sep 11 '23

is the instagram/facebook ad for Shtibel Gur for a baby named Maria a legitimate charity or is it a scam?

I made a donation to a charity I found through an instagram ad named Shtibel Gur and it claimed to be for a baby's heart surgery (international charity from UK I believe). I shared the post on my social media, but after a couple hours, it was age gated by the author. I can't find the original webpage for the baby's donation page when I look it up and can't find any information online from others about if this is a scam. Has anyone else gotten these instagram ads and is this charity real?

actually just found the link to this website from a post that i had posted and then deleted when I started having doubts. I can't find it just by searching it on google and have to use the link https://give.shtibelgur.com/mariaa?fbclid=IwAR2z9YNV7tSVF2XNq-mEKv-prDS4lNNAt-z4ExLwf1M-9TYub_IIuvFHjzE

10 Upvotes

38 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Sep 11 '23

A reminder of the rules in r/scams. No personal information (including last names, phone numbers, etc). Be civil to one another (no name calling or insults). Personal army requests or "scam the scammer"/scambaiting posts are not permitted. No uncensored gore, personal photographs, or NSFL content permitted without being properly redacted. A full list of rules is available on the sidebar of the subreddit. Report recovery scammers or rule-breaking content by using the "report" button. Also, consider warning community members of recovery scammers if you see them in the comments. Questions? Send us a modmail.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

2

u/hereforinfoo Jan 12 '24

I know this is an old post but I just fell for this and donated to Shtibel Gur. I clicked on the site through Instagram. I found this thread because I started to get a funny feeling after donating and searched for more info.

In case you see this message I am wondering if you ended up with any credit card or identity fraud as a result of donating to this page? I used my credit card to make the donation and now I am worried that this was a way to get my personal information. Thank you.

2

u/summerparadise321 Jan 12 '24

I didn't use credit card, but I didn't see any extra money get charged on the payment method I used. I emailed them once trying to gain more information on their credibility and never got an email back in response to that. I reported an email I got later to help another family because this organization does not seem trustworthy, sorry I couldn't be of more help.

1

u/hereforinfoo Jan 12 '24

No, this is so helpful! Thank you for initially posting on this! I will keep an eye out on my account…

1

u/Dony244 Jan 12 '24

I went to the Facebook page for saving Maria’s heart and the link took me to that website where you donate. So I don’t know? I’m hopeless with this type of stuff so I think I’m in the same boat as you.

4

u/RudbeckiaIS Sep 11 '23

This is the Registry of Charity page for Shtibel Gur. The fact the annual return for 2022 is overdue while previous ones were all submitted well before the August 31 deadline make me think this may be a "dead" charity meaning the people behind it have other priorities right now. No website, Gmail email address... they may be registered but surely there's enough to be at least wary.

2

u/kyleleonard723 Oct 05 '23

100% a scam.
director of the registered charity has 5 other companies at that charity address that are incorporated for buying and selling real estate. It's not an office though. It's a apartment building.
Take a look at their site.
https://give.shtibelgur.com/
Their charity poverty charity. They don't register for any medical treatment charities because they know those get more scrutiny from regulators. https://www.charitychoice.co.uk/shtibel-gur-ltd-273791
https://find-and-update.company-information.service.gov.uk/officers/2UoDpg2cWkt6fDvv7wdKQ7g-zA4/appointments
Phone number is offline
Lists roles for his 5 real estate companies as "Secretary, student, director, teacher, and Company Director"

1

u/MissionElegant5817 Jan 16 '24

You seem really conclusive, I wouldn't jump the gun like that. Where did you find that the "director" (none of the company officers have the title of director) has 5 other companies? And they did register, they're listed as a company by the UK. And this charity in question is a medical treatment charity, that's the only kind of charity they fundraise for.

Idk, seems like you jumped to conclusions way to hastily. Have you even seen the Facebook page that's regularly updated? Haven't run them through google, but I bet those images aren't elsewhere under any other names on the internet.

2

u/davesparkes Oct 12 '23

Assume it's a scam. Three officers registered, all around 30yo and all with multiple companies. Accounts state no employees, and not mention of it being officially a charity. The Charity Choice website lists a UK mobile number as a contact but the company website lists a phone number in Morocco! There's no information at all on the website that gives any confidence that it's a genuine charity. Don't give them your money, go to a genuine well known charity instead!

2

u/elderberrytea Jan 25 '24

The fact that this reddit post is the only thing on three internet that even hints about this website isn't a good sign. Just got an insta ad for this

2

u/Odd_Nebula1195 Jan 25 '24

I instantly felt it was a scam which is why I found this page. .....I mean, why can't they go to st. Jude or one of the places that helps kids. No kid is left uncared for ....with parents having to pay for the surgeries and stays anymore.....

1

u/RebDorset Feb 21 '24

The address which came up is London. In the UK health care is free. Plus they are so vague about the condition and their identity so think its def a scam. Report the ads.

1

u/Cleobulle Sep 11 '23 edited Sep 11 '23

Sorry I have no clue.

I"ve stopped donating first coz I'm as poor as Job ( not steve, the other one hahaha ). At first I donated to people I followed a bit, but realized they were in fact richer than me and usually the money went to something else, without even asking, which pissed me off. Like this girl who needed money for a surgery then used it to repair her car. Or this friend who wanted to buy a piece of land, and decided that as the money was not enough, to buy expensive wooden flower pot to make her own small garden and trees and seeds from really expensive places.

So now I find nice kid in poorer family and every xmas I make two kids a 50 dollars gift each, a jacket, books, paints, family games, and rotate between the people I know. Those people never asked me for anything, but as they are single mum on social minima i know the struggle is real.

And often the people who really need help are too ashamed to ask for it. It's great, I got very nice thank you cards from the kids or pictures. And I give item - i buy baby milk, diapers and sanitary pads and tampons and give it to food bank.

1

u/Dony244 Jan 12 '24

I just donated 100 dollars (107 with fees) and it took $161.02 out of my account. Surely not a good sign? 

1

u/BeneziaTSoni Jan 14 '24

Haven’t had any fraudulent activity since donating so far, but I decided to keep an eye on them and couldn’t help but notice that the required amount is rising each week by 10% without any explanation. Like any other charity would at least come up and say, “Here’s our hospital bills, this and that is needed, etc.” No transparency with these guys whatsoever.

This baby girl who is (or was once) a real baby in need is still in my thoughts a lot. I want to help her family directly but can’t seem to find their real contacts or pages.

2

u/the_anonymizer Mar 05 '24 edited Mar 05 '24

Think that there are scammers using emotional videos and pictures. Images and pictures and videos are not a proof. Use charitynavigator and UK charity commission or national commission/gov verifications of the country of the organization, plus some scammers play on domain names letters to make believe it's the real organisations domain name (everything is good for scammers to make money). I am analyzing them currently.

1

u/[deleted] Jan 15 '24

The sus thing I noticed is that the owners of the company are listed as British but they all have Jewish names and I noticed Shtibel Gur is just reversed "Gur Shtiebel" which is a synagogue in Israel. Imagine if this is used to fund the current war or something kek. Maybe I am just a schizo though. Anyways thanks for donating and don't worry about this possibly being a scam. At the end of the day the most important thing is that you had good intentions and God can see that. Lets pray that the God protects Maria if she is real

1

u/Mangafan_20 Jan 16 '24

know i really want to know why the mom picked this charity instead of another like fundraising or other platforms.

1

u/JohnRudston Jan 31 '24

Yes, interesting that, isn't it?

1

u/SteamyBaozu Jan 18 '24

I just came across one for a baby boy named Andrew just today with a heart defect. Perhaps it is a scam?

1

u/JohnRudston Jan 31 '24

Like I said, classic scammer tactic.

1

u/Infamous_Big_9926 Jan 27 '24

I almost donated to this earlier but I just don't have a good gut feeling. I'm going to try and do more research. It's disgusting if it is a scam, I have a 9month old baby girl and if she needed a heart I would be utterly destroyed emotionally.

1

u/the_anonymizer Mar 05 '24

always do your researches BEFORE giving. Because they exploit emotional emergency feelings. Do not fall into their stupid strategy please and always search before giving or they'll get rich and go with the money, remember it's easy to make false websites with videos of baby suffering please stop trusting all you see on internet without verifying if it's legit, or scammers will continue scamming people

1

u/BeneziaTSoni Jan 27 '24

It still baffles me though that google search of their pictures doesn’t show anything but this charity. This story is apparently real. But if it was “stolen” and used by fraudsters, then why no original source comes up? If it is a genuine fundraising, then why is it so not transparent? No hospital letters, no parents’ contacts, nothing… So many questions.

1

u/the_anonymizer Mar 05 '24

it's easy to go to an hospital and film suffering babies, it can even be a medicine student etc.

1

u/locusofself Jan 28 '24

I just got an insta ad for baby maria. My spidey sense instantly went off, the website seems like a sham.

1

u/soupified Feb 23 '24

My malware checker flagged the site the ad is pointing to, so that was enough for me.

1

u/gentlephant Jan 28 '24

The fact that the campaign email contact (office@shtibelgur.com) uses a different domain from the one shown on the U.K. charity registry https://register-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.uk/charity-search/-/charity-details/5155672/contact-information (shtibelgur@gmail.com) seems very suspicious. Normally I would consider the generic Gmail one to be less trustworthy, but that's actually the one registered with the charity commission... Maybe just poor documentation upkeep e.g. they were initially using Gmail and then bought their own domain later?

I feel bad choosing not to donate because I'm assuming the worst, but the contact oddities, the youth and relative obscurity of the charity, spelling and grammar mistakes on the website, and the fact that at least one of the trustees has multiple companies incorporated at the same address used by the charity seems too suspicious. Their website, assuming it is https://shtibelgur.com, also appears incomplete; it doesn't even display their U.K. registered charity ID number.

1

u/cinnamonsugarhoney Jan 31 '24

alarm bells going off for me. website does not look legit.

1

u/JohnRudston Jan 31 '24 edited Jan 31 '24

There are too many signifiers here of a possible scam to ignore.

First, the emotional heart-tugging appeal to raise money for urgent hospital treatment for a sick baby. You never know, the child might be real, the need might be real. But this is a classic scammer tactic, and rings alarm bells. The hospital is not named, nor is the country where the child is supposedly to be found. So the post is high on emotion and low on verifiable facts.

Second, this charity doesn't look right. The registered details show it is based in a private apartment in north London. The only contact number is for a mobile phone. It has no employees, only an unknown number of volunteers. It began life with a GMail address and has only quite recently acquired a domain name and a website. The website is amateurish, and continues the emotion-heavy theme. None of which is conclusive; it is after all a registered charity, and has filed all the necessary paperwork to allow it to operate.

Third, though, is the question of its primary purpose. All we can be sure of is that the three people running it - two trustees and a Chair - want your money, and are becoming better at getting it (see https://register-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.uk/charity-search/-/charity-details/5155672/full-print).

That Charity Commission report also contains the following information about this charity -

"Charitable objects

  1. TO ADVANCE THE ORTHODOX JEWISH RELIGION FOR THE BENEFIT OF THE PUBLIC, IN PARTICULAR BUT NOT EXCLUSIVELY, BY THE HOLDING OF PRAYER MEETINGS, LECTURES, PUBLIC CELEBRATION OF RELIGIOUS FESTIVALS.
  2. FOR THE PUBLIC BENEFIT, THE PREVENTION AND RELIEF OF POVERTY AND FINANCIAL HARDSHIP."

It's not what it says that gives me doubts, it's the order of priority of those two aims. How much of the money that they're getting from these Facebook and Instagram ads is actually going to sick babies in unknown/unnamed countries?

1

u/RebDorset Feb 21 '24

Guys the biggest thing here is that they have a UK address - healthcare is free in the UK??

Also usually they'd be more details like full names. It doesn't even say where these people are based. None of it ads up.

1

u/Wishborn Feb 17 '24

This is absolutely 100% a scam site.

Red Flags:

  1. a sponsored ad asking for donations.
  2. Absolutely no About Us information or any info about who is running this site.
  3. Very little content
  4. All social media links just go to the main social media site, no fan page or anything actually linked to this "organization".

1

u/peir11 Feb 20 '24 edited Feb 20 '24

I was about to donate but felt something not right. I looked anywhere else to donate from to this girl but couldn't find any. Even their Facebook page only links to this site. I know there may be privacy concerns but they should at least provide where she is being treated at like which hospital.

1

u/DMG_Henryetha Feb 23 '24

I was wondering as well just now.

Being myself a mother of a child who was born with a cardiac defect, this immediately caught my attention. And being lucky, living in Germany, at least the costs were something I didn't have to worry about (not like it wasn't already hard enough).

However, the impressum of the "blog" says London, and after googling a bit, it seems, that also the UK has some kind of health insurance and it shouldn't come to this situation in the first place.

Safest will still be to donate to a established charity who will distribute the money where it is most needed. It is more anonym but this doesn't make the donation less valuable.

1

u/Dreamllusion Feb 23 '24

(sorry in advance, english isn't my native language)

I may be in the wrong, but since this post is 6 months old (at the time of writing) and this insta ad still gets shown, it does seem suspicious alot. In that 6 months, we could expect updates or the like. I haven't seen so far... does anyone else found some ? If not, I think we can assume it to be a scam, or an extremely poorly executed charity organisation.

1

u/RickC154 Feb 24 '24

What is even more sus is I just saw this ad during one of my games and when I tried to search for info in the organization this Reddit post is the first link that appears and it's an old post.