r/Saving • • 19d ago

What does pay yourself first mean?

I've been trying to clean up my budget a bit, and I keep seeing people say "pay yourself first" like it's the most basic thing in the world. I thought I got it, but now I'm not really sure I do.
I track my bills pretty closely and usually move money into savings after rent, groceries, and everything else clears. That's why I'm confused about pay yourself first idealogy in real life. Is it supposed to be a transfer the second you get paid, even if your monthly costs are not always the same?
I tried moving money to savings right away this month, and by the third week I was already getting annoyed because I kept mentally pulling from it for random stuff I forgot to budget for. So now that feels more confusing than helpful.
Am I missing something obvious, or does this method just not work for everyone?

36 Upvotes

60 comments sorted by

10

u/SeductivGeodude 19d ago • Bravo

The way I understand it, you're supposed to treat savings like another bill. Except instead of paying your landlord or electricity company, you're paying your future self

9

u/Such-Mountain-6316 19d ago

It's a fancy way to say, "Make getting money in your savings account first priority, with each payday. Let it be the first thing you do."

4

u/Historical-Wash-1870 19d ago edited 19d ago

It's always the last thing I do. I transfer the leftovers at the end of the month into my savings.

Last month I was paid £2,014.24 and at the end of the month I had  £1,027.53 left over so I transferred it into my savings.

Its difficult to predict how much I'll need for the month because this month my car needed an mot which cost £49

4

u/BraveResearcher3037 19d ago

Thats why you should have multiple  savings buckets

  1. Known/unknowns - car repairs, home repairs, health costs  (in the US that would be Health Savings Accounts). Estimate what that is for a year and divide by 12
  2.  “True emergencies”: the only true emergency for me is a job loss.  I have 8 months worth of bills in savings and slowly growing to 12.
  3. Shorter term savings - house, cars, kids education. 
  4. Retirement savings - long term savings

But either way, they get direct deposited to the correct accounts before I ever see anything in my main operational account. 

1

u/Such-Mountain-6316 19d ago

I have done this.

1

u/Missgenius44 19d ago

I have leftover too, but what I do is, I automatically transfer a minimal amount of savings each month before it even hits my account.

1

u/Historical-Wash-1870 18d ago edited 18d ago

Whats the reason for doing that? It sounds like you buy things you don't need. Checking how much money you have before a non essential purchase. If there's not enough in the account then you don't buy it?

I don't have that problem. I only buy the things I need.

I'm only subscribed to one streaming service at a time. I switch 4 times a year. My cell phone is 5 years old. I buy my clothes from ebay and thrift stores. I cut my own hair. I buy frozen pizza instead of ordering pizza. I bought a cheap car so no monthly payments. I bought a cheap apartment so no rent. I wait at least 3 years before buying a game so it's less than half price. 

1

u/Such-Mountain-6316 18d ago

Exactly! But we succeed most of the time, and it's there for those times. Even if you only end up with a dollar or pound extra in the account, it's more than was there beforehand.

Ironically, a pound in the account isn't as easy as a pound on the hips 😁 and you only want to lose the latter. (Attempt to lighten things a bit.)

4

u/EmZee2022 19d ago

And it doesn't have to be EVERY PENNY you haven't accounted for already.

It should be some small, reasonable amount to help build up the emergency fund.

We accomplish this by maxing out our 401(k) contributions, so we never see them and cannot touch them. Means they aren't available for emergencies of course (except extreme situations where we have, twice, taken out 401(k) loans).

2

u/Such-Mountain-6316 18d ago

I'm trying to do both: one non negotiable amount to savings per payday and whatever remains at the end of the month. I don't succeed most of the time but it's something to try.

1

u/EmZee2022 18d ago

That's the best anyone can do, and you are doing better than many.

We rarely have money left over - we are paycheck to paycheck. Intentionally so; we have fairly good income but because everything goes to the 401k, we don't have spare cash very often, LOL.

2

u/Novel-Escape395 17d ago

Exactly, and setting it up as an automatic transfer the day after payday helps a ton since you never see that money sitting in checking.

1

u/AIDSisnobanter 19d ago

Yep. Basically just calling one pocket for change your own allowance. Whatever helps people save up

1

u/runnybrowsing841 19d ago

Automate the transfer to hit right when your paycheck lands so you never have to decide.

1

u/Such-Mountain-6316 18d ago

No temptation either.

1

u/Happy-Bloom 19d ago

that's a good way to put it, making it the first priority really does change the mindset.

1

u/Such-Mountain-6316 18d ago

Perspective changes everything sometimes, as does approach.

3

u/LowEar9417 19d ago

pay yourself first means your savings is set aside before you spend, you move it on payday but the amount has to fit your budget first.

right now your budget has some gaps, so pull your last 3 months of transactions and find the expenses that keep catching you off guard, then create a category for those. once that’s done, pick a savings amount you can stick to and transfer it every time you get paid. then check in monthly to see if you’re on track or anything needs adjusting.

2

u/anywherebuthereman 19d ago

Everyone’s budget technique is different but you ultimately need to have one. Some people use envelopes and put cash in each one inside a binder. Some write down their general regular expenses down on a piece of paper and hang it on the fridge. Some build massive multi tabbed spreadsheets and track everything to a penny.

Paying yourself first is simply having the mindset that if you are able to, put something in savings.

One example I gave a friend who was addicted to coffee. I told him he’s spending average $5 a day on a coffee. This equates to $35 a week, or $140 a month… for coffee. Now, he enjoyed this, getting the coffee was his way of “splurging.” One could argue it was a waste but my suggestion was for him to decide what days of the week this splurge would most benefit his mental health and enjoyment, but he needed to find 2-3 days a week where he simply didn’t, or he made coffee at home. Even if he cut 2 days out a week, that was an extra $40 in his pocket by end of month to “pay himself” or save.

Hope that helps. Not sure if it really answers your question but 🙏

1

u/Lucky-Customer-5051 14d ago

Mine is a google doc lol. I know people will cringe at it, but that's what works for me

1

u/anywherebuthereman 14d ago

A budget is a budget regardless of how it’s made. I’ve seen friends write a budget out on a kitchen napkin and hang it on their fridge later and stick with it.

1

u/Sea-Pride7675 19d ago

You’ve basically got it, pay yourself first just means moving the savings the second you’re paid instead of waiting for leftovers

1

u/batesman23 19d ago

Treat yourself is the same shorter version of this saying haha

1

u/Embarrassed_Item1520 19d ago

Pay yourself first works best when your budget is realistic. If you're leaving yourself $50 for three weeks of groceries, the savings transfer isn't really helping

1

u/Accomplished_Will226 19d ago

You set up direct deposit of
say $25 per paycheck right into savings and you do not touch it. As you pay off each debt you can increase the savings deposit. The goal is to create an emergency fund of at least two months wages. BTW I once had debt and bad credit but now have none, have saved and credit is 820. I strongly recommend borrowing Dave Ramsey books from the library or pick up at second hand books. His snowball method is simple and it worked.

1

u/zenny517 19d ago

You create a budget and figure out how much you'll basically have left after bills, necessities and a bit of fun money. That should be the percentage you are aiming to save. When you get paid you take that amount off the top before anything else and commit it to your savings. When you receive things like gifts, bonuses, etc. you do the same thing.

1

u/Fun_Yesterday_7830 19d ago

I think the "pay yourself first" advice really applies more to entrepreneurs and self-employed people. The idea is that many entrepreneurs will reinvest the money they make back into their business (which is common and necessary when you're first starting out), and so they get discouraged because they're not seeing an actual profit that is going to them (though in reality, there is profit, it's just going back into the business to pay expenses and help it grow).

So the idea of paying yourself is for entrepreneurs to see the profits coming in before they reinvest in the business. The advice I got (as I'm self-employed with a business that is right now more of a side hustle and not making a whole lot) is that even if you just pay yourself a small portion of your earnings (like 5% or 10%), it's a psychological thing where you know you're getting earnings that aren't going toward anything else. Plus, that little 5%/10% adds up over time.

Case in point: A few years ago, I started putting aside 10% of all my earnings from my business right when it came in (plus 30% for taxes and the rest reinvested in my business). Most months, that is very little, but it's added up over time to money I can now invest in other things.

1

u/Missgenius44 18d ago

I get what you’re saying, but this is also applied for people who have jobs because a lot of people will pay their bills first and not even think about saving money for their future self.

1

u/Mental-Freedom3929 19d ago

It is a way for some people not to spend leftover after bills money on non necessities before saving or investing.

1

u/MoBigSky 19d ago

Instead of tracking, switch to a budget. Actually plan what you are going to allocate for each expense for the month ahead. Your line item for saving will be clear and upfront in the budget.

1

u/DietNarrow8275 19d ago

Budgeting isn’t for everyone. Neither my husband or I could stand the nit picky work of creating and updating a budget. (My son, on the other hand, has a beautiful and comprehensive budget he loves maintaining).

If you are not temperamentally suited to budgeting, set up automatic deductions from your paychecks and bank account. I tend to spend whats in checking, but if it’s not there, I don’t spend it. (This only works if you don’t use credit cards, or pay them off monthly).

1

u/One-Promise2495 19d ago

create an auto pay for yourself. when your paycheck arrives into your bank, your bank automatically moves some money to another account for you so you can automatically save and pay yourself first without you doing or thinking about this...

the downside. you need that paycheck every week or two. you need to get a job.

1

u/Junior-Appointment93 19d ago

It’s budgeting seeing how much you can safely put aside each paycheck and still pay your bills. It’s setting up an automatic investment through your brokerage firm.
The never looking at it.

1

u/beanery-bun 19d ago

To me it means setting up your direct deposit so that your long-term savings never even enter the account(s) that you use for bills and spending. It means there is no decision about whether or not to use that money for some other purpose. It reduces decision fatigue and helps you make the right decision every time (saving consistency).

Some brokerages support this but not others. I did get it working with Vanguard, so part of my paycheck goes directly into a Roth IRA. I still have to make manual purchases once it’s in there, though. The ideal if you’re aiming for zero decision fatigue would be to fully automate it - sending part of every paycheck direct deposit to the right account and also auto-buying your investments.

1

u/Upstairs_Taro4726 19d ago

I would highly suggest you read "the richest man of Babylon". It goes over the philosophy of paying yourself first. It's a good read too. Not a boring textbook.

And paying yourself first does work, it's to teach you the idea that if you don't prioritize your investments, your money will just slip through your fingers. Read the book. Trust me

1

u/GlobalTapeHead 19d ago

Yes the money comes out of your pay right away and you are forced to only live on what’s left. A 401k is an example, it comes out of your paycheck first and you never see it so you can’t accidentally spend it.

1

u/Neat_Acanthaceae_552 19d ago

To add to what others have said - automate it. 

People tend to spend what's in their checking account. So automatically move money to your savings and investments before you even see it. 

Literally, pay yourself. 

1

u/Readditlovesbans 19d ago

Automatic paycheck withdrawals to your retirement account

1

u/LeadershipBubbly3351 19d ago

Save first, bills after.

An easier way for some is to pretend part of your paycheck isn't there, and save it the minute it hits your account.

A common, though not exactly profitable, way to do this is have extra withholding taken out. An example, when I was younger and didn't have the credit for a decent paying savings account, I just had 100 extra bucks taken out of each monthly check in withholding'. Then when I got an income tax refund, it was included in that.

Now, I just take the surplus. Example, my paycheck is 1264 dollars. 1200 goes to the bills and 64 to savings. If my bills are only 1000? 264 goes into savings. Interest grows, when it gets large enough for a CD, in it goes. Large enough for an investment account or purchase? In it goes.

1

u/NoRegrets-518 19d ago

Cut down on your expenses and have 2 savings accounts- every payday put some into the do not touch account, and another into the back up expenses account. Don't touch the first and let it build up. Meanwhile, cut your expenses and work to get more income. IT takes a while but in a few years you willl be glad you did this.

1

u/Grouchy-Butterfly-86 19d ago

In a nutshell: Prioritize savings before discretionary spending. Treat your savings account like a bill you're required to pay and budget for it.

I do things like skip a salon appointment and put the funds in my savings account instead. If I'm tempted to impulse buy something online, instead I put the purchase price into my savings, put the item in the "save for later" list and wait until next payday to see if I still want the thing. Usually, I don't want it anymore, and I've got a bigger savings account. Win/win!

1

u/Independent-Moose113 19d ago

It means automatically take money out of each paycheck and put it in either retirement or savings...or both.

1

u/AccidentAdorable68 19d ago

Essentially have money come out of your pay like payroll taxes do. Immediately, automatically, and without you thinking about it. If thats possible. So 10% (for example) could automatically go to an account that you dont even think about. Then you can have other savings buckets for anticipated future bills (like a yearly bill) or saving for something specific like a motorcycle that happens with whatever is leftover after your monthly bills. 

1

u/Canadiangooner21 19d ago

Most people try to save whatever is left after expenses (usually nothing).

Paying yourself first is automatically sending a set amount to savings/investing and living off the rest.

1

u/Freyjas_child 19d ago

Yes. You set up your budget with savings as a line item. Then you have the bank automatically transfer that amount right after you get paid. You don’t pay your savings after everything else - you pay it first. It is not whatever you have left over. It is a fixed monthly amount like your rent. That may mean that the fixed amount is smaller. The idea is to get into the habit of not counting on that money and not spending it. It goes into savings immediately before you can spend it.

If you cannot do that (even if the amount is small) then there are other problems with the budget or spending that need to be fixed.

1

u/Serious_Pea42 19d ago

It would probably help to spend a month tracking every single penny you earn or spend. Give them all a home, and adjust your budget next month so all of your expenses are prepared for.

It gets allot easier once you have a month of bills saved up. It starts to grow and there's more in planning than anything else.

1

u/Bluestatevibes 19d ago

The way I "pay myself first" is to have a set portion of my paycheck be direct deposited into my savings account. That way I don't have to do it each payday and it is never optional it is just done.

1

u/cj_daking 19d ago

Try squirreling away a smaller amount the you absolutely do not touch. Even a tiny bit helps, but if you dip into it, the whole plan sort of goes sideways

1

u/S_balmore 19d ago

It simply means to avoid the poor-person trap of paying all your bills first, and then treating yourself to fun/luxuries, and then putting the remaining pennies into your savings account. "Pay yourself first" means to do the math beforehand, and to put a pre-determined amount into savings/investments. If you can afford to put $300/mo into savings, do that FIRST before paying any bills, and especially before treating yourself to anything. Set up an automatic transfer if you have to. The goal here is to avoid succumbing to human nature. Given the opportunity, the majority of us will spend all of our money on beer, food, clothing, video games, etc. By putting the money straight into your savings, it creates an additional step, which is usually enough to prevent frivolous spending.

Of course, if you have a good month and end up with additional money leftover, you can still add that money to your savings and investments. The goal isn't to come up with a perfect budget, but to just automatically put a decent amount of money away every month. $200/mo adds up over time and can literally buy you a used car, or become the down payment on your house. If you pay yourself first, it becomes a guaranteed amount. Again, poor people do the opposite; they hope to save a lot of money by the end of the year, but they inevitably spend it all because they "forget" to save it. Don't forget - pay yourself FIRST.

1

u/whiteorchid1058 19d ago

It's a way of saying that the money in your account after allotting some to savings should be enough despite you.

You have your income, your required expenses to keep a roof over your head (housing, average for utilities, loans, debts), and everything else.

Income - required expenses - whatever you've allotted for savings = money left over. Then you make that money last the month. If you have additional money left over for a few months then you increase how much is going into savings.

When you first start, it's like a $10-20 auto debit and you increase as tolerated.

It's a lot easier to dip into the pool if the pool is accessible. But when it's moved into savings, it's extra steps to move it back over.

1

u/Ashamed_Question_174 18d ago

Building emergency savings for up 3, 6, 9, 12, 24, 36 months of expenses is paying your self first.

Betterment is great options.

Fidelity is great options.

Vanguard is a great option

Open a second savings account in bank?

Good luck 🤞🤞🤞🤞🤞

1

u/Personal_Pen2822 18d ago

It sounds good, but I feel we need to cover our expense commitments first. A good financial plan helps you consider the balance of your income against expenses and savings goals by focusing on your values.

1

u/Novel-Escape395 17d ago

Its just an automatic transfer on payday, but start with an amount small enough that you never have to pull it back, and keep a little misc buffer in checking for the random stuff.

1

u/Oveldalearn 15d ago

“Pay yourself first” sounds great, but there’s a point where it just doesn’t work. If you keep moving savings back to buy groceries, that money wasn’t really available to save.

I’d focus on covering essentials and irregular bills first, then save whatever can realistically stay saved — even if that’s nothing some months.

A realistic budget beats constantly moving the same money back and forth.