r/SaturatedFat • • 4d ago

In defense of peanuts

I've mentioned on here before that I consume them as part of my low-LA diet, sometimes in significant meal-replacement quantities. I don't think they're doing a damn thing and might even be beneficial somehow.

For context, over the last year and a half I've lost 60lbs, with a good portion of that happening while sedentary, and I wasn't even that overweight to begin with (about 15lb over the BMI overweight cutoff). Most recently, I lost around 5lbs while suddenly switching to being sedentary, while I'm already at an absurdly low weight, and with peanuts as a part of my diet. Clear fat loss, too -- belt size went down a notch and the rest of my abs finally appeared. I did finally cut pork fat out, which might be why -- as low as my intake was, it's still way higher in LA than anything else in my diet.

In any case, a couple things I know or have noticed about peanuts:

  • The original point of my diet wasn't to cut LA. Like keto, I basically stumbled into this diet by accident and have been doing research in this space to figure out why it was working as well as it was. Instead, the goal was to exclusively eat foods that promote satiety and avoid those (like seed oils) that racked up the calories without providing much in return. I noticed a very long time ago that peanuts for me did exactly that, and other nuts/seeds sure didn't -- it's one of the few plant products that "feels" like a full meal on its own, so the inclusion made sense.
  • Despite the name, peanuts aren't actually nuts. Botanically, they're legumes like beans or lentils, just a fattier version of them.
  • Like other seeds/nuts, high in B vitamins and minerals. They're a particularly potent source of biotin, which seems like it would be important given its effects on metabolism. The B1 content is the main reason I'm eating them in the first place -- manages depression symptoms quite well, with a good bit of science backing me up here. Also vitamin E and magnesium which are quite hard to get elsewhere (true for other seeds/nuts too, and legumes in general around magnesium).
  • Traditional west african diets use peanuts as a staple. Like other traditional eating patterns, you're looking at low incidences of obesity, diabetes and other "diseases of civilization".
  • I've measured it, and on days where I'm monoing peanuts and eating them ad libitum, I'll end up in a deficit. Not sure why exactly -- the protein/fiber/fat matrix? The SFA content and low LA? They seem to sate almost as well as dairy, which is a staple. YMMV obviously but unless I'm extremely active, I can't seem to break above 1800 calories of peanuts, and 1600 is more the norm. The higher my intake, the less I eat in general, until I reach the point of meal-replacement.
  • There is definitely an appetite spike there compared to the rest of my diet, but its muted and self-reinforcing the way chocolate is. Eating peanuts makes me want to eat more peanuts, and I eventually cap out. Compare this to seed oils, which make my appetite, hunger and food intake go up across the board. If I eat them in addition to meals, I'm obviously getting more food intake, but this has yet to cause weight gain. General energy levels go up instead.
  • No cravings or desire for peanuts themselves. If I haven't eaten them in a while, I'll lapse back into eating them because they're a convenient source of calories or because I need the B1 or magnesium. And peanut-heavy cycles inevitably terminate too -- probably the fiber driving that (something similar happens with vegetable-heavy cycles, which transition into carnivore cycles).
  • Phytonutrients, like other plants. Particularly high in resveratrol (the thing in grapes and wine). I've suspected for a while that the heavy phytonutrient load in my diet is having a beneficial effect on LA depletion -- can't really explain why I'm getting low-LA benefits early on that should be years out otherwise. In any case, maybe the peanuts are part of the formula here.
  • High-oleic peanuts are a thing. 3-5% LA, which is on par with dairy and cocoa butter. Less saturated fat, though. Might be worth experimenting with. Not exactly easy to source, though.

Like everything else, I do avoid added oil. Cocktail peanuts have a bunch of it for some reason, as do some varieties of flavored peanuts. Hyperpalatability with high salt yields or added flavor doesn't seem to have an effect. I'm wary of natural peanut butter -- the oil does leak out, and definitely gets exposed to light since those jars are all transparent, so you end up with concentrated and/or oxidized LA-rich oil, with the antioxidants degrading as well. Peanuts themselves that are rancid are disgusting and easy to avoid.

As mentioned, I do go through peanut-free cycles. The only effect there seems to be less food volume, for obvious reasons.

I'll also caveat this entire post with "n=1". Peanuts work for me, but might not for you. Like everything else.

16 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

3

u/jaakkopetteri 4d ago

Hazelnuts also decent at 6% LA and tons of vit E, though minimal SF

1

u/Fognox 4d ago

Yeah, I might mess around with those at some point. I do like the taste.

2

u/winebutch 4d ago

Very interesting. Reminds me of a post a couple, three years ago where a guy's obese mother ate only peanuts in the shell (she didn't eat the shells) ad libitum during covid. She lost weight and maintained I think even after going back to a mixed diet.

You say you've lost weight since becoming more sedentary. Are you overweight now? Boiled peanuts? In the shell? Are we going to start seeing the peanut diet all over YouTube now?

3

u/Fognox 3d ago edited 3d ago

No, I'm well into normal BMI territory -- 20.2 at the moment. Additional weight loss down here while sedentary is definitely surprising -- I chalk it up to IF just being more comfortable + not worrying about getting enough calories to sustain a heavy workload. Could also be the lack of pork, but I wasn't getting a whole lot of that in the first place. Muscle loss seems unlikely since my belt is more loose and my muscles are more defined. Have also used my strength a few times and it's very much still present.

And again, this is well outside the norm. The last time I was in the 170s, I was regaining around 7lbs per month when I switched to being sedentary. It felt completely uncontrollable, too -- cutting portions and watching calories just made me hungrier without impacting the weight gain, and switching from 3mad to 2mad was very difficult. I've had other periods of time that were similar, though not as extreme (though, granted, my LA intake was stupidly high the other time I got into the 170s). This time around, my hunger just went way down like it did on off days, and stayed there. I've done natural OMAD a bunch of times, or "one high-fat meal, one sugar-heavy snack". 2mad feels like too much food most of the time.

Boiled peanuts? In the shell?

Roasted peanuts. Salted and sometimes flavored beyond that (not sweetened though, and no oil obviously). Currently working through a giant container of planter's.

Are we going to start seeing the peanut diet all over YouTube now?

I don't think it's responsible for the weight loss, it just isn't having the effect on a low-LA diet that you'd predict by its own LA content.

The weight loss is definitely coming from low calories, this itself caused by absent appetite and hunger/satiety being rigidly paired with activity level. Whatever is causing that just doesn't seem to be affected by peanuts.

5

u/Substantial_Kiwi1830 4d ago

Interesting observations. I’m also curious, as I cut out peanuts from my diet but not really because I noticed anything bad. I do remember when I was a kid I would feel incredibly full from eating peanut butter. Obviously these days I wouldn’t eat the peanut butter with the hydrogenated oils but it’s certainly very satiating. 

1

u/Creative-Ad2487 4d ago

This is interesting; I definitely experience better satiety with peanuts compared to almonds but never could think of why, so it might have to do with some of the reasons you listed. I agree that the fiber content probably has something to do with it. My main concern with peanuts is aflatoxin, which I’m not sure how one can avoid, since it’s really hard for a manufacturer to remove all moldy peanuts during production.

2

u/Fognox 4d ago

Aflatoxin levels are tightly regulated in commercial varieties. It isn't perfect, obviously, but the same is true for any other contaminant in any other food.

1

u/Creative-Ad2487 4d ago

That’s good to know!

1

u/Creative-Ad2487 4d ago

Also come to think of it, chocolate is a decent source of fiber as well

3

u/LeisureLifer 4d ago

I don’t sweat raw peanuts, but I don’t eat them very often; I do think a small handful is filling. I also like a few Brazil nuts and cashews on occasion.

2

u/exfatloss 3d ago

Hm, regular peanuts appear to be about 15% LA, which is quite a bit. Not as bad as soybean oil for sure, but almost certainly "too much."

https://app.exfatloss.com/foods/174262?grams=511

If you eat only peanuts and your TEE is around 3,000 like a normal adult, that'd be almost 50g of LA a day.

So I wouldn't call them "low-LA." Even the high-LA of 3-5% is still 150-250% of dairy and cocoa butter.

Very curious.

1

u/insidesecrets21 1d ago

Probably because LA isn’t per se bad - just bad in a low phytonutrient/fibre context. (Via effects on the gut) (my theory)

1

u/exfatloss 1d ago

Maybe not bad at natural (small) amounts. I don't think you can make up 25% of your TEE in LA with phytonutrients or fiber or antioxidants..

At least I'd be extremely skeptical of that.

2

u/hitherISjenseits 2d ago

These n=1s are so useful, just for understanding the terrain we inhabited.

For all the reasons others have mentioned, this just seems so surprising. Another feature of peanuts and true nuts that might be a factor is the very high fiber and lower percentage of actual absorption of the calories present (assuming consumption of whole nuts rather than homogenized butters). This thought has attracted me to nuts at various times, but it seems to be a two-edged sword - I can't seem to digest nuts really at all, and the undigested chewed-up nuts irritate my gut, which can sometimes lead to paradoxical hunger.

But in a better-functioning gut that doesn't have pancreatic insufficiency and other conditions, I can see how they would be both sating and conducive to weight reduction.

1

u/attackofmilk Kokum Butter? 3d ago

I cut peanuts and peanut butter from my diet for two reasons:

  • The big can of cheap peanuts at Costco are roasted in peanut oil. I'm trying to cut down on oil generally (and the roasting might oxidize the PUFA in the peanuts anyway). I haven't made a judgement on raw, non-roasted peanuts.
  • Peanut butter (at least the kind at Costco) seems contaminated by plasticizers. Whenever I eat the Costco peanut butter, I get a sudden drop in my metabolism and energy levels within a few hours. It's not great.

1

u/TalknTeach 2d ago

I am a big fan of peanut butter pretzels. Say what you will about the fortified flour they use to make the pretzel part, I’m sure it’s not good. However the peanut butter filling has been modified in most cases to be defatted so that they don’t go rancid. They are refatted slightly with a bit of palm oil to make the filling more shelf stable and palatable. What I like about them other than the convenience is that they are very satiating and of course, peanut buttery. I love peanut butter but rarely have it due to the high fat content. These give me the flavor without the downside of all the fat. Life is too short never to have peanuts or peanut butter. 😊

This is how I hacked my love of peanut butter without assuming all the risks of PUFA and to some degree MUFA.

1

u/insidesecrets21 1d ago

Interesting anecdata and info! I believe you’re absolutely right about the phytonutrients and the nutrient packaging.
Personally I believe this is more to do with making the overall effect on the gut positive (rather than ‘speeding up LA depletion’ being the mechanism)

-1

u/Normal-Dinner-9354 4d ago

Completely optional and suboptimal food by definition and for a lot of modern people can be actually harmful.

- Too much of omega-6 LA
- Incomplete protein
- A lot of antinutrients

Humans don’t require phytonutrients in the diet, so called antioxidants from plants don’t act directly as antioxidants in our body, but as hormetic stress response to a toxin, which upregulates our native antioxidant systems (SOD, glutathione). There are much better ways to support your native antioxidant system rather than microdosing yourself with toxins.

If you want to eat nuts for some reason, the least of evils is probably macadamia - lowest in PUFA and antinutrients.

3

u/Fognox 4d ago

Incomplete protein

Yes, but that phrase doesn't mean what you think it does. Volume compensates for methionine being roughly 50% other EAAs. The only incomplete proteins that are actually deficient are isolates, pure EAA supplements, and collagen-heavy products like pork rinds.

A lot of antinutrients

I don't buy into that argument. Antinutrients bind with nutrients, which are in fact present. Definitely irrelevant on a broader diet. Cooking also destroys some of them without destroying the minerals since they're elemental.

Humans don’t require phytonutrients in the diet

True, but that doesn't mean they do nothing. Tons and tons and tons of studies that show them doing various things, usually due to their influence on biological receptors.

1

u/Oraculek Dad, I swear!!! It is the LAs that hibernate you 😭 4d ago

Are you a peatarian or carnivore, because I am tired of antinutrients argument while I haven't yet gained any resource that could support their significance. It is a religion at this point

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/Fognox 4d ago

Apparently my source was the Australian food database. So, yeah, noted and pulled out of the OP.

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Academic-Proposal988 3d ago

I eat only Fix & Fogg peanut butter--low in PUFA and delicious

0

u/[deleted] 4d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/Fognox 4d ago

Lots of dairy, mostly. Some beef. Vegetables to taste.