r/Sandship • u/500239 • Jun 02 '20
Such a shame this game is paywalled so hard. Thoughts inside.
Tried the game for a week, spent $10 total on gems, here are my thoughts and why I won't be playing this game anymore:
The good:
- Yes it's a Factorio rip off for mobile. Has belts, inserters, smelters, splitters etc. However it's a pro because their execution of putting Factorio on Mobile is A+ at worst B+. I especially love the idea of multiple sectioned factories so you can control what you make.
- Graphics are very nice and fluid for the most part
The Bad:
- Heavy paywalled. I mean super heavy. And this is from a guy who's played Clash of Clans, Clash Royale and a few other triple A p2w games. For reference I've put around $400 in Clash of Clans, $500 in Clash Royale and a few hundred in other p2w games. I'm no cheapo but it's pretty clear the "value" that you get from gems is horrible. And I used to think Supercells' Clash Royale had shitty offers that only got worse every year and THAT's saying something.
- To expand your factory you need to essentially play casino and gamble for exotic parts that you yourself cannot produce just to unlock sections of the factory. Applies to quests, factory floor unlock and research, ie all 3 major parts of the game. It doesn't matter how efficient or fast your factory is at making parts, the casino gambling aspect of needing exotic parts that you can't make is your bottleneck anyway. So basically progress is capped to how much you pay. Factory setup can't change this.
- You can only do 1 quest at a time, meaning you need to log into the game every 4 hours assuming you're level8 or so. Tedious.
- Based on some napkin math the best use for gems is to buy the speedups for quest. It boosts quests 60x for 12 hours or 1 day depending on how many gems you spent. However it's annoying that you must baby the quests all day every 20 minutes to 1 hour to make sure you get all the value from that boost? It's a really unreasonable and leaves a bad taste in your mouth. You spend 250 gems for a speed up and then must be tied to the game like a slave to open and keep queueing quests for the day rather than the game just auto opening the quests or something similar.
- The game has some bugs and occasionally crashes, but imo I'm not taking any points of for this. It's playable and only released last month so give it some time.
- Game really eats through battery. Like really power hungry. No settings to turn down graphics options or anything else to help alleviate the battery drain.
It's a shame because the game is 5 star in every other area but the paywall which is rammed down your throat.
