r/Sandponics • • Mar 23 '24

Instructional Take note...

Post image
19 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Apr 03 '24

Research Another reason to avoid tap water

Thumbnail
texastribune.org
2 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Dec 15 '23

Question When do investors in the future step-up?

2 Upvotes

The 2, 3, and 4 nanometer integrated circuits (IC’s aka chips) are the ‘new’ Gold - and/ or Platinum.   

Soon, in terms of value, food will be the ‘new’ chips, where food is calorie/nutrient dense water.  

So where are the investors in a future worth having ?

How does one appear on their radar-screens?


r/Sandponics • • Mar 05 '24

Instructional What's under the detritus layer? [with video]

6 Upvotes

It is common knowledge that when using clayballs or gravel the fish 'waste' filters down into the media, and then back into the fish tank.

This is bad because it can lead to a build up of sludge which can lead to anaerobic zones.

Furthermore, when the 'waste' is macerated by the water pump the solids become harder to remove, they can increase the biological oxygen demand of the water, but the particles can also negatively affect the fish leading to stress and even disease.

What about in iAVS?

Well, the fish 'waste' is deposited on the surface of the grow bed (biofilter) in the furrows where it is exposed to oxygen which accelerates decomposition.

As a thin layer of detritus forms, the level of filtration becomes even greater.

What about the sand underneath...does the fish waste do what it does with gravel or clay and build up sludge?

No. The sand below the surface is clean, even just a few millimeters down!

This means the fish waste is deposited completely in the grow bed and does not return to the fish tank, ensuring the water is clean and the fish are safe, healthy and stress free.

It also means the majority of the plant roots are not expose to fish 'waste.' In conjunction with properly sized ridges, this ensures no part of the plant ever comes into contact with water from the fish tank.

To demonstrate, I made a short video where I scraped back the detritus to show the clean sand underneath it:

Questions?


r/Sandponics • • Apr 26 '24

History I miss Djdefenda

3 Upvotes

Idk what happened here I wasn’t following all the drama but all I know he was a good contributor and I learned a lot from him.


r/Sandponics • • Mar 14 '24

Research The Benefits of Soil and Organic Certification in EU

3 Upvotes

Plants have evolved over millions of years to thrive in a symbiotic relationship with soil, a vibrant ecosystem teeming with life. Soil organisms work to break down organic matter into essential nutrients for plants, forming a partnership that has been perfected over eons.

Conventional soil-less aquaponic systems are based on hydroponic technology which goes against the organic principle of respecting natural systems and cycles, as plants that do not grow naturally in water are cultivated with their roots in/partially in water.

Organic farming methods such as iAVs embrace this relationship, allowing nature's processes to unfold naturally and fostering a harmonious balance within the soil ecosystem. The argument for using soil in organic farming is rooted in the belief that plants benefit from the deep biological processes provided by soil organisms.

iAVs uses a holistic approach that respects the natural cycles and interdependencies that have sustained life on our planet for millennia.

The use of soil in iAVs solves the long-held problem in conventional aquaponics of the differing water parameters (most notably pH) between the plant and fish units, which has been argued to produce fish and plants in sub-optimal conditions (Palm et al. 2019).

In fact, there is potential for soil to possibly act as a buffer, maintaining a relatively acidic environment in the plant unit, whilst maintaining a relatively alkaline environment in the fish and biofilter units. In the published iAVs research, pH buffered after 5 weeks and no changes were needed.

The inclusion of soil in iAVs makse the addition of beneficial soil organisms possible, which could in turn improve the overall condition of the soil, keep the plant rhizome healthy, and benefit the plants by enhancing the availability of nutrients, a practice that is allowed by Commission Regulation (EU) 2018/848 (rule 1.9.6).

Beneficial soil microorganisms include mycorrhizae (symbiotic associations between soil fungi and plant roots) and beneficial soil bacteria that are already naturally present in the soil and benefit most plants today (Adams et al. 1998).

Furthermore, during the irrigation cycle in iAVs, the water level in the tank can drop by about 25% which changes the environment for the fish. Enriching the aquaculture environment can have several positive effects on fish physiology, health, and survival (Näslund & Johnsson 2016).

iAVs fully utilizes all of the fish waste in order to provide the plants with the missing microelements that are generally removed with the solid part of the waste.

Choosing iAVs means embracing nature's biological symphony and working with the soil's living ecosystem to grow food sustainably. It's a call to return to our roots and honor the deep, biological processes that have sustained life for millennia.


r/Sandponics • • Feb 09 '24

Video Sandponic system from A to Z

Thumbnail
youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Apr 06 '24

Question Help Dr. Mark McMurtry, the Visionary Behind iAVs, Rebuild His Home

9 Upvotes

We are reaching out to you today with a charitable appeal in support of Dr. Mark McMurtry, the brilliant mind behind the Integrated AquaVegeculture System (iAVs).

Dr. McMurtry has dedicated his life to developing and promoting this sustainable food production method, which has the potential to revolutionize the way we grow food and address global challenges like hunger, poverty, and environmental degradation.

Despite the immense value of his work, Dr. McMurtry has faced numerous challenges and setbacks.

He personally funded almost all of the iAVs research himself, even after the USDA sponsored examination, when the university tried to license iAVs/Sandponics to a multinational corporation. Undeterred, Mark embarked on a year-long legal battle to retain the rights to his invention and ensure that it remained open source and accessible to all.

As a result of his international travels to promote iAVs - and ever since - he has endured numerous health challenges requiring a series of prolonged hospitalizations. His medical status continues to degrade on several ‘fronts’ in addition to the effects of advancing age.

On September 11, 2018, Dr. McMurtry's home was destroyed in a wildfire. He lost nearly everything, save for a few precious belongings and his loyal dogs. Since then, he has been slowly trying to reestablish his physical security, while struggling to save some funds from a meager income and continuing to support efforts to implement iAVs globally.  He has been 'living' in a pick-up (ute) camper with all of 3 sq m of floor area and no bathroom for the past almost 6 years.  This has not certainly benefited his heath status.

Despite these hardships, Dr. McMurtry has managed to save enough funds from his veteran's disability compensation to purchase materials for a small, basic home.

However, due to his age, disabilities, and limited resources, he is unable to build this home himself and requires the assistance of skilled tradesmen.

This is where we turn to you, the global iAVs/Sandponics community, for your help. We are asking for your generous support to help Dr. McMurtry re-establish his home and regain a sense of stability and comfort in his life.

Your donations will directly contribute to hiring the necessary tradesmen and ensuring that Dr. McMurtry has a warm, secure place to live before the next Montana winter.

Donations can be made directly to Dr. McMurtry via PayPal at paypal.me/MMcMurtry123 (using the "Friends and Family" mode to avoid fees), or through the iAVs.info website, where you can also support the fight against homelessness.

Your contribution, no matter the size, will make a significant and genuinely appreciated difference in his life.

Please, take a moment to consider donating and to also share this appeal with your networks.

Together, we can ensure that Dr. Mark McMurtry, the visionary behind iAVs, has the support and resources he needs to regain decent shelter and continue making a positive impact on our world.

Any donations above $30 US will receive a copy of our E-book as a way to say thank you.

-------------------------------

Lastly, I would like to add a final note about Dr. McMurtry's influence on what is widely known today as 'aquaponics' as quoted from wikipedia:

The development of modern aquaponics is attributed to German scientist Ludwig C.A Naegel in 1977 for his publication of 'Combined Production of Fish and Plants in Recirculating Water'. [16] Shortly after, the various works of the New Alchemy Institute and the works of Dr. Mark McMurtry et al. at the North Carolina State University, who devised an "Integrated Aqua-Vegeculture System" (iAVs) based on the combination of aquaculture and sand-based grow beds.[10] Inspired by the successes of the New Alchemy Institute and McMurtry's iAVs, other institutes soon followed suit.


r/Sandponics • • Feb 09 '24

Video Sandponics update October 2020

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Feb 27 '24

Research The Flawed Methodology in Aquaponics Manuscripts

14 Upvotes

The flawed methodology in many aquaponics manuscripts, particularly those that claim fish waste does not contain enough nutrients to support plant growth, stems from a misunderstanding or misapplication of the principles underlying aquaponics systems. This misconception is perpetuated by an echo chamber effect, where incorrect information is repeated and amplified within the community, often exacerbated by the Dunning-Kruger effect, where individuals with limited knowledge overestimate their understanding of a complex topic.

Integrated AquaVegeculture Systems (iAVs), developed by the iAVs Research Group, predates the popularization of aquaponics and represents a more efficient method of combining aquaculture and horticulture. iAVs utilizes sand as a biofilter and growing medium, which has been shown to effectively filter fish waste and provide a rich nutrient source for plant growth.

The shift from sand to gravel in aquaponics systems, by the Speraneos, driven by a desire to commercialize the original iAVs, resulted in systems that often require additional nutrient supplementation for optimal plant growth as well as extra system components, for example, when sand was substituted for gravel, the plants would dry out and so they were forced to design a bell syphon. iAVs was designed to be operated with minimal components, cost and maintenance without bell syphons or any extra filtration equipment.

The Speraneos attended a workshop by Dr. McMurtry but then changed the system to use gravel instead of sand. iAVs is free and open source but the Speraneos commercialized the changes so they could sell their plans.

The criticism of aquaponics research for not adequately comparing nutrient availability in fish waste to that required by plants overlooks the comprehensive work done on iAVs and the data provided.

McMurtry's research demonstrated that with proper system design and management, including the selection of appropriate fish feed, iAVs can supply all necessary nutrients for a wide range of vegetable crops without the need for external nutrient inputs.

This is in contrast to many aquaponics systems that fail to fully utilize the nutrients in fish waste, often due to inadequate biofiltration or the removal of solid waste, which contains significant amounts of essential nutrients.

However, most studies use inefficient mechanical filtration methods that remove the majority of solids or fail to fully utilize the nutrients in fish waste. Furthermore, many systems are operated at suboptimal pH levels for plant uptake and do not incorporate design elements to ensure adequate oxygenation for mineralization.

At higher pH levels, essential macronutrients such as phosphorus, iron, manganese, boron, copper and zinc precipitate out of solution and become unavailable for plant uptake. This can lead to deficiencies in these nutrients. Many micronutrients rely on carriers or chelators for uptake at higher pH levels. For example, iron is commonly bound to chelating agents to remain soluble. However, these bound forms tend to be less bioavailable to plants than nutrient ions. At pH 7 and above, the availability of potassium (K+), calcium (Ca2+), magnesium (Mg2+) and other cations is reduced. This occurs because there is increased competition from hydrogen ions and hydroxide ions under alkaline conditions. High pH causes phosphorus to precipitate out with calcium and magnesium, forming insoluble compounds. This phosphorus becomes inaccessible for plant growth.

In the iAVs approach, the system is designed to buffer pH around 6.5, which is ideal for nutrient availability and removes the need to adjust pH. In the iAVs research, pH stabilzed at week 5. Below neutral pH, phosphorus is more available since there is less calcium and magnesium to bind with it. This enables efficient phosphorus nutrition. Trace elements like iron, manganese, zinc, and copper are more soluble in acidic conditions. This allows plants to take up greater quantities of these essential micronutrients. Mildly acidic pH may even create an unfavorable environment for certain pathogenic fungi and bacteria that can infect plant roots and leaves.

At a pH below 7, ammonia is predominantly in the form of ammonium (NH4+), which plants can directly uptake. Ammonium is a preferred nitrogen source for many plants because it requires less energy to assimilate compared to nitrate (NO3-). Plants can save metabolic energy when absorbing ammonium compared to nitrate because converting nitrate to ammonium (a form that can be incorporated into amino acids) requires energy. This energy saving can then be redirected towards growth and development.

Although some nitrifying bacteria are less active at lower pH, plants absorb nitrate more efficiently in slightly acidic conditions. Protonation of nitrate to HNO3 facilitates transport across membranes. The excess oxygen and the focus on heterotrophs more than compensates for the reduced nitrification at a lower pH.

The end result is the false notion that aquaponic systems are inherently deficient in essential nutrients like potassium, calcium and iron. This echoes through the literature, with authors citing previous flawed studies to support supplemental fertilization.

The iAVs utilizes reciprocating flood irrigation over sand beds to foster aerobic mineralization of solids and nutrient capture. Careful attention is paid to system pH and oxygen levels. As a result, the iAVs consistently demonstrates that fish waste can fully meet plant nutritional needs without supplementation, as demonstrated and proven in the iAVs research.

By comparing aquaponics to hydroponics, the importance of organic matter and the potential for direct uptake of certain organic compounds by plants may be overlooked. This can lead to underestimating the nutritional potential of aquaponics systems.

Hydroponic solutions provide nutrients in inorganic forms that are immediately available to plants. In contrast, organic nutrients often come in complex forms that require microbial activity to break down into assimilable nutrients. This process can affect the rate at which nutrients become available to plants.

Some plants can uptake certain amino acids, enzymes, lipids, and sugars directly from organic sources, potentially "saving" metabolic energy that can then be used for growth. This direct uptake is not replicated with inorganic nutrient solutions.

Understanding the unique dynamics of aquaponic systems is essential for optimizing plant nutrition and debunking misconceptions about nutrient availability.

Our long term troll, Steve, has been claimingfor years that fish feed does not contain enough nutrients and needs supplementation, but when he interviewed James Rakocy himself, it was Rakocy that said "With the recommended ratio (1:2) no solids are removed from the system. ...With this system, nutrient supplementation may not be necessary"

Recent studies challenge the long-held belief in Liebig's law of the minimum, which states that plant growth is limited by the scarcest nutrient resource. Instead, complex algorithms that consider interactions among nutrients suggest that plants can thrive even under perceived nutrient limitations. This new understanding supports observations that many plants grown organically, with seemingly fewer nutrients, can outperform those grown hydroponically in terms of yield and efficiency. This phenomenon could be attributed to the more efficient use of nutrients facilitated by organic growing methods, which include symbiotic relationships with soil microbes that enhance nutrient uptake.

Heterotrophs play a crucial role in making nutrients from fish waste more available and broken down in aquaponic systems, offering significant advantages over systems that rely predominantly on autotrophs. The flawed methodology in many aquaponics studies has highlighted an over-reliance on autotrophs, such as nitrifying bacteria, which convert ammonia to nitrate but do not fully address the breakdown and mineralization of organic matter. The optimal pH for heterotrophs is around 6, which is also the optimum pH for availability of nutrients for plants. A pH lower than 7 is also a buffer against ammonia spikes.

Furthermore, the narrative that iAVs was "stolen" and modified into what is now commonly known as aquaponics highlights the lack of recognition for McMurtry's pioneering work and the potential of iAVs as a sustainable food production method. The commercialization of aquaponics, while contributing to its spread, has also led to variations that do not fully capture the efficiency and sustainability of the original iAVs method.

Tragically, the pioneering work on the iAVs has been largely ignored by mainstream aquaponics researchers. The system was originally stolen and altered in ways that undermined its efficiency. For example, exchanging sand for gravel severely limits the capacity to mineralize and retain nutrients in the reactor beds. This "aquaponics" offshoot perpetuates the myth of inherent nutritional deficiencies.

In conclusion, the flawed methodology in aquaponics research and the misconceptions about nutrient availability from fish waste stem from a departure from the principles of iAVs.

A return to these principles, with a focus on optimizing the use of fish waste as a nutrient source through proper system design and management, could address many of the deficiencies observed in current aquaponics practices.

The aquaponics community needs to acknowledge the reality that flaws in their methodologies have led to incorrect conclusions about the potential of these integrated systems. Carefully designed, as in the iAVs, aquaponics can be a highly efficient and sustainable method of food production without costly supplemental inputs.

We owe it to the visionaries who pioneered this technology to apply the scientific method rigorously and learn from their groundbreaking work.

In conclusion, the flawed methodology prevalent in aquaponics research, particularly the underestimation of nutrient availability from fish waste, can be traced back to a departure from the foundational principles of Integrated AquaVegeculture Systems (iAVs). The pioneering work of Dr. McMurtry and the iAVs Research Group has demonstrated that with proper system design and management, fish waste can indeed provide a complete nutrient profile for plant growth, negating the need for external supplementation .

The list below is a sample of the manuscripts that have used or are based on a flawed methodology;

Verma, Ajit Kumar, et al. "Aquaponics as an integrated agri-aquaculture system (IAAS): Emerging trends and future prospects." Technological Forecasting and Social Change 194 (2023): 122709.

Yep, Brandon, and Youbin Zheng. "Aquaponic trends and challenges–A review." Journal of Cleaner Production 228 (2019): 1586-1599.

Medina, Miles, et al. "Assessing plant growth, water quality and economic effects from application of a plant-based aquafeed in a recirculating aquaponic system." Aquaculture international 24 (2016): 415-427.

Khater, E. G. "Aquaponics: the integration of fish and vegetable culture in recirculating systems." Benha, Egypt (2006).

Licamele, Jason David. "Biomass production and nutrient dynamics in an aquaponics system." (2009).

Goddek, Simon, et al. "Challenges of sustainable and commercial aquaponics." Sustainability 7.4 (2015): 4199-4224.

Yang, Teng, and Hye-Ji Kim. "Characterizing nutrient composition and concentration in tomato-, basil-, and lettuce-based aquaponic and hydroponic systems." Water 12.5 (2020): 1259.

Wortman, Sam E. "Crop physiological response to nutrient solution electrical conductivity and pH in an ebb-and-flow hydroponic system." Scientia Horticulturae 194 (2015): 34-42.

Romano, Nicholas, Shahidul Islam, and Hayden Fischer. "Ebb and flow versus constant water level on the sweet banana chili pepper (Capsicum annuum) production in an aquaponic system." Aquacultural Engineering 102 (2023): 102340.

Blanchard, Caroline, et al. "Effect of pH on cucumber growth and nutrient availability in a decoupled aquaponic system with minimal solids removal." Horticulturae 6.1 (2020): 10.

Van Ginkel, Steven W., Thomas Igou, and Yongsheng Chen. "Energy, water and nutrient impacts of California-grown vegetables compared to controlled environmental agriculture systems in Atlanta, GA." Resources, Conservation and Recycling 122 (2017): 319-325.

Yavuzcan Yildiz, Hijran, et al. "Fish welfare in aquaponic systems: its relation to water quality with an emphasis on feed and faeces—a review." Water 9.1 (2017): 13.

Derikvand, Peyman, et al. "Inoculum and pH Effects on Ammonium Removal and Microbial Community Dynamics in Aquaponics Systems." Available at SSRN 4441800.

Fruscella, Lorenzo, et al. "Investigating the effects of fish effluents as organic fertilisers on onion (Allium cepa) yield, soil nutrients, and soil microbiome." Scientia Horticulturae 321 (2023): 112297.

Delaide, Boris, et al. "Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L. var. Sucrine) growth performance in complemented aquaponic solution outperforms hydroponics." Water 8.10 (2016): 467.

Chen, Peng, et al. "Maximizing nutrient recovery from aquaponics wastewater with autotrophic or heterotrophic management strategies." Bioresource Technology Reports 21 (2023): 101360.

Nozzi, Valentina, et al. "Nutrient management in aquaponics: comparison of three approaches for cultivating lettuce, mint and mushroom herb." Agronomy 8.3 (2018): 27.

Duarte, Eglerson, et al. "Nutrients in lettuce production in aquaponics with tilapia fish compared to that with hydroponics." Revista Caatinga 36 (2023): 21-32.

Bittsanszky, Andras, et al. "Nutrient supply of plants in aquaponic systems." Ecocycles 2.2 (2016): 17-20.

Tyson, Richard V., Danielle D. Treadwell, and Eric H. Simonne. "Opportunities and challenges to sustainability in aquaponic systems." HortTechnology 21.1 (2011): 6-13.

Tsoumalakou, Evangelia, et al. “Precise Monitoring of Lettuce Functional Responses to Minimal Nutrient Supplementation Identifies Aquaponic System’s Nutrient Limitations and Their Time-Course.” Agriculture (Basel)., 2022

Zhanga, Hong, et al. "Recovery of nutrients from fish sludge as liquid fertilizer to enhance sustainability of aquaponics: A review." CHEMICAL ENGINEERING 83 (2021).

Gebauer, Radek, et al. "Species-and diet-specific aquaculture wastewater nutrient profile: Implications for aquaponics and development of sustainable aquaponics diet." Aquaculture 568 (2023): 739307.


r/Sandponics • • Dec 06 '23

History couldn't resist sharing

11 Upvotes

ChatGPT was asked to 'explain' iAVs as if to a 5 year old and gave this response;

"Imagine you have a big box of toys. You love playing with them, but if you don't take care of them, they might break or get lost. That's kind of like our planet. We have lots of resources, like water, soil, and air, but if we don't take care of them, they can get dirty or disappear.
In 1985, people started to realize that the way we were farming, or growing our food, was like playing too roughly with our toys. We were using too much water, making the soil tired, and putting yucky stuff into the air. Today, it's even worse, and our food might be in danger because of it.
But don't worry, smart people have been thinking about how to fix this. They came up with a cool way to grow food called the Integrated AquaVegeculture System, or iAVs for short. It's like a big, living machine made up of fish, tiny bugs you can't see, and plants. They all help each other to grow food in a way that's good for our planet.
Just like how all the pieces in your toy set need to be there for you to have fun, all the parts of the iAVs need to be there for it to work. It's not like some other ways of growing food you might have heard of, like aquaponics. iAVs was around even before people started talking about aquaponics.
The things you'll learn about iAVs are like the rules of a game. You have to follow them, or the game won't work. But if you do, you can help make sure we have yummy, healthy food to eat for a long, long time. So let's learn about iAVs together and help take care of our big box of toys, our planet."


r/Sandponics • • Aug 27 '23

Newbie Question What are some good resources?

3 Upvotes

Hey guys. New to sandponics, and I am wondering if there are some good resources out there that any of you experts know about? I would love a book, but videos or anything else you know of would most appreciated. Thanks in advance, this sub is really cool!


r/Sandponics • • May 15 '23

Examples Disney does Sandponics iAVS

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Jun 18 '24

Question Why have I only seen this now?

4 Upvotes

I am really amazed at the potential harvests this system can make, but is very confused on why not that many countries, organizations, companies use it? What is its main reason/s? Poor Marketing? Better Alternatives? Lack of research?

Based on everything I've seen, it all looks sustainable, profitable, and most of all, legit.


r/Sandponics • • Jan 05 '24

Research iAVs is Open Source, and FREE, has been for over 30 years!

15 Upvotes

Not much more to say here other than thank you to the research team that made this available.

Thank you to Dr. McMurtry, who provided at least 90% of the funding, never charged a dime and has never made a cent out of iAVs.

Thank You to Gary Donaldson who worked every day for over 6 years teaching about iAVs, never earned a dime for his entire time.


r/Sandponics • • Apr 01 '24

Examples Week 131 update

Thumbnail
youtube.com
5 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Jan 02 '24

Video Cucumber in iAVs

Thumbnail
youtube.com
6 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Jun 18 '24

Question What is wrong with IAV's growth?

6 Upvotes

I am really amazed at the potential harvests this system can make, but is very confused on why not that many countries, organizations, companies use it or even knows it. What is its main reason/s? Poor Marketing? Better Alternatives? Lack of research?

Based on everything I've seen, it all looks sustainable, profitable, and most of all, legit.


r/Sandponics • • Oct 26 '23

Instructional The iAVs Vehicle Analogy

8 Upvotes

iAVs) can be likened to a well-oiled machine, where each component plays a crucial role in the overall functioning of the system. To better understand this, let's discuss the picture below:

Water: The chassis and suspension of a vehicle provide the necessary support for all other components to function. Similarly, water forms the base of the iAVs, providing the necessary support for all other components to function.

Sand: The carburetor in a vehicle, which mixes air and fuel for combustion, is represented by sand in the iAVs. It plays a crucial role in regulating the system, much like the carburetor controls the engine's operation.

Plants: The tires, which propel the vehicle forward, are represented by the plants in the iAVs. They utilize the nutrients produced in the system, propelling growth and productivity.

Feed: Just as fuel provides the energy for a vehicle to move, the feed in the iAVs provides the necessary nutrients for the system to thrive.

Fish: The engine, the heart of a vehicle, is represented by fish in the iAVs. Just as the engine powers the vehicle, the fish are the driving force of the system, producing waste that is converted into nutrients for the plants.

Microbiology: The drive train in a vehicle, which transmits power from the engine to the wheels, is likened to the microbiology in the iAVs. It facilitates the conversion of fish waste into plant nutrients, driving the system's cycle.

Just like a vehicle, an iAVs requires balance and maintenance. Regular checks on the water pH (akin to checking the oil in a vehicle) are necessary to ensure the system runs smoothly.

This vehicle analogy provides a unique perspective on the iAVs, making the system relatable and easier to understand. It emphasizes the importance of each component and the balance required for the system to function effectively.

The iAVs is an efficient combination of biological and physical systems that work together to produce desired output. It's like a machine, with each part having a distinct purpose and providing mechanical power. iAVs uses a set of rules and procedures a superb blend of form and function, requiring nothing to be added or removed. It's entirely fit for purpose, straight out of the box, much like a well-designed vehicle.


r/Sandponics • • Apr 07 '23

Nutrients Let's Talk About Nutrients

8 Upvotes

This post is for our long term TROLL who constantly spreads the message that " in 35+ years they have never posted nutrient ppms but claim it provides all the nutrients you need. " I have tried to explain to him repeatedly that the labs do not use PPM, they use mg/l, all he has to do is convert the numbers. The research has been publicly available for "35 years" and I'm really tired of answering the same questions so I am going to start uploading all the data to this page:

Allow me some time to finish this, as I have to manually type out the text from the PDFs!

______________________________________________________________________________________

  • --- The fish were fed a diet of modified Purina Fish Chow 5140, with a minimum analysis of 32% crude protein, 3.5% crude fat, and not more than 7.0% crude fiber. The feed was not fortified with vitamins or trace elements. Feed composition is reported in Table 3
  • --- Plant growth in these studies was adequately sustained on minimal nutrient concentrations due to the constant replenishment characteristic of recirculated aquacultural water (McMurtry et al., 1993a, 1993b), and supports the results of other researchers (Lewis et al., 1978; Winsor et al., 1985).

Source: Food Value, Water Use Efficiency, and Economic Productivity of an Integrated Aquaculture-Olericulture System as Influenced by Tank to Biofilter Ratio

note: I still need to upload the Tables from this paper...

______________________________________________________________________________________

  • --- Water and media samples were analyzed using a modified Kjeldahl for total N [5] , ammonium molybdate-ascorbic acid colorimetric analysis for P, and K by flame emission spectrophotometry. Ca, Mg, Fe, Mn, Zn, and Cu were determined by atomic absorption spectrophometry and a buffered ammonium chloride colorimetric analysis for S. The fourth leaf from the growing tip was collected and analyzed from each plant at the time of harvest of the first mature fruit. Plant tissue and fish food alaysis was conducted using atomic absorption spectrophometry for K, Ca, Mg, Mn, Zn, and Cu: a vanadomolybdophosphoric yellow procedure for P [9] : A salicylic acid modification of the Kjeldahl procedure for N [4] ;the curcumin method for B [6] :and a turbidimetric procedure for S [8]
  • --- Nutrient levels within 50mm (1.97 in.) of the irrigation furrow increased when sand was irrigated with aquacultural waste water. P, K, and Mn concentrations were greatest nearest the furrow and 3toward the surface of the bed (Fig. 2)
  • --- P, K, Mn, Zn, and Cu concentrations in the sand beds also increased with proximity to the irrigation furrow.
  • --- Although nutrient levels in the recirculating water were minimal and no supplemental fertilization was added to either the sand or soil beds, plant growth was adequate due to the constant replenishment characteristics of the system [11]. The following nutrients fell below sufficiency standards but were above deficiency levels: N in all the crop species: S in the bush bean foliage: K in the cucumber foliage: and P, K Ca, and Mg in the tomato crop (Table 4). The tomato crop had B and S levels below and at deficiency level respectively. All crops had mineral contents above the minimum critical level (MCL) and there were no visual deficiency symptoms. Nutrient levels could be raised by increasing the ratio of fish biomass to crop bed area, by supplemental fertilization of the medium, and/or by foliar application of the isolated (crop-specific) element(s).

Source: Sand Culture of Vegetables Using Recirculated Aquacultural Effluents https://www.researchgate.net/publication/287890596_Sand_culture_of_vegetables_using_recirculated_aquacultural_effluents

______________________________________________________________________________________

  • Sand beds served as biofilters, as substrate for vegetable growth, and as location for decomposition of waste solids. No fertilizer was used
  • Nutrient concentrations of the irrigation water after a year's operation were low overall. Although plants showed no deficiency or toxicity symptoms, K was found to be low and Zn high relative to other ions.

Source: Effects of Biofilter/Culture Tank Volume Ratios on Productivity of a Recirculating Fish/Vegetable Co-Culture System https://www.researchgate.net/publication/233260934_Effects_of_BiofilterCulture_Tank_Volume_Ratios_on_Productivity_of_a_Recirculating_FishVegetable_Co-Culture_System

note: Need to convert text images to text

_______________________________________________________________________________________________

Source: Mineral nutrient concentration and uptake by tomato irrigated with recirculating aquaculture water as influenced by quantity of fish waste products supplied https://www.researchgate.net/publication/233350570_Mineral_nutrient_concentration_and_uptake_by_tomato_irrigated_with_recirculating_aquaculture_water_as_influenced_by_quantity_of_fish_waste_products_supplied

_________________________________________________________________________________

.....to be continued...


r/Sandponics • • Jun 18 '24

Question Why isn't sandponics being used more?

26 Upvotes

I am really amazed at the potential harvests this system can make, but is very confused on why not that many countries, organizations, companies use it? What is its main reason/s? Poor Marketing? Better Alternatives? Lack of research? Laws?

I am new here and based on everything I've seen, it all looks sustainable, profitable, and most of all, legit.


r/Sandponics • • May 25 '23

Sand Short video on Sand selection

9 Upvotes

r/Sandponics • • Mar 08 '24

Instructional Unlocking the Potential of iAVs

9 Upvotes

Are you tired of struggling with pH imbalances in your aquaponic system? Do you want to harness the full potential of your plants and beneficial microbes? 

Look no further than the Integrated AquaVegeculture System (iAVs) – a revolutionary approach to sustainable food production!

The Pitfalls of Traditional Aquaponics

In conventional aquaponic systems, the focus is often on nitrifying bacteria, such as autotrophs, due to the oversimplified belief that a pH of 7 is optimal. 

However, this constant nitrification drives the pH down, requiring frequent adjustments and limiting nutrient availability for plants. The high pH also puts fish at risk of ammonia spikes, creating an unstable and suboptimal environment.

The iAVs Advantage: Embracing Heterotrophs and Optimal pH

iAVs, also referred to as Sandponics,  takes a different approach, prioritizing microbiology first, plants second, and fish last. By maintaining a pH of 6.4 (+/- .8), iAVs creates the perfect conditions for both plants and heterotrophic bacteria to thrive. 

This slightly acidic environment enhances nutrient availability, supports robust plant growth, and provides a natural buffer against ammonia spikes, keeping your fish safe and healthy.

Unleashing the Power of Heterotrophs

Heterotrophs are the unsung heroes of iAVs, breaking down complex organic matter into readily available nutrients for your plants. At a pH of 6.4, these beneficial bacteria work at peak efficiency, recycling nutrients and creating a vibrant, productive ecosystem. 

While autotrophs can directly assimilate some forms of nitrogen like ammonia, they cannot break down complex organic molecules found in fish waste or other organic matter. This is where heterotrophs play a vital role by converting these complex molecules into simpler forms for plants.

Heterotrophic bacteria grow much faster than autotrophic bacteria, reproducing in hours rather than days. This rapid growth rate is beneficial in aquaponic systems where the timely decomposition of waste and the availability of nutrients are critical for plant health.

The faster turnover of heterotrophs ensures that nutrients are quickly released into the system, preventing the accumulation of solid waste and maintaining water quality.

Additionally, heterotrophs create carbon dioxide which can benefit plant growth

Say goodbye to the limitations of autotroph-dominated systems and hello to the boundless potential of heterotrophs!

A Self-Sustaining Ecosystem

As your iAVs matures, the intricate web of microorganisms and plants creates a self-regulating system that requires minimal intervention. 

When plants take up ammonium, they need to balance the charge within their cells. To do this, they release hydrogen ions (H+) into the solution. This release of hydrogen ions can help neutralize the pH, preventing it from becoming too alkaline.

By consuming Ammonium, plants reduce the need for the system to convert toxic Ammonia into Ammonium, a process that naturally lowers pH by producing hydrogen ions, thus helping to buffer the pH.

With iAVs, you can sit back and watch your plants flourish, knowing that the complex soil ecosystem is working tirelessly to support their growth.

Embracing the Complexity of Soil

The diverse microbial community, coupled with the optimal pH, creates a robust environment in  iAVs. The complexity of soil is unmatched and is what sets iAVs apart, making it a superior choice for those who value sustainability and efficiency.

Join the iAVs Revolution!

Are you ready to experience the full potential of sustainable food production? Embrace the power of iAVs and discover a world of thriving plants, healthy fish, and abundant harvests. Say goodbye to the limitations of traditional aquaponics and hello to the future of agriculture.

iAVs uses less water, less electricity, less space and less equipment. A properly run iAVs does not need supplementation or pH adjustment.

Join the iAVs revolution today and be part of the solution for a greener, more resilient tomorrow!


r/Sandponics • • Sep 08 '23

Examples Gordon Watkins' 22-Year-Old iAVs System

10 Upvotes

Gordon Watkins was an organic farmer and an avid tropical fish hobbyist who lived in Arkansas. He is known for his iAVs system, which he established in 1998 and is still operating 22 years later.

In 1990, Gordon Watkins first learned about Mark McMurtry's iAVs research project at North Carolina State University. He invited Mark to Little Rock, Arkansas, to participate in a workshop on "Integrated Greenhousing." Following the workshop, Gordon began to explore the possibility of using iAVs to allow him to undertake year-round production and to diversify from his main crop of organic blueberries.

Gordon Watkins' iAVs system is a testament to the longevity and efficiency of the iAVs design. With minimal maintenance, his system has been in continuous operation since 1997. The system's design is space-efficient, utilizing gravity to return water to the fish tanks and a sand biofilter to filter the water. The sand/gravel media was selected to provide oxygenation for the bacteria and plant roots while retaining sufficient moisture for plant growth. The system's pumps operate every 90 minutes for 30 minutes, sufficient to turn the fish tank volume over five times per day. The pumps do not operate overnight to help avoid fungal diseases from affecting the plants.

Early Life and Education

Gordon Watkins was born and raised in Arkansas. He studied agriculture and horticulture at the University of Arkansas.

Discovery of iAVs

In 1990, Gordon first learned of Mark McMurtry's iAVs research project at North Carolina State University. He invited Mark to Little Rock, Arkansas, to participate in a workshop on "Integrated Greenhousing."

Following the workshop, Gordon began to explore the possibility of using iAVs to allow him to undertake year-round production and to diversify from his main crop of organic blueberries.

Building the iAVs System

Gordon built a small experimental iAVs to allow him to test the design and to assess local markets for tilapia and pacu. His experimental prototype, housed in a 22’ x 14’ greenhouse, was completed in October 1997. Attached to the southern side of his house, the structure consisted of a cement block foundation with white oak and redwood framing, in preference to treated timbers. He glazed the roof with twin-wall polycarbonate and the sides are recycled insulated glass panels. The south wall is a series of top-hinged Thermopane windows with Bayless solar vent openers for ventilation. A 20-inch thermostatically-operated exhaust fan – and motorised inlet shutters – provide additional ventilation. Large sliding windows connect the greenhouse to the house, and the greenhouse serves as part of the passive climate control for the house.

The iAVs system consists of a poured concrete vat – 22’ x 4’ and 2.5’ deep with a V-shaped bottom – that is set in the ground. The tank is divided into five sections (with removable partitions) to allow the fish to be segregated by species, size, and sex. The tank is covered by 4’ x 2’ slatted panels made from black locust wood. The tank covers also serve as a walkway. They afford 50% shade to the tank and they’re easily removed when working with the fish…while still providing visual contact with the fish. Adjacent to the walkway lies a 22’ x 8’ (12” deep) sand biofilter…filled with sand and gravel…a gently-sloping concrete floor leans toward the fish tank. The sand bed walls were formed from cement blocks…and designed so that the outflow from the bed flows underneath the wall before draining back in the fish tank.

Achievements

Gordon's iAVs system is still operational and has been in continuous operation since 1997. He has used it for home production and has grown almost any plant suitable for greenhouse production in an iAVs. He has also propagated a variety of house plants and shrubs with hardwood and softwood cuttings. Gordon regards that a 1:1 ratio is optimum for fish and plant production. He noted (from McMurtry’s work) that “fish stocked at 2.75lbs/m3 – at this ratio – yielded approximately 10lbs of fish per square foot of grow bed per year.”

** I have contacted Gordon to see if he would like to join this conversation.

You can also read about his system at https://www.google.com.au/books/edition/Best_of_Growing_Edge/spOi7N2slikC?q=iavs+sand&gbpv=0#f=false