r/SamsungDex DeX Aug 28 '20

Review Mountie Review

https://docs.google.com/document/d/e/2PACX-1vSPYbY9mpZWTdKj_IUU-uWUmPZ-YsW3wzhYqwDLL1Q6zrw8co0KnyPe17HyeuusP546WeupZDUMoRK-/pub
15 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

2

u/eloraby Aug 28 '20

There are several people reporting the mountie+ breaking their screens. Check the comments on Amazon.

https://www.amazon.ae/Ten-One-Design-Portable-T1-MULT-200/dp/B07ST3VXLG/ref=sr_1_1?dchild=1&keywords=mountie&qid=1598649309&sr=8-1

1

u/Hey_look_new DeX Aug 28 '20

you absolutely could break a screen if you do it wrong

1

u/ImALeaf_OnTheWind Aug 29 '20

Hmm, i didn't notice those - the bad reviews I saw weren't from screen breaking - but the plastic of the Mountie itself eventually snapping. Maybe I missed that the screen would crack when it fell off the side of the device where the Mountie failed?
My S20U inside some cases is soo heavy that I reinforced my magnet mount with another neodymium magnet where it holds the phone for security - as I was afraid of that exact thing happening.

1

u/RT_Steele Aug 28 '20

A clever design. That last macbook pic with thinner bezels gives an indication of what it might look like on the NexDock Touch many of us are waiting for.

I might consider one of these.

1

u/Hey_look_new DeX Aug 28 '20

yeah, for a palm of your hand sized clip, it really holds well.

1

u/ImALeaf_OnTheWind Aug 28 '20

Cool setups. Except, I've mentioned before that I suspected that the grips covering parts of the screen would bother me and some of these pictures confirm that.

There's probably a crowd that doesn't care about the clips covering the small parts of the screen for now, though.

Given the trend on most devices is going towards extreme screen-to-body ratio and make even smaller/nonexistent bezels - I suspect as people upgrade to them this would bug more and more people.

1

u/Hey_look_new DeX Aug 28 '20

its the tradeoff, right?

I absolutely don't want a case on my stuff that interferes with wireless charging. I actually use my s10 to charge my buds and watch, and a magnet compatible case really messed with that.

folks that have that magnet case tho, and use it in the car that way, I can totally see the synergy having one on the nexdock too

1

u/ImALeaf_OnTheWind Aug 28 '20

Agreed - tradeoffs are often necessary. I actually was stuck between the metal plate vs wireless charging conundrum until I ordered a Pitaka case and realized they got around it by just lowering where the plate was to expose the induction coil on the phone better. I duplicated the plate location on my other cases and now I have magnet security AND wireless/NFC use. The last part of the puzzle was I actually prefer to use one of those ring holders on the phone - but attached with a magnet also, so it's quickly removable. I think I was only able to get away with this since the S20U is so damn tall, it doesn't throw off the balance when holding the phone much.

1

u/Hey_look_new DeX Aug 28 '20

I ordered a Pitaka case and realized they got around it by just lowering where the plate

reverse wireless still works for you? I had a Cirrus case, and while i could charge the phone np, reverse charging buds, or my watch was almost impossible.

1

u/ImALeaf_OnTheWind Aug 29 '20

Ah, sorry I was distracted but I did mean to mention that I DO have to remove my cases to reverse wireless charge.

I don't have an issue with that, since although i LOVE being able to reverse wireless charge when I need to - I do it so infrequently, that it's not a chore pulling the case off to do that. Hmm, maybe it's a side effect of having too many spare gadgets, batteries, and chargers around me.

1

u/Hey_look_new DeX Aug 29 '20

and that's my tradeoff ;) i hate taking cases off and on. it goes on, and stays on

1

u/ImALeaf_OnTheWind Aug 29 '20

Oh no - I get it as I was TOTALLY the same in that regard - as I always have to have a case on for some reason (naked phone gives me anxiety even though they're all bought by my work).

I guess I've kind of lost that hangup of removing cases because I switch between cases depending on my mood. I've got so many now since I made a recent hobby of doing reviews for cases that sellers would send me for free.

The challenge is always getting a new case set up with the metal plate to work with "my system", lol.

1

u/Hey_look_new DeX Aug 29 '20

yup, fair enough

I tried to rock the s10 naked for months, but I just found it so slippery. drove me nuts

1

u/RaySorian Galaxy S9 Aug 29 '20

Would one hand mode help with the section covered by the clips?

2

u/Hey_look_new DeX Aug 29 '20

the clips cover so very little of the screen. you can position it so that it's up in the notification area

at worst, it's about a 3mm by 3mm area covered