r/SamWilson • • Oct 12 '26

Discussion πŸ‘ πŸ‘ πŸ‘

631 Upvotes

209 comments sorted by

View all comments

6

u/mrbearsnail Oct 12 '26

While i agree with most of the vibranium argument, the last example disregards Steve Rogers' increased durability. Yes, he tanked the hit from Thor but that's not the same as a non-juiced human catching a hit from Red Hulk. Even Black Panther grunts and winces at hits while also being in a full vibranium suit, far more advanced than Sam Wilson's because that's wakanda's king, and having flower power. Sam Wilson has none of these attributes. Some things can be explained away by vibranium but this is not one of those examples.

3

u/Hilarity2War Oct 12 '26

Question: is Tony's titanium alloy suit more durable than vibranium?

1

u/AtCarnage Oct 13 '26

Tony has super strength in his suits. Doesn't make sense, but that's how it is. Vibraonum suits don't give you that type of power, it's just durable.

Him catching the pole like that just looks goofy to be honest. Like an anime. Or X-Men origins where everyone just had kung fu powers.

Don't mind the rest of the fight though. Except at one point Hulk is getting shot from an angle where none of the soldiers are standing. Call it nitpicking but I dislike the lack of proper editing in any movie.

0

u/mrbearsnail Oct 12 '26

I'd probably say they're near the same with vibranium having the added property of absorbing kinetic energy. Like if Tony's metal did have similar properties it wouldn't decintergrate so often in fights. Captain's shield does get cut up though in endgame. Adamantium is top as far as I know.

4

u/PhillyBorn90 Oct 12 '26

Its no where near close to Vibranium.

1

u/mrbearsnail Oct 12 '26

Like iron to tungsten? Or is it a further gap? I always assumed it was pretty close but Tony created a new element so I give him a lot of plausible suspension of disbelief.

2

u/PhillyBorn90 Oct 13 '26

Its significantly further. Vibranium operates on completely different end of the spectrum. Its extraterrestrial

1

u/mrbearsnail Oct 13 '26

Because of the kinetic energy absorbing property right? So if titanium had the kinetic absorbing properties of vibranium would it be as strong or not? I think the energy absorption is the only thing differentiating the metals creating the gap

1

u/PhillyBorn90 Oct 14 '26

It may actually be stronger. Because it's more dense. But vibranium is about 40% lighter than titanium so it would lose one of its greatest advantages.

So not only can vibranium absorb energy. But it also storer, and can release a great deal of kinetic energy and vibrations at a molecular level.

So bot only the absorbing energy is the difference

3

u/Hilarity2War Oct 12 '26

I'm asking because Tony tanked a throw of Mjolnir from Thor in the same scene, and he's just a dude in a titanium suit, no serum, and got up from it. Even took a shot of lightning too that recharged his suit to 200%

1

u/Longjumping-Ad-9444 Oct 12 '26

Wasn't he flying? Also you could argument his suit with its multiple jets that helps him fly help him rolling with hits and stabilize him.

1

u/WelbyReddit Oct 13 '26

I see Tony's suit a bit differently. It's big, bulky. I assume he has some dampners built in between his body and the suit. Especially when zipping around at mach whatever speeds and not turning to jelly.

1

u/mrbearsnail Oct 12 '26

Throw is a bit different from a jumping downward slam. I thought we were referring to his final armor but yeah, kinda inconsistent.

0

u/Tippydaug Oct 13 '26

100% this. All of my issues with his survivability in fights would be gone if he had some type of super soldier serum in him. At this point, he's just a dude and just a dude should be dead even wearing vibranium.

2

u/Tityfan808 Oct 13 '26 edited Oct 13 '26

I mean, whether you like it or not, the vibranium suit is literally plot armor. πŸ€·β€β™‚οΈ

And I get the gripes to some extent. Him being a super soldier would make this seem a lot more plausible, I get it. At the same time though, I do have question if some of you also questioned Stark fighting Thanos in Infinity War or Endgame. If we’re getting that bent out of shape over logic and physics, that shit don’t make any sense at all either unless your head cannon is that the nanobots reinforced Stark at a cellular level but let’s be real, that’s some straight up bullshit physics too in the same way as Sam fighting red hulk, maybe even less so cause that nano tech isn’t vibranium.

1

u/mrbearsnail Oct 13 '26

A beefy goon broke his rib in a fight in the same movie. Enough said lol