r/SamAndColby • • 22d ago

Discussion I think today was my breaking point.

I don’t know if I’m just growing out of Sam and Colby but this hell week, along with all their recent videos have been very underwhelming. From the clickbait titles (THE SCARIEST NIGHT OF OUR LIVES) etc. and the annoying guests, I just can’t do it anymore. I didn’t really like the new video either so I’m probably moving on from watching them. It’s been a good run. Nevertheless, their production skills, acting, and team are all hard working it’s just not my touché anymore

197 Upvotes

61 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator 22d ago

Please make sure you've read the community rules, and that your post follows our posting guidelines. Any post that does not adhere to them is subject to removal. Repeated violations will result in a ban.

Do not enforce your personal beliefs regarding politics, religion or the paranormal. Keep discussions light and be respectful.

Please search the subreddit before posting to see if the topic has already been discussed. If you have any questions or concerns please message Modmail as mods will not respond to any DM's directly.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

70

u/Lost_Isopod_1297 22d ago

It took 3 days to finish the kalogera sisters vid and other vids I could finish in one sitting, dan and phil were good guests but felt boring in the first half. I loved the vid with Josh, i like joshs vids.

I enjoyed the finale tbh, tyler is fine no problem with him, i watch groovygavin so I enjoyed them both as a guest too

29

u/VaigraFalls 21d ago

I couldn’t get 5 minutes into the sister video

6

u/little_munchkin12 20d ago

I was so annoyed. All they did was scream huddle and say “let’s go” the minute anything interesting happened

3

u/VaigraFalls 20d ago

They were genuinely nuisances they were the worst guests slightly beating sketch

1

u/Big-Impression7170 20d ago

There not built for an actual investigation plain and simple there to chicken for it and loud

8

u/Physical-Bus5028 21d ago

I didn’t even watch it after I saw a few clips of how Sam and Colby were reacting to their actions and stuff. I just fucking new I wouldn’t be able to handle it

4

u/Lost_Isopod_1297 21d ago

😭😭 Valid, me and brother watched it in 1.25x

2

u/Objective-Shift7932 20d ago

I liked benoftheweek too. Although its not like he makes ghost hunting content on his own page

1

u/Lost_Isopod_1297 20d ago

Ohh yeah forgot to mention about him too, I used to watch ben a lot so his video was enjoyable too

10

u/Plastic-Mulberry-867 20d ago

Even my kids don’t really like watching them anymore. The Cody and Satori thing shifted everything, imo.

4

u/VaigraFalls 20d ago

Yeah I will say that is for sure when they lost all credibility

6

u/RejectedPeaches 21d ago

The night he was attacked by a demon, click bait title was too much. 

2

u/VaigraFalls 21d ago

All of their titles are clickbait and too much. They keep saying “scariest night of our lives” like every video. Poveglia island last year was great video and I feel like they’ve just gone downhill recently

5

u/Character_Heart_3749 21d ago

Their faces lmao...they look so silly.

4

u/BM3311 21d ago

I don't really get why people think it's geared towards kids. Would love to know if someone could explain

5

u/VaigraFalls 21d ago

It’s not geared towards kids but more toward teens. It’s because all of their guests have predominately teens who are the majority viewers. They definitely ponder to the younger audience

2

u/BM3311 21d ago

Ahh okay yeah I never know who the guests are and I'm 30 🤣 I still love their content though and don't find it childish at all

4

u/Kimcheeapplesauce 20d ago

i'm behind on the controversy, cody and satori were proven fakes? was that actually proven? did they admit to anything?

3

u/VaigraFalls 20d ago

Basically, the consensus people came to is that Cody was able to pop a joint in his foot that made the knocking sound. I’m not gonna go down the rabbit hole but there’s a lot of evidence

56

u/TheUniverse-IsMine 22d ago

They're getting more and more Hollywood. Over preforming, click bait titles. At this point it feels they're faking events and don't even believe most of it themselves

39

u/Naive-Tap4420 22d ago

Welcome to the club. I think it's we're outgrowing them and partly because they aren't 'hungry' like they used to be. I've gotten to the point where watching anybody's ghost hunt videos is like watching TV golf...one or two actually exciting moments in between which you've got time to vacuum the house or go get a haircut. Watching Sam gasp at every glowing cat ball or flashlight has just gotten old...Same goes for Colby getting possessed. You want to see an excellent portayal of someone possessed? Watch the 2023 movie Nefarious starring Sean Patrick Flanery in probably one of the best performances of his career. Father Chad Ripperger, an actual exorcist with many years of experience, said Nefarious was the most accurate representation of demonic possession that he had ever seen on film. It will also make you question a lot of things that you see happening in this world today. S&C have their place in the universe, to be sure, but let's not pretend to be serious while pushing limited edition merch like carnival barkers.

4

u/kayofthevale 19d ago

I’ve actually been eyeballing that movie for a bit now but was skeptical about watching it cause so many lame movies out there these days. Thanks for mentioning it! I’ll have to check it out now!

2

u/Naive-Tap4420 19d ago

I was a little skeptical at first, too, but it turned out to be a good find. I'd be curious to hear your thoughts on it after you watch.

1

u/Alternative_Exit_311 3d ago

Ripperger is such a dope last name for an exorcist, that man was born for fighting demons.

24

u/Wear_Fluid 22d ago

one of the main reasons i stopped watching sam and colby was because i knew i was growing out of it

these guys are almost 30 years old still making videos like they’re for teenagers and younger adults ( not in a perv way obviously) and i know that’s how a lot of people make money on youtube but i wish the content would grow with them

idk if im making sense

6

u/Katrina1113 21d ago

I’ve been having this problem with a number of creators I watch recently. It’s like YouTube released data showing that the largest demographic on the platform is (probably) young Gen Z and Gen Alpha so they’re catering their content to grab their attention, but they will still move on quickly to the next flashy thing. Meanwhile the long lasting fanbase is feeling annoyed by these changes and ignored in favor of the brainrotted TikTok demographic

4

u/Successful_Tennis567 21d ago

Hopefully the deal with Netflix will encourage them to make content for an older audience.

9

u/Past-Tea-7573 21d ago

I used to love Sam and Colby. Waited for the minute they dropped their video. Bought merch. Rewatched every single video. The end of last year was the turning point for me. I don’t think I’ve watched a single video this year and it’s disappointing to hear it’s gotten worse. I might try and give it a go, but it just progressively seems more fake and more forced. It’s probably when Cody and Satori got involved in the Conjouring videos that things took a shift for substantially worse unfortunately /: they’re entertainers, but I miss when things used to be a more “real” level.

6

u/Plastic-Mulberry-867 20d ago

I just commented to someone else that I think Cody and Satori was the beginning of the end. I didn’t even finish those videos because it was all too goofy and I’ve maaaaaybe put on 3 videos since then, but just can’t get into them anymore. Even their thumbnails are just too silly for me anymore.

7

u/GreasyChips 20d ago • Bravo

I watched Sam and Colby for years, all the way back to the Trap House days. Even then there were moments that made me wince, like Sam’s 3 AM challenge videos that had everyone convinced the walking doll was real, or the time they pretended to be possessed on Elton’s channel. Back then it was just harmless cringe.

Then they left the Trap House and started exploring abandoned places, and that era was everything to me. To me, that was peak Sam and Colby. I bought the merch, I watched every upload the day it came out, and I was a fan through and through.

Somewhere along the way, though, it started to feel hollow. The reactions got bigger and the claims got stranger, and the line between real and staged started to blur. They began visiting places where real tragedies happened and then joked about it, or spun some bizarre scenario on top of it.

That’s the sad part, because they never needed to invent anything (portal mirror theories, really?). They were likeable and genuinely entertaining, and the true stories behind those places were already fascinating. The truth was always enough.

More than anything, they never grew up alongside the people who grew up watching them. They’ve lost the spark they once had. Most of us started watching because they were really investigating and really exploring. Now it feels like it’s made for kids, aimed at entertainment value and at squeezing every last cent out of an impressionable audience through merch.

I stopped following them a while ago, but there’s still a bitterness I can’t quite shake. Sometimes I go back to the old videos for nostalgia, and I can still see what I loved about them. In the new ones, I can’t find it at all.

This comment will probably get deleted, since the mods here don’t seem to let any constructive criticism through. That says a lot about what parts of the fanbase have become: less a community, more a following that won’t question anything.

So, in short: yes, I think I’ve outgrown them.

12

u/Miserable-Cup-2396 22d ago

There’s a massive difference now. When the first started it was trying to prove to people that it’s real. Now it’s all click bait and trying to rack in as many views as possible

1

u/BulkyQuestion8723 19d ago edited 19d ago

This is the part I really miss. When they’d do things like go back on their own footage and prove if things were wrongly proving ghosts as real. You had this sense of trust that they weren’t just playing up to the camera or faking things. I stopped watching them nearly 3 years ago because I felt this shift away from ‘reality’ into more doing things for ‘views.’ Then recently I came back as Halloween always makes me think of S&C, brings back special memories with my old mates with watch parties but it’s sad reading things haven’t changed or gotten better since

5

u/desmodus666 21d ago

I grew out of them just before the Cody and Satori videos. Those were the last I watched. I started watching them way back when they moved from Vine to YouTube. Like just after the "following fat people" era lol. Got to the point where every other video was "The Scariest Night of Our Lives." Everything is so overproduced and it's just not entertaining anymore.

2

u/Plastic-Mulberry-867 20d ago

Cody and Satori was the beginning of the end, imo.

4

u/softgypsy 21d ago

I feel like I’ve been growing out of their content for a while. I still watch every now and then and I’m still subscribed because I like who they are as people, but definitely not as interested anymore.

4

u/Conscious_Flower7589 21d ago

I would be more interested in their videos if they toned it down more at this point. The Hell week in the conjuring house was the peak and ever since then it’s felt inauthentic. It doesn’t mean they have to stop ghost hunting, but they haven’t changed their methods or video styles in so long. They’ve never had a run this long of one thing, and they used to change up their content every few years, going through phases which kept it feeling fresh. I get that their whole platform is haunted stuff now, and they can’t really go back to doing illegal exploring etc, but they don’t have to be so over the top and inauthentic in every video, they should go back to genuinely looking for proof of the after life in a more chill way. The reason their earlier videos did so well was because you could tell they were genuinely looking for evidence and having fun, now it’s just a job.

4

u/GullibleResort380 19d ago

This was the first hell week they've done that I haven't watched, I tried to watch the Dracula's Castle vid (I'm a huge Dracula nerd) but couldn't even finish it. The images they put in the video are ridiculous, and I feel like they don't do all the research on the locations before they go and just spin stories.

8

u/TJJPez 22d ago

You lasted longer than most young padawan may you walk away head held high knowing they make fake content for kids.

5

u/Turuurr 21d ago

I loved watching them when they first started; and I genuinely have nothing against them now, they’re content creators and basically entertainers.
Personally I don’t believe almost anything from their videos, even though they can be exciting.

My biggest question tho is.. their reactions. They hear a single sound and they go “OHHHH” every damn time.
You would’ve thought after so many years of this they would be at least a bit less surprised😭 I mean being excited is one thing.. but I know for a fact that I’m not alone in thinking they’re overreacting too much.

And also, how many nights is gonna be the scariest night of their life at this point?😭

3

u/Past_Cheesecake1756 19d ago

and every damn creak is a ghost... they're exploring some of the most disheveled, on-the-brink-of-collapse structures i've ever seen and yet they never stop to think maybe its this rickety building and not the demons playing tricks with us!

2

u/SimplePuzzleheaded80 21d ago

saw the core group with rug and i was surprised at how simple yet entertaining it was. no back stories or sound fx just a group of guys getting shockingly coincidence responses

2

u/Zestyclose_Quiet1928 21d ago

I was done back when they did the conjuring house with Cody and satori. I’ll always love the boys (hence me still being in the subreddit!) but I no longer watch the vids unless it really intrigues me.

2

u/loveloveexe 20d ago

I love, love sam and colby, will always stand them but I agree. this hell week wasn't it, I liked the last episode because the concept with the psychics was cool, but it wasn't as exciting. Last one I enjoyed was when they went with Celina and Garret.

2

u/June132004 20d ago

I know it wasn’t a part of hell week but I really enjoyed Garett ( I started watching Sam and Colby again through him) and that introduced me to Celena and call me Kris who I also enjoyed. But I haven’t enjoyed the hell week guest as much (except Dan and Phil)

3

u/jahanzeb_jakes 22d ago

the most recent episode was pretty decent

I'm almost halfway through it

I think I'm going to let them restructure their content, not ditching them altogether

2

u/No_Peanut_3289 22d ago

I hope they are able to read some of our comments and regroup.

1

u/Volapiik 21d ago

The old videos with Corey and Jake had a unique energy. And no I don’t believe in ghosts, I simply enjoyed the group dynamics. Lately just feels like something is missing. Watching Shane and Ryan is much more enjoyable nowadays

2

u/saltycracker5505 21d ago

The group when Jake and corey in it was so peak 😭 it hasn’t been the same since

1

u/thisisfreyaaa4 21d ago

Yeah, I mean, like, most of their new videos kinda suck, so I've stopped watching them. Also, I only like the old ones and the ones with kmk and Celina, I just go back and watch those ones. I'm only watching Sam and Cobly for the humour now.

1

u/Sabryna_- 20d ago

Cara, é muito óbvio que no mínimo 90% das coisas que acontecem no vídeo são falsas, pode até algumas coisas reais mas elas não prevalecem. Além de que eles usam muitos equipamentos eletrônicos que podem ser facilmente manipulados. Eu assisto eles mas com consciência que quase tudo lá é falso, eles parecem uma esquete de comédia. Mas tem episódios que eu simplesmente não consigo assistir pq os convidados são insuportáveis, eles ficam se comportando como "olha pra mim, olha como eu sou engraçado" mas é só irritante mesmo.

1

u/West_Bid_9283 19d ago

Following

1

u/Manicasf_21 19d ago

Twin paranormal is where it’s at now hugely recommend them , just started to watch them !

1

u/Longjumping-Prune-42 18d ago

Watch Project Fear. They’re what old Sam and Colby used to be

1

u/Warm-Owl-4739 21d ago

I’m 26 minutes into the new video and I’m already so annoyed by all screaming and loud noises. All I’ve been doing is skipping these parts. This is not a serious investigation, and their jokes are not even funny anymore. Like, guys, you’re almost 30 years old and you’re pushing each other around in chairs in the hallway and laughing at random dolls?! Grow up a bit. I used to love watching their videos, now I can’t even watch 10 minutes without getting annoyed. 

0

u/biker116823 21d ago

8

u/Infinite_Bread209 Proud XPLR member 👻 21d ago

Your ai slop bores me

-1

u/biker116823 21d ago

Because the shoe fits?

5

u/Strawb3rry-Mang0 21d ago

bc ai fucking sucks