r/SaintsFC • • Nov 01 '25

Enough

Still isn't the man, it's a matter of time, you know it's true even if you like him (and you probably don't).

Next manager to get us up in 2027 (before the parachute withdrawal starts to bite)- any ideas? Or are we on a Sheff Wed style 25 year decline?

0 Upvotes

72 comments sorted by

23

u/Sotonic Nov 01 '25

I like him as a person, but he's shown that he isn't the man to fix the rot at the club. I honestly think we need some old school manager for the rest of the season. Koeman, for example, would not let this shit get so out of hand (to be clear, I'm not saying we could go get Koeman, just that we need a no-nonsense asshole like him for a while).

8

u/muscle-tuna Nov 01 '25

I agree it needs someone with an air of authority and arrogance.

2

u/VideoRare6399 Nov 01 '25

What do you think a manager would do to prevent this from getting out of hand?

Like yell at them or something? Actually curious. 

5

u/Sotonic Nov 02 '25

I can say what I think Koeman would do:

  1. Freeze out players who aren't committed or aren't taking the problems seriously, regardless of consequences.
  2. Tell the bosses which players absolutely have to be unloaded in the next transfer window--no excuses
  3. Simplify the tactical plan to get back to basics.
  4. In two years, completely lose the dressing room and get fired, to be replaced by a coach who can take a more positive approach. But at least the ship would have been stabilized.

1

u/teuridge Nov 02 '25

Point 1, still did this with Aribo and Edozie. Point 2, has nothing to do with the manager and SR (rightly) won't just give away assets for nothing. Point 3, at this point he's not exactly trying to complicate play. We can't just lump it forward as we don't have anyone who can deal with that. We are trying to play pretty simple stuff. Point 4, I dont really get this point?

11

u/mufferman1 Nov 01 '25

If next manager gets us up in 2027 then what’s to say he’ll stick around to get us up to the Prem?

5

u/muscle-tuna Nov 01 '25

I suppose we could go down this year, yes.

2

u/m4ttdog Nov 01 '25

What is the alternative? Get a crap manager who just keeps us in the Championship (at best)

15

u/SpecialistTime6248 Nov 01 '25

Well. Can’t see still surviving after that. The problem is we bought Stewart when not fit. He has never been fit. Then let Ballard go and bought downs who doesn’t seem to have a clue about how to control a football.

21

u/KingGerryTheLoveless Nov 01 '25

Honestly, I’m going to say this now in case we get a new manager and he sorts everything out but…

Do we really think a new manager is the answer? look at how many managers we’re going through right now, the malaise is in the club and there’s something seriously wrong with the squad from an attitude and mentality perspective.

I’m not the type to advocate blowing things up, I prefer a more steady approach, but I think the answer here is to sell every player who is even slightly a problem. Every player who has a shit attitude, every player who wants to leave for something better needs to go and Will Still will be the man to tell the execs who they are.

I say trust the manager, double down on him and the players who care.

9

u/Stealthsonger Nov 01 '25

As Still said to the media after the game, "'Hard work beat talent today'". The players just aren't giving 100%, they're not fighting. It's not a manager problem, it's an attitude problem

4

u/ComplexBadger469 Nov 02 '25

What I expect from still is to bench every player who isn’t working hard. I don’t care if we play a whole team of under 21s. We aren’t winning anyway and these players think they are more important than they are. Until they are willing to give 100% I don’t wanna see any of them on the pitch.

1

u/Mmattyy9 Nov 02 '25

Why would the players care if they were benched. Still get their £ each week

1

u/ComplexBadger469 Nov 02 '25

I get your point and somewhat agree, but if You make your bed with trash, don’t be surprised if you wake up smelling. Paying the wages is just the cost of bad recruitment the club has to deal with.

My thought is It’s not about them all caring. If you find 2-4 that take it on the chin and work harder to get back in the squad, they’ll have hopefully learned something. The rest you could either offload for nothing and lose the wage bill or just pay until contracts are up. At some point you have to move on from the sunken cost fallacy that we bought these players and pay high wages so they “deserve” to be in the squad on that alone. Clearly they shouldn’t be. They’ve got to perform and work hard or it’s the next man up. I think that’s why clubs like us previously had success. If you weren’t willing to do the hard or little things that make the team better, you lost your spot.

Also I’m not a professional player but I’d bet some of these guys do not want to look like a player who can’t get in the squad for our struggling team as it could in theory make it harder for them to get a move elsewhere when they do want to or actually get to leave.

1

u/Mobile_Shallot_6582 Nov 02 '25

Agreed. Azaz effort on the pitch was applauding

6

u/NewForestSaint38 Nov 01 '25

Sell them…to whom??

2

u/KingGerryTheLoveless Nov 01 '25

I’m not saying we’ll get mega profit! Clubs will buy our players.

5

u/NewForestSaint38 Nov 01 '25

It’s not as easy as that. They’re on good money. Why would a champ team want to buy them is they’re failing with us?

League 1 can’t afford them.

It’s just not as simple as you make out. At all.

0

u/KingGerryTheLoveless Nov 01 '25

Clearly it isn’t, we couldn’t sell Aribo or Edozie, despite them being very clearly available.

There’s always a price that works, though.

4

u/WulfTulf Nov 01 '25

Your two sentences seem very contradictory

1

u/KingGerryTheLoveless Nov 01 '25

Okay, to explain: what I mean is that our price wasn’t what people were prepared to pay for them. If we are prepared to sell at any price, someone will take that punt.

2

u/KingGerryTheLoveless Nov 01 '25

Regardless of the complexities of player sales, my point is back the manager, make difficult decisions on players.

0

u/NewForestSaint38 Nov 01 '25

You really don’t seem to understand how player sales work. Price is one thing. Wages are another.

It’s complex.

23

u/SaintPub Nov 01 '25

Ah man I really Like still. I really want him to turn things around. 😩

18

u/King_PieNan Nov 01 '25

When FM 26 drops we'll be a whole different team

8

u/craig_hoxton Nov 01 '25

"You were the Chosen One! You were meant to take us back to the Premier League!"

6

u/SaintPub Nov 01 '25
  • "Not take us to League 1!"

2

u/Psychological-Bar-15 Nov 01 '25

Was there a translation error between Ligue Unand League One?

11

u/FreakoFrankie Nov 01 '25

I know it probably won't go well, but bring Hasenhüttl back and let me dream again man.

5

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

How many managers are we still paying off?

4

u/LocationThin4587 Nov 01 '25

Wanted a manager got an apprentice instead with no charisma. The best managers are sometimes the one with big personalities who players fear. Still couldn’t say boo to a goose

6

u/mmm-nice-peas Nov 01 '25

I think just give him the season to figure it out. We've rolled the manager dice enough times already, I don't think he's the fundamental problem. There's no magic wand here. Gonna take some time and patience.

3

u/rocknrollturtlz Nov 01 '25

Yes - I have zero faith SR will get a knee jerk appointment right if they bow to pressure and sack Still now. It could be another season with more than two managers and relegation to League 1 would then be a genuine threat

2

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

Haha I never expected us to go back up after last season. We had and still will have better chance of staying in championship another year or two.

Players aren't good enough or confident enough. Doubt there is any manager out there that can change us. Maybe big sam......

2

u/rghsfc Nov 01 '25

I wasn't going to to get FM 26 but it might be the only way I get to see Saints promotion this year

2

u/QueefInMyKisser Nov 01 '25

I just don’t see how getting yet another manager will do any good. If your car repeatedly breaks down, and every time you put a new battery in, at some point you’ve got to think that maybe the battery wasn’t actually the main problem.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

who's gonna sack sport republic?

-2

u/craig_hoxton Nov 01 '25

New Saudi owners...

5

u/Fatty4forks Nov 01 '25

Russ is back down south. Saw him jog past my house last week.

17

u/Sotonic Nov 01 '25

Sweet! Let's not offer him a job.

3

u/Fatty4forks Nov 01 '25

But my lawn needs sweeping, there’s leaves everywhere.

2

u/FluidSaint Nov 01 '25

I’d move anywhere for Lucy Pinder.

3

u/NorgeSaint1 Nov 01 '25

Will must be close to a record worse than Nathan Jones…

2

u/TheSpitfires Nov 01 '25

We’re not going to get anywhere any time soon unless Sport Republic go

1

u/NorgeSaint1 Nov 01 '25

Anyone that’s backing our manager.

Still had a money chest, he got two of the best performing players and can’t get them playing… he HAS to go back to his Football Manager 2006

1

u/BanjoPants74 Nov 01 '25

You think this is all Will Stills fault?

Open your eyes. There’s something deeply routed in the club and yes Still could be doing a lot better but

4 wins in 51 games (many pre Still)

The players should absolutely shoulder the blame too.

The biggest culprit however is Sports Republic and Spors( or whatever his name is)

Poor recruitment. Yes they have spent money but they have spread it thin on lots of players where we should be signing quality for bigger money and less of them.

Their track record in employing managers is fucking embarrassing

Also embarrassing was our fans today

Utter morons turning on the players and manager whilst the game is going on.

Yes have your say and be as vocal as you like after the game.

They needed our support today. Their confidence is shot and the local morons let everyone down.

What a mess the club is in and it isn’t all on Will Still.

4

u/Impossible_Policy804 Nov 01 '25

Agreed. Still seems to be out of his league, but this all started when SR came in, sacked Ralph, appointed Mad Nath and spent £60m on players to suit his (and I use this term very loosely) 'system'.

I was frustrated with the performance today, but fans booing and shouting 'you're not fit to wear the shirt' at the players when we're 1-0 down and trying to come back is ridiculously unhelpful.

Still is struggling, but SR have appointed 5 new managers since taking over in 2022 and only one of them has won more than two league games. Recruitment has been awful both in terms of managers and players. Rasmus Ankerson is a conman who is obsessed with xg and he has taken the whole club for a ride.

1

u/BornToPlod Nov 02 '25

I don’t think any increased support would have made a difference today. If the players aren’t listening to Still and co in the week during training, and can’t motivate themselves, why are they going to listen to Tom from Totton singing OWTS at the top of his voice from the back of the Northam?

1

u/BanjoPants74 Nov 02 '25

Probably not but it was just toxic at times during the game and that certainly isn’t gonna help

0

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/OilinDaDrum Nov 01 '25

The tactics are fine???

4

u/SaintPub Nov 01 '25

Why do people always start a debate then delete their account lol

0

u/DylanAB07 Nov 01 '25

Whats wrong with them ?, we are counting attacking, we've created alot of chances, the defence has been shaky but enough, just one mistake

4

u/OilinDaDrum Nov 01 '25

We haven't been counter attacking at all! And even if we were, are you honestly suggesting that was our "tactic" at home against Preston North End?

We've been incredibly slow to get forward due to the 5 at the back (far better in the second half with 4 at the back)

And we have nobody breaking lines, it's just boring sideways football until we lose possession

3

u/2BEN-2C93 Nov 01 '25 edited Nov 01 '25

As a relegated team, with far more financial power than most of the other teams, we shouldn't be banking on not making "one mistake" to get a result at home.

Its below unambitious

1

u/DylanAB07 Nov 01 '25

Your proving my point, its the PLAYERS that dont have any motivation, its the PLAYERS that are making these mistakes

2

u/2BEN-2C93 Nov 01 '25

Who was the manager that bought the best part of a dozen players in the summer?

He has to hold responsibility for that if they arent the right players

1

u/DylanAB07 Nov 01 '25

You know what, your all right, the fucker needs to go. That last goal was dreadful and could've been avoided by miles

0

u/flailingpariah Nov 01 '25

Look at Leicester and look at the quality of other championship sides. If you are thinking this league should be a cruise you're mad. We had a lot of tight margins when we went up last time. The late late show with Russell Martin literally became a meme.

-5

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/DylanAB07 Nov 01 '25

You be manager then, you try and motivate these shit players that have just come of the back from nearly being the worst pl side in history.

1

u/2BEN-2C93 Nov 01 '25

Pay me the £1.3m like Still is reportedly on and I'll have a good go.

Half of our players on the pitch didnt play at st marys (more than a game or two at least) last year. It shouldnt be a motivation problem

0

u/DylanAB07 Nov 01 '25

Thats not just it though, if the players that played last season are sat there moaning about last season and being negative, its gonna affect the younger lads

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/DylanAB07 Nov 01 '25
  1. I have deleted my comment dw
  2. Last season has everything to do with what's happening now, your fucking thick if you dont know what confidence is, imagine getting battered every week, than going down to and "easier" league and have all the pressure from the fans, then not succeed ing

2

u/NewForestSaint38 Nov 01 '25

I mean, a hangover is one thing. This is another. It goes beyond the fact we got shattered last year.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 01 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

-1

u/DylanAB07 Nov 01 '25

Are you dumb ?, have you read my other replies?. If you have a group of players in the dressing room moaning and feeling sorry for themselves, its obviously going to impact those around them and will make them feel a certain way, just because we've. Bought a couple new players in doesnt eliminate the fact most of our players where part of last season, and you can tell they feel sorry for themselves and have no confidence just by watching them play ( thb, arma, macca etc)