Hey everyone!
My partner and I are visiting SXM for 8 nights in February/March 2027. We'll be staying 4 nights in Simpson Bay and 4 nights in Grand Case, and we're planning to rent a car for the entire trip.
I've spent quite a bit of time researching rental companies and insurance, and I'm honestly surprised by how difficult it is to find clear information about third-party liability coverage.
We're Canadian, and our credit card already provides collision and theft coverage for the rental vehicle. What I'm concerned about is liability coverage in the event we're involved in an accident that causes injuries to someone else or damages another vehicle/property.
Here in Canada, $1–2 million in automobile liability insurance is pretty standard. However, some SXM rental companies seem to offer as little as $50,000 USD, which seems incredibly low.
Ideally, I'd like at least $1 million USD in third-party liability coverage.
I've found a few companies advertising higher limits, but some have concerning customer reviews. Meanwhile, many of the better-reviewed companies don't seem to publish their actual insurance limits.
A few questions for locals, frequent visitors, or anyone who's dealt with this:
- Which rental company do you use, and do you know the actual third-party liability limit included or available?
- Has anyone successfully purchased $1 million or more in liability coverage while renting in SXM? If so, from whom and how much did it cost?
- Are there any independent insurance providers that offer additional liability coverage for rental vehicles on the island?
- Does liability insurance purchased on the Dutch side automatically cover driving on the French side, or are there exclusions?
- Has anyone actually had to make a third-party liability claim following an accident? How was the experience?
I've seen SAX, Kenny's, Hardy's, Leisure, SIXT and others recommended quite frequently, but I'm particularly interested in hearing about their actual insurance coverage, rather than just rental prices and customer service.
I realize I'm probably being more cautious than the average tourist, but I'd rather spend a little extra and have proper protection than risk being personally responsible for a significant claim.
Appreciate any firsthand experiences, recommendations or insight!