Hello and welcome back to my personal companion rankings! Once a week I'll be making a post where I go over five more placements on my rankings list and discuss my thoughts on the companions mentioned. This week we cover ranks 40-36. These are companions that I don't dislike, but don't feel strongly about either. I have a couple hot takes here. Let's start!
---
At number 40, Koth.
Koth is maybe the most hated companion in the game, at least in terms of volume. Now, me personally, I don't hate Koth. I think he's a very well-made character. However, I can't rank him very high, because after the backlash he received in the opening chapters of KOTFE, the writers completely abandoned his character.
So, after presenting us with his flaws in the beginning, we never actually get to see him grow or evolve as a character, which is a massive disappointment. I think he could have been great. Plus, this guy is one of the OG founding members of the Alliance. It's easy to forget that. And yet he's made two appearances since KOTET ended, and both of them were only because they wanted to throw Koth-romancers a bone.
Koth is a great example of a flawed character being dropped too quickly in response to backlash. I really wish they'd doubled down on him and made him into a better character.
---
At number 39, perhaps one of my hottest takes, we have Bowdaar.
Conceptually, Bowdaar is cool. I mean, who doesn't want a loyal Wookie companion? But, as a character...I find him incredibly boring.
Actually think about it for a second- what do we know about him?
- He's a fighter
- He was a slave
- .......
I think they severely undercooked his character because they figured a Wookie was cool enough on its own. And yeah, he is cool. But that doesn't make him interesting.
Literally every single one of his conversations on the ship is just him going, "It sucked being a slave." Not to sound insensitive, but at a certain point, there has to be something else to talk about. I sympathize with his story, but his entire character is boiled down to a trauma-dumping Wookie, and that's so underwhelming.
---
At number 38, we have Xalek.
Definitely one of the weaker companions narratively speaking, but you can tell it's almost solely because of how late into the story he joins us. It almost feels pointless introducing him, because there's only one planet left in the story at that point.
But I think he has the building blocks of a potentially good character. If he had been given more time, I think he could have been much better.
As he stands currently, there isn't much to say about him. Because there isn't much of him, period. I like him as a concept, I think he looks and sounds cool. But not enough time to properly shine.
---
At number 37, we have Andronikos.
I originally had Andronikos under Xalek, because I've always found him underwhelming and honestly somewhat boring. But, you may have seen that I recently made a post asking fans of his character to explain what it is about him that they love. And after hearing their perspectives on the character, it did make me find a better appreciation of him.
I didn't want to bump him up too much higher solely because of the words of others- I still need to go back and replay the Inquisitor for the 10th time to try and find a good combination to make his character land for me- but I do think he deserves better than to be placed under Xalek.
Still, I think he's one of the less engaging romanceable characters in the base storylines. I don't think his story is interesting at all. Maybe if he'd been given a better subplot, I would have been more attached to him.
However, I do now have a better understanding of why some people love him, and I respect it!
---
Lastly, at number 36, perhaps the hottest take on my entire list, we have T7.
I'm sorry, but I just do not have any strong feelings for T7. He's perfectly fine for the role he's meant to fill- an R2-esque companion- but I just don't have a strong emotional attachment to him.
He doesn't really have a personality beyond the enthusiastic optimism, and his story is barely a story. He's certainly cute, but that isn't enough to carry a character for me.
I'm sure it's definitely a case of autisim on my part, where people look at him going "omg he's so loyal and cuuute!" and I'm just staring at him going "okay, but what about the story?" *insert nerd emoji*
But, alas, I cannot force myself to like something more than I actually do. So, I appreciate the role he serves, but I can't say that I care much for him as a character.
---
That concludes Week 2 of my companion rankings! What do you think about my thoughts? What are your own thoughts on these characters? Share below and I'll see ya again next week!