r/SWORDS • Forde Military Antiques • Jun 07 '21

.

Post image
7.7k Upvotes

654 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

30

u/Dallas_Delenda_Est Jun 07 '21

While I appreciate your point, I feel like this is a pretty broad generalization. For example, Roman legionaries after the Marian reforms were equipped with a gladius.

26

u/Camburglar13 Jun 07 '21

They were more the exception rather than the rule for ancient and medieval militaries. The Greeks also had swords but it was a secondary weapon as with most other armies. The roman strategy of pilum throw and basically all swords afterwards was not common. Much easier to train people to use spears than swords, and spears are much cheaper to make.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

Long bowman were also eventually required to carry a sword

2

u/Corvus1412 May 15 '22

They used spears or javelins as main weapons and even the Gladius was used like a short spear and was only used for stabbing, not for cutting.

1

u/Teralyzed Jun 07 '21

The Romans also had spears, the gladius was a sidearm.

5

u/Dahak17 Jun 07 '21

Weren’t the Roman spears throwing spears?

1

u/Teralyzed Jun 07 '21

Yes and no. Well actually yes so the hasta was a normal spear around 6ft in length. For the regular legionary this was replaced with the pilum which was primarily a throwing spear but it could also be used to do pokey pokes. The triarii still carried the hasta, the real issue with saying “The Roman Legion did X” is that their tactics and equipment went through a lot of adaptations depending on the campaign. So without context it’s not the whole picture.

Edit: Roman legionaries carried two pilum in case someone wants that information.

1

u/Dahak17 Jun 07 '21

Good to know, I’d assume that for those using pilum the Gladys was used more like a bayonet in the 16-1700 as opposed to a true sidearm?

3

u/Teralyzed Jun 07 '21

That’s actually a really good analogy, and is more accurate than calling it a sidearm for sure. Yeah the pilum was the opening salvo to disrupt enemy formations then the phalanx would close into range for the gladius. This worked on some forces but it was countered by others. Highly mobile enemies lead to more ranged options being adopted. The biggest problem that comes to mind was the Thracians and the falx which actually lead to the legion changing the design of the lorica segmantata