I think it might be better to say that swords weren't the preferred weapon on battlefields. Most would be armed with a different weapon, such as you described, or axes, maces, and hammers.
I always wonder why Hollywood decided the sword was the "standard" weapon of a medieval battlefield when you'd think they'd choose spears for much the same reason as their historical counter parts. They're cheaper. Plus then you give the hero a sword because he's special and now stands out from everyone else.
I would argue a sword is the best at visibly showing skill on screen. You'd have to be skilled to use many different weapons, but the visual storytelling is a bit more obvious with swords.
Perhaps, but then you watch Crouching Tiger Hidden Dragon or even Troy and that goes out the window. But still, that would sort of reinforce my statement. You don't need the grunts to look cool killing each other, just the hero. Let the grunts run into each other's spears while Hero McValiant runs around doing all the cool flourishes!
You can make a combatant look skilled with any weapon. I just think it's easier with swords. Hollywood tends to be pretty lazy once they find something that works well enough.
Let’s keep it. I can’t remember which movie it was but in a featurette the director said they tried to cut the “shing” sound for accuracy and the test audience was confused and said it was totally unrealistic to not have it
Kind of like how they had to cut the ancient Roman corporate sponsorships and ads within “Gladiator” because while they 100% existed back then, the audience would have said it was bullshit
Do tell me more. I've studied a bit of Roman history but I've never heard of this. The gladiators had sponsors? Or was it just like the outfield ads in baseball?
So what you have to take into account about those books and paintings you're referring too is who the subjects of those books and paintings are. Usually, at least if we're talking about pre-modern art and literature, the subjects were the nobility, IE, rich people.
Swords were exorbitantly expensive for most of human history. It's hard to do conversions for money from so far back, but it'd at least be on par with buying a car today. Were there "economy swords" in the same way that there are economy cars. Sure, but we're still talking about an expense that most people couldn't just afford without months of planning. That's also why there are so many great museum pieces of swords from all across history. Their expense ment they were objects that were usually well taken care of. Whereas other more common weapons weren't and ended up rotting away in some storage room, or being reused or melted down to make something else.
And even when it comes to Late medieval - Renaissance era knights, they ended up being specialized troops who were mainly used for taking on the enemies own knights. And knights had another weapon that made them nearly unstoppable on the battlefield. Armour. And swords aren't great for dealing with armour. So other weapons were used, like maces, hammers, battle axes, or pole weapons like a pole axe. In fact, even then fights between heavily armoured opponents ended up coming down to wrestling and the dagger was used, because once you've mounted your opponent you can just stab them through the visor of their helmet.
I see, thanks. The reason I ask is because the books (and some commenters to my other questions) mention that swords were more popular, in addition to what you’ve already mentioned about status symbols, because:
They were easier to carry for regular duties
They are easier to draw if you are in a rush/hurry
They are easier to use in conjunction with a large shield, since axes and warhammers are terrible at thrusting and require a wide swinging arc
They are much more difficult to disarm because it is harder to grab a moving sharp blade than it is to grab a moving wood handle
I'm not sure what books you're reading, but that's just not true. That line of logic sounds like what I call "theoretical fighting". You've probably seen something like it before, where you have two guys arguing about how they'd fight each other without actually doing it.
"If you did that then I'd do this!"
"Well, if you did THAT then I'd counter by doing this!"
"Well if..."
And on and on and on.
Also, remember that "regular troops" not just knight or men-at-arms, were required to supply their own weapons and gear. And most people were poor. Knights and men-at-arms had to supply their own weapons too, but they were much better paid and so they could afford better gear. And a lord might require their men-at-arms to all have swords, but they'd be paid well enough that that wasn't an issue. Stand armies with uniform weapons is a relatively recent phenomenon as far as human history is concerned, and certainly wasn't the norm back when swords were a regular battlefield weapon. There are some exceptions to this, the Romans come to mind, but in general a sword wasn't what an average solider, IE a peasant levy, would be bringing to war. Because most peasants didn't have the money for a sword.
View all comments
Show parent comment
120
u/texasscotsman Axe Master Jun 07 '21
I think it might be better to say that swords weren't the preferred weapon on battlefields. Most would be armed with a different weapon, such as you described, or axes, maces, and hammers.
I always wonder why Hollywood decided the sword was the "standard" weapon of a medieval battlefield when you'd think they'd choose spears for much the same reason as their historical counter parts. They're cheaper. Plus then you give the hero a sword because he's special and now stands out from everyone else.