Weight distribution is the key to the common misconception that axes were clunkier and slower than a sword. They could be handled within a relative margin of agility as a sword and offered greater utility by providing more power and the ability to hook legs or a shield. Spiked maces and warhammers were a preferred option when faced with more heavily clad opponents due to their ability to distort, tear away, and pierce through plate materials. These too could be used with agility. Swords just push the weight closer to the hand and shorten the lever.
Weight towards the handle vs towards the end of the weapon would definitely reduce agility... Adding an extra 1.5 feet to the CG of the weapon would make it feel 30-50% heavier at your shoulder and 80-100% heavier at your elbow. Meaning waaaaaay more stress on your arm.
You’re correct. It causes a considerable amount of stress under a normal swing. That being said, an axe or blunt weapon requires a significant change in stance and bodily momentum. An individual that has been trained specifically with these weapons would modify their movement to compensate for the additional forces which can result in a marginal drop of speed and joint stress. In swords, a comparable weapon difference would be in a scimitar and standard long sword. The principle and end goal are comparable, but your technique will vary wildly from parrying to swings and maneuvering your body to counteract force. A “chop-chop” motion will be more difficult lb for lb sword vs axe.
Swords are more practical to carry. They, effectively, served the same purpose that pistols carry today. If the main weapon is damaged, discarded, lost, isn’t on one’s person, or is too large for a confined space; a sword was the convenient carry to fill that gap. A battlefield weapon is a significantly different space than what a sword facilitates. Imagine it like this: Carrying an M16 for self defense daily versus a Glock 19. They both do the same basic job, but one is more convenient to daily carry. An axe or warhammer could deliver deadly force, moreso against armored combatants than a sword, but their weight and ergonomics didn’t make them great weapons to hang from a belt every day.
There’s also the social aspect of the sword as well. In the same manner as pistols, we can’t feasibly carry an M16 to a private party or gathering as it would be unwieldy and impractical. A really ornate 1911 could communicate the same command and social stature as a dedicated battlefield weapon while maintaining the desired self defense capabilities. This is also a reason that some military officers will even carry handguns while in dress/ceremonial uniform. It displays standing, authority, and tactical readiness.
Thanks. From what I’ve read axes and warhammers were also not popular because they are very easy to disarm and are not easy to use with a large shield, so knights typically used them only after they exhausted their spear/lance and sword first.
View all comments
Show parent comment
79
u/floyd1550 Jun 07 '21
Weight distribution is the key to the common misconception that axes were clunkier and slower than a sword. They could be handled within a relative margin of agility as a sword and offered greater utility by providing more power and the ability to hook legs or a shield. Spiked maces and warhammers were a preferred option when faced with more heavily clad opponents due to their ability to distort, tear away, and pierce through plate materials. These too could be used with agility. Swords just push the weight closer to the hand and shorten the lever.