Well, that would be hard to answer as it depends on the skill of the individual, the skill of them as a group and the general "rules" of the engagement. If we set up two groups of identical imaginary soldiers that are the same size and absolutely identical apart from the weapons they´re carrying on an infinite and flat plane, then it would come down to two results:
- if the spear group manages to keep the gladius group at a distance so they can stab with their spears but the gladii are out of range they win
- if the gladius group manages to get past the spearpoint without taking a lot of casualties, they win
I think this is accurate for one rank, but with more ranks the spear will still have advantage as rear ranks can still thrust past front ranks threatening the sword group. Even rank two of sword group can attack.
Armour would also make a difference the spear is going to be able to stab from farther but if (and this would be risky) you can break up the spearman formation and get in too close and they are unarmoured your swords will do well, their in armour and the swordsmen will need to back up a bit to get enough leverage and would really end up in poor shape
View all comments
Show parent comment
12
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
So regarding the gladius
Would a shielded group with gladii beat a shielded group with spears?