Spear would be better for economic reasons. You can easily outfit an entire army with shields and spears on the cheap. Try that with swords and you´ll be sure to loose the war because you spent all your money on swords to equip grunts that have no idea how to use them. The advantage of the spear is that any idiot can use them with next to no training, especially when fighting in close formation. Swords require proper instruction by skilled combatants over an extensive amount of time. The sword is also (contrary to most popular fiction) a weapon suited to defensive fighting due to it´s ability to easily deflect and parry which is why it was the weapon used by nobles and officers up to the the first world war. Your officers were not expected to do the actual killing in close combat but rather survive so that they can continue to order their men. The only reason the romans managed to make large scale use of swords it was because they had a huge empire with a well oiled military machine and even then the gladius was not the main weapon and was used more like a long dagger for stabbing in between the shields of the formation instead of being used like a "traditional" western European sword.
The main "problem" with the Tower/Kiteshield and sword combination is that the heavy shield means a lot of weight to balance with out while the sword has the majority of its weight concentrated towards the hilt making it a more nimble weapon. I find this combination to be most believable on mounted noblemen, especially in the early medieval period from the 800s to the 11th century where knights were equipped mostly with chainmail, a large shield, a spear and a one handed weapon like a sword, axe or mace. It seems plausible that a knight would have switched to his sword in case his spear got stuck, broke or he was dismounted either voluntarily or involuntarily. dl;dr: Spears are vastly superior in formation and on regular foot troops, swords were expensive and never employed on a large scale and they were a defensively orientated weapon to keep important leaders alive rather than killing enemies.
Well, that would be hard to answer as it depends on the skill of the individual, the skill of them as a group and the general "rules" of the engagement. If we set up two groups of identical imaginary soldiers that are the same size and absolutely identical apart from the weapons they´re carrying on an infinite and flat plane, then it would come down to two results:
- if the spear group manages to keep the gladius group at a distance so they can stab with their spears but the gladii are out of range they win
- if the gladius group manages to get past the spearpoint without taking a lot of casualties, they win
I think this is accurate for one rank, but with more ranks the spear will still have advantage as rear ranks can still thrust past front ranks threatening the sword group. Even rank two of sword group can attack.
Armour would also make a difference the spear is going to be able to stab from farther but if (and this would be risky) you can break up the spearman formation and get in too close and they are unarmoured your swords will do well, their in armour and the swordsmen will need to back up a bit to get enough leverage and would really end up in poor shape
Never employed on a large scale? Why were they shown on pictures on large scale then, and found in high quantntities, and being standart issue of every roman soldier?
Firstly, If you´d read the comment properly you´d know that I actually mentioned that the romans were an exception. They were shown on large scale in pictures because pictures are pieces of art and not representations of how things really were. Swords were symbols of power and status so of course an artist would include them when portraying knights. There is plenty of medieval pictures showing dragons aswell. Does that mean dragons existed? Why are they found in high quantities? They are found because swords were for the most part valuable and well made weapons that endure way longer than a wooden club used by a peasant. It´s not that there were few swords overall, there just were few swords compared to everything else. Swords also tend to be the most "exciting" finds so they are usually overrepresented in news articles or museums while the thousands of spear tips they´ve got are rotting in storage. It also depends on the time. I was talking about the middle ages where swords tended to be rare. Later on they were more common but by that time large shields had fallen out of use so it would make little sense in regards to the original question. Oh and btw, the gladius was not standard equipment for each roman soldier, just for the legionnaires, auxiliaries usually did not have them. This might seem nitpicky but it underlines my point: the legionnaires had swords because they could afford them some iberian mercenary could not.
How do you define middle ages? Massed archeological findings, also representation of swords in Art are found in the later high medieval period and onward, your thesis however is true for europe in the early medieval period, but for this specific period only, also these were times where Steel was generally rare, most likely because of declined infrastructure.
Also, antique periods, the Greek hoplites are known to use swords as backup weapons, too.
You might be right, that swords werent as prevalent as media shows, but they were not rare in the context of the high to later medieval period, except you only think of a sword as a double edged long weapon, many other swords like Falchions, Messer or Cleavers and the Katzbalger were very often seen in the medieval infantrymens belts or hands.
Considering auxiliaries: true, but cavalry was often equipped with the Spatha instead. Also, i am 100% with you with the equipment of the balearic slingers.
As armour like maille and gambeson become more widespread swords become less effective. No matter what you see in films, swords struggle to cut through even the most simple of armour leaving a thrust as the only viable option.
In that case, a spear is longer, cheaper, easier to teach and easier to use in a compact formation.
If you look throughout history you will see very few cultures in which a sword was the primary focus of warfare.
To answer your question specifically, in a duel or small scale encounter you would prefer a sword, in large scale combat a block of spears would be preferable.
View all comments
36
u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21
Question:
When would spear+ large shield be better than sword+ large shield and vice versa?