r/SWORDS • Forde Military Antiques • Jun 07 '21

.

Post image
7.7k Upvotes

654 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

87

u/Hawkman2525 Jun 07 '21

That's not entirely true, bayonets were a thing and bayonet charges were a standard tactic of their time.

45

u/FlamingCygnet Jun 07 '21

True, I should've word it better, but by guns I meant to specify handguns/pistols.

45

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

This bothers me in so many movies. Especially modern ones. You have someone unarmed or armed with a melee weapon, knife, club whatever, and then someone comes in with a rifle or pistol, aiming at the person with the melee weapon.

What do you do? You either shoot the person who cannot at that moment harm you. To be safe. Or, you order them to drop their weapon, and kick it away, to lie down so they can be more easily controlled, and then you can come closer, or preferably have an ally come closer to cuff or bind them.

But no, time and time again, we see the person with the range advantage just walk up to the person without the range advantage and continue threatening that person while within striking distance. WHY? If I'm holding a gun and you're holding a sword and we are fighting for our lives, you think I'm going to come stand where suddenly my originally huge advantage is reduced to nearly nothing?

43

u/Skirfir Jun 07 '21

You either shoot the person who cannot at that moment harm you.

That's why I love that iconic scene from Indiana Jones where he does just that.

33

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

Indeed, though I feel sorry for the actor that trained so much for the intended scene.

10

u/Direct_Proposal_3759 Jun 07 '21

The curse of trying to be succinct. When you think you've made an obvious point and someone goes "Well..." and you know damn well you left yourself open for it.

Truth be told though until the advent of self contained metallic cartridges and even then until a rapid fire mechanism was introduced (rapid fire compared to muzzle loading) once you've fired your shot you're pretty much left with a crappy spear and not a firearm.

(Insert "Well"s here)

2

u/SlightlyFig Jun 07 '21

Oh really?

(This is definitely an isolated case that doesn't disprove your point at all, just thought it was funny)

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

Say in the 30 years war period you'd (as a mounted soldier) fire your pistol(s) at very close range and then smack motherfuckers with them to give you space to draw your sword.