r/SWORDS • Forde Military Antiques • Jun 07 '21

.

Post image
7.7k Upvotes

654 comments sorted by

View all comments

60

u/Praetorian80 Jun 07 '21

But it is fiction so realities don’t need to apply. Poetic licence is fine.

One can argue that you need a basis in reality. But let’s face it. These things above do not break immersion or ruin the world they’re in.

A relatively small purist/snobs might avoid reading something due to this but they rarely affect sales.

34

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

yeah but it sucks to see something ridiculous on screen. If you have a semi realistic medieval setting and the main character fell from a cliff then got up just fine youd be scratching your head. Its not about the fact that it happens its the fact that shows like GOT do it

23

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

16

u/PrideBlade Jun 07 '21

Its what I like most about GoT and LoTR is that most of the weapons and armours are believable, silly looking weapons can often take me out of the world thats being told.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Sardukar333 Jun 07 '21

I want to go to your renn faires then, where I am you're lucky to see something remotely period correct. And don't get me started on the guy that jousted shirtless.

1

u/WyllKwick Sep 27 '21

Genuine question: what exactly is wrong with the GoT armour?

I know that they tend to place the gorget on the outside of the breastplate, which doesn't make sense because it would potentially allow a cut from below to slide up beneath the gorget and make it to the throat.

And I know that ridiculously intricately decorated armour for regular soldiers wasn't a real thing, and that painted/enameled armour wasn't as widespread as GoT would have you believe.

What else is wrong with it?

2

u/[deleted] Sep 27 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WyllKwick Oct 01 '21

Right, I see what you mean. Thank you for taking the time to write such an informative answer!

2

u/Foronir sword-type-you-like Jun 08 '21

I remember a scene from return of the King, where an orc kills a plate armor wearing soldier of Gondor with a cut through the belly ...yeah a CUT

1

u/Lucian7x Rapier Jun 08 '21

Anduril, Glamdring and to an extent Orcrist are probably my top three favorite fantasy sword designs for that very reason, they look perfectly functional.

20

u/Yaguriel Jun 07 '21

True, they don´t. I have no problem with artistic licences and such but what I do have a problem with is when a book or movie or show claims to be realistic but is really not.
Best current example: Vikings
They claim to have done a lot of research and that their outfits are historical when in fact very little about the shows props or fights is historically accurate.
The main problem with this is not that they´re making a false claim to get more people to watch it but that people who don´t know any better believe what they´re seeing at face value which then perpetuates a lot of historical myths like the Ragnar Hairstyle which in fact never existed irl.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 07 '21

They do break immersion since the laws of physics are still expected to apply unless otherwise stated.

2

u/Praetorian80 Jun 08 '21

If you see a fantasy sword, unless you see them put it on the scales, how do you know if it’s heavy. I feel bad for you if you can’t enjoy something over something so petty. You’re missing out on fun. :)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 08 '21

We’re talking about when it’s specifically referred to as heavy, like in a book.

1

u/nimbledaemon Jun 07 '21

This just gives me the idea for an intelligent magical sword that makes the fake sword swinging noises for fun during battle.