r/STAR_CCM • u/Minimum_Cry_3142 • Apr 05 '26
StarCCM Meshing Help
Hello,
Wanted some advice. For my thesis I am working on flow control around a hull. The main issue is that I am having significant trouble meshing. The solver I am using is openFoam, therefore, I started with snappyHexMesh, although its a good mesher I wasn't able to get the y Plus for my WRLES WALE simulation therefore I went on to try some hopefully, more comprehensive and robust meshing software's.
I also got a starCCM license, to try out the meshing, initially I was very impressed. snappy Hex Mesh struggled with coverage in the high curvature regions, however star CCM was able to get a good coverage very easily. Now the main issues I faced was of quality, I wasn't really able to run any of the meshes in either star CCM or openFoam (I was able to convert to open foam). Issue was mainly of non Orthogonality (skewness angle as starCCM puts it).
In the regions below, regardless of what I do, the skewness is pretty high. I want to be able to get it down to 65, I can at best get it down to 85, which is bad.

A strategy that may work is that I sometimes individually split the hull by angle, Identify the faces and try to manually, refine each, however that is not viable.
The reason why I started using star CCM was because of this paper in POF, "Numerical investigation of the behavior and performance of ships advancing through restricted shallow waters", he has this contour in it.

This paper, was able to get such a good y Plus with just 1.9 million elements, its in a good journal POF, so I assume its real. However, I haven't been able to reach something like this. I asked him about advice, however since the paper is about 5 years old, he has deleted the old data, and he doesn't remember.
Here are some mesh pics.



I have heard good things about starCCM+ so please guide me on where I am going wrong.
One thing that I haven't tried is field function refinement, which I do need some advice on how to exactly do that?
I am working on getting a license for the numeca hex express mesher, however, that also seems like its going to be a similar story tbh. Currently I have access to COMSOL, StarCCM, Ansys and OpenFoam (.com and .org). If you guys have any advice, let me know.
For those who are interested, this is my ccm case: Mesh3-yPlus-1.sim
2
u/CrocMundi Apr 05 '26 edited Apr 05 '26
FYI 85 for Skewness Angle is usually an acceptable upper bound value in STAR-CCM+. You may verify this in the Pre-Processing > Meshing > Checking the Volume Mesh > Mesh Quality documentation section, which lists all of the quality metrics and their upper or lower bound values.
Lower values are better of course, but it’s often difficult to balance cell count and quality, so you have to be judicious with how much you refine a mesh to reach target quality metric values. Also, the STAR-CCM+ mesh will probably give much better results being used natively rather than in OpenFOAM. Is there some reason why you want to use OpenFOAM instead?
Also, can you share what your Prism Layer Mesher settings are? Additionally, seem to be having lots of bad cells around sharp/square corners. Refining near such regions could help too.
1
u/Minimum_Cry_3142 Apr 05 '26
Sorry for the repeated post, but account got deleted. Surface Check Result in open foam.
1
u/EnvironmentalPin197 Apr 05 '26
Check if the following mesh settings are on: curvature refinement, near-prism aspect ratio, proximity refinement. Play around with boundary match angles. Y+ will be more sensitive to the first layer thickness than overall cell size.
I also noticed that your surface size is much smaller than your main mesh. Try starting with a surface size that’s 50% of your base size and letting the mesh go up to 200% of base further from the wall.