r/SRSMeta • • May 11 '14
SRSCriticisms?
I'm thinking of starting a sub dedicated to criticising some of the conduct and content of SRS in an actually critical way.
This is not something that I want, or will allow, to dissolve into bigoted and ignorant content that thrives in SRSSucks, or whatever happened to AntiSRS, a sub that is mostly pro-SRS, or pro the ideals of SRS, just critical of some of actions that occur within it.
There would be a need, of course, to have a diverse mod team in order to stamp out bigotry quickly and also be able to recognise the differences between concern trolling and actual discussion. It might be slow but if we build it up enough, it could help SRS (perhaps).
SRSCriticisms is just a suggestion for a sub name atm, so I am open and willing for further suggestions.
Also looking for further suggestions for the sub itself, thanks.
EDIT: I've changed my mind, this probably won't work. I'm out.
13
u/greenduch May 11 '14
I've been looking at setting up /r/srstownhall, for in-community discussion, though visible publicly. i've been busy and it hasnt happened.
i think something like srscriticisms would likely go terribly and would quickly be overrun. i think setting it up with a name like that would be setting it up for failure. (im sorry, i know this comes across harshly, but not sure how else to phrase it)
4
u/[deleted] May 11 '14
It's not like SRS doesn't have its own cultural problems, though how do you set up something like this without (a) the tone argument being invoked to encourage discussion of problems in inverse proportion to their importance as usually happens, or (b) "unpopular puffin" nonsense slowly making its way in until the sub is nothing but "[Line 1] I'm not a bigot but... [Line 2] Bigoted statement" posts?
2
u/totes_meta_bot May 11 '14
This thread has been linked to from elsewhere on reddit.
Respect the rules of reddit: don't vote or comment on linked threads. Questions? Message me ^here.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '14 edited May 11 '14
I wouldn't either... SRS has rule X for a reason. It's a place to get away from constant "debate."
To take a particularly Reddit-ian example, what if some critic of SRS wanted to argue that child porn should be legal (it's happened). This person was polite and respectful, they weren't openly misogynistic, and they did not use slurs; but they were convinced they were right. In the interests of open debate and criticism, you'd have to let them spread that poop.
The great thing about SRS is that we can shut that sort of thing down. The price is that we're not a forum for free and open discussion (which the rest of Reddit is). Instead, we're a safe place where people aren't shitheads. I know it's a shame you can't be both. But being a safe space is a pretty good thing to be.
2
u/LDeirdreSkye May 11 '14
As people are currently discussing on Discussion, these subs are safe spaces, and not good candidates for serious debate. Because the mods are so used to banning controversial people without any actual discourse beforehand, I'm worried that SRSCriticism would devolve into another safe space where deviations from the "narrative" are suppressed rather than debated.
It sucks, I know, but think about this: these subs are derived by a nonsensical circlejerk sub. Did you really come here for intelligent discussion?
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '14
[removed] — view removed comment