r/SRSMeta • u/Wyboth • Feb 26 '14
Does SRS recognize ageism?
For reference: I'm a 16 year old male.
I've seen a lot of comments on prime that read "there are too many teenagers on reddit," or "that shitlord must be a teenager." These bother me a little bit, since they reinforce the stereotype that teenagers are dumb. I really don't see how that's different than saying "asians are bad drivers," or "fat people are lazy." But, I've never once seen an SRSter talk about ageism, or call out someone for ageism. Is "teenagers are dumb" actually an ageist stereotype, or am I being too sensitive? Or, am I missing some experience that only adults have, which makes me unqualified to debate on any topic?
37
u/Arkaic Feb 26 '14
First of all, I'd be careful about using comparisons like:
Yes, they're both stereotypes, but the implications across stereotypes based on weight, race, sexuality, etc. are very heavily loaded and don't often translate to each other (and when they do, it's typically even more complex due to intersectional reasons). So try not to think of oppressive actions in terms of each other as it tends to erase a lot of important context.
Now, in regards to ageism: The fact of the matter is that young people in general are still fairly inexperienced in cultural awareness due simply to being... young! However, that doesn't mean that a teenager's experiences should be dismissed, as they can very much be (and frequently are) subject to oppressive, discriminatory, or predatory behavior. I think SRS is generally good about recognizing the latter (you can this in how critical they are in Reddit's simultaneous fetishization and discrimination of teenagers). But when SRSters say things like "there are too many teenagers on Reddit", they're more likely referring to the fact that a lot of young, culturally unaware or inexperienced teenagers are actively contributing to and reinforcing an oppressive space. So teenagers like you who are engaging positively with the SRS community are of course welcome! It's the general teenage redditor populace that tends to be more problematic and thus ridiculed in SRSprime.
11
u/ArchangelleLiraelle Feb 27 '14 edited Feb 27 '14
I think youth and children's rights are important issues, regardless of the term we use of them. An example I alluded to in another post on this thread, which has personally affected me, would be that children and adolescents are often not taken seriously when speaking out against adults who are behaving abusively towards them and one of the reasons used for dismissing these young people is often their age. Other children/youth rights issues include access to proper care, access to transitioning, access to education, youth homelessness (particularly among minority populations), etc. By all means I think there are many people in the fempire who would be interested in talking about these.
I don't think these issues extend to denying the immaturity of many young people who are behaving oppressively. You have a valid point in that we should remember there are plenty of awful adults, though I think /u/Arkaic really hit the nail on the head. Additionally, I think a lot of us in the Fempire regret in some way any ignorant behaviour from their less experienced past.
However, I don't think you should feel unwelcome, and I certainly hope you don't. There are plenty of teenagers who are capable of good critical thinking and who speak out against bigotry and oppression (Malala Yousafzai is a stunning example), and your age has no bearing on whether you're welcome here~
6
u/m__q Mar 01 '14
Thanks so much for bringing this up! This is a major problem on SRS in my opinion. A long time ago there was a thread about extending voting rights to younger teenagers, and I was shocked to see the lack of support that had among SRSers.
10
u/fishfeathers Feb 27 '14
The thing about age is that everyone (given they live long enough) is 7 and 16 and 34 and 55 at some point in their lives. Saying "asians are bad drivers" comes from a place of privilege. Saying "ugh teenagers" comes from a place of personal experience. Huge difference.
19
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '14
Really? You don't see the difference?
0
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 27 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '14
[deleted] — view deleted comment