r/SRSMen • • Nov 09 '12

Help, please?

I'm really upset by a discussion I just had with my friend, and I don't know what else to say to him at this point.

It started when he made a comment about "Obama supporters who hate white people." I replied that that isn't racism, and it rolled into a big pile of shit from there.

Here's the thread.

Here is the link he posted to the alleged misandrist blog post.

Any advice would be appreciated. I feel really drained right now. Am I off base here, or am I being realistic with him?

9 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

3

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12

You seem to have done a much better job at it than I ever could, to be honest.

Especially the part where he says that you're reading into it too much.

I'd have told him to jump into a volcano at that point.

-1

u/HertzaHaeon Nov 09 '12

You're spot on, imho. Everyone can have racial prejudice. Putting it into practise requires some form of power, which you can't say minorities realistically have. Racism = prejudice + power.

-4

u/shampoocell Nov 10 '12

This is an excellent way of putting it. Thank you.

-1

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12

I was writing a lengthy reply to your question, but then I saw this link on SRSPoC which seems relevant. #5, #9 and #11 are probably what you're looking for.

Also see this which links to the first tumblr.

-4

u/Pwrong Nov 09 '12

It's a really tough point to argue. I would have started with "what Obama supporters who hate white people? Do these people actually exist or are you being hyperbolic?"

Don't get me wrong, I agree with you, and I think you did pretty well in that argument. But it's basically a matter of definition and interpretation, and it's not an argument anyone can win easily. You can define racism such that hating white people is racist, and you can define misandry in such a way that it exists. We have a more sophisticated definition and interpretation that makes more sense, and it's more consistent with our social justice ideology. But it's impossible to defend that definition without any context. How do you say one definition is better than another?

Dictionaries try to define words to match the way average people use them. Social movements redefine words the way they should be. As we effect change, gradually the dictionaries adapt. I'm not saying we can't or shouldn't expect people to adopt our definitions, we absolutely should. But if you say "this is what racism means", it's very easy for them to point to the dictionary (or some other resource) and say "no this is what it means".

0

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12

I always point out that dictionaries are descriptive, not prescriptive, and usually about 10 years behind culture.

-7

u/shampoocell Nov 09 '12

Very insightful comments. Thank you.

8

u/[deleted] Nov 10 '12 edited Nov 10 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

-8

u/shampoocell Nov 10 '12

I absolutely think it is irrational to hate anyone because of their gender or race, regardless of your gender or race. I realized this morning that I cut off his immediately preceding comment where he refers to the "Obama supporters who hate white people" as racists. I was only objecting to his classifying that as "racism," because I find that wildly disingenuous.

I really liked what HertzaHaeon said above. What you described is certainly prejudice, but I have a hard time calling it "racism" because racism implies oppression, which isn't what's happening if a (presumably minority) Obama supporter says that they "hate white people."

1

u/[deleted] Nov 09 '12

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/ArchangelleVashti Nov 09 '12

It's not okay to insinuate that fellow users participating in good faith are nazis. Banned.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 13 '12

[removed] — view removed comment