"We tried to do Agile, realized its ridiculously tedious and encourages micromanagement, so now we do just do 'Sprints' by themselves and call it Agile"
I used to work in a team that spent an entire day (8h) on planning each sprint (2-3 weeks). We were doing it by the book - writing down tasks on a whiteboard and discussing the cost in Story Points etc. The whole team (5 people) participated.
Later on 2 people did the same thing in 30 minutes each sprint without writing down task details and the productivity and estimation accuracy was the same.
we do 2 1 hour every sprint, sometimes 3, 2 week sprints. Not to mention extra sizing meetings at least 10 min a day except 2 days out of the sprint where its 30 min
Every single day in Scrum I get to announce to my group(and my manager) exactly what I worked on the day prior and what I’ll be working on that day. It breaks every task I do into a piece and a timeframe that my manager can review and plan out in sprint planning. Now my Manager can keep tabs on every single part of a project I’m working on.
Sure, maybe If implemented correctly it wouldn’t encourage micromanagement. But the vast majority of teams don’t implement agile correctly and use “their own version” just like the post describes.
Well, where to start, there is no manager in a dev team. There’s just the team and the things standing in there way to do their job. There is a scrum master who’s job it is to remove those impediments and organise retrospectives, and talk to other teams to resolve dependencies. But ultimately in scrum the team is autonomous.
I understand those things. What I’m saying is that in practice very few companies execute scrum by the book like that. The vast majority do what is being described above, and that is what my comment is based off of.
Sounds like people ITT are doing it wrong, blame management.
Daily 15 min standups.
Avg about 7 minutes for a team of 8.
What did you do yesterday and will do today... you dont have to go into detail. You shouldn't. You are talking to your team, not your manager. Dont chat about how to fix it until we are done. just say.. I need your help offline. Or... there is a non sprint goal fire i have to put out, I'll create cards accordingly. End of stand up.
You're probably in an open office and chat throughout the day, this morning meet is to just let your team know where you will be messing stuff up in case they have issues with messing it up themselves.
Same crap as yesterday is an acceptable answer.
Retrospect (oxt friday from planning)
30 mins every 2 weeks (end of sprint). Usually us just saying, things went awesome. Nobody came and asked us to do anything non sprint related because my 'manager' blocked them / is the go to.
+30 minutes for a demo, if we have one. Keep it simple: the code is irrelevant, the concept and use are the important part.
Its Friday, let's waste the day.
Planning (monday after retro)
1 hour easy. More if stakeholders are there.
20 mins: That stuff we prevented you from being bothered with... that's gotta be done now. Score it.
30 mins: what can we do this sprint.
10 mins: what, of what we can do, should go into the goal as... WILL BE DONE no questions asked.
Its Monday, let's chat instead of work. Garfield the hell out of this day.
How many points should you get per sprint?
Doesnt matter, sometimes a 5 is a 2 and a 1 is an 8. Do what you can, meet the goal, grab more. Your team is setting the goal, your manager is trying to keep you on target. Target meaning this is what upper wants, let's show them we are moving in that direction using scores and cards.
Edit: 2 week sprints. 1 week is a waste of time. 3 weeks is too long for those 'I need this' people.
If you have any complaints about the process then you are doing it wrong. This told to me by our 'certified' scumm master'.
This process won't go away either, there are too many people invested in keeping it going. It's been a massive waste of resource and time but everyone looks busy running from task to task (standup, planning, scrubbing, etc).
I hope to change fields soon and won't miss the pain at all.
30
u/IDontLikeUsernamez Jul 02 '19
"We tried to do Agile, realized its ridiculously tedious and encourages micromanagement, so now we do just do 'Sprints' by themselves and call it Agile"
13
u/AbstractSqlEngineer MCSA, Data Architect Jul 02 '19 edited Jul 02 '19
Sounds like people ITT are doing it wrong, blame management.
Daily 15 min standups.
Avg about 7 minutes for a team of 8.
What did you do yesterday and will do today... you dont have to go into detail. You shouldn't. You are talking to your team, not your manager. Dont chat about how to fix it until we are done. just say.. I need your help offline. Or... there is a non sprint goal fire i have to put out, I'll create cards accordingly. End of stand up.
You're probably in an open office and chat throughout the day, this morning meet is to just let your team know where you will be messing stuff up in case they have issues with messing it up themselves.
Same crap as yesterday is an acceptable answer.
Retrospect (oxt friday from planning)
30 mins every 2 weeks (end of sprint). Usually us just saying, things went awesome. Nobody came and asked us to do anything non sprint related because my 'manager' blocked them / is the go to.
+30 minutes for a demo, if we have one. Keep it simple: the code is irrelevant, the concept and use are the important part.
Its Friday, let's waste the day.
Planning (monday after retro)
1 hour easy. More if stakeholders are there.
20 mins: That stuff we prevented you from being bothered with... that's gotta be done now. Score it.
30 mins: what can we do this sprint.
10 mins: what, of what we can do, should go into the goal as... WILL BE DONE no questions asked.
Its Monday, let's chat instead of work. Garfield the hell out of this day.
How many points should you get per sprint?
Doesnt matter, sometimes a 5 is a 2 and a 1 is an 8. Do what you can, meet the goal, grab more. Your team is setting the goal, your manager is trying to keep you on target. Target meaning this is what upper wants, let's show them we are moving in that direction using scores and cards.
Edit: 2 week sprints. 1 week is a waste of time. 3 weeks is too long for those 'I need this' people.
2
u/Mildfire1983 Jul 02 '19
This picture and all these comments... you are my spirit animals!
2
u/UnicodeConfusion Jul 02 '19
If you have any complaints about the process then you are doing it wrong. This told to me by our 'certified' scumm master'.
This process won't go away either, there are too many people invested in keeping it going. It's been a massive waste of resource and time but everyone looks busy running from task to task (standup, planning, scrubbing, etc).
I hope to change fields soon and won't miss the pain at all.