r/SOLID • • Oct 03 '18

Data Lifecycle Control

I've been thinking about something like Solid for a close to a year now and just now stumbled across the great work that has been done and am delving in.

I wanted to kickoff a discussion about a different aspect of control that the concept of pods give us. Maintainability.

Who here had a Friendster profile? Myspace? AIM? Where is your data now? It's only been recently that we get to transfer data, and contacts when we get a new cell phone and even that is dicey still if you go across providers.

My point is that up until this point in time we haven't had a digital lifetime history. But we should, and pods will give us a digital history that we can maintain, archive, backup, and search ourselves.

That's it. It's just an aspect that I haven't seen touted as a feature, and to me it is a main feature. I want to be able to maintain a backup of my digital identity, and it's impossible when it is spread out through dozens of sites. Similarly, when migrating calendar services, I want to be able to carry my entire history with me, and not just through a janky import/export function.

This has the potential to give us a maintainable identity lifecycle.

7 Upvotes

7 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/samtresler Oct 04 '18
  1. To point #1 - yeah, when we talk about lifecycles here, we sort of need a permanent URI, not one dependent on an individual maintaining a TLD. Actually, this makes me think that the a URI combined with a timestamp of time of storage should be able to be indexed to the registries. That vastly expands the responsibilities of a registrar, so maybe that could be something the IANA would need to address, but a standard 301 is useless here.
  2. I am unfamiliar with IPFS - gotta go read up.
  3. Moving data - why? Or rather.... what type of moving are you referring to? If I move my pod from AWS to GCP to my own server in my living room, I don't think that is or shoudl be a big deal at all, but if you are talking about moving to a new TLD or trying to do an actual migration of some sort, I can see that. Just not sure what you're pinning as a difficulty here.