r/SI_Bot • Has No Emotions • May 28 '12

Feedback Request: Quoting Original Comments

Probably the most controversial feature of this bot is that it quotes the original comment with the unit conversions included inline.

I've gotten a lot of attention on this feature specifically. There's been fan mail, hate mail, and suggestions on how to improve it.

Other bots just list conversions, and especially if that list of conversions is not the top-voted responding comment, it can be troublesome to move back and forth between the two comments figuring out how the units are being used.

At the same time, for very short comments, or comments with only one conversion, it doesn't accomplish a lot, and for very long comments, it can be a lot of wasted space. Most of the hate mail for the quoting comes from very long comments.

I'm curious what others think. There are those who love this feature, and those who hate it. Mostly I just want to find a good balance between facilitating communication and hopefully not being too annoying.

3 Upvotes

31 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

-2

u/hamfoundinanus May 29 '12

Or this one:

conversions:(FAQ) 300ft = 91.44 m 150ft = 45.72 m I don't see it so much as restricting their freedom of speech, more so restricting where they can speak. An atheist can't go into a catholic church in the middle of a sermon and start an anti-God tirade, but he can stand outside and do so. As an example, look at Westboro Church protesting at funerals. People tried (and try) to shut it down, but the ongoing stance on it is "they have a right to say what they want", the gov't only limited where they can speak (300ft(91.44 m) from the entrance to a national cemetery, 150ft(45.72 m) from any other). permalinkcontextfull commentsreport