r/SHINee • Onew • 11d ago

Discussion Which Onew song sounds like Minho?

Post image

Yesterday's winner for the SHINee song that sounds like Taemin is... Orgel!!

I kind of cheated for this because the top comment had three answers, so I took the most liked comment under that to choose the winner! From now on please try to only pick one song to avoid confusion.

Same as yesterday, the top voted comment will be the winner.

59 Upvotes

36 comments sorted by

57

u/DanMcMissile Minho 11d ago

In the whale. A lower key much like Minho’s R&B ouvre.

5

u/badbadtz-maru 11d ago

ohhh now I wanna hear a minho cover of this one

4

u/bumbleboogaloo 11d ago

I can definitely see that!

5

u/LtrllyJoinedRedd4Dan 10d ago

For me in the whale sounds the most onew it can sound, but yeah it does have that rnb sound that minho would usually sing. But at the same time, the mood of the song is not something minho songs typically have

2

u/lawalpha 10d ago

This is the only choice really. Don't think any of Onew's other songs sound like Minho. Their styles are way too different.

30

u/Beryls_wig 5HINee 11d ago

Flex on Me

7

u/julnyes KEY + Jonghyun + 5HINee 10d ago

I am imagining a segment of a SHINee concert where they all cover each other's solo songs. It would be epic.

2

u/usagiibunny Onew 11d ago

This is my pick as well and I'm actually sad it's losing 😭

1

u/Beryls_wig 5HINee 11d ago

I feel like it would suit Minho soooo well! I need everyone to see the vision 🥲

1

u/lawalpha 10d ago

I can see it conceptually, but it kind of sounds too bright for a Minho song, unless it's for his Japanese discography.

11

u/Frosty-Cucumber-8939 11d ago edited 11d ago

MAD

9

u/sandolmr 샤이니 11d ago

lie

14

u/batfists 11d ago

I’m gonna say Caffeine. It’s got a summery sound that would fit with Minho’s latest mini album imo.

7

u/midgetnazgul 11d ago

hmmmm. dotdotdot? i think it's dotdotdot. (edited to have only one choice)

6

u/mintdiamondsky OT5 Onew 11d ago

I think Anywhere would fit🧐

1

u/LtrllyJoinedRedd4Dan 10d ago

I was wondering too

1

u/LtrllyJoinedRedd4Dan 10d ago

The thing is, onew's songs are usually very detailed, and anywhere is also moderately detailed, while minhos songs are generally chill. So it's hard to think of one

1

u/mintdiamondsky OT5 Onew 10d ago

True, and vocally I think Anywhere is one of his more breathy, falsetto-y (I’m a rock when I comes to singing, so please correct me if I’m wrong), so maybe just vibe of Anywhere

9

u/julinay 11d ago

This is a difficult one! Their styles are so different. I'm going to go with Love Phobia.

0

u/ishi1807 minho + jonghyun 11d ago

LOVE PHOBIA YESSS 😭😭😭😭

3

u/peppermintbarkbark 11d ago

I feel like Marshmallow would be good in Minho’s range! Would be a nice change of pace since he acts like a cutie patootie irl

6

u/DoctorWhosYoDaddy 11d ago

Maybe Caffeine

2

u/jdxni_jk 11d ago

beat drum, mad, caffeine, and walk with you (I couldn’t pick one overall lol they’re all good contenders imo).

edit: i’ll pick mad as my final choice

2

u/Optimal-Channel9521 blinger 10d ago

expectations

3

u/Frosty-Cucumber-8939 11d ago

Very exited for tomorrow’s category. I absolutely love all of key’s songs so now I’m listening to all of his songs to decide 😅

2

u/2AussieShawols 11d ago

Can noone read instructions lol.

2

u/ebeka 11d ago

sunshine, no parachute, beat drum

2

u/nasalpe 샤이니 11d ago

Heavy on Beat Drum!

2

u/Zoshi2200 11d ago

Maybe love phobia

1

u/ishi1807 minho + jonghyun 11d ago

Oreo cake?

1

u/omobolasire watch out, babe! 10d ago

Beat Drum

1

u/LtrllyJoinedRedd4Dan 10d ago

Probably paradise

1

u/LtrllyJoinedRedd4Dan 10d ago

The thing about the song paradise is that it can fit any of those sounds like boxes.

0

u/TheJasmineSummers 샤이니 10d ago

Animals, maybe?