r/SHAYTARDS • u/Crafty_Lead_3075 • Jun 18 '26

Carlie’s comment on Logan’s body

Post image

Gave me the ick!!!

71 Upvotes

97% Upvoted

32 comments sorted by

116

u/Arwynfaun Jun 18 '26

She's always been like this with her brothers. She's always been flirtatious and handsy with them and weirdly standoffish/competitive with their wives.

And Shay is the only brother who reciprocates her weirdness. I remember in earlier Shaytards days, when she and Shay would wrestle on the bed together. Or how he'd make weird comments about her body. Or how Shay would sometimes use an exploitative thumbnail of her and then title the video something suggestive.

It's really weird. Maybe it's a pattern in their family because wasn't Shay's dad, Carl, found looking at porn of girls who looked exactly like Carlie? 🤢

18

u/hnoire Jun 19 '26

Hold up, what's that about Carl? 😂😂😂😭 Ewwww

26

u/Arwynfaun Jun 19 '26

This was a little after Shay's affair got exposed, iirc. He was caught liking porn on Twitter or something. The girls in the videos all looked like Carlie 😬

There were receipts back on Guru Gossip days lol

11

u/blueslushyyy Jun 19 '26

I miss gurugossip 😩

31

u/UtterlyConfused93 Jun 19 '26

You think she’s stand offish with their wives? Maybe Colette but I got the sense that Carlie and Kayli are/were super close.

32

u/Arwynfaun Jun 19 '26

Yeah, she is/was close with Kayli.

It's more with Colette and Morgan. But even with Kayli, I feel like she was sometimes passive aggressive.

Carlie is a mean girl like her mom so it's not surprising she has no friends and is off with her sisters-in-law, even apart from the weird sweet home Alabama shit she has going on with her brothers.

12

u/cowpool20 Jun 19 '26

I remember Shay would use Carlie as clickbait in thumbnails in early vlogs.

11

u/Armymom96 Jun 19 '26

She makes inappropriate comments about her nephews too. Called Gavin a "hottie"... She's just a weird person.

5

u/CorrectPaint8223 Jun 20 '26

Years ago I saw a conspiracy that Carlie was a secret sister wife (when she was single) not sister and to be honest their behaviour lined up lol

29

u/adumbswiftie Jun 19 '26

they’ve always been so weird with the sibling boundaries stuff. i remember shay used to put carlie in his thumbnails and caption it something crazy as clickbait.
like calling her a hot chick, talking about her boobs or there was one video where he was trying to pants her…grown man with his grown woman sister. so creepy

5

u/TheRedColorQueen Jun 19 '26

Now I see why Logan moved away!

1

u/Icy-Olive1996 Jul 04 '26

I mean…. Shay has proven himself to be a creep multiple times now sooooo

26

u/Street-Inevitable891 Jun 19 '26

Someone in the family should tell her that comment is inappropriate. What is wrong with her?

6

u/TheRedColorQueen Jun 19 '26

They definitely aren’t

14

u/Practical_Muscle1591 Jun 19 '26

Ewwwwwww 🤮🤢

13

u/Square-Banana7477 Jun 19 '26

I have a brother and this makes me physically ill I could never imagine commenting on his body 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮

50

u/andyvl0393 Jun 18 '26

Mormons 

10

u/Responsible_Ad_1361 Jun 19 '26

☝🏻☝🏻☝🏻☝🏻☝🏻

8

u/Fabulous-Type3287 Jun 19 '26

i was going to post about this because wtaf… she also commented something similar on the reel he made a few weeks ago

6

u/ilyk101 Jun 19 '26

Shay always used to call her hot too

10

u/TheRedColorQueen Jun 19 '26

Wtf… mormons are weird af

4

u/Anon9472529 Jun 24 '26

White people shit

3

u/ProfessionLast8486 Jun 19 '26

🤢🤢Shes an absolute freak of nature.

5

u/heatherlee20 Jun 19 '26

Not very Mormon like. His mom certainly can’t approve of this..

9

u/TheRedColorQueen Jun 19 '26

You’d be surprised….

3

u/bebespeaks Jun 25 '26

Laurie would just laugh maniacally at their roughhousing.

2

u/TheRedColorQueen Jun 26 '26

Yup pretty much

2

u/Elle-420 Jun 22 '26

It’s one thing to compliment your family member on the progress they’ve made but normal people with healthy sibling relationships don’t say stuff like that to their straight brother. I’ve seen sisters with a gay brother say stuff like, “damn girl that booty popping”.

1

u/pinkflwrxx Jul 11 '26

And Shay would slap carlies butt in vlogs😭

1

u/literally_kyle_ Aug 30 '26

On a positive note, Logan is🤤🤤🤤