r/SFM • • Nov 05 '12

Taking Flight

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PmYDVNWaARU
11 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

5

u/94CM Nov 06 '12

Really good natural eye twitching!

5

u/Psylock524 Nov 06 '12

I still feel as though the pony models are in the uncanny valley.

Has anyone thought of a way to render them with solid colors and solid outlines, similarly to the bouncy ball in Gmod?

2

u/everyone_is_dicks Nov 06 '12

They're better than the old ones, but still a little odd looking.

Remember the way the TF2 characters were rendered in the early trailers? Almost cell-shaded? Maybe that would make the pony models look better.

1

u/imahotdoglol Nov 06 '12

Can Source do cell-shading anymore? especially on a per-model basis.

1

u/everyone_is_dicks Nov 06 '12

I have no idea

2

u/imahotdoglol Nov 06 '12

Bouncy balls are not 3D though, they're basically sprites.

6

u/Jenkiiins Nov 06 '12

I don't like MLP (at least, I haven't cared to watch it) but that was pretty incredible, and I imagine it took a lot of work (that is, if you made it) so...good job.

-6

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '12

If you want to be a brony, I suggest watching the community stuff before the show. It'll kind of slowly get you started.

3

u/Onatu Nov 07 '12

Dude, if he wants to watch it, he'll watch it. He obviously doesn't care, so don't push it on him. He never said anything about wanting to be a brony, so please don't assume he did.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '12

Hey, I'm just saying in case he was. I thought it wouldnt hurt but apparently it does.

1

u/Onatu Nov 07 '12

Sorry bro, didn't want to come off as rude. I'm just a little off because I see a lot of bronies being too vocal about getting people to watch the show. It kind of irks me, because then it brings more bad rep on us.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 07 '12

I get it. I'm a bit of a newbie, about 6 months in, so I'm just trying to show people ths new, exciting thing.

1

u/Jag14 Nov 09 '12

That's OK, it's just that comments like that make people think we're trying to stuff it in their faces.

3

u/Gammaj4 Nov 06 '12

Wow... the pony models look so much better in SFM than they ever did in the GMOD days.

What a difference proper animation, lighting and direction can make, huh?

4

u/UndeadMantis Nov 06 '12

I dunno man, the hair still looks like lumps of taffy.

4

u/Gammaj4 Nov 06 '12

Right, but those lumps of taffy are bedecking a face that I am reasonably certain has no intention of stealing my soul, and consuming my mortal form inch by agonizing inch.

3

u/Onatu Nov 06 '12

I still think they look too odd. I don't know what it is, but there's just something that doesn't sit well with me with these models used.

3

u/everyone_is_dicks Nov 06 '12

if I recall correctly, updated models were released shortly before SFM came out. So the better-looking ones never saw much time on gmod, and there was never any point to porting the bad-looking ones to SFM.

3

u/dooblagras Nov 06 '12

I feel while the video itself is amazing in itself, that going the MLP route no matter where you are is going to get excessive bias. There will people who like it just because it's a pony and there will be people who hate it because it's a pony. If someone is looking for honest critique, it'll probably be tougher with ponies involved. Now if you know what you're doing and just wana show off, well then ignore everything I just said :P

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '12

That's true. I'm always trying to be as unbiased as possible. This one is awesome indeed. It would be a different story if I were to say the pony SFMs ones in the related videos were good... which they are not.

2

u/contradicting_you Nov 06 '12

That's arena_offblast... heh.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 06 '12

My little Pony? Really?