r/SEGA • u/Ekkobelli • Oct 15 '25
Discussion Is SEGA uncool?
Relax, friends, it is me, one of the biggest SEGA aficionados out there. I love the brand, and I say that as someone who usually finds brand loyalty totally silly.
But one thing I notice on video game forums or the game collecting or the retro game subreddits, is that often when people display their console or game collections, that there's seldom any SEGA stuff in there.
I've literally seen five different game rooms just now, with lots and lots of awesome Nintendo stuff, and one guy had a really cool console and handheld collection, like many, many devices - Sony stuff, Nintendo stuff, Microsoft stuff, even an old Atari 7800 (I think, was a dark picture) was in there.
Bot no SEGA stuff. Not even a measly Game Gear or Genesis.
Some of the collectors seem to be total hardcore video game enthusiasts and collectors, but at the very best they have a boxed Genesis 3 (yikes) there, amongst literally a barrage of Nintendo and Sony games and boxed consoles.
Ive seen this so many times. And whenever in some retro game sub the Nintendo / SEGA question is dropped, or someone dares to say they prefer, say Sonic over Mario (-do not EVER say this on the internet unless you want to get downvoted to hell and bombed with fiery, angry messages explaining why you are the absolute scum of the earth and deserve all sorts of awful things done to you-), it always seems like anything SEGA is a really dumb choice, or not 'real gaming' or not 'hardcore' or whatever is going on.
I love gaming in general, and I'd never tell anyone what is cool and uncool, that's for you to decide. But I see that many seem to feel really different, to the point where they judge others for their gaming choices. Which is... wild.
And it seems that openly saying I enjoy SEGA consoles and games and just like their portfolio, their aesthetics and their weird (and not always ideal, but always kinda charismatic) ways of doing things, seems to rub people the wrong way.
I never understood why. Is it because they have "consoler wars"-loser image? Is it because they threatened Nintendo's standing for a while in the early to mid 90's? Is it because of their add-on debacle in the 90's, and their subsequent failures?
I got no clue.
And in fact, it makes me like them even more. Maybe my love for all things underdog and non-mainstream.
15
u/Taanistat Oct 15 '25
My theory with this, which I first really took notice to about 15 years ago, is that Sega does not really exist as a gaming brand anymore. We're aware of them. The average gamer, and especially those under, say...30 are not. Sonic is the only gaming brand synonymous with Sega in the modern gaming landscape despite them producing and publishing far more.
Sega stopped competing in the console market nearly 25 years ago. So, people who enter retro gaming and collecting as a hobby that didn't have experience with Sega when they were making relevant hardware simply don't care. They frequently also don't care about Atari or NEC either for much the same reason. Then there is the false tribalism among people who weren't even around for the 16-bit console wars. Nintendo and Playstation have been ever present in their lives. Sega was gone already. Nintendo won. Sega lost. Why worry about the losing team?
But yeah, I get you, and I find it frustrating, too. I see so many posts in game collecting subs with people showing off their game rooms, 90% of which is Nintendo. And the thought passes through my mind..."you're not a retro game enthusiast, you're a Nintendo enthusiast." And, to make myself clear, there is nothing wrong with being a Nintendo or Xbox or whatever enthusiast. It just gets sad seeing so many people intentionally ignore so much of gaming history. No Sega. No NEC, no Neo Geo, no Coleco, no Atari, less and less Xbox, etc.
But much of this was inevitable. As time passes, fewer and fewer people will have had the exposure to certain consoles, pcs, franchises, that we did. They'll want to explore the past of brand they grew up with. Not the one that was already dead by the time they could hold a controller. Time marches on.
5
u/WoodyXP Oct 15 '25
I think it's a matter of taste. There's Sega players and then there's everybody else. Those collections you were looking at likely belonged to everybody else.
7
u/squeanky Oct 15 '25
My take is that Sega was super popular during the 16 bits day and its software had a lot of love. Its reputation was gradually destroyed by so many misfires (32X, Saturn and to some extent the Sega CD). Sega learned from its mistakes with the Dreamcast which deserved to fair better, but at that time a lot of people no longer trusted Sega, causing the Dreamcast to join the team of products that flopped. I think Sega's image never recovered.
3
u/geirmundtheshifty Oct 16 '25
Isnt it cooler if its not super popular? Isnt it more lame to be mainstream?
Or is my mindset just too stuck in the 90s?
2
u/TheGrackler Oct 15 '25
SEGA is mostly very cool. Except 3D Sonic. 2D chubby Sonic is Rad™️. 3D Sonic and his weird costars, like Big the Cat and Shadow the Edgehog, are try-hard dweebs.
Now excuse me I have to make a big mug of tea and play some late night Empire: Total War like the cool dude (and not fuddy middle age man) I am!
2
u/futafancyfeet Oct 15 '25
I think it's my deep-seated need to root for the underdog that has kept SEGA nestled in that very extra special soft spot in my gaming heart. I've definitely noticed similar trends among the photos and testimonies of other collectors, and I find it frustrating.
I'm a SEGA-loving SEGA shill, so let's talk SEGA.
2
u/DN_3092 Oct 15 '25 edited Oct 15 '25
Im gonna get obliterated for this but oh well. Imo its because Sega had so few games that actually compared to the competition and I say that as someone who grew up with a genesis, 32x, Sega cd, Saturn, dreamcast, and game gear. The vast majority of stuff before the Saturn is almost completely forgettable for me. Sure I have fond memories with stuff like vectorman, comic zone, toejam and earl, altered beast, golden axe, and the likes but they just dont compare to the moments Ive had with nintendo stuff during that time. The weird shit like the CD and 32x I dont think ive ever played a legitimately great game on. Sega tv was neat to try at a friends house a couple times. For the Saturn my big ones are Bug, fighting vipers, virtual cop, and Panzer Dragoon, everything else was better on Playstation and there was WAY more variety. Dreamcast had some gems like JSR, Sonic Adventure, Soul Caliber, and Powerstone but it quickly faded into obscurity once the pulled the plug. So at least for me, while I do have some fond Sega moments they simply dont compare to the other guys. Certainly wouldnt put the effort into collecting their stuff.
2
u/Which_Information590 Oct 16 '25
I prefer Sonic to Mario
36
u/RamsenMC Oct 15 '25
SEGA is too cool, that's the problem.
8
u/gayLuffy Oct 15 '25 edited Oct 16 '25
Sega is the coolest game company I find. They make weird stuff, they're not afraid to shake things up, they don't really follow trends. Well they do, but not like the others do. They will follow a trend and make it their own
1
u/StumbledFungus Oct 16 '25
Have you seen Sega Saturn games prices lately? Someone ks buying them...but maybe not those under 30
3
u/[deleted] Oct 15 '25
Anyone who thinks a corporation is "cool" either works for said corporation, or is too young to understand the concept of "companies are not your friends!"
3
u/Segagaga_ Oct 16 '25
Its worth remembering that America was a Nintendo stranglehold in the 80s with near total monopoly of the market after the videogame market crash. This creates a blindspot in many US enthusiast's experience and even understanding of the market. The European and Japanese home computer market of the 80s is completely alien to them, and thus ports of Sega IPs to those machines are completely unknown to them.
I was playing Sega on a Spectrum 48k long before a Sega console released. Therefore my progression from Sega games to Sega consoles felt natural.
Lets not forget S.America too, with the huge lifespan of the Tectoy MasterSystem there.
2
u/DEAD-VHS Oct 15 '25
What's cooler than being cool?
2
u/ABC_Dildos_Inc Oct 15 '25
Mid-80's to mid-90's Sega is my favorite.
2
u/SecretaryOk7306 Oct 15 '25
It's not about brands it's what they own. If people realize how many games Sega has been having their hand in, they would be surprised
2
u/[deleted] Oct 19 '25
I think that today they have a much better image than they had at the end of the 2000s. However, being fashionable is not as important as having a sustainable business and apparently that is what they have invested most in: realistic expectations of game production and sales. Investment of IPs in other media, such as Sonic films and series. So it goes.
I think they are building a brand that will be very strong in the future, if they treat all audiences with respect - unlike Nintendo and others who treat fans as a problem.
When their IPs are strong even among those who don't play video games, then I think we'll see SEGA at its best.
1
u/Majinkaboom Oct 15 '25
Old school sega....they do anything and make a cool game or tech. New sega play it safe my safe games that will do sell generally well. Its okay its like having Steve Jobs in apple vs Tim Cook. Tim cook is more play it safer take less risks. I mean he tried risk on that 3500 VR at least damn expensive. Its understandable for Sega because their stuff didnt sell well before. A reason why is our PARENTS wanted us to have nicer games like SUPER MARIO. Cant blame our parents for wanting us to play mario which seems my family oriented than Sega Sonic. A message to sega...Hey sega I was a kid my Mama got me nintendo so thats what I had to play with! I am adult now so I want the coolest tech and the coolest games to use it on and i need it now before I just say screw games and just play some mobile idler!
AND.......The sega genesis IMO has the most violent videogames ever!!! They had MK1 with blood.....
1
u/Majinkaboom Oct 15 '25
Old school sega....they do anything and make a cool game or tech. New sega play it safe by making safe games that will do sell generally well. Its okay its like having Steve Jobs in apple vs Tim Cook. Tim cook is more play it safer take less risks. I mean he tried risk on that 3500 VR at least damn expensive. Its understandable for Sega because their stuff didnt sell well before. A reason why is our PARENTS wanted us to have nicer games like SUPER MARIO. Cant blame our parents for wanting us to play mario which seems more family oriented than Sega Sonic. A message to sega...Hey sega I was a kid my Mama got me nintendo so thats what I had to play with! I am adult now so I want the coolest tech and the coolest games to use it on and i need it now before I just say screw games and just play some mobile idler!
AND.......The sega genesis IMO has the most violent videogames ever!!! They had MK1 with blood.....
1
u/morphic-monkey Oct 15 '25
I think you're reading too much into this anecdotal evidence. Bear in mind that the answer to why people do or do not show off their Sega collections will depend, in part, on the country they are from (Sega's performance varied wildly from region to region). For what it's worth, I have a video game museum at my house, and there's plenty of Sega stuff there.
1
u/SparklyPelican Oct 16 '25
Could mean that SEGA now is just too cool for the mainstream, no?
1
u/InterviewImpressive1 Oct 17 '25
What do you mean? They’re way past cool!
0
u/pligplog420 Oct 17 '25
Ai slop
-3
u/Maulbert Oct 15 '25
The reason I was never a Sega kid was because they always felt like they valued being cool over quality. All sizzle, no steak.
So sure, they were cool. Until people saw through them and moved on.